Osteogenesis imperfecta

Osteogenesis imperfecta
Synonyms	Brittle bone disease,[1] Lobstein syndrome,[2] fragilitas ossium, Vrolik disease[1]
The classic blue sclerae of a person with osteogenesis imperfecta
Specialty	Pediatrics, medical genetics, osteology
Symptoms	Bones that break easily, blue tinge to the whites of the eye, short height, loose joints, hearing loss[1][3]
Duration	Long term[3]
Causes	Genetic (autosomal dominant, new mutation)[1]
Diagnostic method	Based on symptoms, DNA testing[3]
Treatment	Healthy lifestyle (exercise, no smoking), metal rods through the long bones[4]
Prognosis	Depends on the type[3]
Frequency	1 in 15,000 people[1]

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI), also known as brittle bone disease, is a group of genetic disorders that mainly affect the bones. It results in bones that break easily. The severity may be mild to severe.^[1] Other symptoms may include a blue tinge to the whites of the eye, short height, loose joints, hearing loss, breathing problems, and problems with the teeth.^[1][3]

The underlying mechanism is usually a problem with connective tissue due to a lack of type I collagen. This occurs in more than 90% of cases due to mutations in the COL1A1 or COL1A2 genes. These genetic problems are often inherited from a person's parents in an autosomal dominant manner or occur via a new mutation. There are eight types with type I being the least severe and type II the most severe.^[1] Diagnosis is often based on symptoms and may be confirmed by collagen or DNA testing.^[3]

There is no cure.^[3] Maintaining a healthy lifestyle by exercising and avoiding smoking can help prevent fractures. Treatment may include care of broken bones, pain medication, physical therapy, braces or wheelchairs, and surgery. A type of surgery that puts metal rods through long bones may be done to strengthen them.^[4] Tentative evidence supports the use of medications of the bisphosphonate type.^[5][6]

OI affects about one in 15,000 people.^[1] Outcomes depend on the type of disease. Most people, however, have good outcomes.^[3] The condition has been described since ancient history.^[7] The term "osteogenesis imperfecta" came into use in 1895 and means imperfect bone formation.^[1][7]

Classification

Of the eight different types of OI, type I is the most common, though the symptoms vary from person to person.

Type	Description	Gene	OMIM	Mode of inheritance
I	mild	Null COL1A1 allele	166240 (IA), 166200 (IB)	autosomal dominant, 60% de novo[8]
II	severe and usually lethal in the perinatal period	COL1A1, COL1A2,	166210 (IIA), 610854 (IIB)	autosomal dominant, ~100% de novo[8]
III	considered progressive and deforming	COL1A1, COL1A2	259420	autosomal dominant, ~100% de novo[8]
IV	deforming, but with normal sclerae most of the time	COL1A1, COL1A2	166220	autosomal dominant, 60% de novo[8]
V	shares the same clinical features of IV, but has unique histologic findings ("mesh-like")	IFITM5	610967	autosomal dominant[8][9]
VI	shares the same clinical features of IV, but has unique histologic findings ("fish scale")	SERPINF1	610968	autosomal recessive[8]
VII	associated with cartilage associated protein	CRTAP	610682	autosomal recessive[8]
VIII	severe to lethal, associated with the protein leprecan	LEPRE1	610915	autosomal recessive

Type I

Collagen is of normal quality but is produced in insufficient quantities:

• Bones fracture easily
• Slight spinal curvature
• Loose joints
• Poor muscle tone
• Discoloration of the sclera (whites of the eyes), usually giving them a blue-gray color. The blue-gray color of the sclera is due to the underlying choroidal veins which show through. This is due to the sclera being thinner than normal because the defective Type I collagen is not forming correctly.
• Early loss of hearing in some children^[10]
• Slight protrusion of the eyes

IA and IB are defined to be distinguished by the absence/presence of dentinogenesis imperfecta (characterized by opalescent teeth; absent in IA, present in IB). Life expectancy is slightly reduced compared to the general population due to the possibility of fatal bone fractures and complications related to OI Type I such as basilar invagination.

Type II

Collagen is not of a sufficient quality or quantity

• Most cases die within the first year of life due to respiratory failure or intracerebral hemorrhage
• Severe respiratory problems due to underdeveloped lungs
• Severe bone deformity and small stature

Type II can be further subclassified into groups A, B, and C, which are distinguished by radiographic evaluation of the long bones and ribs. Type IIA demonstrates broad and short long bones with broad and beaded ribs. Type IIB demonstrates broad and short long bones with thin ribs that have little or no beading. Type IIC demonstrates thin and longer long bones with thin and beaded ribs.

Type III

Collagen improperly formed, enough collagen is made but it is defective

• Bones fracture easily, sometimes even before birth
• Bone deformity, often severe
• Respiratory problems possible
• Short stature, spinal curvature and sometimes barrel-shaped rib cage
• Triangular face^[11]
• Loose joints (double jointed)
• Poor muscle tone in arms and legs
• Discolouration of the sclera (the 'whites' of the eyes are blue)
• Early loss of hearing possible

Type III is distinguished among the other classifications as being the "progressive deforming" type, wherein a neonate presents with mild symptoms at birth and develops the aforementioned symptoms throughout life. Lifespans may be normal, albeit with severe physical handicapping.

Type IV

Collagen quantity is sufficient but is not of a high enough quality

• Bones fracture easily, especially before puberty
• Short stature, spinal curvature, and barrel-shaped rib cage
• Bone deformity is mild to moderate
• Early loss of hearing

Similar to Type I, Type IV can be further subclassified into types IVA and IVB characterized by absence (IVA) or presence (IVB) of dentinogenesis imperfecta.

Type V

Having the same clinical features as Type IV, it is distinguished histologically by "mesh-like" bone appearance. Further characterized by the "V triad" consisting of a) radio-opaque band adjacent to growth plates, b) hypertrophic calluses at fracture sites, and c) calcification of the radio-ulnar interosseous membrane.^[12]

OI Type V leads to calcification of the membrane between the two forearm bones, making it difficult to turn the wrist. Another symptom is abnormally large amounts of repair tissue (hyperplasic callus) at the site of fractures. Other features of this condition include radial head dislocation, long bone bowing, and mixed hearing loss.

At least some cases of this type are caused by mutations in the IFITM5 gene.^[9]

Type VI

With the same clinical features as Type IV, it is distinguished histologically by "fish-scale" bone appearance. Type VI has recently been found to be caused by a loss of function mutation in the SERPINF1 gene. SERPINF1, a member of the serpin family, is also known as pigment epithelium derived factor (PEDF), the most powerful endogenous antiangiogenic factor in mammals.

Type VII

In 2006, a recessive form called "Type VII" was discovered (phenotype severe to lethal). Thus far it seems to be limited to a First Nations people in Quebec.^[13] Mutations in the gene CRTAP causes this type.^[14]

Type VIII

OI caused by mutation in the gene LEPRE1 is classified as type VIII.^[14]

Other genes

A family with recessive osteogenesis imperfecta has been reported to have a mutation in the TMEM38B gene on chromosome 9.^[15] This gene encodes TRIC-B, a component of TRIC, a monovalent cation-specific channel involved in calcium release from intracellular stores.

It is extremely likely that there are other genes associated with this disease that have yet to be reported.

Pathophysiology

People with OI are born with defective connective tissue, or without the ability to make it, usually because of a deficiency of Type-I collagen.^[16] This deficiency arises from an amino acid substitution of glycine to bulkier amino acids in the collagen triple helix structure. The larger amino acid side-chains create steric hindrance that creates a bulge in the collagen complex, which in turn influences both the molecular nanomechanics and the interaction between molecules, which are both compromised.^[17] As a result, the body may respond by hydrolyzing the improper collagen structure. If the body does not destroy the improper collagen, the relationship between the collagen fibrils and hydroxyapatite crystals to form bone is altered, causing brittleness.^[18] Another suggested disease mechanism is that the stress state within collagen fibrils is altered at the locations of mutations, where locally larger shear forces lead to rapid failure of fibrils even at moderate loads as the homogeneous stress state found in healthy collagen fibrils is lost.^[17] These recent works suggest that OI must be understood as a multi-scale phenomenon, which involves mechanisms at the genetic, nano-, micro- and macro-level of tissues.

As a genetic disorder, OI has historically been viewed as an autosomal dominant disorder of type I collagen. Most cases have been caused by mutations in the COL1A1 and COL1A2 genes. In the past several years, there has been the identification of autosomal recessive forms.^[19] Most people with OI receive it from a parent but in 35% of cases it is an individual (de novo or "sporadic") mutation.

Diagnosis

There is no definitive test for OI. The diagnosis is usually suggested by the occurrence of bone fractures with little trauma and the presence of other clinical features. A skin biopsy can be performed to determine the structure and quantity of type I collagen. DNA testing can confirm the diagnosis, however, it cannot exclude it because not all mutations causing OI are known and/or tested for. OI type II is often diagnosed by ultrasound during pregnancy, where already multiple fractures and other characteristic features may be present. Relative to control, OI cortical bone shows increased porosity, canal diameter, and connectivity in micro-computed tomography.^[20]

An important differential diagnosis of OI is child abuse, as both may present with multiple fractures in various stages of healing. Differentiating them can be difficult, especially when no other characteristic features of OI are present. Other differential diagnoses include rickets, osteomalacia, and other rare skeletal syndromes.

Treatment

There is no cure.^[3] Maintaining a healthy lifestyle by exercising and avoiding smoking can help prevent fractures. Treatment may include care of broken bones, pain medication, physical therapy, braces or wheelchairs, and surgery. A type of surgery that puts metal rods through long bones may be done to strengthen them.^[4]

Bisphosphonates can increase bone mass, and reduce bone pain and fracture.

Bone infections are treated as and when they occur with the appropriate antibiotics and antiseptics.

Bisphosphonates

In 1998, a clinical trial demonstrated the effectiveness of intravenous pamidronate, a bisphosphonate which had previously been used in adults to treat osteoporosis. In severe OI, pamidronate reduced bone pain, prevented new vertebral fractures, reshaped previously fractured vertebral bodies, and reduced the number of long-bone fractures.^[21]

Although oral bisphosphonates are more convenient and cheaper, they are not absorbed as well, and intravenous bisphosphonates are generally more effective, although this is under study. Some studies have found oral and intravenous bisphosphonates, such as oral alendronate and intravenous pamidronate, equivalent.^[22] In a trial of children with mild OI, oral risedronate increased bone mineral densities, and reduced nonvertebral fractures. However, it did not decrease new vertebral fractures.^[23][24] A Cochrane review in 2016 concluded that though bisphosphonates seem to improve bone mineral density, it is uncertain whether this leads to a reduction in fractures or an improvement in the quality of life of individuals with osteogenesis imperfecta.^[6]

Bisphosphonates are less effective for OI in adults.^[25]

Surgery

Metal rods can be surgically inserted in the long bones to improve strength, a procedure developed by Harold A. Sofield, MD, at Shriners Hospitals for Children in Chicago. During the late 1940s, Sofield, Chief of Staff at Shriners Hospitals in Chicago, worked there with large numbers of children with OI and experimented with various methods to strengthen the bones in these children.^[26] In 1959, with Edward A. Miller, MD, Sofield wrote a seminal article describing a solution that seemed radical at the time: the placement of stainless steel rods into the intramedullary canals of the long bones to stabilize and strengthen them. His treatment proved extremely useful in the rehabilitation and prevention of fractures; it was adopted throughout the world and still forms the basis for orthopedic treatment of OI.

Spinal fusion can be performed to correct scoliosis, although the inherent bone fragility makes this operation more complex in OI patients. Surgery for basilar impressions can be carried out if pressure being exerted on the spinal cord and brain stem is causing neurological problems.

Physiotherapy

Physiotherapy is used to strengthen muscles and improve motility in a gentle manner, while minimizing the risk of fracture. This often involves hydrotherapy and the use of support cushions to improve posture. Individuals are encouraged to change positions regularly throughout the day to balance the muscles being used and the bones under pressure.

Children often develop a fear of trying new ways of moving due to movement being associated with pain. This can make physiotherapy difficult to administer to young children.

Physical aids

With adaptive equipment such as crutches, wheelchairs, splints, grabbing arms, or modifications to the home, many individuals with OI can obtain a significant degree of autonomy.

History

The condition, or types of it, has had various other names over the years and in different nations. Among some of the most common alternatives are Ekman-Lobstein syndrome, Vrolik syndrome, and the colloquial glass-bone disease. The name osteogenesis imperfecta dates to at least 1895^[27] and has been the usual medical term in the 20th century to present. The current four type system began with Sillence in 1979.^[28] An older system deemed less severe types "osteogenesis imperfecta tarda" while more severe forms were deemed "osteogenesis imperfecta congenita."^[29] As this terminology did not differentiate well between the types, and all forms of osteogenesis are congenital, this naming convention has since fallen out of favour.

The condition has been found in an ancient Egyptian mummy from 1000 BC. The Norse king Ivar the Boneless may have had this condition, as well. The earliest studies of it began in 1788 with the Swede Olof Jakob Ekman. He described the condition in his doctoral thesis and mentioned cases of it going back to 1678. In 1831, Edmund Axmann described it in himself and two brothers. Jean Lobstein dealt with it in adults in 1833. Willem Vrolik did work on the condition in the 1850s. The idea that the adult and newborn forms were the same came in 1897 with Martin Benno Schmidt.^[30]

Epidemiology

In the United States, the incidence of osteogenesis imperfecta is estimated to be one per 20,000 live births.^[31] An estimated 20,000 to 50,000 people are affected by OI in the United States.

Frequency is approximately the same across groups, but for unknown reasons, the Shona and Ndebele of Zimbabwe seem to have a higher proportion of Type III to Type I than other groups.^[32] A similar pattern was found in segments of the Nigerian and South African populations. In these varied cases, the total number of OIs of all four types was roughly the same as any other ethnicity.

Society and culture

The Brittle Bone Society is a UK charity that supports people with the condition.

Figures in film, television, video games and novels depicted as having osteogenesis imperfecta include:

• Robby Novak (also known as Kid President), a motivational speaker and YouTube personality as of 2013.^[33] He often comments on his own ability to overcome the disorder.^[34]
• Samuel L. Jackson's fictional character Elijah Price in M. Night Shyamalan's 2000 film Unbreakable, who was born with type I osteogenesis imperfecta.^[35]
• Jeff "Joker" Moreau, a fictional character from the Mass Effect video game series voiced by Seth Green. Given that the series is set in the fictional future, he is able to take medications to help with his disease and is a pilot. The medication, along with a mix of Cerberus implants and braces, allow him to walk and dance, although not as fluidly as normal humans.^[36]

Other animals

In dogs, OI is an autosomal-recessive condition. In Golden Retrievers, it is caused by a mutation in the COL1A1, and in Beagles, the COL1A2. A separate mutation in the SERPINH1 gene has been found to cause the condition in Dachshunds.^[37] Several mouse models of OI have been described, whereby the abnormal gait 2 (AGA2) mouse line exhibits severe skeletal^[38] and cardio-pulmonary^[39] phenotypes due to a carboxy-terminus mutation in the COL1A1 gene in the mouse.

References

External links

Classification	V · T · D ICD-10: Q78.0 ICD-9-CM: 756.51 OMIM: 166200 MeSH: D010013 DiseasesDB: 9342
External resources	MedlinePlus: 001573 eMedicine: ped/1674 Patient UK: Osteogenesis imperfecta Orphanet: 666

Wikimedia Commons has media related to Osteogenesis imperfecta.

• Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) (disease) at Encyclopædia Britannica
• GeneReview/NCBI/NIH/UW entry on Osteogenesis Imperfecta
• synd/1743 at Who Named It?
• Osteogenesis Imperfecta Overview  NIH Osteoporosis and Related Bone Diseases ~ National Resource Center