Emily Williams (architect)

Emily Eolian Williams (1869–1942) was an early pioneering woman in architecture^[1] who was active in Pacific Grove, San Jose and San Francisco in the early 20th century, at a time, when very few women were able to enter the profession.^[2][3] She mainly designed houses, with conveniently planned interiors, and a few institutional buildings and an exhibition stand at the Panama-Pacific International Exposition in San Francisco.

Family and Educational Background

The daughter of Edward Williams, president of the San Jose Water Works, and his first wife, Emily nee Miree, Emily Williams attended the California State Normal School in San Jose, today San Jose State University, and became a teacher in the Midway District, Santa Clara. She also studied at the University of the Pacific and, from 1892-93 to 1893-94, at the newly opened Leland Stanford University in Palo Alto. Around 1898, she met Lillian McNeill Palmer.^[4] They discovered mutual interests and became lifelong partners. After Emily’s father died in 1899, she moved in with the Palmer family and Lillian’s parents, Donald and Annie Palmer, accepted her as a family member. Actually, in the 1910 US Census, she is listed as an “adopted“ daughter of the Palmers.^[5] Lillian encouraged Emily to pursue her dream of becoming an architect and Emily supported Lillian's desire for journalism and metal artistry.^[6]

Architectural Education

In 1901, the two women moved to San Francisco where Emily studied for a semester drafting and architecture at a high school, the California School of Mechanical Arts, now the Lick-Wilmerding High School.^[7] There she encountered a science teacher, Lilian Bridgman, who also aspired to become an architect and had already designed her own house with the encouragement of architect Bernard Maybeck. This quite likely encouraged Emily to continue her pursuit of architecture.^[2] However, her modest architectural training does not compare to that of Julia Morgan who earned a Bachelor of Science in Civil Engineering from UC Berkeley after four years of study and a Certificate from the Ecole des Beaux-Arts in Paris, the highly regarded architectural school.^[8] Emily's projects remained small-scale and mainly domestic.

After her studies, Emily tried to find a job as an architectural “draftsman” but was rejected as women were thought as not belonging in architecture. In order to gain experience, she used an inheritance from her father to build a small cottage in Pacific Grove with Lillian's help.^[9] The two women, who completed all the work “with their own fair hands” without the help of craftsmen, received attention from the press and soon became a tourist attraction. The cottage is still inhabited today.

Practice as a Residential Designer in Pacific Grove and San Jose

Emily’s first client was her older sister, Edith, who believed in Emily's abilities and commissioned three cottages on adjacent lots as income property. Further commissions came from acquaintances of the Williams family and feminists such as Dr. Anna Lukens who wanted to avoid the harsh winters of New York and spend time in mild California.^[10] Another client was the well-off Mrs. Lucy Pray who wanted her daughter to have a college education at the University of California. She commissioned a house in Berkeley so that her daughter could live at home while studying.^[11] Another prominent client was Mrs. Jessie Jordan, wife of Stanford University President David Starr Jordan, who commissioned Emily to design a house for them in nearby Carmel while her husband was travelling.^[12] The Jordans knew Emily from the time she studied at Stanford. Donald and Annie Palmer, the parents of Lillian, asked her to design a house at 66 South Priest (now 66 South Fourteenth) Street in San Jose, where Lillian and Emily lived at times.^[13] This house, a listed historic property, is today known as the Arthur Monroe Free House, named after its second owner, a lawyer and US Representative.^[14]

Role Model

Emily also served as a role model for at least one woman desiring to become an architect.^[2] In 1907, Emily designed a large house in San Francisco for Mrs. Gertrude Austin, a former resident of San Jose who knew the Williams family. While the design of the house was underway, the young Elizabeth Austin, then a student of architecture at the University of California at Berkeley, may have been able to participate in the discussion of the project between her mother and the architectural designer, Emily Williams, and observe the construction.

Publicity

Small notices in the local Pacific Grove Daily Review and other dailies and an article in the San Jose Mercury and Herald – probably written by Lillian Palmer, who worked for the Mercury – resulted in commissions in Pacific Grove, Carmel, San Jose, San Francisco, and Berkeley ^[2][3] (see list below). Emily also designed two investment properties for herself and Lillian which, in the end, did not produce the anticipated financial gains as they could not maintain the necessary payments and had to sell them.

Designs of Public Buildings

With the help of a benefactor, Etta Belle Lloyd, Emily received two public commissions in Pacific Grove.  The first, in 1907, was from the Woman’s Civic Club to design a public “Look-Out” on a rocky promontory in the Pacific Ocean called Lovers Point.^[15][16] The second commission, a few years later, was to remodel two large wooden cabins into an attractive club house for the Woman’s Civic Club.^[17] Despite the publicity generated by these projects, Emily did not seem to have gained any new clients from the woman’s club.^[18][19]

Travel and Move to San Francisco

In 1908, Emily and Lillian traveled to Europe and Asia for pleasure and study.^[20] In Vienna, Emily studied classical architecture and Lillian metal work. On their return, they settled in San Francisco and Lillian was successful producing and selling her metal artwork at "The Palmer Shop".^[21] Emily received only a few commissions but built their own home at 1037 Broadway and a weekend cabin “Wake Robins” in the Santa Cruz Mountains. Around 1920, the Palmers moved to Los Gatos and Emily designed a house for herself and Lillian on the same property. They lived in the Santa Cruz Mountains during the Great Depression while they rented out their San Francisco and Los Gatos houses for income. Around 1914, Emily received a most unusual commission for an exhibition stand for the Alaska Garnet Mining and Manufacturing Company which was owned and run by twelve women from St. Paul, Minnesota. The connection was quite likely established through Don Palmer, a mining engineer and father of Lillian Palmer. Unfortunately, no photos of the design have been found.

The Women’s Network

As earlier in Pacific Grove, Emily networked through the women’s network such as the Pacific Grove Woman’s Civic Club, and in San Francisco the Business and Professional Woman’s Club which was founded by Lillian Palmer. She used the Club’s newsletter The Business Woman for an advertisement geared especially to women:^[22]

Like a Dress, Ready-Made Buildings Are Seldom Made To Fit

Architecturally Designed Dwellings

Mean Real Homes

A well-planned structure, whether a concrete building or a week-end

cabin, should to the smallest detail, suit your individual needs.

Before you build

Consult

EMILY WILLIAMS

Despite these networking efforts, Emily received only a few commissions in the early 1920s, and appears to have stopped working as an architect in 1924. Emily Williams died in 1942 in Los Gatos, suffering from lifelong asthma, and is buried at the Los Gatos Memorial Park, San Jose, California. She was eulogized by a moving obituary, probably written by her partner Lillian.^[23][24]

“Death Wednesday morning, June 3, brought to a close the colorful life and career of Miss Emily E. Williams, beloved clubwoman and Los Gatos resident whose girlhood determination to establish women's rights in the business world led to personal success as an architect and gave inspiration to all women careerists.

With her death is also severed a "life-partnership" with Miss Lillian Palmer, whose own similar ideals concerning women's rights first aligned the two women together and formed the basis for a friendship of forty-four years duration... “

List of Known Buildings Designed by Emily E. Williams

Original Project Name           Street                                  City                Date

Williams-Palmer House/Cottage         246 Chestnut Street                     Pacific Grove       1903

Edith Williams 1st House                 242 Chestnut St                         Pacific Grove       1904

Edith Williams 2nd House                241 Alder St                             Pacific Grove       1904

Edith Williams 3rd House                243 Alder St                             Pacific Grove       1904

Pray House                               1325 Spruce                             Berkeley            1904

Foote House                              475 Spencer Avenue                    San Jose            1906

House near Beach (not found)           beach                                    Carmel              1906

Sequoia Lodge by the Sea

(Dr. Anna Lukens House)                  529 Ocean View Boulevard           Pacific Grove       1906

Don Palmer House                     66 S. Priest now S. 14th Street      San Jose            1906

Austin House                            2728 Union Street                       San Francisco     1907

Lillian Palmer House                    218 Chestnut                                  Pacific Grove 1907

Emily Williams House                   220 Chestnut                                   Pacific Grove 1907

Jordan House                           NE corner of Camino Real & 7th    Carmel                1907

W.B. Richards House                         119 Grand Avenue Pacific Grove 1907

Pacific Grove Lookout                  Lovers' Point near Japanese Tea

     Garden Pacific Grove       1907

House for a prominent man            (not located)                                   Berkeley   1909

House in an interior town               (not located)                             ?                    1909

Wright House                                     1715 Dayton Avenue Alameda 1909

Deer Park Inn Remodel                Highway 89/Alpine Meadows Rd  Tahoe City          1909

"Wake Robin" Weekend House        Black Road                              Santa Cruz          1910

Pac. Grove Woman's Civic Club        172 Grand Avenue   Pacific Grove 1910

Howell House                                     245 Ocean View Blvd.                   Pacific Grove        1911

McIntire House                                   117 S.17th Street San Jose 1913

Williams-Palmer House                 1037 Broadway                          San Francisco      1913

PPIE exhibition booth                   Palace of Varied Industries, PPIE San Francisco      1914-15

Williams-Palmer House, Addition of   1037-39 Broadway                      San Francisco      1921

second story 

Additions to TenWinkel Cottage         1071-73 Lombard St                    San Francisco      1922

Hill House                                     426 36th Avenue San Francisco 1923

Cassidy House                          424-26 Mississippi                       San Francisco      1924

Kennedy House                         1027-31 Broadway                      San Francisco      1924 

Williams-Palmer House     151 Whitney Avenue        Los Gatos         pre 1924

Recognition

An article published in the San Jose Mercury and Herald on November 11, 1906, stated: "Miss Williams' houses have won her an enviable reputation... They are not only beautiful and artistic, but convenient, livable and planned to save steps and with places to put things." The article explained that Williams' interiors were better than those designed by men.^[6]

See also

• Women in architecture

References

Literature

• Women as Architects - With Special Application to Miss Emily Williams, San Jose's Successful Woman Architect, Sunday San Jose Mercury and Herald, 1906-11-11, p.19/5.
• Douglas, Jack, Lillian McNeill Palmer: Naglee Park Artisan, Naglee Park Campus Community Advisor, Spring 2001, http://www.nagleepark.org/pdf/AdvisorSpring2001.pdf, retrieved 8-8-2017
•  Douglas, Jack, Naglee Park Home Added to the National Register, Naglee Park Campus Community Advisor, Spring 2002, http://www.nagleepark.org/pdf/AdvisorSpring2002.pdf, retrieved 8-8-2017.
• Douglas, Jack, Emily Williams, Architect and Feminist, Naglee Park Campus Community Advisor, June 2003, http://www.nagleepark.org/pdf/AdvisorSpr2003.pdf, retrieved 8-8-2017.
• Horton, Inge S., Emily Williams, San Jose’s First Woman Architect, Continuity, V. 17, no. 4 (Winter 2006): p15-16, http://www.preservation.org/newsletters/winter2006.pdf, retrieved 8-8-2017.
• Allaback, Sarah, The First American Women Architects, University of Illinois Press, Urbana, IL, 2008, p. 229-230.
•  Diehl, Sarah J., "Emily E. Williams (1869–1942): Early Pacific Grove Architect", Heritage Society of Pacific Grove, 2009, 2
•  Horton, Inge Schaefer, Early Women Architects of the San Francisco Bay Area: The Lives and Work of Fifty Professionals, 1890–1951, 2010, McFarland & Company, Jefferson, NC, ISBN 978-0-7864-4656-8.
• Horton, Inge S., "Emily Williams: San Jose's First Woman Architect", Newsletter of PAC San Jose, Vol.17, No.4. Retrieved 5 March 2012.
• Susan Dinkelspiel Cerny, An Architectural Guidebook to San Francisco and the Bay Area, Gibbs Smith, 2007. p. 208.
• Ulleseit, Linda, Under the Almond Trees, 2014, Flying Horse Books, Independent Publishing Platform, ISBN 978-1499252200.