Palmer Inquiry

The Palmer Inquiry was an inquiry led by former Australian Federal Police commissioner Michael John "Mick" Palmer into the unlawful detention of Cornelia Rau, an Australian citizen, suspected of being an illegal immigrant. The report was issued on 6 July 2005 at the request of and to the Minister of Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs, Amanda Vanstone.

The inquiry also initially looked at the "Vivian Alverez Matter", an incident with some similarities, which was taken up and completed by the Commonwealth Ombudsman, Neil Comrie.

Background

Cornelia Rau, a lawful citizen, was found to have spent several years in immigration detention despite being registered as a "missing patient". This was closely followed by another similar issue, that of Vivian Alverez Solon, who was deported to the Philippines, despite being a lawful citizen, and despite also being registered as a missing person by her family.

Criticism

The incidents received a lot of press and public outrage at the time, with both incidents concerning mental health patients not properly being identified as citizens of Australia. There was a fear that these incidents were not isolated and chould happen again. Criticism of the inquiries at inception were that they were of a non-judicial nature, were closed and had limited terms of reference.^[1]

Outcome

The inquiry identified a number of shortcomings in the process of arrest and detention, and made a number of recommendations. The Department of Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs accepted most of the recommendations^[2] though it is not clear if all of them have been implemented.

The absence of known similar incidents since indicates that the report, recommendations, and consequential implementation may have been successful.

References

External links

• The Palmer Report
• Inquiry into the Circumstances of the Vivian Alvarez Matter