Lesley J. McNair

Lesley J. McNair
McNair as Army Ground Forces commander, circa 1942.
Nickname(s)	Whitey
Born	(1883-05-25)May 25, 1883 Verndale, Minnesota, United States
Died	July 25, 1944(1944-07-25) (aged 61) Saint-Lô, France
Buried	Normandy American Cemetery and Memorial, France
Allegiance	United States
Service/branch	United States Army
Years of service	1904–1944
Rank	Lieutenant General General (posthumous)
Service number	0-1891[1]
Unit	Field Artillery Branch
Commands held	Battery C, 4th Field Artillery Regiment 2nd Battalion, 16th Field Artillery Regiment 2nd Battalion, 83rd Field Artillery Regiment Civilian Conservation Corps District E, VII Corps Area 2nd Field Artillery Brigade, 2nd Infantry Division United States Army Command and General Staff School Army Ground Forces First United States Army Group (fictional)
Battles/wars	Vera Cruz Expedition Pancho Villa Expedition World War I World War II
Awards	Army Distinguished Service Medal (3) Purple Heart (2) Legion of Honor (France)
Spouse(s)	Clare Huster (m. 1905)
Relations	1 son

Lesley James McNair (May 25, 1883 – July 25, 1944) was a senior United States Army officer who served during World War I and World War II. He attained the rank of lieutenant general during his life; he was killed in action during World War II, and received a posthumous promotion to general.

A Minnesota native and 1904 graduate of the United States Military Academy, McNair was a Field Artillery officer with a background in the Ordnance Department. A veteran of the Veracruz occupation and Pancho Villa Expedition, during World War I he served as assistant chief of staff for training with the 1st Division, and then chief of artillery training on the staff at the American Expeditionary Forces headquarters. His outstanding performance resulted in his promotion to temporary brigadier general; at age 35, he was the Army's youngest general officer.

McNair's experience of more than 30 years with equipment and weapons design and testing, his administrative skills, and his success in the areas of military education and training led to his World War II assignment as commander of Army Ground Forces. In this role, McNair became the "unsung architect of the U.S. Army",^[2] and played a leading role in the organizational design, equipping, and training of Army units in the United States before they departed for overseas combat. His concentration on advanced officer education, innovative weapons systems, improved doctrine, realistic combat training, and development of combined arms tactics enabled the Army to modernize and perform successfully on the World War II battlefield, where the mobility of mechanized forces replaced the static defenses of World War I as the primary tactical consideration.

He was killed by friendly fire while in France to act as commander of the fictional First United States Army Group, part of the Operation Quicksilver deception that masked the actual landing sites for the Invasion of Normandy. During Operation Cobra, an Eighth Air Force bomb landed in his foxhole during combat near Saint-Lô when the Army attempted to use heavy bombers for close air support of infantry operations as part of the Battle of Normandy.

Early life

McNair in 1904's Howitzer, the West Point yearbook. The reference to King William bottles describes a brand of Scotch whisky.

McNair was born in Verndale, Minnesota on May 25, 1883,^[3] the son of James (1846–1932) and Clara (Manz) McNair (1853–1925).^[4] He was the second-born of their six children, and the first son.^[4] His siblings who lived to adulthood were: sister Nora (1881–1971), the wife of Harry Jessup;^[5][6] brother Murray Manz McNair (1888–1976);^[5][7] and sister Irene (1890–1979), the wife of Harry R. Naftalin.^[5][8]

McNair attended school in Verndale through the ninth grade, the highest available locally; his parents then relocated to Minneapolis so McNair and his siblings could complete high school.^[9][10] After graduating from South High School,^[11] he competed successfully for an appointment to the United States Naval Academy.^[9] While he was on the Naval Academy waiting list as an alternate,^[12] he began studies at the Minnesota School of Business in Minneapolis, where he concentrated primarily on mechanical engineering and statistics courses.^[13]

Frustrated with the wait to start at the Naval Academy,^[12] in 1900 McNair applied for admission to the United States Military Academy.^[14] Selected as an alternate in July 1900,^[15] he was subsequently accepted as a member of the class that began that August.^[16] While at West Point, his fellow students nicknamed him "Whitey" for his ash blond hair; they continued to use it with him for the rest of his life.^[10] The description of McNair which accompanied the photo of him in West Point's yearbook for his senior year refers to him as "Pedestrian Whitey" and details an incident when he had to walk from Newburgh to West Point (a distance of 11 miles (18 km)) after having missed the last train while returning from visiting his fiancée in New York City;^[17] the yearbook also contains an anonymously authored poem, "'Whitey's' Record Walk", about the same incident.^[18]

Several of McNair's classmates also went on to prominent careers in the Army, including: George R. Allin;^[19] Charles School Blakely;^[20] Robert M. Danford;^[21] Pelham D. Glassford;^[22] Edmund L. Gruber;^[23] Henry Conger Pratt;^[24] Henry J. Reilly;^[25] Joseph Stilwell;^[26] and Innis P. Swift.^[26] McNair graduated in 1904, and was commissioned as a second lieutenant.^[16] The top five or six graduates usually chose the Engineer branch; McNair's high class standing (11th of 124) earned him a place in the second choice of most high-ranking graduates, the Artillery branch.^[16]

Early career

Proof battery at Sandy Hook Proving Ground, New Jersey where McNair served early in his career. A proof battery enabled testing with different types of artillery. The Sandy Hook firing range extended 3,000 yards along the beach. For long range firing, the guns were aimed out to sea.

McNair was first assigned as a platoon leader with the 12th Battery of Mountain Artillery at Fort Douglas, Utah.^[27] While there, he requested duty with the Ordnance Department, and passed a qualifying examination.^[27] After approval of his transfer request, he was first assigned to Sandy Hook Proving Ground, New Jersey, where he began a lifelong interest in testing and experimenting with new equipment and weapons.^[27] Initially, McNair's Ordnance testing centered on improving the mountain guns used by units including his 12th Battery for artillery support of troops in rugged terrain where limbers and caissons could not travel.^[27]

After assignment to the staff of the Army's Chief of Ordnance from 1905 to 1906, McNair was assigned to the Watertown Arsenal, where he completed self-directed academic studies in metallurgy and other scientific topics.^[28] In this posting, he gained experience with both laboratory and practical methods of experimentation, including analyzing bronze, steel, and cast iron to determine the best materials to use in manufacturing cannons and other weapons.^[28] In addition, he gained firsthand experience with the uses and applications of several foundry machines, including forges, steam hammers, lathes, planing machines, and boring machines.^[28] His business college background in statistical analysis and engineering (including technical drawing) helped make him successful at testing and experimentation; as a result of his experience at Watertown, for the rest of his career the Army frequently relied on him to oversee boards that developed and tested weapons and other equipment, and made recommendations on which items were most suitable for procurement and fielding.^[28] He was promoted to first lieutenant in June 1905 and temporary captain May 1907.^[29] (His captain's rank applied in the Ordnance branch, but not in the Artillery.)^[29]

Pre-World War I

1921 photo of U.S. soldier and pack animal carrying components of a mountain howitzer. McNair designed and experimented with pack saddles and other mountain artillery equipment early in his career.

In 1909, McNair returned to the Artillery branch and was assigned to the 4th Field Artillery Regiment at Fort Russell, Wyoming.^[30] Assigned to command of Battery C, he earned accolades for his leadership skills and technical expertise.^[30] Jacob L. Devers, who was assigned to Battery C after his 1909 West Point graduation, recalled McNair as an outstanding commander who set a superior personal example, and knew how to motivate his subordinates to perform to a high standard.^[30] During his battery command, McNair also worked with mixed success on recommendations to modernize pack howitzers, pack saddles, ammunition carriers, and other equipment (much of it of his own design) for the Army's mule-transported mountain artillery.^[31]

Battery C, 4th Field Artillery during the 1916 Pancho Villa Expedition. McNair commanded Battery C from 1909 to 1912.

McNair's skills in technical drawing, engineering, prototype building, and statistical analysis began to be known Army-wide; in 1912 the commandant of the Field Artillery School requested him by name for assignment to his staff.^[32] Instructors at the school had spent more than a year gathering information on 7,000 rounds fired during tests and field exercises; because the school was short-staffed, the commandant called on McNair to compile the data into firing tables that would make it easier for Artillery crews Army-wide to plan and control indirect fire.^[32] While carrying out this assignment in 1913, he also spent seven months in France to observe and gather information on the French Army's artillery training, education, and employment.^[32] In April 1914, he was promoted to permanent captain.^[33]

From April to November 1914, McNair took part in the Veracruz Expedition as the 4th Field Artillery Regiment's commissary officer. Assigned following another "by name request", this time from regimental commander Lucien Grant Berry, McNair was responsible for procuring, storing, maintaining, accounting for, and distributing the regiment's materiel, including equipment and weapons.^[33] During 1915 and 1916, he was again assigned to the Field Artillery School, where he continued to work on procedures for the implementation of the firing table data he had published.^[33] He also continued to experiment with different types of artillery pieces so he could make manufacturing and procurement recommendations as the Army began to prepare for possible involvement in World War I.^[33] He returned to the 4th Field Artillery Regiment for the Pancho Villa Expedition on the Texas-Mexico border; initially an unassigned staff officer available for additional duties,^[34] he later commanded a battery.^[35] In May 1917, he was promoted to major. From May to August, he was assigned as an instructor for the officer training camp at Leon Springs, Texas.^[36]

World War I

McNair as an AEF brigadier general, 1919.

McNair receives Distinguished Service Medal.

McNair receives Legion of Honor.

In 1917, the United States entered World War I. McNair was assigned to the 1st Division, then located at Camp Stewart, in El Paso County, Texas.^[37] Assigned to the division staff as assistant chief of staff for training, McNair was given responsibility for the organization's pre-deployment mobilization, individual soldier training, and collective unit training.^[38] When the division departed for France, McNair shared quarters aboard ship with the division's assistant chief of staff for operations, George Marshall. During their long ocean voyage, they forged a personal and professional bond which they maintained for the rest of their careers.^[38]

McNair was promoted to temporary lieutenant colonel in August 1917, soon after his arrival in France, and was assigned to the American Expeditionary Forces (AEF) headquarters as chief of artillery training and tactics in the AEF staff's training division (G-5).^[38] He was promoted to temporary colonel in June 1918, and temporary brigadier general in October; at age 35, he was the youngest general officer in the Army.^[39] He continued to impress his superiors with his technical and tactical expertise, and at the end of the war he received the Distinguished Service Medal from John J. Pershing and the French Legion of Honor (Officer) from Philippe Pétain.^[40][41]

In June 1919, McNair was named to the AEF board which was charged with studying the problem of how to provide adequate mobile fire support to infantry during combat.^[42] This panel, called the Lassiter Board after its chairman, Major General William Lassiter, was one of several formed by the AEF to review wartime plans and activities, and make recommendations for the Army's future equipment, doctrine, and training.^[42]

Post-World War I

School of the Line

McNair remained with the Lassiter Board only briefly because he received orders assigning him as one of the faculty members of the Army's School of the Line.^[43] The school had ceased operations during the war and was being re-formed at Fort Leavenworth to offer professional education to field grade officers on planning and overseeing the execution of operations at division level and above.^[44] McNair reverted to his permanent rank of major, and remained on the faculty until 1921.^[45]

In addition to receiving accolades for his work to help design and field the course curriculum, McNair also played a key role in another task traditionally assigned to the School of the Line: developing and promulgating the Field Service Regulations, the Army's main document for codifying training and readiness doctrine.^[46] While on the School of the Line's faculty, he was one of the main authors of the 1923 revision of Field Service Regulations.^[47] The officers who were assigned to the faculty and were responsible for restarting the School of the Line after World War I all received credit for having attended the course, including McNair.^[48]

Hawaiian Department

Newspaper account of McNair testimony at Billy Mitchell's 1925 court-martial.

In 1921, McNair was posted to Fort Shafter and assigned as assistant chief of staff for operations (G-3) at the headquarters of the Army's Hawaiian Department.^[48] While in Hawaii, he became a participant in the Army’s ongoing debate over the best methods for providing coastal defense, which engaged proponents of the Coast Artillery branch and Army Air Service.^[49] Assigned to the project by Hawaiian Department commander Major General Charles Pelot Summerall because of his reputation for objectivity in carrying out analysis and experimentation with military weapons and equipment, McNair created a committee made up of himself, two coast artillery officers, and an aviation officer to investigate the strengths and weaknesses of the two branches, especially with regard to defending Army and Navy bases on Oahu, and make recommendations on the best way to employ coast artillery and military aircraft.^[49]

Coast Artillery sound locators and searchlight, 1932. McNair's report on defending the coasts of Hawaii indicated that sufficient sound detection and illumination equipment like this was critical to success.

The McNair board carried out numerous tests of coast artillery and bomber aircraft in a variety of conditions, and compiled tables and charts to depict the results.^[49] The panel concluded that coastal artillery was sufficient for shore defense, provided that adequate equipment for detecting and illuminating enemy ships was available, and that bombers were less accurate, but more effective at destroying enemy ships at longer distances from shore, provided they could overcome obstacles including inclement weather.^[49]

In addition to his work on the coastal defense problem, McNair was also responsible for directing a review of War Plan Orange, the Army and Navy joint defense plan for countering an attack on Hawaii by Japan. This possibility was a major concern of U.S. military leaders during the years between World War I and World War II.^[50] Among McNair's contributions to updating this plan was the creation of several contingency plans ("branches and sequels" in Army parlance) to augment the main war plan.^[50] These contingency plans included: using chemical weapons to defend against a Japanese attack; declaring martial law in Hawaii; and determining how to maintain a defense against Japanese invaders while waiting for reinforcements from the U.S. mainland.^[50]

In 1924 and 1925, McNair and Summerall defended McNair's work when it was criticized during the continuing debate about the future of the Army Air Service.^[51] The head of the Air Service, Major General Mason Patrick argued that the McNair board's findings underestimated the capabilities of bomber aircraft, and that the data the board had compiled was inaccurate.^[51] In response, Major General Frank W. Coe, the chief of the Coast Artillery Corps, pointed out that McNair's panel included both Coast Artillery and Air Service officers, and that experiments with aircraft had included coast artillery officers as observers.^[51] In addition, the aircrews that had participated in the McNair board experiments had opportunity to provide input and voice concern over the board's methods and conclusions.^[51] Coe concluded his argument by recommending that the McNair board's findings be approved by the Army as its official position on the issue of coastal artillery versus bombers for shore defense.^[51] Coe's recommendation was not followed; subsequent panels and committees continued to investigate and debate the issue.^[51] In addition, the debate continued on the larger question of whether the Air Service should remain a component of the Army or become a separate branch of the military.^[52]

McNair's involvement in the issue continued during the 1925 court-martial of Brigadier General Billy Mitchell, whose zealous advocacy of creating a separate Air Force resulted in accusations of insubordination.^[53] Mitchell based his public assertions about non-aviation officers being ignorant of aviation matters on events he falsely claimed to have witnessed in Hawaii during the McNair board's experiments.^[54] Summerall was so incensed at the questioning of his and McNair's integrity that he attempted to be appointed as president of the court-martial.^[54] During Mitchell's trial, Major General Robert Courtney Davis, the Army's adjutant general, ordered Summerall and McNair to provide testimony.^[54] They refuted Mitchell's claims that during his time in Hawaii in 1923 the Hawaiian Department had no plan to defend Oahu from Japanese attack.^[54] They also demonstrated that Mitchell was incorrect in stating that the Air Service was not treated fairly in the distribution of resources in Hawaii; in fact, Summerall had reallocated funding, equipment and other items from other branches to the Air Service.^[54] Mitchell was convicted, and sentenced to a five-year suspension from active duty.^[55] He resigned from the Army so he could continue to advocate for the creation of a separate Air Force.^[56] Despite the controversy, McNair's work enhanced his reputation as an objective and innovative thinker, planner, and leader, and he was clearly under consideration for positions of increasing rank and responsibility.^[53]

Purdue University

In 1924, McNair was appointed professor of military science and tactics for the Reserve Officers' Training Corps (ROTC) program at Purdue University.^[57] In accordance with the National Defense Act of 1920, ROTC offered a two-year course of instruction for freshmen and sophomores, which was compulsory at many universities, including Purdue.^[58] The program also offered advanced instruction for juniors and seniors who desired to continue military training and possibly earn a commission in the Army Reserve, National Guard, or Regular Army.^[58] In addition to following this academic model, since 1919 Purdue had organized its ROTC cadets as a motorized field artillery unit, a circumstance which played to McNair's strengths.^[59]

McNair's profile in the Purdue University yearbook for 1928.

Purdue's president, Edward C. Elliott, was a strong advocate at the national level for ROTC, and a leading voice in opposition to the pacifist movement which gained strength and influence following World War I.^[60] McNair became an advocate for military preparedness generally and ROTC specifically, and also argued in opposition to the pacifists.^[60] Already a prolific author of professional journal articles on technical military subjects, he authored numerous articles and letters in favor of military training and readiness, and in opposition to the pacifist movement.^[60] He also continued to write on Army-specific subjects, including articles that argued for reforming the Army's officer promotion system to replace seniority with merit as the primary consideration.^[60]

McNair also effected several positive changes to Purdue's ROTC program.^[61] As outlined by Elliott, Purdue ROTC had been the subject of several rapid leadership changes which had resulted in disorganization and low morale.^[61] McNair's leadership, technical expertise, and administrative abilities resulted in enhanced student participation, improved morale, and developed the program into the Army's largest light artillery unit.^[61] When the Chief of Field Artillery attempted to reassign McNair to Fort Bragg, North Carolina, to lead revision the Army's field artillery regulations, Elliott protested; his request to keep McNair until the end of the usual four-year assignment for ROTC professors was granted, and McNair remained at Purdue until 1928.^[61]

Army War College

In 1928, McNair was promoted to lieutenant colonel and entered the United States Army War College.^[62] As the highest-level formal education program for Army officers, in the 1920s the curriculum had been revised so that the program of instruction concentrated on economic, industrial, and logistics issues related to large-scale wartime mobilizations, as well as the doctrine, strategy, and tactics requirements associated with organizing, training, deploying, and employing large scale units for combat (typically division and above).^[63] In addition to completing seminars on staff functions (G-1 for personnel, G-2 for intelligence, G-3 for operations and training, and G-4 for logistics), McNair and his War College classmates served on committees that studied war plans and suggested improvements, reviewed regulations and proposed updates, and studied and discussed strategic-level foreign and defense policy issues to improve their understanding.^[64] Among his classmates were several officers who became prominent during World War II, including: Simon Bolivar Buckner Jr.,^[65] Roy Geiger,^[66] Oscar Griswold,^[67] Clarence R. Huebner,^[68] Troy H. Middleton,^[69] and Franklin C. Sibert.^[70]

Upon graduating, McNair received an evaluation of "superior", with a recommendation from the commandant that he be considered for high command or a senior staff position on the War Department General Staff.^[71] In addition, the commandant forwarded to the War Department McNair's final research project on ways for the department to maximize efficiency when allocating funding for unit training, calling it "a study of exceptional merit made at the War College".^[72]

U.S. Army Field Artillery School

Carlos Brewer, one of three successive chiefs of the Artillery School Gunnery Department who experimented on indirect fire techniques with McNair's support.

After his War College graduation, McNair was assigned as assistant commandant of the Field Artillery Center and School.^[73] In this position, he worked with the school's Gunnery Department to address field artillery doctrine issues that had lingered since World War I, including limited mobility, inadequate communications, and overly detailed fire direction techniques.^[73] Recognizing that continuing improvement to innovations including machine guns and tanks made the static trench warfare of World War I unlikely to be repeated, successive Gunnery Department directors Jacob Devers, Carlos Brewer, and Orlando Ward experimented with new techniques, including increasing the speed of artillery support to mobile armor and infantry by empowering Artillery-qualified fire support officers attached to those formations to direct artillery fire, and enhancing accuracy through artillery fire that could be seen and directed by forward observers rather than the unobserved timed fire and rolling barrages that had prevailed in World War I.^[73] McNair supported these innovations, and prevented interference from senior officers who tried to block them.^[73]

McNair as Assistant Commandant of Ft. Sill in 1929.

Devers, Brewer, and Ward also argued for centrally controlled massing of artillery at the battalion level, instead of the current doctrine of dispersal down to the battery level.^[73] In their view, massing artillery and centrally controlling it from a brigade fire direction center enabled senior commanders to rapidly provide direct support to the areas on the battlefield where it was most needed.^[73] McNair had advocated this tactic since World War I; he again agreed with the Gunnery Department, and worked to help implement this doctrinal change while also protecting the Gunnery Department from outside interference.^[73] Over time, improvements to communications equipment and procedures and changes to doctrine enabled implementation of many of these changes, and they largely became the standard by which field artillery units conducted operations in World War II.^[73]

At the completion of McNair's assignment as deputy commandant in 1933, he received the highest marks on his efficiency report, along with recommendations for promotion to colonel, and assignment to regimental or brigade command.^[74]

Battalion command

McNair commanded 2nd Battalion, 16th Field Artillery Regiment at Fort Bragg from July 1 through October 1, 1933, when organizational changes re-designated the unit as 2nd Battalion, 83rd Field Artillery Regiment.^[74] McNair commanded the renamed unit until August 1934, and led it through its renaming and reorganization.^[74]

Civilian Conservation Corps

Article announcing McNair as Louisiana area CCC Commander.

In August 1934, McNair was assigned to command of Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC) District E, part of the VII Corps Area.^[75] Headquartered at Camp Beauregard, Louisiana, District E was composed of thousands of CCC members based at 33 camps throughout Louisiana and Mississippi.^[75] As with other Regular Army officers who took part in organizing and operating the CCC, McNair's work to plan, direct, and supervise the activities over a wide area gave him practical experience at mobilizing, housing, feeding, providing medical care for, supervising, and improving the physical and mental resilience of thousands of young members.^[75] This experience working with large bodies of men was an asset as McNair ascended into the Army's senior ranks.^[75] In addition, McNair benefited from the experience of working with civilian government leaders to plan and direct CCC activities, which was also put to good use in his later assignments as one of the Army's highest-level commanders.^[75] He was promoted to colonel in May 1935.^[76]

Executive officer to the Chief of Field Artillery

25 mm Hotchkiss anti-aircraft gun. McNair experimented with Hotchkiss anti-tank and anti-aircraft guns while assigned to the office of the Chief of Field Artillery.

With his promotion to colonel, McNair was assigned as executive officer for the Army's Chief of Field Artillery.^[77] In addition to carrying out the usual administrative duties of the position, such as managing the chief's appointment calendar and handling his correspondence, McNair was able to continue experimenting with and testing field artillery equipment and weapons, including trips to Aberdeen Proving Ground in Maryland to test the Hotchkiss Anti-Tank Gun and Hotchkiss Anti-Aircraft Gun.^[77] He also studied and authored articles on the use of autogyros for field artillery targeting and indirect fire observation, which anticipated the use of helicopters in modern warfare.^[77] In January 1937, McNair was promoted to brigadier general.^[78]

Brigade command

In March 1937, McNair was assigned to command of the 2nd Field Artillery Brigade, a unit of the 2nd Infantry Division, then based at Fort Sam Houston, Texas.^[79] The Army continued to experiment with equipment, weapons, and organizational design as it moved towards mechanization and modernization; the Army Chief of Staff directed tests of the triangular division concept (as opposed to the square division of World War I) through creation of a Proposed Infantry Division (PID).^[80] The 2nd Infantry Division was selected to conduct the tests, and McNair performed additional duty as the PID's chief of staff.^[80] In this position, he managed and supervised the PID's design, field tests, after action reviews, and reports and recommendations to the War Department.^[80]

The triangular division model was adopted, and became the Army's standard design for infantry divisions in World War II.^[81] In his annual performance appraisal, his division commander, Major General James K. Parsons, rated McNair as superior, and recommended him for assignment as a corps or army chief of staff.^[82] On the question of how McNair compared to his peers (unique to the appraisals of general officers), Parsons rated McNair second of the 40 generals personally known to him.^[82] McNair remained in command of the 2nd Field Artillery Brigade until March 1939, when he was appointed to serve as commandant of the Command and General Staff College.^[83]

Command and General Staff College

Percy B. Bishop. As commander of the VII Corps Area, he evaluated McNair's command of Ft. Leavenworth and ranked him first of more than 30 brigadier generals he knew personally. McNair routinely received the highest possible ratings on his performance appraisals.

The Chief of Staff of the Army, General Malin Craig, selected McNair to command the Command and General Staff College because he believed its teaching methods needed to be updated, and that the combat unit planning and reporting processes it taught needed to be streamlined. Craig felt that McNair's background made him ideally suited to lead this effort;^[84] in addition, Craig's deputy, Brigadier General George Marshall, believed that the Command and General Staff College program of instruction was too rigid and too focused on a staff process geared towards leadership of Regular Army units.^[85] In Marshall's view, the curriculum needed to be overhauled to reflect the likely needs of the World War II army, including faster, more flexible methods for planning and execution of large scale mobilizations, and incorporation of processes for training draftees and members of the National Guard, who would report for duty with less training and experience than members of the Regular Army.^[85] In addition, Marshall wanted to ensure that graduates were prepared to plan and execute the offensive maneuver-based operations Army leaders anticipated would characterize World War II, as opposed to the defensive trench warfare of World War I.^[85]

In addition to modernizing the curriculum, McNair reduced the course length to accommodate the civilian schedules of National Guard and Reserve officers, many of whom would otherwise be unable to attend.^[86] While working to update and streamline the curriculum, McNair updated the Army's core doctrine, the Field Service Manual. He began his service as commandant in time to finalize publication of the 1939 edition, which was divided into three Field Manuals (FMs): FM 100-5, Operations; FM 100-10, Administration; and FM 100-15, Large Units.^[87] Because of criticism of the 1939 edition, McNair almost immediately began work on an update, with Marshall, now the Army's Chief of Staff, directing that it be published no later than January 1, 1941.^[88] The work on the 1941 edition was still in progress when McNair was again reassigned; when it was published it became the primary doctrinal document for the Army's World War II activities.^[89] His efficiency reports continued to reflect his superior performance; for the first appraisal he received while commandant, Craig rated McNair second of the 41 brigadier generals he knew.^[90] In an evaluation of his performance for his additional duty as commander of the Fort Leavenworth post, Major General Percy Poe Bishop, the commander of the VII Corps Area rated him as fifth of 31. By the time of his second appraisal as commandant, the War Department had waived the requirement for written evaluations on officers supervised directly by the Army Chief of Staff, but in his second role as commander of Fort Leavenworth, Bishop rated McNair as superior in all areas, recommended him for a high level command in combat, and ranked him as first of the more than 30 brigadier generals he knew personally.^[90]

World War II

General Headquarters, United States Army

McNair confers with an umpire during the Louisiana Maneuvers.

In July 1940, McNair began his new assignment as chief of staff for General Headquarters, United States Army (GHQ), the organization the Army created to oversee World War II mobilization, organization, equipping, and training.^[91] Marshall was appointed to command GHQ in addition to his duties as Chief of Staff of the Army; in order to concentrate on his primary role, he largely delegated responsibility for running GHQ to McNair.^[92] As part of this working relationship, Marshall provided McNair broad advice and guidance, and McNair obtained approval from Marshall for the most important decisions.^[92] As GHQ's responsibilities increased following U.S. entry into the war, McNair's responsibilities were encroached upon by members of the War Department staff; for instance, the logistics staff section (G-4) retained authority over corps area commands in matters involving billeting, equipping, and supplying soldiers undergoing mobilization training, which limited GHQ's ability to plan them and oversee their execution.^[93]

In response, McNair proposed establishing GHQ's unity of command over the Army's four field armies and eight corps areas; under his concept, each corps area headquarters would have responsibility for all administrative functions within their areas of responsibility, enabling GHQ and the field armies, corps, and divisions to focus on organizing, training, and administering the mobilized troop units that were preparing to go overseas.^[94] Though Marshall was initially receptive, members of the War Department General Staff disagreed with McNair's proposal, and Marshall concurred with them.^[95]

The small GHQ staff Marshall assembled included representatives from each of the Army's major field branches – Infantry, Field Artillery, Cavalry, Coast Artillery, Armor, Engineers, and Signal,^[96] along with liaison officers representing the National Guard and Army Reserve. As operations tempo increased, the staff expanded to include functional area representatives (G-1, G-2, G-3, and G-4).^[96] Among the individuals who served on the GHQ staff were Lloyd D. Brown, who later succeeded Omar Bradley as commander of the 28th Infantry Division, and Mark W. Clark, who went on to command the 15th Army Group.^[97] McNair's National Guard liaison was Kenneth Buchanan, who later served as assistant division commander of both the 28th and 9th Infantry Divisions, and commanded the Illinois National Guard as a major general after the war.^[97]

McNair listens as Omar Bradley, 82nd Infantry Division commander, explains a scenario to McNair at the Louisiana Maneuvers.

As GHQ chief of staff, McNair played a leading role in planning and conducting the 1940 and 1941 Louisiana Maneuvers and Carolina Maneuvers, large scale war games that enabled the Army to observe and draw conclusions with respect to training, doctrine, leadership, and other items of interest, which in turn led to changes in doctrine, equipment, and weapons.^[98] In addition, these maneuvers were used to identify which senior officers were most capable, enabling the Army to assign the best performers to command and top level staff positions, and relieve or reassign those perceived as less capable. McNair was promoted to temporary major general in September 1940, and temporary lieutenant general in June 1941.^[99]

The War Department also assigned GHQ operational responsibilities, including planning for the defenses of facilities in Iceland, Greenland, and Alaska.^[100] McNair generally delegated the responsibility for this aspect of GHQ activities to his deputy, Brigadier General Harry J. Malony, so that he could concentrate on GHQ's organizational and training responsibilities, but maintained overall control of each role.^[100] McNair established the GHQ on the site of the Army War College (now the location of the National War College) at Washington Barracks (now Fort Lesley J. McNair), as the college had been closed for the duration of the war.^[101] McNair continued to command Army Ground Forces from this location rather than moving into the Pentagon when its construction was completed in 1943.^[101]

Army Ground Forces

McNair at his desk while commanding Army Ground Forces.

AGF creation and operations

In March 1942, the Army eliminated the General Headquarters in favor of three new functional commands: Army Ground Forces (AGF), commanded by McNair; the Army Air Forces (AAF), commanded by Lieutenant General Henry H. Arnold; and the Services of Supply (later the Army Service Forces or ASF), commanded by Lieutenant General Brehon B. Somervell.^[102] McNair's task at AGF was to expand the Army's ground forces from their March 1942 strength of 780,000 officers and men to more than 2.2 million by July 1943,^[102] and more than 8 million by 1945.^[103] His duties grew significantly, and included all Army boards, formal schools, training centers, and mobilization camps, as well as special activities having to do with the four combat arms (Infantry, Field Artillery, Cavalry, and Coast Artillery).^[104] As part of this reorganization, the Army eliminated the branch chief positions which had been responsible for these arms, transferring their authority to McNair.^[104] In addition, he had authority over four new "quasi-arms" which did not fall under the traditional combat arms – Airborne, Armor, Tank Destroyer, and Antiaircraft Artillery.^[104] In addition to Mark Clark, other officers who served on McNair's AGF staff and later achieved prominence included: Alexander R. Bolling; Floyd Lavinius Parks; James T. Duke; Willard Stewart Paul; Lyman Lemnitzer; and Robert A. Hewitt.^[105]

The Army intended for this reorganization to end inter-branch rivalries and competition for pre-eminence and resources; in fact it met with mixed success as advocates for each branch continued to argue among themselves.^[106] Additionally, competition for authority and resources also emerged between the War Department General Staff and the three functional commands, and between the functional commands themselves.^[106] Used to working "hands on", and functioning with the smallest staff possible, McNair largely concentrated on the task at hand, and avoided the rivalries as much as possible.^[107] Despite this approach, he was still involved in controversies with the other functional commands, including an ongoing rivalry over allocation of the best qualified recruits and draftees.^[108]

Personnel recruiting and training

Training

McNair and George S. Patton, commander of I Armored Corps review map during training exercise at Desert Training Center, 1942.

McNair organized and supervised training of individuals with the goal of instructing them in basic soldiering skills, ensuring that they would become proficient generalists prepared for more complex unit training.^[109] Once individuals were qualified, units carried out collective training, beginning with the lowest level, and continuing to build through successive echelons until divisions, corps, and armies were capable of carrying out large scale simulated force against force exercises.^[109] He insisted that training be as close to wartime conditions as possible, including the use of live ammunition, or simulators that replicated live ammunition, so that soldiers and commanders would be prepared to fight once they deployed overseas.^[109]

National Guard

McNair identified difficulty with training National Guard units, chiefly because of their lack of prior military experience other than monthly drills and short annual training periods.^[110] He recommended demobilizing the National Guard; Marshall and the Secretary of War disagreed, partly because they anticipated political backlash, and partly because the manpower they provided was in such demand.^[110] McNair also found National Guard senior commanders wanting; in his view, National Guard officers should not progress beyond the grade of colonel, and professional full-time officers should command at the division level and above.^[110] In this, he was mostly successful; all but two National Guard division commanders were replaced by regular Army officers,^[110] and most National Guard generals carried out stateside assignments, or non-combat overseas assignments.^[111] Some served in roles below division commander (such as assistant division commander), or carried out administrative and training roles, such as provost marshal or school commandant.^[112] In addition, some accepted reductions in rank so they could serve in overseas assignments.^[113]

Fielding army divisions

Original War Department estimates called for the Army to raise, equip, train, and deploy as many as 350 divisions.^[114] Later estimates revised this number downward to between 200 and 220.^[114] A variety of factors, including the entry of the Soviet Union into the war on the sides of the Allies, the need to ensure that enough farmers and agricultural workers were available for food production, and the need to maintain a U.S. workforce large enough to handle the production of weapons, vehicles, ammunition, and other equipment caused Army Chief of Staff Marshall to decide that maintaining the Army's ground combat strength at 90 divisions would strike the balance between too few soldiers to defeat the Axis powers, and so many that there were not enough civilians in the U.S. workforce.^[115]

To accomplish this goal, McNair and the AGF staff created new division manning and equipping tables, which reduced the number of soldiers required to man a division.^[116] By 1945, this initiative had accomplished Marshall's goal by enabling the Army to field 89 divisions with the same number of soldiers required to man 73 divisions in 1943.^[116]

Individual replacement system

As AGF commander, McNair worked to solve the problem of how to integrate replacement soldiers into units that had sustained casualties.^[117] Though soldiers were supposed to be allocated to requesting units based on their qualifications and the priority of the unit, he found that in practice many commanders in the combat theaters used replacement soldiers to form new units, or personally selected individual replacements from personnel centers without regard to their qualifications.^[117] Assigning soldiers to units for which they were not qualified, such as armor crewmen to infantry units, negated the training they had received before going overseas.^[117] To address these concerns, McNair advocated faster qualification of replacement soldiers by reducing their training from six months to 13 weeks.^[118] The War Department reduced the training requirement to 17 weeks, but mandated continued use of the individual replacement system.^[118]

Fort Ord, California, 1941. The AGF established WWII personnel replacement centers at Fort Ord and Fort Meade, Maryland.

Because the AGF had responsibility for implementing the individual replacement system, McNair attempted improvements, including directing the establishment of the Classification and Replacement Division within his command, and streamlining the physical, psychological, and mental criteria used to determine fitness for service.^[119] Issues with the ASF's management of replacement centers within the United States led AGF to establish two new ones at Fort Meade, Maryland, and Fort Ord, California.^[120] Because infantry soldiers suffered disproportionately high casualties in combat, McNair argued for, and ultimately succeeded in, procuring higher quality recruits and draftees for the AGF.^[103][121] In addition, he undertook several initiatives to improve the morale and esprit de corps of infantry soldiers, and enhance the goodwill of the civilian population towards the infantry, including creation of the Expert Infantryman Badge, and implementation of the "Soldier for a Day Initiative", which gave civilian government and business leaders the opportunity to interact with mobilized soldiers before they left the United States for combat assignments.^[122]

These initiatives were not always successful; by late 1944-early 1945, the number of units fighting continuously or nearly continuously caused the replacement system to break down.^[115] As a result, rear echelon soldiers were often pulled from their duties to fill vacancies in front line combat units, and training for some replacement soldiers and units was cut short so they could be rushed into combat.^[115] Some units were worn down to the point of combat ineffectiveness. In others, low morale, fatigue, and sickness became more prevalent.^[115] Overall, although the Individual Replacement System was criticized in the years immediately after the war, more recent assessments have viewed it more favorably.^[123] As one example, a 2013 essay by Robert S. Rush concluded "Success results NOT from rotating organizations in and out of combat but from sustaining those organizations while in combat."^[123]

Recruitment efforts

McNair on the cover of Time magazine (December 1942) as part of AGF public relations effort

McNair attempted to improve recruiting into the AGF through improved public relations.^[124] One initiative as part of this effort was his creation of an office on the AGF staff, the Special Information Section (SIS).^[124] Approximately 12 officers and enlisted soldiers with experience as writers and editors worked in the SIS to promote improved public appreciation for AGF soldiers, especially the infantry.^[124] In addition, the SIS worked with civilian writers and editors, musicians, cartoonists, film makers, and artists who worked in other mediums to enhance the prominence of infantrymen in their work.^[124] As part of this initiative, McNair wrote personally to several leading magazine and newspaper publishers to ask for their aid.^[124]

In another effort to inform the public of the Army's personnel needs and improve the way the AGF was perceived, on Armistice Day in November 1942, McNair delivered a radio address over the Blue Network.^[125] In his remarks, titled "The Struggle is for Survival", McNair described the fighting capability and ruthless attitude of soldiers in the Japanese and German armies, and stated that only similar qualities in American ground troops – by implication, meaning not "the more genteel forms of warfare" practiced by the AAF and ASF – would see the Allies through to victory.^[126] The public response to McNair's remarks was largely favorable, though he did receive some criticism for extreme language that seemed to suggest an unfeeling attitude towards death and destruction.^[125] More importantly, McNair's radio address did little to improve recruiting into the Army Ground Forces; the public may have developed a better appreciation for infantry, armor, and artillery, but volunteers and draftees continued to be attracted to the AAF and ASF, and the AAF and ASF continued to lobby for the bulk of new service members deemed "high quality" to be assigned to them.^[126][127]

African-American soldiers

During World War II, War Department regulations for African Americans required that they be admitted into the Army in numbers proportionate to their share of the population.^[128] In addition, the Army was required to establish segregated African American units in each major branch of the service, and give qualified African Americans the opportunity to earn officer commissions.^[128] The AGF worked to reconcile these requirements with its mission of producing trained soldiers and units that were capable of meeting and defeating the enemy in battle.^[128] To that end, the AGF activated and trained African American units in all major branches of the ground forces, and black soldiers who graduated from officer candidate schools (OCS) were assigned to African American units as they received their commissions.^[128] At the peak of the Army’s expansion in June 1943, there were nearly 170,000 African Americans training at AGF facilities, or about 10.5 percent of its personnel strength.^[128] These figures were in line with the War Department requirements; at the time, African Americans accounted for between 10 and 11 percent of the U.S. population.^[128]

Tank and crew of the 761st Tank Battalion, an African American armor unit organized and trained by the AGF.

Beginning with a small number of African American units in the Regular Army and National Guard, the AGF organized and trained many more, including the African-American 92nd and 93rd Infantry Divisions, and the 2nd Cavalry Division.^[129] By 1943, the AGF had created nearly 300 African American units,^[130] including the 452nd Anti-Aircraft Artillery Battalion, the 555th Parachute Infantry Battalion, and the 761st Tank Battalion.^[131]

The War Department General Staff initially suggested incorporating African Americans into units with white soldiers at a ratio of 1 black to 10.6 whites.^[130] Based on difficulties with completing training and inculcating leadership skills, in large part because the abilities of the recruits were lagging as a result of having grown up in the segregated education system and culture then prevalent in the United States,^[128] McNair advocated for separate battalions of African American soldiers, arguing that they could be more effectively employed in this manner.^[130] In McNair’s construct, such units could be deployed for functions including guarding lines of communication in rear areas and near front lines, or maintained as a reserve by division and corps commanders and committed where they were most needed during combat.^[130] The proposal that was adopted was closer to what McNair had advocated; the AGF compensated for the perceived low quality of recruits with measures such as lengthening the initial training period.^[128] Generally African American officers filled company grade positions as they completed OCS, with white officers holding the field grade and senior command positions.^[132] In cases where there were not enough African Americans, white officers filled the company grade positions as well.^[132]

Anti-tank weapons and doctrine

M3 towed anti-tank gun, the Army's primary anti-armor weapon of the late 1930s and early 1940s.

In terms of unit organization, developing and employing anti-tank weapons, and creating suitable doctrine proved to be an ongoing challenge, for which some historians have faulted McNair.^[133] Marshall favored creation of self-propelled anti-tank weapons; McNair had long favored towed weapons, including the M3 gun.^[134] McNair recognized the limitations of the anti-tank weapons then available, and favored a defensive approach for their use, advocating that units emplace and camouflage them, but official doctrine called for a more offensive mindset.^[134] It also called for anti-tank units to conduct independent operations; McNair favored a combined arms approach.^[135] He believed the use of anti-tank weapons was an economical and efficient means to defeat enemy tanks, and would free up U.S. tanks for wider offensive operations.^[136]

When the M3 anti-tank gun proved to be a less than optimum anti-tank weapon, the Army began development of tank destroyers – self-propelled tracked vehicles which mounted a gun capable of engaging a tank, but which were faster and more maneuverable because they had thinner armor than a tank. When it appeared that the Infantry and Cavalry branch chiefs might subsume proposed tank destroyer units into their own task organizations, Marshall attempted to continue progress on tank destroyer development without generating active dissent by approving creation of the Tank Destroyer Center at Camp Hood.^[135] In practice, the separate Tank Destroyer Center meant that commanders of armor and infantry units had little or no experience with anti-tank weapons, or the most effective way to employ them.^[137]

M10 Tank Destroyer, anti-armor weapon fielded by the U.S. Army in World War II.

After having initially fielded the anti-tank weapon it had available – the M3 towed gun - the Army began to field self-propelled anti-tank weapons, first the M3 Gun Motor Carriage, and then the M10 tank destroyer.^[135] As a result of the Army's inability to resolve the questions of equipment and doctrine, it continued to struggle with efforts to develop viable anti-tank doctrine, and efforts to employ anti-tank guns or tank destroyers as part of combined arms team often proved ineffective.^[135]

The ongoing debate within the Army about which type of anti-tank or tank destroyer weapon to use, and what design specifications ought to be included also hampered the AGF's abilities to field the weapons and provide adequate training.^[138] As a result, during their initial employment and use, AGF observers in combat theaters identified several issues, including some as basic as training ammunition for the M3 Gun Motor Carriage being used unknowingly during combat, which obviously limited its effectiveness.^[139] Over time, commanders in combat resorted to field expedient measures to solve the problems, including learning to employ anti-tank guns and later tank destroyers in mutually supporting positions, and integrating them with infantry and armor units to maximize their effectiveness as part of a combined arms effort.^[140] The AGF in turn incorporated these lessons learned into mobilization training, so that over time soldiers and units deploying for combat were making use of the most up to date doctrine and tactics.^[140]

Tanks

T20 Medium Tank. McNair opposed fielding the T20 in part over over concerns that its weight and space requirements would delay the transport to Europe of other needed equipment due to limited cargo ship availability.

At the start of World War II, the United States fielded the M3 Lee and M4 Sherman as its primary medium tanks.^[141] After action reports from the North African Campaign and other engagements convinced commanders including Jacob L. Devers that the U.S needed to deploy a heavier tank with more firepower in order to counter German Tiger I and Panther tanks.^[142] During his assignment as Chief of Armor earlier in the war, Devers had rejected the M6 heavy tank for being under-powered and under-gunned for its weight and size.^[142] As a result, the Army's Ordnance Department had overseen the creation of the T20 Medium Tank.^[142] In 1942, Devers advocated the immediate shipment of 250 T20s to the European Theater.^[142] McNair opposed this request, still convinced that smaller but heavily armed self-propelled tank destroyers could be employed faster and more effectively, especially when considering factors such as available space on cargo ships transporting weapons and equipment to Europe.^[142] The Army attempted development of an improved version of the T20, the T23, but design flaws kept it from being moved into production.^[143]

In 1943, McNair and other commanders with tank experience succeeded in convincing George Marshall of the need for a tank with more armor and firepower than the M3 and M4.^[142] An improved prototype, the T26, was produced as the M26 Pershing;^[143] the Army ordered and fielded 250 Pershings, but they arrived in Europe too late to have an effect on the conduct of the war.^[143]

Death and burial

McNair after being awarded the Purple Heart in Tunisia in April 1943. His left arm is in a sling under his shirt.

In 1943, McNair traveled to North Africa on an inspection tour of AGF troops in order to acquire firsthand information about the effectiveness of training and doctrine, with the goal of making improvements in AGF's mobilization and training process when possible.^[144] On April 23, he was observing front line troops in action in Tunisia when he sustained shrapnel wounds to his arm and head; a company first sergeant standing nearby was killed.^[145]

McNair deployed to the European Theater in 1944; his assignment was initially undetermined, and Marshall and Dwight Eisenhower, the supreme commander in Europe, considered him for command of the Fifteenth United States Army or the fictional First United States Army Group (FUSAG).^[146] With Lieutenant General George S. Patton, the FUSAG commander, slated to take command of the actual Third United States Army after the invasion, the Army required another commander with a recognizable name and sufficient prestige to continue the Operation Quicksilver deception that masked the actual landing sites for the Invasion of Normandy.^[146] Eisenhower requested McNair as Patton's FUSAG successor, and Marshall approved.^[146]

Lesley J. McNair grave marker, updated to reflect posthumous promotion, dedicated November 11, 2010.

In July 1944, McNair was in France to observe troops in action during Operation Cobra, and add to the FUSAG deception by making the Germans believe he was in France to exercise command.^[146][147] He was killed near Saint-Lô on July 25, when errant bombs of the Eighth Air Force fell on the positions of 2nd Battalion, 120th Infantry, where McNair was observing the fighting.^[148][149] In one of the first Allied efforts to use heavy bombers in support of ground combat troops, several planes dropped their bombs short of their targets.^[148] Over 100 U.S. soldiers were killed, and nearly 500 wounded.^[150]

Grave marker, prior to 2010.

McNair was buried at the Normandy American Cemetery and Memorial in Normandy, France; his funeral was kept secret to maintain the FUSAG deception, and was attended only by his aide, and Generals Omar Bradley, George S. Patton, Courtney Hodges, and Elwood Quesada.^[147][151] When his death was reported by the press, initial accounts indicated he had been killed by enemy fire;^[146] not until August were the actual circumstances reported in the news media.^[146] McNair is the highest-ranking military officer buried at the Normandy cemetery.^[152] Along with Frank Maxwell Andrews, Simon Bolivar Buckner, Jr., and Millard Harmon, he was one of four American lieutenant generals to be killed in World War II.^[153] McNair's tombstone originally indicated his rank of lieutenant general.^[154] In 1954, Buckner and he were posthumously promoted to general by an act of Congress.^[154] The American Battle Monuments Commission (ABMC) was unaware of his promotion; upon being informed in 2010, the ABMC replaced his gravestone with one that indicates the higher rank.^[154]

Hearing loss

While generally in excellent physical condition even as he aged, McNair began to experience hearing loss early in his career.^[155] The condition progressed, and included tinnitus, but did not interfere with his work; physical examinations indicated he had no trouble with tasks including speaking on the telephone.^[155] By the time he reached the ranks of the Army's senior commanders, his hearing loss was severe enough that he compensated by reading lips, and by foregoing participation in events where his difficulty in hearing would pose an obstacle, such as large conferences.^[156] By the late 1930s, he worried that his hearing condition might result in his mandatory retirement for medical reasons.^[157] Instead, Marshall issued a waiver which allowed him to continue to serve.^[157] His hearing loss may have prevented him from obtaining a field command during World War II, but Marshall was unwilling to lose his abilities as an organizer and trainer.^[157]

Legacy

Sign near main gate to Fort McNair, the former Washington Barracks.

McNair was held in high regard by his contemporaries, as evidenced by performance appraisals that routinely gave him the highest possible ratings.^[158] Marshall also held McNair in high esteem,^[159] as demonstrated by the fact that McNair was a top stateside commander during World War II, was considered for a top command in Europe, and was ultimately selected to command the First United States Army Group as part of a deception plan that required a general with a good reputation and high name recognition for successful execution.^[146] In addition, soon after McNair was assigned to serve as commandant of the Command and General Staff School, Marshall learned that he would become the Chief of Staff of the Army.^[159] In a letter to McNair, Marshall wrote: "You at the head of Leavenworth are one of the great satisfactions I have at the moment in visualizing the responsibilities of the next couple of years."^[159] Mark W. Clark served under McNair as operations officer (G-3) at AGF Headquarters before ascending to the general officer ranks.^[160] In his autobiography, Clark referred to McNair as "one of the most brilliant, selfless and devoted soldiers" he had ever encountered.^[160]

McNair's primary legacy was his role as "the brains of the Army", in that his involvement in unit design (the triangular division), education (the Command and General Staff Officer Course), doctrine (updating the Field Service Manual and revising field artillery methods and procedures), weapons design and procurement (experimentation with field artillery, anti-tank weapons, and anti-aircraft weapons), and training of soldiers and units (as commander of Army Ground Forces), especially in the era between World Wars I and II, made him one of the primary architects of the Army as the United States employed it for World War II.^[161]

News story on Purdue's 1941 graduation, including McNair's LL.D.

Another enduring McNair legacy was his training method of beginning with basic soldier skills and then building through successive echelons until large units became proficient during exercises and war games that closely simulated combat.^[109] These concepts remain the Army's core principles for planning, executing, and overseeing individual and collective training.^[109]

McNair Hall, Fort Sill, Oklahoma.

McNair received the honorary degree of LL.D. from Purdue University in 1941 and the University of Maine in 1943.^[162] The Lesley J. McNair Bridge was a temporary structure over the Rhine River in Cologne, Germany;^[163] it stood from 1945 until it was dismantled after the erection of a permanent bridge in 1946.^[164] Washington Barracks in Washington, D.C. was renamed Fort Lesley J. McNair in 1948.^[165] Roads and buildings on several U.S. Army posts carry the name "McNair", including McNair Avenue^[166] and McNair Hall^[167] (Fort Sill), McNair Road (Joint Base Myer–Henderson Hall),^[168] McNair Drive (Fort Monroe),^[169] and McNair Hall (Fort Leavenworth).^[170] McNair Barracks in Berlin, Germany was named for Lesley J. McNair.^[171] The facility was closed as a U.S. military installation in 1994, and has since been redeveloped, but retains a museum which details its use as a U.S. base.^[172] McNair Kaserne in Höchst, Germany was also named in his honor.^[173] It was closed and turned over to the German government when the 17th Signal Battalion moved to Kitzingen in 1992,^[173] and has since been redeveloped as an apartment building.^[173] Veterans of Foreign Wars Post 5263 in Lawton, Oklahoma (near the Fort Sill Artillery Center and School) is named for him.^[174]

McNair was inducted into the Fort Leavenworth Hall of Fame, which was created in 1969 and is managed by the United States Army Combined Arms Center.^[175] The Fort Leavenworth Hall of Fame honors soldiers who were stationed at Fort Leavenworth, and significantly contributed to the Army's history, heritage, and traditions.^[175] In 2005, McNair was inducted into the U.S. Army's Force Development Hall of Fame.^[176]

There is a collection of McNair papers at the National Archives and Records Administration.^[177] Purdue University maintains another folder of papers related to McNair's service there.^[178]

Family

Newspaper announcement of McNair-Huster wedding. Mrs. McNair was born "Clara" but was usually called Clare.

McNair married Clare Huster (1882–1973) of New York City on June 15, 1905.^{[27][179][180]} They were the parents of a son, Douglas (1907–1944).^[180]

McNair and family in 1943. Douglas stands at right. Seated (left) are Douglas's wife Freda and daughter Bonnie Clare. Seated (right) is Clare McNair's.

Clare McNair

After McNair's death, Clare McNair was employed by the United States Department of State to investigate working conditions for female members of the United States Foreign Service Auxiliary, the organization created to augment the Foreign Service during World War II.^[181] She traveled to several foreign locations, including North Africa, Europe, and Latin America to interview employees and observe working conditions in order to make recommendations for improvements.^[181]

Colonel Douglas J. McNair.

Douglas C. McNair

Douglas Crevier McNair was born in Boston, Massachusetts on April 17, 1907, while his father was stationed at the Watertown Arsenal.^[182] He was a 1928 graduate of West Point, and became an artillery officer after initially qualifying in the infantry branch. The younger McNair advanced through command and staff positions to become chief of staff of the 77th Infantry Division with the rank of colonel.^[182] He was killed in action on the island of Guam on August 6, 1944, only 12 days after the death of his father.^[148][182] He died when two other 77th Division soldiers and he became involved in a skirmish with Japanese soldiers while scouting locations for a new division command post.^[182] Douglas McNair posthumously received the Silver Star, Legion of Merit, and Purple Heart.^[182] First interred on Guam, he was later buried at the National Memorial Cemetery of the Pacific in Hawaii.^[183] The 77th Division named its temporary encampment near Agat, Guam "Camp McNair" in his honor.^[184] Another Camp McNair, this one near Fujiyoshida, Japan, served as a U.S. military training facility from the late 1940s until the 1970s, and was used extensively during the Korean War.^[185] In addition, the McNair Village housing development at Fort Hood, Texas was also named for him.^[186] Besides his mother, Douglas McNair was survived by his widow, Freda Louise Elliott (married 1935), and their daughter Bonnie Clare (born 1943).^[182]

Military awards

Lesley McNair's awards and decorations included:^[1][162]

	Army Distinguished Service Medal (with two oak leaf clusters)
	Purple Heart (with one oak leaf cluster)
	Mexican Border Service Medal
	World War I Victory Medal
	American Defense Service Medal
	American Campaign Medal
	European-African-Middle Eastern Campaign Medal
	World War II Victory Medal
	Officer of the Legion of Honor (France)

Note: Two Distinguished Service Medals, one Purple Heart, and the World War II Victory Medal were awarded posthumously.

Dates of rank

Insignia	Rank	Component	Date
No insignia	Cadet	United States Military Academy	August 1, 1900[14]
No insignia in 1904	Second Lieutenant	Regular Army	June 15, 1904[14]
	First Lieutenant	Regular Army	May 20, 1907[29]
	Captain	Regular Army (Temporary)	May 20, 1907[29]
	First Lieutenant	Regular Army	July 1, 1909[30]
	Captain	Regular Army	April 9, 1914[33]
	Major	Regular Army	May 15, 1917[38]
	Lieutenant Colonel	National Army (Temporary)	August 5, 1917[38]
	Colonel	National Army (Temporary)	June 26, 1918[39]
	Brigadier General	National Army (Temporary)	October 1, 1918[39]
	Major	Regular Army	July 16, 1919[43]
	Lieutenant Colonel	Regular Army	January 9, 1928[187]
	Colonel	Regular Army	May 1, 1935[76]
	Brigadier General	Regular Army	January 1, 1937[78]
	Major General	Army of the United States (Temporary)	September 25, 1940[188]
	Major General	Regular Army (Permanent)	December 1, 1940[189]
	Lieutenant General	Army of the United States (Temporary)	June 9, 1941[99]
	General	Regular Army (Posthumous)	July 19, 1954[190]

Works by McNair

(Partial list)

• "The R.O.T.C.". The Coast Artillery Journal. Fortress Monroe, VA: U.S. Army Coast Artillery School. February 1928. pp. 172–175. 
• "And Now The Autogiro" (PDF). The Field Artillery Journal. Washington, DC: United States Field Artillery Association. January–February 1937. pp. 5–17. 
• "Radio Address: The Struggle is for Survival; The Importance of Training and Personnel". ibiblio.org/. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina. November 11, 1942. 

References

Sources

Books

• Adams, John A. (2015). General Jacob Devers: World War II's Forgotten Four Star. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press. ISBN 978-0-253-01517-4. 
• Air Force Judge Advocate General's School (1990). The Air Force Law Review. Washington, DC: United States Air Force. 
• American Battle Monuments Commission. Normandy Cemetery and Memorial (PDF). Washington, DC: ABMC. Retrieved March 20, 2017. 
• Axelrod, Alan (2007). Encyclopedia of World War II. 1. New York, NY: Facts on File, Inc. ISBN 978-0-8160-6022-1. 
• Calkin, Homer L. (September 1, 1978). Women in the Department of State: Their Role in American Foreign Affairs (PDF). Washington, DC: United States Department of State. 
• Calhoun, Mark T. (2015). General Lesley J. McNair: Unsung Architect of the US Army. Lawrence, KS: University Press of Kansas. ISBN 978-0-7006-2069-2. 
• Cameron, Robert Stewart (2008). Mobility, Shock, and Firepower: The Emergence of the U.S. Army's Armor Branch, 1917–1945. Washington, DC: Center of Military History, U.S. Army. 
• Carafano, James Jay (2000). After D-Day: Operation Cobra and the Normandy Breakout. Mechanicsburg, PA: Stackpole Books. ISBN 978-0-8117-3487-5. 
• Curator, Fort Sam Houston Museum (1990). Camp Bullis: A History of the Leon Springs Military Reservation, 1890–1990. Camp Bullis, TX: Fort Sam Houston Museum. 
• Davis, Henry Blaine Jr. (1998). Generals in Khaki. Raleigh, NC: Pentland Press. ISBN 978-1-57197-088-6. 
• Ent, Uzal W. (1996). Fighting on the Brink: Defense of the Pusan Perimeter. Paducah, KY: Turner Publishing Company. ISBN 978-1-56311-209-6. 
• Gabel, Christopher R. (September 1, 1985). Seek, Strike and Destroy: US Army Tank Destroyer Doctrine in World War II. Ft. Leavenworth, KS: Combat Studies Institute, U.S. Army Command and General Staff College. 
• Gore, James Howard (1922). American Legionnaires of France. Washington, DC: W. F. Roberts Co. 
• Greenfeld, Kent Roberts; Palmer, Robert R.; Wiley, Bell I. (1987). United States Army in World War II: The Army Ground Forces; The Organization of Ground Combat Troops (PDF). Washington, DC: Center of Military History, U.S. Army. 
• Haskew, Michael E. (2015). Tank: 100 Years of the World's Most Important Armored Military Vehicle. Walker, MI: Zenith Press. ISBN 978-0-7603-4963-2. 
• History Division, Headquarters III Corps and Fort Hood (January 25, 1991). FH PAM 870-1: Fort Hood Memorializations (PDF). Fort Hood, TX: Headquarters III Corps and Fort Hood. 
• Matloff, Maurice (1990). Command Decisions: The 90 Division Gamble. Washington, DC: Center of Military History, U.S. Army. 
• McNair, James Birtley (1955). McNair, McNear, and McNeir Genealogies: 1955 Supplement. Los Angeles, CA: Westernlore Press. 
• Mushaben, Joyce Marie (2008). The Changing Faces of Citizenship: Integration and Mobilization Among Ethnic Minorities in Germany. New York, NY: Berghahn Books. ISBN 978-1-84545-468-5. 
• Onofrio, Jan (2000). Kansas Biographical Dictionary. St. Clair Shores, MI: Somerset Publishers, Inc. ISBN 978-0-403-09313-7. 
• Nineteen Hundred and Four Howitzer Board (1904). The Howitzer. West Point, NY: United States Military Academy. 
• Palmer, Robert R.; Wiley, Bell I.; Keast, William R. (1991). United States Army in World War II: Army Ground Forces; The Procurement and Training of Ground Combat Troops (PDF). Washington, DC: Center of Military History, U.S. Army. 
• Palmer, Robert R. (September 1, 1945). Army Ground Forces Study No. 8: Reorganization of Ground Troops for Combat. Washington, DC: Historical Section – Army Ground Forces. 
• Patton, George S.; Harkins, Paul D. (1975) [1947]. War as I Knew it. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin Company. ISBN 978-0-395-73529-9. 
• Price, Frank James (1974). Troy H. Middleton: A Biography. Baton Rouge, LA: Louisiana State University Press. ISBN 978-0-8071-2467-3. 
• Tucker, Spencer C. (2016). World War II: The Definitive Encyclopedia and Document Collection. I. Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO. ISBN 978-1-4408-4593-2. 
• Seventy-Seventh Division Association (1947). Ours to Hold it High: The History of the 77th Infantry Division in World War II. Washington, DC: Infantry Journal Press. 
• Wiley, Bell I. (1946). The Training of Negro Troops: Army Ground Forces Study No. 36 (PDF). Washington, DC: Center of Military History, United States Army. 
• Zaloga, Steve (2008). Armored Thunderbolt: The U.S. Army Sherman in World War II. Mechanicsburg, PA: Stackpole Books. ISBN 978-0-8117-0424-3. 

Internet

• Calhoun, Mark T. (2012). "General Lesley J. McNair: Little-Known Architect of the U.S. Army" (PDF). kuscholarworks.ku.edu/. Lawrence, KS: University of Kansas. 
• "Minnesota Death Index, 1908–2002, entry for Nora M. Jessup". Ancestry.com. Provo, UT: Ancestry.com, LLC. Retrieved March 19, 2017. (Subscription required (help)). 
• "California Death Index, 1940–1997, entry for Irene Naftalin". Ancestry.com. Provo, UT: Ancestry.com, LLC. Retrieved March 19, 2017. (Subscription required (help)). 
• "Memorial, Douglas C. McNair". apps.westpointaog.org/. West Point Association of Graduates. Retrieved March 20, 2017. 
• Hall, Jeff (2011). "Memorial, Col. Douglas Crevier McNair". Find A Grave.com. Provo, UT: Ancestry.com, LLC. 
• "Burial record, Clare H. McNair". Arlington National Cemetery. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of the Army. Retrieved March 20, 2017. 
• "Information Page, VFW Post 5263". VFW: Posts; Oklahoma; Post 5263. Kansas City, MO: Veterans of Foreign Wars. Retrieved March 20, 2017. 
• "Fort Lesley J. McNair History" (PDF). Military District of Washington. Washington, DC: U.S. Army. Retrieved March 20, 2017. 
• "McNair Kaserne". mcnairkaserne.org/. Doug Otoupal. Retrieved March 20, 2017. 
• "Awards, Lesley James McNair". Hall of Valor. Springfield, VA: Military Times. Retrieved March 20, 2017. 
• "Memorial, Lesley J. McNair 1904". apps.westpointaog.org/. West Point, NY: West Point Association of Graduates. Retrieved March 20, 2017. 
• Thayer, Bill. "Transcription of Entries in Biographical Register of the Officers and Graduates of the United States Military Academy at West Point". penelope.uchicago.edu/. Bill Thayer. Retrieved August 27, 2016. 
• Calhoun, Mark T. (2015). "Product page, General Lesley J. McNair: Unsung Architect of the U. S. Army". kansaspress.ku.edu/. Lawrence, KS: University Press of Kansas. 
• "Force Development Hall of Fame". www.fa50.army.mil/. Washington, DC: U.S. Army. Retrieved March 21, 2017. 
• Combined Arms Center. "Fort Leavenworth Fall of Fame". usacac.army.mil/. Fort Leavenworth, KS: United States Army. Retrieved March 21, 2017. 
• "Lesley J. McNair papers, 1928". Purdue University Libraries, Archives and Special Collections. West Lafayette, IN: Purdue University. Retrieved March 22, 2017. 
• "McNair, Lesley James, 1883–1944: Person Authority Record". catalog.archives.gov/. College Park, MD: National Archives and Records Administration. Retrieved March 22, 2017. 
• Carey, Brian Todd (October 29, 2015). "The Tragic Death of General Lesley J. McNair During Operation Cobra". Warfare History Network. McLean, VA: Sovereign Media. 
• "Lt.Gen. Lesley McNair Bridge". Dig It. Cologne, Germany: Westdeutscher Rundfunk. Retrieved March 23, 2017. 
• "Contact Us". Fort Sill, Oklahoma. Ft. Sill, OK: U.S. Army Fires Center of Excellence. Retrieved March 23, 2017. 
• "Home Page: TRADOC Analysis Center". www.trac.army.mil/. Ft. Leavenworth, KS: U.S. Army Training and Doctrine Command. Retrieved March 23, 2017. 
• Ricks, Thomas E. (November 27, 2013). "A few words in favor of the much-derided individual replacement system for soldiers". Voices: Thomas E. Ricks. Washington, DC: Foreign Policy magazine. 
• "General George Marshall’s WWII Career". World War II. Largo, FL: Armed Forces History Museum. April 17, 2013. 
• Sibert Family (1980). "Memorial page: Franklin C. Sibert 1912". apps.westpointaog.org/. West Point, NY: West Point Association of Graduates. 

Magazines

• Aultman, Dwight E. (April–June 1916). "Field Artillery Directory: Regular Army" (PDF). Field Artillery Journal. Washington, DC: United States Field Artillery Association. 
• Zdon, Al (February 1, 2015). "Minnesota American Legion Military Hall of Fame: Lesley J. McNair" (PDF). The Legionnaire. Saint Paiul, MN: Minnesota American Legion and Auxiliary. 

Newspapers

• "Town Notes: Walter B. Congdon and Lesley McNair". Bemidji Pioneer. Bemidji, MN. May 31, 1900. (Subscription required (help)). 
• "Houlton and Woolnough: They Are Recommended for Cadetships". Saint Paul Globe. Saint Paul, MN. July 17, 1900. (Subscription required (help)). 
• McEvoy, William J. (December 18, 1925). "Five Year Suspension for Billy Mitchell". Lebanon Daily News. Lebanon, PA. United Press. (Subscription required (help)). 
• "Erickson Resigns as Draft Director: Accepts Colonelcy in U.S. Army". North Adams Transcript. North Adams, MA. June 17, 1942. (Subscription required (help)). 
• "Billy Mitchell's Resignation was Accepted Today". Lebanon Daily News. Lebanon, PA. United Press. January 29, 1926. (Subscription required (help)). 
• "Gen. McNair Killed in Action". Dixon Evening Telegraph. Dixon, IL. Associated Press. July 27, 1944. (Subscription required (help)). 
• "McNair Unable to Visit Sisters On Trip Here Last Year". Minneapolis Star Tribune. Minneapolis, MN. July 28, 1944. (Subscription required (help)). 
• "George L. Eubanks Now On Rhine". Mexia Weekly Herald. Mexia, TX. July 6, 1945. (Subscription required (help)). 
• "Postwar Duties for Stackpole". The Evening News. Harrisburg, PA. July 21, 1945. (Subscription required (help)). 
• "Col. Abendroth Pledges His Best to D.C. Guard". The Sunday Star. Washington, DC. July 17, 1949. (Subscription required (help)). 
• "High Ranking Fighting Men Lost in Two Wars". Chicago Tribune. Chicago, IL. December 24, 1950. 
• "Death notice, Murray M. Manz". Minneapolis Star Tribune. Minneapolis, MN. August 8, 1976. (Subscription required (help)). 
• McVeigh, Alex (June 12, 2008). "2,000 Troops Run for Army Birthday". www.army.mil/. Washington, DC: U.S. Army. 
• Guthrie, Monica K. (July 23, 2015). "Fort Sill welcomes its new chief of staff". Fort Sill Cannoneer. Ft. Sill, OK. 
• Sprock, Phyllis (Jun 6, 2011). "Street names on Fort Monroe reveal post’s past". The Peninsula Warrior. Norfolk, VA. 
• Dougherty, Devon (May 29, 2016). "General McNair: Verndale man made the U.S. a superpower". Wadena Pioneer Journal. Wadena, MN. 

External links

• "Film clip: Lieutenant General Lesley James McNair receives posthumous recognition in the United States". CriticalPast. Reston, VA: CriticalPast, LLC. Retrieved March 20, 2017. 
• "Film clip: Lieutenant General Lesley J. McNair visits the 20th Army headquarters in Naples, Italy". CriticalPast. Reston, VA: CriticalPast, LLC. Retrieved March 20, 2017. 
• Dodge, Russ (August 4, 2010). "Memorial, Lesley J. McNair". Find A Grave. Provo, UT: Ancestry.com, LLC. 
• Evans, John (October 2, 2011). "Memorial, Clare Huster McNair". Find A Grave. Provo, UT: Ancestry.com, LLC. 
• "Awards, Lesley J. McNair". en.ww2awards.com/. Badhoevedorp, Netherlands: World War 2 Awards.com. Retrieved March 20, 2017. 

Wikimedia Commons has media related to Lesley J. McNair.