Quantum money

Quantum Money is a proposed design of bank notes making them impossible to forge, by using quantum physics. The idea influenced the development of quantum key distribution protocols used in quantum cryptography.

The idea was put forward in about 1970 by Stephen Wiesner, a graduate student at Columbia University, though it was rejected by a number of scientific journals, meaning that it remained unpublished until 1983.^[1]

How it works

In addition to a unique serial number on each bank note (these notes are actually more like checks, since a verification step with the bank is required for each transaction), there is a series of isolated two-state quantum systems.^[2] For example, photons in one of four polarizations could be used: at 0°, 45°, 90° and 135° to some axis, which is referred to as the vertical. Each of these is a two-state system in one of two bases: the horizontal basis has states with polarizations at 0° and 90° to the vertical, and the diagonal basis has states at 45° and 135° to the vertical.

At the bank, there is a record of all the polarizations and the corresponding serial numbers. On the bank note, the serial number is printed, but the polarizations are kept secret. Thus, whilst the bank can always verify the polarizations by measuring the polarization of each photon in the correct basis without introducing any disturbance, a would-be counterfeiter ignorant of the bases cannot create a copy of the photon polarization states, since even if he knows the two bases, if he chooses the wrong one to measure a photon, it will change the polarization of the photon in the trap, and the forged banknote created will be with this wrong polarization.

For each photon, the would-be counterfeiter has a probability of success in duplicating it correctly. If the total number of photons on the bank note is , a duplicate will have probability of passing the bank's verification test. If is large, this probability becomes exponentially small. The fact that a quantum state cannot be copied is ultimately guaranteed by its proof by the no-cloning theorem, which underlies the security of this system.

Drawbacks

Unlike other ecash protocols and cryptographic currencies such as Bitcoin, quantum money cannot be backed-up. A partial solution is to use a quantum error correcting codes, and keep the money in, say, 4 places, such that if 1 part is destroyed, the error can be recovered.

It is widely accepted by experts that although a good idea to stimulate discussion, quantum money would in fact be wholly impractical, since the technology to trap a two-state system for sufficiently long has not yet been developed. Even if it is, it would seem likely that it would cost far more to protect the bank note than its monetary value.^[3] It is also noted that in this system, if a note does not pass the bank's verification test, it does not necessarily mean that it has been forged: it could be a real note whose photon polarizations have been tampered with or measured in the incorrect basis (perhaps by a would-be counterfeiter or malfunctioning teller machine).

References

1. ↑ S. Wiesner, Sigact News, 15, 78 (1983)
2. ↑ Lo, Spiller & Popescu, Introduction to Quantum computation and information (1998) pp. 81–83
3. ↑ Simon Singh, The Code Book (1999)