Pantsir-S1

Pantsir-S1
NATO reporting name: SA-22 "Greyhound"

Pantsir-S1 on 8×8 Truck KAMAZ-6560 TLAR
Type Transportable gun/SAM system
Place of origin Russia
Service history
In service 2012–present
Used by See list of operators
Wars Syrian Civil War
War in Donbass
Production history
Designer KBP Instrument Design Bureau
Designed 1994
Manufacturer Ulyanovsk Mechanical Plant
Unit cost US$ 13.15[1]–14.67[2] million (export)
Produced 2008
No. built 200[3]
Variants Pantsir-S (prototype), Pantsir-S1, Pantsir-S1-O (or Pantsir-S1E), Pantsir-S2
Specifications (Pantsir-S1)
Crew 3

Main
armament
95Ya6 series (basic missile), 95YA6-2/M series missile-targets, 23Ya6 missile (Domestic) 57E6, 57E6-E (Enhanced) (Export only)
Secondary
armament
Two dual 2A38M 30 mm (1.2 in) autocannon guns

Pantsir-S1 (Russian: Панцирь-С1, NATO reporting name SA-22 Greyhound) is a combined short to medium range surface-to-air missile and anti-aircraft artillery weapon system produced by KBP of Tula, Russia. The system is a further development of 2K22 Tunguska (NATO reporting name: SA-19/SA-N-11) and represents the latest air defence technology by using phased array radars for both target acquisition and tracking.

The Pantsir-S1 was designed to provide point air defence of military/industrial/administrative installations against aircraft, helicopters, precision munitions, cruise missiles and UAVs and to provide additional protection to air defence units from enemy air attacks employing precision munitions especially at the low to extremely low ranges.[4][5]

Design

The first finished version was completed in 1995 with the 1L36 radar, later was designed another.[6] It is a short to medium range ground based air defence system, wheeled, tracked or stationary with two to three operators. Its air defense consists of automatic anti-aircraft guns and surface-to-air missiles with radar or optical target-tracking and radio-command guidance.

Its purpose is the protection of civil and military point and area targets, for motorised or mechanised troops up to regimental size or as defensive asset of higher ranking air defence systems like S-300/S-400. The system has capability for anti-munitions missions. It can hit targets on the waterline/above-water.[7] It can operate in a fully automatic mode.[8] It has the ability to work in a completely passive mode. The probability of hitting a target for 1 rocket is not less than 0.7 with a reaction time of 4–6 seconds.It can fire missiles and gun armament while in motion.[9] For its main radar station, early detection in height may be between 0-60° or 26-82° depending on the mode.[10] The system has claimed significant advantages over other systems, such as Crotale NG (France), Roland-3 (France + USA), Rapier 2000 (UK), SeaRAM (Germany + USA). This is not confirmed by comparative testing, but clearly follows from declared limit of possibilities of systems (2010).[11][12] Since 2013, there is a variant with two radar stations for early detection * standing back to back *.[13] The system has a modular structure which enables a fast and easy replacement of any part.

[14] After receiving target coordinates (from any source) it may defeat the target (using all the radar except the early detection radar) within a range from -5 to +85 (82[15]) degrees (vertical).[16] The interval between missile launches is 1-1.5 seconds (a world record for analogue systems).[17]

Development

An alternative mounting of antiaircraft complex Pantsir-S1 on a tracked GM-352 chassis

Originally Soviet strategic missile systems had been placed in fixed, hardened sites. Newer systems such as the S-300PS/PM (SA-10/20) on the other hand was much more mobile which reduced its vulnerabilities to attack, However, once the S-300 unit was found by enemy forces it was still very vulnerable to precision weapon systems. One of the roles for the Pantsir-S is to provide air defence to the S-300 missile systems.[18]

It was also decided that a wheeled chassis would be better suited for the Pantsir-S rather than a tracked chassis. The reasoning being that wheeled vehicles are faster, less prone to breakdowns, easier to maintain, and cheaper to produce.[18]

Development as Pantsir-S started in 1990 with a plan to be a successor of Tunguska M1. A prototype was completed in 1994 and displayed at the MAKS-1995. The program soon ran into difficulties which resulted in a halt in funding. However, KBP continued development of the program using its own funds. This resulted in a complete re-design of both the turret and radar systems and removal of any older Tunguska equipment.[18]

The system has two new radars with increased range, capable of tracking more air targets but also land targets and has an integrated IFF system. Within the cabin two new LCD multi-function displays have replaced the multiple CRT display and a new central computer system greatly decreased the reaction time, single operator operation can be achieved when needed. Due to the new technologies adopted, the overall volume of the weapon station is reduced by a third while the overall weight is reduced by half. The system also has enhanced missiles (from type 57E6 to type 57E6-E probably interchangeable) and guns (from type 2A72 to type 2A38M).

Live firing tests took place in June 2006 at the Kapustin Yar firing range, Astrakhan Region, Russia. Final test series prior to delivery in May 2007 at Kapustin Yar included a forced march of 250 km (160 mi) to an unprepared launch position simulating the accomplishing of a typical air-defence mission.

The Pantsir-S1 air-defence missile-gun system was adopted for service with the Russian Army by an order of the Chairman of the Government of the Russian Federation Dmitry Medvedev on 16 November 2012.[19] Modernized Pantsir-S2 entered service in 2015.[20]

On 19 October 2012, two missiles fired from a Pantsir shot down a live cruise missile in a test in Russia.[21] In 2014 tests, targets moving as fast as 1,000 metres per second (3,300 ft/s; Mach 2.9) were shot down with Pantsir.[22]

In 2014 upcoming planned exercise under jamming for the first time Pantsir-S1 utilized a new missile with almost double the range (35 km (22 mi)). The missile in question is the 23Ya6 missile replacing the 95YA6 series with ranges from 20–30 kilometres (12–19 mi).[23]

Russia is developing a track-based Pantsir system to be more maneuverable with Russian Ground Forces and Airborne Troops.[24]

Pantsir-M/ME

Pantsir systems will be deployed on the Russian aircraft carrier Admiral Kuznetsov. Russian destroyers and other large ships will be modernized to accommodate the system.[24] Entered series production in 2015.[25] Russia's Defense Ministry has purchased three Naval "Pantsir-M"s.[26] The Pantsir-M differs from the land-based version by having two GSh-6-30K/AO-18KD 30 mm (1.2 in) six-barrel rotary cannons, as found on the Kashtan CIWS which it will replace, in place of the single-barrel autocannons, and an additional radar separate from the one fitted on top of the turret itself. One Pantsir-M combat module can simultaneously engage four targets with four missiles and has an ammunition supply of 32 missiles. The ship-based complex may include several combat modules, with module ammunition supply stored in the storage and reloading system under the deck. The system may also be armed with the 100 km (62 mi)-range Hermes-K missile for engaging surface or coastal targets. The Pantsir-M will be mounted aboard the Karakurt-class corvette and is planned to enter service by the end of 2017.[27][28][29][30]

Pantsir-S2/S2E

Modernized system for the Armed Forces and for export. Incorporates new tracking radar, 2 faced radars with enhanced features and range. In service with Russia and Algeria.

Pantsir-SM

The Pantsir-SM variant incorporates a multi-functional targeting station, increasing target detection range from 40 to 75 km (25 to 47 mi) and engagement range from 20 to 40 km (12 to 25 mi).[31]

Pantsir-SA

After testing Pantsir in the arctic, it was decided to design a new version specifically for the Arctic, to use at temperatures below −50° Celsius called Pantsir-SA.[32][33]

Operations

The specific feature of the Pantsir-S1 system is the combination of a multiple-band target acquisition and tracking system in conjunction with a combined missile and gun armament creating a continuous target engagement zone from 5 m (16 ft) height and 200 m (660 ft) range up to 15 km (9.3 mi) height and 20 km (12 mi) range, even without any external support. [34]

Modes

Using a digital data link system up to six Pantsir-S1 combat vehicle can operate in various modes.

Prototypes

Armament

Missile

57E6
Type Surface-to-air missile
Place of origin Russia
Service history
In service 2012–present
Used by See list of operators
Production history
Designer KBP Instrument Design Bureau
Designed 1994
Produced 2008
Variants 57E6, 57E6-E,[35] 57E6Y[36]
Specifications (57E6-E[35])
Weight 90 kg (200 lb) and 74 kg (163 lb) without container packing and storage of missiles[37]
Length 3.2 m
Diameter 0.17 m
Warhead frag-HE and multiple continuous rod
Warhead weight 20 kg
Detonation
mechanism
Contact and proximity

Propellant Solid-fuel rocket
Operational
range
20 kilometres (12 mi)
Flight altitude 15 kilometres (49,000 ft)
Boost time 2 seconds
Speed Start 1,300 m/s (Mach 3.8), 780 m/s (Mach 2.3) to 18 km (11 mi) distance[38]

Pantsir-S1 carries up to twelve export designated 57E6 or 57E6-E two-stage solid fuel radio-command-guided surface-to-air missiles in sealed ready-to-launch containers. Missiles are arranged into two six-tube groups on the turret. The missile has a bicalibre body in tandem configuration. The first stage is a booster, providing rapid acceleration within the first 2 seconds of flight, after which it is separated from the sustainer-stage. The sustainer is the highly agile part of the missile and contains the high explosive multiple continuous rod and fragmentation warhead, contact and proximity fuses as also radio transponder and laser responder to be localised for guidance. The missile is not fitted with seeker to keep target engagement costs low. Instead high-precision target and missile tracking is provided via the system's multiband sensor system and guidance data is submitted via radio link for up to four missiles in flight. Missiles can be fired at up to four targets, but more often in salvos of two missiles at one target. They are believed to have a hit probability of 70–95% and have a 15-year storage lifetime in its sealed containers. Pantsir-S1 combat vehicles can fire missiles on the move.

Warhead weight 20 kg (44 lb)(5.5 kg (12 lb) explosive + 2,000 14.5 g fragments and rods).[39][37] Fuses: contact and non-contact radar adaptive (a range of up to 9 m (30 ft)).[38]

Autocannon

Two dual 2A38M 30 mm (1.2 in) autocannon guns are fitted with 700 rounds of a variety of ammunition—HE (High Explosive) fragmentation, fragmentation tracer, and armour-piercing with tracer. Ammunition type can be selected by the crew depending on the nature of the target. Maximum rate of fire is 2,500 rounds per minute per gun. Range is up to 4 km (2.5 mi). The combined gun-missile system has an extremely low altitude engagement capability (targets as low as 0 m AGL can be engaged by this system).

Wheeled combat vehicles have to be jacked up to keep the machine in the horizontal position and be able to fire the gun with full accuracy. The KAMAZ-6560 has four oil hydraulic jacks for this purpose.

Gun:

Fire control

The Pantsir-S1 fire control system includes a target acquisition radar and dual waveband tracking radar (designation 1RS2-1E for export models), which operates in the UHF and EHF waveband. Detection range is 32–36 kilometres (20–22 mi) and tracking range is 24–28 kilometres (15–17 mi) for a target with 2 m2 (22 sq ft) RCS.[40] Can also reliably achieve more, to 45 km (28 mi).[10] This radar tracks both targets and the surface-to-air missile while in flight. Minimum target size 2–3 square centimetres (0.31–0.47 sq in) (0.0004 square metres (0.0043 sq ft))[37]

As well as radar, the fire control system also has an electro-optic channel with long-wave thermal imager and infrared direction finder, including digital signal processing and automatic target tracking. A simplified, lower-cost version of Pantsir-S1 is also being developed for export, with only the electro-optic fire control system fitted.

The two independent guidance channels—radar and electro-optic—allow two targets to be engaged simultaneously. And four[41] for more recent options (2012). Maximum engagement rate is up to 10-12[9] targets per minute.

Types of purposes. Aircraft, UAVs, helicopters, anti-radar missiles (detection range of AGM-88 HARM missile 13–15 kilometres (8.1–9.3 mi)), air-launched cruise missiles.[39]

Support vehicles

In order to increase high operational readiness KBP has designed several vehicles to support the Pantsir-S1 in the field.[42]

CP Capabilities: Battalion CP – up to six launchers (battalion); Regimental CP – up to three bns; 24 hour continuous operations; Time of shutting down/deployment – 5 min; Number of work stations – 4; Crew – combat crew (3); driver-mechanic (1).

Multi-sensor system

Pantsir-S1 Weapon System. In the centre the EHF phased-array tracking radar. Two twin-barrel 2A38M automatic anti-aircraft guns and 12 ready to launch missile-containers each containing one 57E6-E command guided surface-to-air missile.

Target acquisition radar:

Target tracking radar:

  • Type: Passive electronically scanned array
  • Coverage: cone +/−45°
  • Maximum tracking range: at least 24 km (15 mi), up to 28 km (17 mi)
  • Maximum number of targets can be tracked simultaneously: 20
  • Maximum number of targets can be engaged simultaneously: 3
  • Maximum number of missiles can be radio-controlled simultaneously: 4
  • Band: EHF
  • IFF: Separate or integrated upon customer's request

Autonomous Optoelectronic System:

  • Type: Detection, automatic acquisition and tracking of air and ground targets
  • Target tracking band: Infrared 3–5 µm
  • Missile localisation band: Infra Red 0.8–0.9 µm
  • Maximum number of targets can be tracked simultaneously: 1
  • Maximum number of targets can be engaged simultaneously: 1
  • Maximum number of missiles can be localised simultaneously: 1
  • Limits for minimal height of 5 meters[38]

System:

  • Number of targets that can be simultaneously engaged: 4 (three by radar, one by EO)
  • Maximum number of targets engagement rate: 10 per minute
  • Crew: 1–2 operators for the air defense system and 1 driver
  • Reaction time: 4–6 seconds (including target acquisition and firing first missile), 1–2 seconds for autocannon engagement

Operational history

A Pantsir-S1 unit of the Syrian Armed Forces reportedly scored the first combat kill of the type by downing a Turkish Air Force RF-4E carrying out a reconnaissance flight over the Syrian coast near Latakia on 22 June 2012.[43][44]

Various independent experts believe Pantsir-S1 was operated on the rebel side during the War in Donbass. Remnants of its main armament were reported to have been observed in Ukraine in November 2014.[45] It was filmed in Luhansk and photographed in Makiivka in the rebel-held territories during early 2015.[46][47][48][49] Some media have published these photos with other statements[50]

The system has also been deployed by the Russian armed forces in Syria to guard its deployment during the Russian intervention in the Syrian Civil War.

Operators

Map of Pantsir-S1 operators in blue

Current operators

 Algeria[51]
 Brazil
 Iran
 Iraq
 Jordan
 Oman
 Russia
 Syria
 United Arab Emirates
 Vietnam

See also

References

  1. ""Панцири" едут в Африку". Interfax.ru. Retrieved 14 November 2014.
  2. Newvesti.ru Archived 2011-08-23 at the Wayback Machine.
  3. "Больше 200 зенитных ракетно-пушечных комплексов "Панцирь" выпущено с начала производства". ВПК.name.
  4. "96К6 "Панцирь-С1" - зенитный ракетно-пушечный комплекс".
  5. "PANTSIR-S1 AIR DEFENSE MISSILE-GUN SYSTEM".
  6. "Непробиваемый "Панцирь"". vpk.name. Retrieved 14 November 2014.
  7. "Россия начала испытания гиперзвуковой ракеты для комплекса "Панцирь"". vz.ru (in Russian).
  8. ""Панцирь", С-300 и другие санитары неба". Российская газета.
  9. 1 2 "Зенитный ракетно-пушечный комплекс "Панцирь-С1"". rusarmy.com. Retrieved 14 November 2014.
  10. 1 2 Administrator. "Станция обнаружения целей (СОЦ) 1РС1-1Е". vniirt.ru. Archived from the original on 9 November 2014. Retrieved 14 November 2014.
  11. "Archived copy". Archived from the original on 2013-08-31. Retrieved 2014-11-25.
  12. army-news.ru (in Russian) https://web.archive.org/web/20141106180207/http://army-news.ru/images_stati/9_sravnitelnaya_harakteristika.jpg. Archived from the original on 6 November 2014. Retrieved 30 March 2017. Missing or empty |title= (help)
  13. "ЗЕНИТНЫЙ РАКЕТНО-ПУШЕЧНЫЙ КОМПЛЕКС (ЗРПК) "ПАНЦИРЬ-С". ANTIAIRCRAFT MISSILE-GUN COMPLEX (ZRPK) "PANTSIR-S"". Retrieved 14 November 2014.
  14. """Панцирь-С1" - ракетно-зенитный комплекс-конструктор" в блоге "Армия и Флот" - Сделано у нас". Сделано у нас. Retrieved 14 November 2014.
  15. "Army.lv - международный проект Дмитрия Смирнова". army.lv.
  16. "Схемы 96К6 "Панцирь-С1" - зенитный ракетно-пушечный комплекс". army.lv (in Russian).
  17. 1 2 "Ростех :: Исследования :: Неуязвимый "Панцирь"". rostec.ru.
  18. 1 2 3 "KBP 2K22/2K22M/M1 Tunguska SA-19 Grison/96K6 Pantsir S1/SA-22 Greyhound SPAAGM".
  19. "KBP Instrument Design Bureau - The Pantsir-S1 was adopted for service with the Russian Army". www.kbptula.ru.
  20. "Модернизированный зенитный комплекс "Панцирь-С2" задействовали в учениях ПВО СНГ". ТАСС (in Russian).
  21. "Russia's Pantsir-S System Downs Cruise Missile in Test", RIA Novosti, October 20, 2012
  22. "Россия начала испытания гиперзвуковой ракеты для комплекса "Панцирь"". Деловая газета «Взгляд» (in Russian). 16 June 2014. Retrieved 10 September 2015.
  23. ""Панцирь-С1" отстреляется сверхзвуковыми ракетами | Еженедельник "Военно-промышленный курьер"". vpk-news.ru.
  24. 1 2 "Russia to Arm Warships With Pantsir Air Defense System", RIA Novosti, 11 September 2013
  25. "Разработчик: морской зенитный комплекс "Панцирь-М" пошел в серию". ТАСС (in Russian).
  26. "Минобороны РФ закупило три морских ЗРПК "Панцирь-М"". ТАСС (in Russian).
  27. KBP Unveiled Pantsir-M Naval Variant of Pantsir-S1 for Surface Ship Air Defense - Navyrecognition.com, 2 July 2015
  28. Project 22800 Corvettes to be Fitted with Pantsir-M Naval Variant of Pantsir-S1 Air Defense System - Navyrecognition.com, 28 December 2015
  29. Russian Navy to fit Project 22800 Corvettes with Pantsir-M Air Defense Missile/Gun System - Navyrecognition.com, 31 October 2016
  30. Pantsir-M Naval Air Defense Missile/Gun System to Enter Service with Russian Navy Before Year-End - Navyrecognition.com, 28 February 2017
  31. New targeting device to double Pantsir anti-aircraft range - Armyrecognition.com, 10 October 2016
  32. "Три зенитных ракетно-пушечных комплекса "Панцирь" проходят испытания в Арктике". ТАСС (in Russian).
  33. "Три зенитных ракетно-пушечных комплекса "Панцирь-С1" проходят испытания в Арктике". ВПК.name.
  34. "ЗРПК 96К6 "ПАНЦИРЬ-С1" - ТТХ". pvo.guns.ru.
  35. 1 2 "KBP Instrument Design Bureau 96K6 Pantsyr-S1 self-propelled air-defence system". Jane's Information Group. 2008-04-02. Retrieved 2008-08-20.
  36. "Tunguska/Pantsir-S1 (SA-19 'Grison')". Jane's Information Group. 2008-02-13. Retrieved 2008-08-20.
  37. 1 2 3 "Зенитный ракетно-пушечный комплекс "Панцирь-С" | Армейский вестник". army-news.ru (in Russian).
  38. 1 2 3 "Зенитный ракетно-пушечный комплекс Панцирь-С1 | Ракетная техника". rbase.new-factoria.ru (in Russian).
  39. 1 2 "96К6 "Панцирь-С1" - зенитный ракетно-пушечный комплекс". army.lv (in Russian).
  40. Rosoboronexport. Catalogues of products, missile and artillery systems
  41. "Зенитный комплекс "Панцирь-С1" принят на вооружение российской армии". РИА Новости. Retrieved 14 November 2014.
  42. "System components".
  43. "Newly-supplied Russian Pantsyr-1 anti-air missile used to down Turkish warplane". DEBKAfile. 24 June 2012. Retrieved 24 June 2012.
  44. "Syria – Turkey tension: Conflicting arguments on Phantom". BBC News Middle East. 3 July 2012. Retrieved 9 February 2013.
  45. Ferguson, Jonathan; Jenzen-Jones, N.R. (2014). "Raising Red Flags: An Examination of Arms & Munitions in the Ongoing Conflict in Ukraine. (Research Report No. 3)" (PDF). ARES. p. 78. Retrieved 23 May 2017.
  46. Czuperski, Maksymilian; Herbst, John; Higgins, Eliot; Polyakova, Alina; Wilson, Damon (2015-05-27). Hiding in Plain Sight: Putin's War in Ukraine. Atlantic Council. ISBN 978-1-61977-996-9.
  47. Nemtsov, Boris; Yashin, Ilya; Shorina, Olga (May 2015). Putin. War – Based on materials from Boris Nemtsov (PDF) (Report). Free Russia Foundation.
  48. Smallwood, Michael (5 February 2015). "Russian 96K6 Pantsir-S1 air defence system in Ukraine". Armament Research Services (ARES). Retrieved 20 February 2015.
  49. Higgins, Eliot (May 28, 2015). "Russia's Pantsir-S1s Geolocated in Ukraine". Bellingcat. Retrieved 6 June 2015.
  50. https://topwar.ru/69379-velikobritaniya-predstavila-dokazatelstva-primeneniya-rossiyskih-zrk-pancir-s1-na-vostoke-ukrainy.html
  51. "SIPRI Arms Transfers Database". Stockholm International Peace Research Institute. Retrieved 13 December 2014.
  52. RIA Novosti, 29 March 2007, Algeria could become Russia's main military partner
  53. Kommersant, 29/03/2007, Algeria Moves to First Place among Weapons Buyers Archived 2016-01-18 at the Wayback Machine.
  54. "Russia's arms exporter to reach Pantsir-S1 deal with Brazil in 2016". Moscow: TASS. 2015-04-08. Retrieved 2017-01-17.
  55. Brazil could buy Pantsir S1 and Igla MANPADS air defence missile systems – Armyrecognition.com, February 3, 2013
  56. Brazil has postponed the purchase of Russian missile complexes " Carapace - C1 ", Interfax.ru, October 15th 2015
  57. "Moscou espera decisão de Brasília sobre compra de sistema de defesa antiaérea" [Moscow waits for Brasilia decision about buying aerial defense systems]. Sputnik News Brasil (in Portuguese). 2016-11-30. Retrieved 2017-01-17.
  58. "MBDA e AVIBARS anunciam projeto de Defesa Antiaérea de média altura" [MBDA and AVIBRAS announce medium range Air Defense project]. DefesaNet (in Portuguese). 2014-11-14. Retrieved 2017-01-17.
  59. The Military Balance 2012. P. 324.
  60. Iraq is Buying Russian Weapons Again – Defenseindustrydaily.com
  61. "Iraq cancels $4.2bn Russian arms deal over 'corruption'". BBC News. 10 November 2012.
  62. Iraq to go ahead with billion-dollar Russian arms deal – Globalpost.com, November 10, 2012
  63. مديرية الاعلام. "قيادة الدفاع الجوي تستلم منظومات دفاعية متطورة". Archived from the original on 6 October 2014. Retrieved 14 November 2014.
  64. Russian company Rosoboronexport finishes Pantsir-S1 supplies to Iraq – Armyrecognition.com, 15 February 2016
  65. Jane's Defence Weekly, janes.com
  66. Russiatoday.com
  67. The Military Balance 2012. — P. 342.
  68. "Войска ВКО получили батарею новых зенитных комплексов "Панцирь-С"". РИА Новости. Retrieved 14 November 2014.
  69. "Первые образцы ЗРПК "Панцирь-С1" поступят в российские ВВС в 2008 году / АвиаПорт.Дайджест". АвиаПорт.Ru. Retrieved 14 November 2014.
  70. "Министерство обороны России подвело итоги 2016 года". bmpd. 23 December 2016. Archived from the original on 5 April 2017.
  71. "Тест-драйв ЗРПК "Панцирь-С"". bmpd. 4 May 2016. Archived from the original on 6 May 2016.
  72. Ynetnews, 13 August 2007, IDF: Syria's antiaircraft system most advanced in world
  73. Defenseindustrydaily.com, 22 June 2007, Syria Buying MiG-31s, MiG-35s for $1 billion
  74. SA-22 Greyhound to Syria: Could Russian Air Defense Units Sent to Syria End Up in Hizbullah Hands?. www.cedarsrevolution.net, 19 August 2007.
  75. Eksport Vooruzheniy Journal, №1'2001 (January–February), Preliminary Estimates of Russian Performance in Military-Technical Cooperation with Foreign States in 2000 Archived 2007-12-06 at the Wayback Machine.
  76. Kommersant, 29 March 2007, Russia Has Something To Offer Archived 2009-03-18 at the Wayback Machine.
  77. Jane's Defence Weekly, 30 October 2007, UAE must wait for Pantsirs
  78. RIA Novosti quoting Kommersant, 30 June 2006, UAE to receive latest Russian air defense weapons
  79. (in Vietnamese) "Báo Trung Quốc: Việt Nam đã sở hữu 'mãnh thú' Pantsir-S1", soha.vn, retrieved on 12 June 2014.
This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.