Scotland Act 2012

The Scotland Act 2012 is an Act of the Parliament of the United Kingdom. It sets out amendments to the Scotland Act 1998, with the aim of devolving further powers to Scotland in accordance with the recommendations of the Calman Commission.^[1] It received Royal Assent in 2012.

Main Provisions

The Act gave extra powers to the Scottish Parliament,^[2] most notably:

• The ability to raise or lower income tax by 10p in the pound. Any change is applied equally across all tax bands.^[3]
• Other minor tax powers: control of stamp duty and landfill tax.
• The ability to borrow money, up to £2.2 billion a year.
• Guaranteed Scottish representation in the BBC and Crown Estate.
• Legislative control over several more issues including limited powers relating to drugs, driving, and guns.

The Act has prompted the creation of Revenue Scotland, a Scottish tax authority to replace HMRC for devolved taxes.

Calman Commission

The proposed legislation was based on the final report of the Calman Commission, which was established by an opposition Labour Party motion in the Scottish Parliament in December 2007, against the wishes of the Scottish National Party minority government.

Professor Jim Gallagher, the civil servant who drafted the Bill, was appointed to advise the Scotland Bill Committee of the Scottish Parliament, convened by Wendy Alexander, whose Parliamentary motion started the whole Calman process.^[4]

Passage

The Bill was presented to the House of Commons by the Secretary of State for Scotland, Michael Moore, on St Andrew's Day (30 November), 2010, and received an unopposed second reading on 27 January 2012.

The UK government stated that it would not pass the bill unless it had obtained a legislative consent motion from the Scottish Parliament,^[5] although the Parliament of the United Kingdom could have passed the Bill in any case.^[6] The governing Scottish National Party indicated that it planned to block the bill.^[7][8] However, after a deal was reached between the two governments on 21 March 2012,^[9] the Scottish Parliament unanimously passed a legislative consent motion in respect of the Bill on 18 April 2012.^[10]

Reaction and analysis

The Secretary of State for Scotland, Michael Moore, described the legislation as the largest transfer of fiscal powers from central Government since the creation of the United Kingdom.^[11]

Although the Scottish National Party supported some parts of the Bill as introduced, it opposed others. In particular, it considered that the income tax proposals were flawed.^[12] However, the SNP agreed to support the Bill, after the proposals to return certain powers were dropped,^[13] and agreement was reached that the details of the income tax changes would be subject to approval by MSPs.^[14] After the Bill received legislative consent from the Scottish Parliament, the Cabinet Secretary for Parliamentary Business and Government Strategy, Bruce Crawford, MSP argued that, although the Bill would not harm Scottish interests, it represented a missed opportunity and had been overtaken by events, in particular the return of an SNP majority government in 2011 and the consequent independence referendum.^[15]

Amendment

There is a proposal to amend section 57(2) of the Scotland Act 1998, which provides that the Lord Advocate, as a member of the Scottish Executive, has no power to do anything in contravention of the European Convention rights. Given that, alongside being the adviser to and representative of the Scottish Government in Scots law, the Lord Advocate is head of the system of criminal prosecution in Scotland and every prosecution in a Scottish court proceeds with his/her authority, this provision effectively allows any human rights issue raised in any criminal proceedings in Scotland effectively to be appealed to the UK Supreme Court as a constitutional "devolution issue".^[16] The Supreme Court consists of two Supreme Court judges from Scotland and 10 judges from other parts of the United Kingdom. When hearing appeals the Supreme Court sits with a bench of at least five judges, so even if both Scottish judges are present for a Scottish appeal, the majority of the bench will be judges who may not be especially well versed in Scots law and criminal procedure. According to Lord Hope of Craighead, the Deputy President of the Supreme Court, non-Scottish judges will in practice defer to their Scottish colleagues in Scottish cases, and often simply concur with judgements written by the Scottish judges. However, the situation is seen by some, including the Scottish Government, as undermining the status of the High Court of Justiciary as the final court of appeal in criminal matters in Scots law, and even of undermining the integrity of Scots law. The Advocate General for Scotland asked an expert group, chaired by Sir David Edward, to consider this issue and make recommendations, which led to the amendments to the Scotland Bill proposed by the UK Government. The Scottish Government remains concerned that the amendments may not fully address the issue, particularly as a result of the decision of the Supreme Court in Fraser v HM Advocate, and appointed their own expert group, chaired by Lord McCluskey, to consider the matter and report back.

See also

• for the Scotland Bill 1977–78, see Scotland Act 1978 (subsequently repealed)
• for the Scotland Bill 1997–98, see Scotland Act 1998
• Constitution of the United Kingdom
• History of Scottish devolution
• History of the Scottish National Party
• Politics of the United Kingdom

References

Further reading

• Black, Andrew (30 November 2010). "Q&A: Scotland Bill". BBC News Online. 
• Gallagher, Jim (30 November 2010). "Why the Scotland Bill is good news for England". Daily Telegraph. Retrieved 28 January 2011. 

External links

• Bill as enacted
• Bill as introduced
• The Scotland Bill – Scotland Office
• Official page on the UK Parliament website
• Scotland Bill Committee website
• 3 March 2011 Material provided by the Scottish Government to the Scotland Bill Committee

Devolution in the United Kingdom Devolved areas National level Northern Ireland Scotland Wales Regional level (in England) Combined authorities Directly elected mayoralties Greater London Authority Referendums1 English mayoral referendums London, 1998 2012 North East England 2004 Northern Ireland 1998 Scotland 1979 1997 Wales 1979 1997 2011 Heads of devolved governments Chairs of combined authorities Directly elected mayors London (Mayor) Northern Ireland (FM and dFM) Scotland (FM) Wales (FM) Devolved legislatures2 Northern Ireland Assembly National Assembly for Wales Scottish Parliament Devolved administrations3 Northern Ireland Executive Scottish Government Welsh Government Organisations and laws of the legislatures and governments of the UK and the devolved areas Commissions (UK Parliament) Kilbrandon Commission Holtham Commission Silk Commission McKay Commission Commissions (devolved legislatures) National Assembly for Wales Richard Commission Holtham Commission Scottish Parliament Calman Commission Smith Commission Devolution acts Greater London Authority Acts 1999 2007 Northern Ireland Acts 1998 2006 Wales Acts 1998 2006 2014 Scotland Acts 1998 2012 Select committees Northern Ireland Affairs Scottish Affairs Welsh Affairs Grand committees England Northern Ireland Scottish Welsh Departments and Territorial Offices (MOJ) Cabinet Office - Devolution Secretariat Ministry of Justice - Devolution Directorate-General Office of the Advocate General for Scotland Northern Ireland Office Scotland Office Wales Office Elections London Northern Ireland Scotland Wales Related articles Current Agreements/Treaties Anglo-Irish Treaty Good Friday Agreement Budget Barnett formula Block grant Constitution of the United Kingdom Reserved and excepted matters West Lothian question Proposals Cornwall Cornish Assembly Cornish Constitutional Convention Mebyon Kernow Revived Cornish Stannary Parliament Devolved English parliament Campaign for an English Parliament Northern England Campaign for the North Yorkshire First Other parts of Southern England Wessex Regionalist Party Scotland Full fiscal autonomy Historical Administrations of England English Regional Assemblies, 1998-2010 Administrations of London London County Council Greater London Council Administrations of Northern Ireland 1922–72 1974 Legislatures of Northern Ireland 1922–72 1973–74 1982–86 Northern Ireland-related legislation of the UK Parliament Ireland, 1886 Ireland, 1893 Ireland, 1914 Ireland, 1920 Irish Free State, 1922 Northern Ireland, 1974 Irish Home Rule movement Prime Minister of Northern Ireland Scotland Act 1978 Scottish Office Sunningdale Agreement Wales Act 1978 Welsh Office 1. Rejected referendums are italicised. The others were fully or partially approved. 2. There is no law-making body for any regionally devolved area. 3. Administrations of regionally devolved areas are omitted. Category