Painted turtle

The painted turtle (Chrysemys picta) is the most widespread native turtle of North America. It lives in slow-moving fresh waters, from southern Canada to Louisiana and northern Mexico, and from the Atlantic to the Pacific. The turtle is the only species of the genus Chrysemys, which is part of the pond turtle family Emydidae. Fossils show that the painted turtle existed 15 million years ago. Four regionally based subspecies (the eastern, midland, southern, and western) evolved during the last ice age.

The adult painted turtle female is 10–25 cm (4–10 in) long; the male is smaller. The turtle's top shell is dark and smooth, without a ridge. Its skin is olive to black with red, orange, or yellow stripes on its extremities. The subspecies can be distinguished by their shells: the eastern has straight-aligned top shell segments; the midland has a large gray mark on the bottom shell; the southern has a red line on the top shell; the western has a red pattern on the bottom shell.

The turtle eats aquatic vegetation, algae, and small water creatures including insects, crustaceans, and fish. Although they are frequently consumed as eggs or hatchlings by rodents, canines, and snakes, the adult turtles' hard shells protect them from most predators. Reliant on warmth from its surroundings, the painted turtle is active only during the day when it basks for hours on logs or rocks. During winter, the turtle hibernates, usually in the mud at the bottom of water bodies. The turtles mate in spring and autumn. Females dig nests on land and lay eggs between late spring and mid-summer. Hatched turtles grow until sexual maturity: 2–9 years for males, 6–16 for females.

In the traditional tales of Algonquian tribes, the colorful turtle played the part of a trickster. In modern times, four U.S. states have named the painted turtle their official reptile. While habitat loss and road killings have reduced the turtle's population, its ability to live in human-disturbed settings has helped it remain the most abundant turtle in North America. Adults in the wild can live for more than 55 years.

Description

The painted turtle's shell is 10–25 cm (4–10 in) long, oval, smooth with little grooves where the large scale-like plates overlap, and flat-bottomed.^{[7][nb 2][8][9]} The color of the top shell (carapace) varies from olive to black. Darker specimens are more common where the bottom of the water body is darker. The bottom shell (plastron) is yellow, sometimes red, sometimes with dark markings in the center. Similar to the top shell, the turtle's skin is olive to black, but with red and yellow stripes on its neck, legs, and tail.^[10][11] As with other pond turtles, such as the bog turtle, the painted turtle's feet are webbed to aid swimming.^[12][13][14]

The head of the turtle is distinctive. The face has only yellow stripes, with a large yellow spot and streak behind each eye, and on the chin two wide yellow stripes that meet at the tip of the jaw.^[7][9][10] The turtle's upper jaw is shaped into an inverted "V" (philtrum), with a downward-facing, tooth-like projection on each side.^[15]

The hatchling has a proportionally larger head, eyes, and tail, and a more circular shell than the adult.^[16][17] The adult female is generally longer than the male, 10–25 cm (4–10 in) versus 7–15 cm (3–6 in).^[10][18] For a given length, the female has a higher (more rounded, less flat) top shell.^[19] The female weighs around 500 g (18 oz) on average, against the males' average adult weight of roughly 300 g (11 oz).^[20] The female's greater body volume supports her egg-production.^[21] The male has longer foreclaws and a longer, thicker tail, with the anus (cloaca) located further out on the tail.^{[7][8][9][22]}

Subspecies

Although the subspecies of painted turtle intergrade (blend together) at range boundaries^[23] they are distinct within the hearts of their ranges.^[24]

• The male eastern painted turtle (C. p. picta) is 13–17 cm (5–7 in) long, while the female is 14–17 cm (6–7 in). The upper shell is olive green to black and may possess a pale stripe down the middle and red markings on the periphery. The segments (scutes) of the top shell have pale leading edges and occur in straight rows across the back, unlike all other North American turtles, including the other three subspecies of painted turtle, which have alternating segments.^[24] The bottom shell is plain yellow or lightly spotted. Sometimes as few as one dark grey spot near the lower center of the shell.^[25]
• The midland painted turtle (C. p. marginata) is 10–25 cm (4–10 in) long.^[26] The centrally located midland is the hardest to distinguish from the other three subspecies.^[24] Its bottom shell has a characteristic symmetrical dark shadow in the center which varies in size and prominence.^[27]
• The southern painted turtle (C. p. dorsalis), the smallest subspecies, is 10–14 cm (4–6 in) long.^[28] Its top stripe is a prominent red,^[24] and its bottom shell is tan and spotless or nearly so.^[29]
• The largest subspecies is the western painted turtle (C. p. bellii), which grows up to 26.6 cm (10 in) long.^[30][31] Its top shell has a mesh-like pattern of light lines,^[32] and the top stripe present in other subspecies is missing or faint. Its bottom shell has a large colored splotch that spreads to the edges (further than the midland) and often has red hues.^[32]

Eastern painted turtle C. p. picta	Midland painted turtle C. p. marginata	Southern painted turtle C. p. dorsalis	Western painted turtle C. p. bellii

Similar species

The painted turtle has a very similar appearance to the red-eared slider (the most common pet turtle) and the two are often confused. The painted turtle can be distinguished because it is flatter than the slider. Also, the slider has a prominent red marking on the side of its head (the "ear") and a spotted bottom shell, both features missing in the painted turtle.^[33]

Painted turtle	Red-eared slider

Ecology

Diet

The painted turtle hunts along water bottoms. It quickly juts its head into and out of vegetation to stir potential victims out into the open water, where they are pursued.^[34] Large prey it holds in its mouth and tears up with its forefeet. It also consumes plants and skims the surface of the water with its mouth open to catch small particles of food.^[34]

Although all subspecies of painted turtle eat plants and animals, either alive or dead, their tendencies vary.^[34][35]

• The eastern painted turtle's diet is the least studied. It prefers to eat in the water, but has been observed eating on land. The fish it consumes are typically dead or injured.^[35]
• The midland painted turtle eats mostly aquatic insects and both vascular and non-vascular plants.^[36]
• The southern painted turtle's diet changes with age. Juveniles have a 13% vegetarian diet, adults 88%. This perhaps shows the turtle prefers meat, but can only obtain the amounts desired (by eating small larvae and such) while young.^[37] The reversal of feeding habits with age has also been seen in the false map turtle, which inhabits some of the same range. The most common plants eaten by adult southern painted turtles are duckweed and algae, and the most common prey items are dragonfly larvae and crayfish.^[38]
• The western painted turtle's consumption of plants and animals changes seasonally. In early summer, 60% of its diet comprises insects. In late summer, 55% includes plants.^[39] Of note, the western painted turtle also eats many white water-lily seeds. Because the hard-coated seeds remain viable after passing through the turtle, they are dispersed by it.^[39]

Common foods of the painted turtle
Crayfish	Dragonfly larva	American water lily	Duckweed (water surface)

Predators

Painted turtles are most vulnerable to predators when young.^[40] Nests are frequently ransacked and the eggs eaten by garter snakes, crows, chipmunks, thirteen-lined ground and gray squirrels, skunks, groundhogs, raccoons, badgers, gray and red fox, and humans.^[40] The small and sometimes bite-size, numerous hatchlings fall prey to water bugs, bass, catfish, bullfrogs, snapping turtles, three types of snakes (copperheads, racers and water snakes), herons, rice rats, weasels, muskrats, minks, and raccoons. As adults, the turtles' armored shells protect them from many potential predators, but they still occasionally fall prey to alligators, ospreys, crows, red-shouldered hawks, bald eagles, and especially raccoons.^[40]

Painted turtles defend themselves by kicking, scratching, biting, or urinating.^[40] In contrast to land tortoises, painted turtles can right themselves if they are flipped upside down.^[41]

Important predators of the painted turtle
Of eggs: Red fox	Plains Garter Snake	Crows	Of hatchlings: Common Snapping Turtle	Water Bugs	Of adults: Raccoon

Life cycle

Mating

The painted turtles mate in spring and fall in waters of 10–25 °C (50–77 °F).^[42] Males start producing sperm in early spring, when they can bask to an internal temperature of 17 °C (63 °F).^[43][44] Females begin their reproductive cycles in mid-summer, and ovulate the following spring.^[45]

Courtship begins when a male follows a female until he meets her face-to-face.^[46] He then strokes her face and neck with his elongated front claws, a gesture returned by a receptive female. The pair repeat the process several times, with the male retreating from and then returning to the female until she swims to the bottom, where they copulate.^[45][46] As the male is smaller than the female, he is not dominant.^[46] The female stores sperm, to be used for up to three clutches, in her oviducts; the sperm may remain viable for up to three years.^[47] A single clutch may have multiple fathers.^[47]

Egg-laying

Nesting is done, by the females only, between late May and mid-July.^[45] The nests are vase-shaped and are usually dug in sandy soil, often at sites with southern exposures.^[48] Nests are often within 200 m (220 yd) of water, but may be as far away as 600 m (660 yd), with older females tending to nest further inland. Nest sizes vary depending on female sizes and locations but are about 5–11 cm (2–4 in) deep.^[48] Females may return to the same sites several consecutive years, but if several females make their nests close together, the eggs become more vulnerable to predators.^[48]

The female's optimal body temperature while digging her nest is 29–30 °C (84–86 °F).^[48] If the weather is unsuitable, for instance a too hot night in the Southeast, she delays the process until later at night.^[48] Painted turtles in Virginia have been observed waiting three weeks to nest because of a hot drought.^[49]

While preparing to dig her nest, the female sometimes exhibits a mysterious preliminary behavior. She presses her throat against the ground of different potential sites, perhaps sensing moisture, warmth, texture, or smell, although her exact motivation is unknown. She may further temporize by excavating several false nests^[48] as the wood turtles also do.^[50]

The female relies on her hind feet for digging. She may accumulate so much sand and mud on her feet that her mobility is reduced, making her vulnerable to predators. To lighten her labors, she lubricates the area with her bladder water.^[48] Once the nest is complete, the female deposits into the hole. The freshly laid eggs are white, elliptical, porous, and flexible.^[51] From start to finish, the female's work may take four hours. Sometimes she remains on land overnight afterwards, before returning to her home water.^[48]

Females can lay five clutches per year, but two is a normal average after including the 30–50% of a population's females that do not produce any clutches in a given year.^[48] In some northern populations, no females lay more than one clutch per year.^[48] Bigger females tend to lay bigger eggs and more eggs per clutch.^[52] Clutch sizes of the subspecies vary, although the differences may reflect different environments, rather than different genetics. The two more northerly subspecies, western and midland, are larger and have more eggs per clutch—11.9 and 7.6, respectively—than the two more southerly subspecies, southern (4.2) and eastern (4.9). Within subspecies, also, the more northerly females lay larger clutches.^[48]

Growth

Incubation lasts 72–80 days in the wild^[45] and for a similar period in artificial conditions.^[49] In August and September, the young turtle breaks out from its egg, using a special projection of its jaw called the egg tooth.^[53] Not all offspring leave the nest immediately, though.^[45] Hatchlings north of a line from Nebraska to northern Illinois to New Jersey^[54] typically arrange themselves symmetrically^[55] in the nest and overwinter to emerge the following spring.^[45]

The hatchling's ability to survive winter in the nest has allowed the painted turtle to extend its range further north than any other American turtle. The painted turtle is genetically adapted to survive extended periods of subfreezing temperatures with blood that can remain supercooled and skin that resists penetration from ice crystals in the surrounding ground.^[54] The hardest freezes nevertheless kill many hatchlings.^[45]

Immediately after hatching, turtles are dependent on egg yolk material for sustenance.^[55] About a week to a week and a half after emerging from their eggs (or the following spring if emergence is delayed), hatchlings begin feeding to support growth. The young turtles grow rapidly at first, sometimes doubling their size in the first year. Growth slows sharply at sexual maturity and may stop completely.^[56] Likely owing to differences of habitat and food by water body, growth rates often differ from population to population in the same area. Among the subspecies, the western painted turtles are the quickest growers.^[57]

Females grow faster than males overall, and must be larger to mature sexually.^[56] In most populations males reach sexual maturity at 2–4 years old, and females at 6–10.^[44] Size and age at maturity increase with latitude;^[18] at the northern edge of their range, males reach sexual maturity at 7–9 years of age and females at 11–16.^[46]

Behavior

Daily routine and basking

A cold-blooded reptile, the painted turtle regulates its temperature through its environment, notably by basking. All ages bask for warmth, often alongside other species of turtle. Sometimes more than 50 individuals are seen on one log together.^[58] Turtles bask on a variety of objects, often logs, but have even been seen basking on top of common loons that were covering eggs.^[59]

The turtle starts its day at sunrise, emerging from the water to bask for several hours. Warmed for activity, it returns to the water to forage.^[60] After becoming chilled, the turtle re-emerges for one to two more cycles of basking and feeding.^[61] At night, the turtle drops to the bottom of its water body or perches on an underwater object and sleeps.^[60]

To be active, the turtle must maintain an internal body temperature between 17–23 °C (63–73 °F). When fighting infection, it manipulates its temperature up to 5 °C (8 °F) higher than normal.^[58]

Seasonal routine and hibernation

In the spring, when the water reaches 15–18 °C (59–64 °F), the turtle begins actively foraging. However, if the water temperature exceeds 30 °C (86 °F), the turtle will not feed. In fall, the turtle stops foraging when temperatures drop below the spring set-point.^[34]

During the winter, the turtle hibernates. In the north, the inactive season may be as long as from October to March, while the southernmost populations may not hibernate at all.^[62] While hibernating, the body temperature of the painted turtle averages 6 °C (43 °F).^[63] Periods of warm weather bring the turtle out of hibernation, and even in the north, individuals have been seen basking in February.^[64]

The painted turtle hibernates by burying itself, either on the bottom of a body of water, near water in the shore-bank or the burrow of a muskrat, or in woods or pastures. When hibernating underwater, the turtle prefers shallow depths, no more than 2 m (7 ft). Within the mud, it may dig down an additional 1 m (3 ft).^[63] In this state, the turtle does not breathe, although if surroundings allow, it may get some oxygen through its skin.^[65] The species is one of the best-studied vertebrates able to survive long periods without oxygen. Adaptations of its blood chemistry, brain, heart, and particularly its shell allow the turtle to survive extreme lactic acid buildup while oxygen-deprived.^[66]

Movement

Searching for water, food, or mates, the painted turtles travel up to several kilometers at a time.^[67] During summer, in response to heat and water-clogging vegetation, the turtles may vacate shallow marshes for more permanent waters.^[67] Short overland migrations may involve hundreds of turtles together.^[62] If heat and drought are prolonged, the turtles will bury themselves and, in extreme cases, die.^[68]

Foraging turtles frequently cross lakes or travel linearly down creeks.^[69] Daily crossings of large ponds have been observed.^[68] Tag and release studies show that sex also drives turtle movement. Males travel the most, up to 26 km (16 mi), between captures; females the second most, up to 8 km (5 mi), between captures; and juveniles the least, less than 2 km (1.2 mi), between captures.^[67] Males move the most and are most likely to change wetlands because they seek mates.^[68]

The painted turtles, through visual recognition, have homing capabilities.^[67] Many individuals can return to their collection points after being released elsewhere, trips that may require them to traverse land. One experiment placed 98 turtles varying several-kilometer distances from their home wetland; 41 returned. When living in a single large body of water, the painted turtles can home from up to 6 km (4 mi) away. Females may use homing to help locate suitable nesting sites.^[67]

Distribution

Range

The most widespread North American turtle,^[70] the painted turtle is the only turtle whose native range extends from the Atlantic to the Pacific.^{[nb 3]} It is native to eight of Canada's ten provinces, forty-five of the fifty United States, and one of Mexico's thirty-one states. On the East Coast, it lives from the Canadian Maritimes to the U.S. state of Georgia. On the West Coast, it lives in British Columbia, Washington, and Oregon and offshore on southeast Vancouver Island.^{[nb 4]} The northernmost American turtle,^[53] its range includes much of southern Canada. To the south, its range reaches the U.S. Gulf Coast in Louisiana and Alabama. In the southwestern United States there are only dispersed populations. It is found in one river in extreme northern Mexico. It is absent in a part of southwestern Virginia and the adjacent states as well as in north-central Alabama.^[32][71][72]

Native range of the painted turtle (C. picta) Dark grey for national borders White for state and province borders Dark blue for rivers, only showing those in article

Eastern (C. p. picta)   Midland (C. p. marginata)   Southern (C. p. dorsalis)   Western (C. p. bellii)

Intergrade mixtures (large areas only)   Mix of eastern and midland   Mix of eastern and southern   Mix of midland and western

The borders between the four subspecies are not sharp, because the subspecies interbreed. Many studies have been performed in the border regions to assess the intermediate turtles, usually by comparing the anatomical features of hybrids that result from intergradation of the classical subspecies.^{[nb 5]} Despite the imprecision, the subspecies are assigned nominal ranges.

Eastern painted turtle

The eastern painted turtle ranges from southeastern Canada to Georgia with a western boundary at approximately the Appalachians. At its northern extremes, the turtle tends to be restricted to the warmer areas closer to the Atlantic Ocean. It is uncommon in far north New Hampshire and in Maine is common only in a strip about 50 miles from the coast.^[77][78] In Canada, it lives in New Brunswick and Nova Scotia but not in Quebec or Prince Edward Island. To the south it is not found in the coastal lowlands of southern North Carolina, South Carolina, or Georgia, or in southern Georgia in general or at all in Florida. ^{[32][71][79][80]}

The eastern subspecies's range extends slightly into east central Alabama, where it intergrades with the southern subspecies.^[71] In the northeast, there is extensive mixing with the midland subspecies, and some writers have called these turtles a "hybrid swarm".^[81][82][83] In the southeast, the border between the eastern and midland is more sharp as mountain chains separate the subspecies to different drainage basins.^[71][84]

Midland painted turtle

The midland painted turtle lives from southern Ontario and Quebec, through the eastern U.S. Midwest states, to Kentucky, Tennessee and northwestern Alabama, where it intergrades with the southern painted turtle.^[85] It also is found eastward through West Virginia, western Maryland and Pennsylvania. The midland painted turtle appears to be moving east, especially in Pennsylvania.^[86] To the northeast it is found in western New York and much of Vermont, and it intergrades extensively with the eastern subspecies.^[29][71]

Southern painted turtle

The southern painted turtle ranges from extreme southern Illinois and Missouri, roughly along the Mississippi River Valley, to the south. In Arkansas, it branches out to the west towards Texas, where it is found in the far northeast part of that state (Caddo Lake region)^[87] as well as extreme southeastern Oklahoma (McCurtain County).^[88] It is found in much of Louisiana, where it reaches the Gulf of Mexico (in fresh water). Eastward it is found in western Tennessee, northern Mississippi and much of Alabama, including the Gulf Coast city of Mobile^[32][71][80] An isolated population in central Texas has been reported but is now believed to be non-native.^[89]

Western painted turtle

The western painted turtle's northern range includes southern parts of western Canada from Ontario through Manitoba, Saskatchewan, Alberta and British Columbia. In Ontario, the western subspecies is found north of Minnesota and directly north of Lake Superior, but there is a 130 km (80 mi) gap to the east of Lake Superior (in the area of harshest winter climate) where no painted turtles of any subspecies occur. Thus Ontario's western subspecies does not intergrade with the midland painted turtle of southeastern Ontario.^[74] In Manitoba, the turtle is numerous and ranges north to Lake Manitoba and the lower part of Lake Winnipeg. The turtle is also common in south Saskatchewan,^[90] but in Alberta, there may only be 100 individuals, all found very near the U.S. border, mostly in the southeast.^{[32][71][91][92]}

In British Columbia, populations exist in the interior in the vicinity of the Kootenai, Columbia, Okanagan, and Thompson river valleys. At the coast, turtles occur near the mouth of the Fraser and a bit further north, as well as the bottom of Vancouver Island, and some other nearby islands. Within British Columbia, the turtle's range is not continuous and can better be understood as northward extensions of the range from the United States. High mountains present barriers to east-west movement of the turtles within the province or from Alberta. Some literature has shown isolated populations much further north in British Columbia and Alberta, but these were probably pet-releases.^{[32][71][91][92]}

In the United States, the western subspecies forms a wide intergrade area with the midland subspecies covering much of Illinois as well as a strip of Wisconsin along Lake Michigan and part of the Upper Peninsula of Michigan (UP). Further west, the rest of Illinois, Wisconsin and the UP are part of the range proper, as are all of Minnesota and Iowa, as well as all of Missouri except a narrow strip in the south. All of North Dakota is within range, all of South Dakota except a very small area in the west, and all of Nebraska. Almost all of Kansas is in range; the border of that state with Oklahoma is roughly the species range border, but the turtle is found in three counties of north central Oklahoma.^{[32][71][88][91]}

To the northwest, almost all of Montana is in range. Only a narrow strip in the west, along most of the Idaho border (which is at the Continental Divide) lacks turtles.^[93] Wyoming is almost entirely out of range; only the lower elevation areas near the eastern and northern borders have painted turtles.^[94] In Idaho, the turtles are found throughout the far north (upper half of the Idaho Panhandle). Recently, separate Idaho populations have been observed in the southwest (near the Payette and Boise rivers) and the southeast (near St. Anthony).^[95] In Washington state, turtles are common throughout the state within lower elevation river valleys.^[96][97] In Oregon, the turtle is native to the northern part of the state throughout the Columbia River Valley as well as the Willamette River Valley north of Salem.^[32][91][98]

To the southwest, the painted turtle's range is fragmented. In Colorado, while range is continuous in the eastern, prairie, half of the state, it is absent in most of the western, mountainous, part of the state. However, the turtle is confirmed present in the lower elevation southwest part of the state (Archuleta and La Plata counties), where a population ranges into northern New Mexico in the San Juan River basin. There are also some unconfirmed sightings in parts of the far west of the state (e.g. Mesa County).^[99] In New Mexico, the main distribution follows the Rio Grande and the Pecos River, two waterways that run in a north-south direction through the state.^[100] Within the aforementioned rivers, it is also found in the northern part of Far West Texas.^[87] In Utah, the painted turtle lives in an area to the south (Kane County) in streams draining into the Colorado River, although it is disputed if they are native.^{[91][101][102]} In Arizona, the painted turtle is native to an area in the east, Lyman Lake.^[103][104] The painted turtle is not native to Nevada or California.^[32][91]

In Mexico,^[100] painted turtles have been found about 50 miles south of New Mexico near Galeana in the state of Chihuahua. There, two expeditions^[105][106] found the turtles in the Rio Santa Maria which is in a closed basin.^[32][91]

Human-introduced range

Pet releases are starting to establish the painted turtle outside its native range. In California, it is an invasive species that endangers the local western pond turtle, although competition from similarly released red-eared sliders is a greater threat.^[107] It has also been introduced into waterways near Phoenix, Arizona,^[103] and Miami, Florida,^[108] and to Germany, Indonesia, the Philippines, and Spain.^[3]

Habitat

To thrive, painted turtles need fresh waters with soft bottoms, basking sites, and aquatic vegetation. They find their homes in shallow waters with slow-moving currents, such as creeks, marshes, ponds, and the shores of lakes. The subspecies have evolved different habitat preferences.^[42]

• The eastern painted turtle is very aquatic, leaving the immediate vicinity of its water body only when forced by drought to migrate.^[62] Along the Atlantic, painted turtles have appeared in brackish waters.^[42]
• The midland and southern painted turtles seek especially quiet waters, usually shores and coves. They favor shallows that contain dense vegetation and have an unusual toleration of pollution.^[28][109]
• The western painted turtle lives in streams and lakes, similar to the other painted turtles, but also inhabits pasture ponds and roadside pools. It is found as high as 1,800 m (5,900 ft).^[30]

Population features

Within much of its range, the painted turtle is the most abundant turtle species. Population densities range from 10 to 840 turtles per hectare (2.5 acres) of water surface. Warmer climates produce higher relative densities among populations, and habitat desirability also influences density. Rivers and large lakes have lower densities because only the shore is desirable habitat; the central, deep waters skew the surface-based estimates. Also, lake and river turtles have to make longer linear trips to access equivalent amounts of foraging space.^[40]

Adults outnumber juveniles in most populations, but gauging the ratios is difficult because juveniles are harder to catch; with current sampling methods, estimates of age distribution vary widely.^[110] Annual survival rate of painted turtles increases with age. The probability of a painted turtle surviving from the egg to its first birthday is only 19%. For females, the annual survival rate rises to 45% for juveniles and 95% for adults. The male survival rates follow a similar pattern, but are lower overall than females, creating an average male age lower than that of the female.^[111] Natural disasters can confound age distributions. For instance, a hurricane can destroy many nests in a region, resulting in fewer hatchlings the next year.^[111] Age distributions may also be skewed by migrations of adults.^[110]

To understand painted turtle adult age distributions, researchers require reliable methods.^[112] Turtles younger than four years (up to 12 years in some populations) can be aged based on "growth rings" in their shells.^[113] For older turtles, some attempts have been made to determine age based on size and shape of their shells or legs using mathematical models, but this method is more uncertain.^[113][114] The most reliable method to study the long-lived turtles is to capture them, permanently mark their shells by notching with a drill, release the turtles, and then recapture them in later years.^[115][116] The longest-running study, in Michigan, has shown that painted turtles can live more than 55 years.^[113][117]

Adult sex ratios of painted turtle populations average around 1:1.^[118] Many populations are slightly male-heavy, but some are strongly female-imbalanced; one population in Ontario has a female to male ratio of 4:1.^[46] Hatchling sex ratio varies based on egg temperature. During the middle third of incubation, temperatures of 23–27 °C (73–81 °F) produce males, and anything above or below that, females.^[45] It does not appear that females choose nesting sites to influence the sex of the hatchlings;^[16] within a population, nests will vary sufficiently to give both male and female-heavy broods.^[110]

Taxonomy and evolution

The painted turtle (C. picta) is the only species in the genus Chrysemys.^[6] The parent family for Chrysemys is Emydidae: the pond turtles. Emydidae is split into two sub families; Chrysemys is part of the Deirochelyinae (Western Hemisphere) branch.^[119] The four subspecies of the painted turtle are the eastern (C. p. picta), midland (C. p. marginata), southern (C. p. dorsalis), and western (C. p. bellii).^[120]

The painted turtle's generic name is derived from the Ancient Greek words for "gold" (chryso) and "freshwater tortoise" (emys); the species name originates from the Latin for "colored" (pictus).^[121] The subspecies name, marginata, derives from the Latin for "border" and refers to the red markings on the outer (marginal) part of the upper shell; dorsalis is from the Latin for "back", referring to the prominent dorsal stripe; and bellii honors zoologist Thomas Bell, a collaborator of Charles Darwin.^[122] An alternate East Coast common name for the painted turtle is "skilpot", from the Dutch for turtle, schildpad.^[123]

Classification

Originally described in 1783 by Johann Gottlob Schneider as Testudo picta,^[6][124] the painted turtle was called Chrysemys picta first by John Edward Gray in 1855. The four subspecies were then recognized: the eastern by Schneider in 1783,^[124][125] the western by Gray in 1831,^[125][126] and the midland and southern by Louis Agassiz in 1857.^[127][128]

Until the 1930s many of the subspecies of the painted turtle were labeled by biologists as full species within Chrysemys, but this varied by the researcher. The painted turtles in the border region between the western and midland subspecies were sometimes considered a full species, treleasei. In 1931, Bishop and Schmidt defined the current "four in one" taxonomy of species and subspecies. Based on comparative measurements of turtles from throughout the range, they subordinated species to subspecies and eliminated treleasei.^[129]

Since at least 1958,^{[81][nb 6]} the subspecies were thought to have evolved in response to geographic isolation during the last ice age, 100,000 to 11,000 years ago.^[32] At that time painted turtles were divided into three different populations: eastern painted turtles along the southeastern Atlantic coast; southern painted turtles around the southern Mississippi River; and western painted turtles in the southwestern United States.^[27] The populations were not completely isolated for sufficiently long, hence wholly different species never evolved. When the glaciers retreated, about 11,000 years ago, all three subspecies moved north. The western and southern subspecies met in Missouri and hybridized to produce the midland painted turtle, which then moved east and north through the Ohio and Tennessee river basins.^[81][27]

Biologists have long debated the genera of closely related subfamily-mates Chrysemys, Pseudemys (cooters), and Trachemys (sliders). After 1952, some combined Pseudemys and Chrysemys because of similar appearance.^[130] In 1964, based on measurements of the skull and feet, Samuel B. McDowell proposed all three genera be merged into one. However, further measurements, in 1967, contradicted this taxonomic arrangement. Also in 1967, J. Alan Holman,^[131] a paleontologist and herpetologist, pointed out that, although the three turtles were often found together in nature and had similar mating patterns, they did not crossbreed. In the 1980s, studies of turtles' cell structures, biochemistries, and parasites further indicated that Chrysemys, Pseudemys, and Trachemys should remain in separate genera.^[132]

David E. Starkey and collaborators advanced a new view of the subspecies in 2003. Based on a study of the mitochondrial DNA, they rejected the glacial development theory and argued that the southern painted turtle should be elevated to a separate species, C. dorsalis, while the other subspecies should be collapsed into one and not differentiated.^[133] However, this proposition was largely unrecognized because successful breeding between all subspecies was documented wherever they overlapped.^[125][134] Nevertheless, in 2010, the IUCN recognized both C. dorsalis and C. p. dorsalis as valid names for the southern painted turtle.^[3]

Fossils

Although its evolutionary history—what the forerunner to the species was and how the close relatives branched off—is not well understood, the painted turtle is common in the fossil record.^[136] The oldest samples, found in Nebraska, date to about 15 million years ago. Fossils from 15 million to about 5 million years ago are restricted to the Nebraska-Kansas area, but more recent fossils are gradually more widely distributed. Fossils newer than 300,000 years old are found in almost all the United States and southern Canada.^[1]

DNA

The turtle's karyotype (nuclear DNA, rather than mitochondrial DNA) consists of 50 chromosomes, the same number as the rest of its subfamily-mates and the most common number for Emydidae turtles in general.^{[9][137][138]} Less well-related turtles have from 26 to 66 chromosomes.^[139] Little systematic study of variations of the painted turtle's karotype among populations has been done.^[140] (However, in 1967, research on protein structure of offshore island populations in New England, showed differences from mainland turtles.^[141])

Comparison of subspecies chromosomal DNA has been discussed, to help address the debate over Starkey's proposed taxonomy, but as of 2009 had not been reported.^[140][142] Interestingly, the complete sequencing of the genetic code for the painted turtle was at a "draft assembled" state in 2010. The turtle was one of two reptiles chosen to be first sequenced.^[143]

Interaction with humans

Conservation

The decline in painted turtle populations is not a simple matter of dramatic range reduction, like that of the American bison. Instead the turtle is classified as G5 (demonstrably widespread) in its Natural Heritage Global Rank,^[70] and the IUCN rates it as a species of least concern.^[3] The painted turtle's high reproduction rate and its ability to survive in polluted wetlands and artificially made ponds have allowed it to maintain its range,^[7][144] but the post-Columbus settlement of North America has reduced its numbers.^[37][145]

Only within the Pacific Northwest is the turtle's range eroding. Even there, in Washington, the painted turtle is designated S5 (demonstrably widespread). However, in Oregon, the painted turtle is designated S2 (imperiled),^[146] and in British Columbia, the turtle's populations in the Coast and Interior regions are labeled "endangered"^[147] and "of special concern", respectively.^{[148][nb 7]}

Much is written about the different factors that threaten the painted turtle, but they are unquantified, with only inferences of relative importance.^{[40][111][37]} A primary threat category is habitat loss in various forms. Related to water habitat, there is drying of wetlands, clearing of aquatic logs or rocks (basking sites), and clearing of shoreline vegetation, which allows more predator access^[153] or increased human foot traffic.^[154][155] Related to nesting habitat, urbanization or planting can remove needed sunny soils.^[156]

Another significant human impact is roadkill—dead turtles, especially females, are commonly seen on summer roads.^[157] In addition to direct killing, roads genetically isolate some populations.^[157] Localities have tried to limit roadkill by constructing underpasses,^[158] highway barriers,^[41] and crossing signs.^[159] Oregon has introduced public education on turtle awareness, safe swerving, and safely assisting turtles across the road.^[160]

In the West, human-introduced bass, bullfrogs, and especially snapping turtles, have increased the predation of hatchlings.^[41][161] Outside the Southeast, where sliders are native, released pet red-eared slider turtles increasingly compete with painted turtles.^[162] In cities, increased urban predators (raccoons, canines, and felines) may impact painted turtles by eating their eggs.^[153]

Other factors of concern for the painted turtles include over-collection from the wild,^[163] released pets introducing diseases^[164] or reducing genetic variability,^[162] pollution,^[165] boating traffic, angler's hooks (the turtles are noteworthy bait-thieves), wanton shooting, and crushing by agricultural machines or golf course lawnmowers or all-terrain vehicles.^{[166][167][168]} Gervais and colleagues note that research itself impacts the populations and that much funded turtle trapping work has not been published. They advocate discriminating more on what studies are done, thereby putting fewer turtles into scientists' traps.^[169] Global warming represents an uncharacterized future threat.^[145][170]

Oregon conservation video: If video play problematic, try external links within citations.^[171][172] Note list of factors at 0:30–0:60 and hoop trap at 1:50–2:00.

Pets and other uses

According to a trade data study, painted turtles were the second most popular pet turtles after red-eared sliders in the early 1990s.^[173] As of 2010, most U.S. states allow, but discourage, painted turtle pets, although Oregon forbids keeping them as pets,^[174] and Indiana prohibits their sale.^[164] U.S. federal law prohibits sale or transport of any turtle less than 10 cm (4 in), to limit human contact to salmonella.^[175] However, a loophole for scientific samples allows some small turtles to be sold, and illegal trafficking also occurs.^[161][176]

Painted turtle pet-keeping requirements are similar to those of the red-eared slider. Keepers are urged to provide them with adequate space and a basking site, and water that is regularly filtered and changed. According to Petco, the animals are described as being somewhat unsuitable for children as they do not enjoy being held. Hobbyists have kept turtles alive for decades.^{[177][178][179]}

The painted turtle is sometimes eaten but is not highly regarded as food,^{[37][180][181]} as even the largest subspecies, the western painted turtle, is inconveniently small and larger turtles are available.^[182] Schools frequently dissect painted turtles, which are sold by biological supply companies;^[183] specimens often come from the wild but may be captive-bred.^[184] In the Midwest, turtle racing is popular at summer fairs.^{[183][185][186]}

Capture

Commercial harvesting of painted turtles in the wild is controversial and, increasingly, restricted.^[187][188] Wisconsin formerly had virtually unrestricted trapping of painted turtles but based on qualitative observations forbade all commercial harvesting in 1997.^[189] Neighboring Minnesota, where trappers collected more than 300,000 painted turtles during the 1990s,^[157] commissioned a study of painted turtle harvesting.^[183] Scientists found that harvested lakes averaged half the painted turtle density of off-limit lakes, and population modeling suggested that unrestricted harvests could produce a large decline in turtle populations.^[163] In response, Minnesota forbade new harvesters in 2002 and limited trap numbers. Although harvesting continued,^[163] subsequent takes averaged half those of the 1990s.^[190] As of 2009, painted turtles faced virtually unlimited harvesting in Arkansas, Iowa, Missouri, Ohio, and Oklahoma;^[191] since then, Missouri has prohibited their harvesting.^[192]

Individuals who trap painted turtles typically do so to earn additional income,^[163][187] selling a few thousand a year at $1–2 each.^[183] Many trappers have been involved in the trade for generations, and value it as a family activity.^[189] Some harvesters disagree with limiting the catch, saying the populations are not dropping.^[189]

Many U.S. state fish and game departments allow non-commercial taking of painted turtles under a creel limit, and require a fishing (sometimes hunting) license;^{[nb 8]} others completely forbid the recreational capture of painted turtles. Trapping is not allowed in Oregon, where western painted turtle populations are in decline,^[197] and in Missouri, where there are populations of both southern and western subspecies.^[192] In Canada, Ontario protects both subspecies present, the midland and western,^[198] and British Columbia protects its dwindling western painted turtles.^[53]

Capture methods are also regulated by locality. Typically trappers use either floating "basking traps" or partially submerged, baited "hoop traps".^[199] Trapper opinions,^[199] commercial records,^[190] and scientific studies^{[199][200][201]} show that basking traps are more effective for collecting painted turtles, while the hoop traps work better for collecting "meat turtles" (snapping turtles and soft-shell turtles). Nets, hand capture, and fishing with set lines are generally legal, but shooting, chemicals, and explosives are forbidden.^{[nb 9]}

Culture

Indian tribes were familiar with the painted turtle—young braves were trained to recognize its splashing into water as an alarm—and incorporated it in folklore.^[203] A Potawatomi myth describes how the talking turtles, "Painted Turtle" and allies "Snapping Turtle" and "Box Turtle", outwit the village women. Painted Turtle is the star of the legend and uses his distinctive markings to trick a woman into holding him so he can bite her.^[204] An Illini myth recounts how Painted Turtle put his paint on to entice a chief's daughter into the water.^[205]

As of 2010, four U.S. states designated the painted turtle as official reptile. Vermont honored the reptile in 1994, following the suggestion of Cornwall Elementary School students.^[202] In 1995, Michigan followed, based on the recommendation of Niles fifth graders, who discovered the state lacked an official reptile.^[206] Illinois citizens, in 2004, voted to select the painted turtle as their state reptile and the legislature made it official in 2005.^[207] Colorado chose the western painted turtle in 2008, following the efforts of two succeeding years of Jay Biachi's fourth grade classes.^[208] In New York, the painted turtle narrowly lost (5,048 to 5,005, versus the common snapping turtle) a 2006 statewide student election for state reptile.^[209]

In the border town of Boissevain, Manitoba, a 10,000 lb (4,500 kg) western painted turtle, Tommy the Turtle, is a roadside attraction. The statue was built in 1974 to celebrate the Canadian Turtle Derby, a festival including turtle races that ran from 1972–2001.^[210]

Another Canadian admirer of the painted turtle is Jon Montgomery, who won the 2010 Olympic gold medal in skeleton (a form of sled) racing, while wearing a painted turtle painting on the crown of his helmet, prominently visible when he slid downhill. Montgomery, who also iconically tattoed his chest with a maple-leaf,^[211] explained his visual promotion of the turtle, saying that he had assisted one to cross the road. BC Hydro referred to Montgomery's action when describing its own sponsorship of conservation research for the turtle in British Columbia.^[212][213]

Several private entities use the painted turtle as a symbol. Wayne State University Press operates an imprint "named after the Michigan state reptile" that "publishes books on regional topics of cultural and historical interest".^[214] In California, The Painted Turtle is a camp for ill children, founded by Paul Newman. Painted Turtle Winery of British Columbia trades on the "laid back and casual lifestyle" of the turtle with a "job description to bask in the sun".^[215] Also, there are two Internet companies in Michigan,^[216][217] a guesthouse in British Columbia,^[218] and a café in Maine that use the painted turtle commercially.^[219]

In children's books, the painted turtle is a popular subject, with at least seven books published between 2000 and 2010.^{[nb 10]} "Painted turtle: state reptile of Michigan" is a short song for children.^[227][228]

Notes and references

Notes

Citations

Bibliography

External links

• Media related to painted turtle at Wikimedia Commons
• Missouri Department of Conservation video of southern painted turtle (click video link): Note the discussion of red line on top of shell.
• View a preview of the Painted turtle genome at Ensembl.

Family Emydidae (pond turtles) Kingdom: Animalia Phylum: Chordata Class: Reptilia Order: Testudines Suborder: Cryptodira Superfamily: Testudinoidea Family: Emydidae Genus Species of the subfamily Deirochelyinae Chrysemys Painted turtle Deirochelys Chicken turtle Graptemys Alabama map turtle Barbour's map turtle Black-knobbed map turtle Cagle's map turtle Escambia map turtle False map turtle Northern map turtle Ouachita map turtle Pascagoula map turtle Pearl River map turtle Ringed map turtle Texas map turtle Yellow-blotched map turtle Malaclemys Diamondback terrapin Pseudemys Alabama red-bellied cooter Northern red-bellied cooter Florida red-bellied cooter Peninsula cooter Rio Grande cooter River cooter Texas river cooter Trachemys Big bend slider Baja California slider Central Antillean slider Colombian slider Cuatro Cienegas slider Cuban slider D'Orbigny's slider Hispaniolan slider Jamaican slider Maranhão slider Meso-American slider Nicaraguan slider Ornate slider Pond slider Yaqui slider   Species of the subfamily Emydinae Clemmys Spotted turtle Emys Blanding's turtle European pond turtle Sicilian pond turtle Western pond turtle Glyptemys Bog turtle Wood turtle Terrapene Coahuilan box turtle Common box turtle Ornate box turtle Spotted box turtle Phylogenetic arrangement based on turtles of the world 2011 update: annotated checklist. Subspecies and the extinct (Gyremys sectabilis) are not included.

Extant turtle taxonomy Kingdom: Animalia Phylum: Chordata Class: Reptilia Subclass: Anapsida Order: Chelonii or Testudines Suborder Superfamily Family Subfamily Genus Cryptodira   Chelydridae   Chelydra Macrochelys Chelonioidea Cheloniidae Carettinae Caretta Lepidochelys Cheloniinae Chelonia Eretmochelys Natator Dermochelyidae   Dermochelys Kinosternoidea Dermatemydidae   Dermatemys Kinosternidae Kinosterninae Kinosternon Sternotherus Staurotypinae Claudius Staurotypus Testudinoidea Emydidae Deirochelyinae Chrysemys Deirochelys Graptemys Malaclemys Pseudemys Trachemys Emydinae Clemmys Emys Glyptemys Terrapene Geoemydidae Geoemydinae Batagur Cuora Cyclemys Geoclemys Geoemyda Hardella Heosemys Leucocephalon Malayemys Mauremys Melanochelys Morenia Notochelys Orlitia Pangshura Sacalia Siebenrockiella Vijayachelys Rhinoclemmydinae Rhinoclemmys  Platysternidae   Platysternon Testudinidae   Aldabrachelys Astrochelys Chelonoidis Chersina Cylindraspis Geochelone Gopherus Homopus Indotestudo Kinixys Malacochersus Manouria Psammobates Pyxis Stigmochelys Testudo Trionychia Carettochelyidae   Carettochelys Trionychidae Cyclanorbinae Cyclanorbis Cycloderma Lissemys Trionychinae Amyda Apalone Chitra Dogania Nilssonia Palea Pelochelys Pelodiscus Rafetus Trionyx Pleurodira   Chelidae Chelinae Acanthochelys Chelus Mesoclemmys Phrynops Platemys Rhinemys Chelodininae Chelodina Elseya Elusor Emydura Flaviemys Myuchelys Pseudemydura Rheodytes Hydromedusinae Hydromedusa Pelomedusidae   Pelomedusa Pelusios Podocnemididae   Erymnochelys Peltocephalus Podocnemis Phylogenetic arrangement based on turtles of the world 2012 update: annotated checklist. Extinct turtles not included. Portal Book See also List of Testudines families