Godred Crovan

Godred Crovan
King of Dublin and the Isles
Godred's name as it appears on folio 50v of British Library Cotton MS Julius A VII (the Chronicle of Mann): "Godredus Crouan".[1]
Died	1095 Islay
Burial	possibly Iona
Issue	Lagmann, Aralt, Amlaíb
Dynasty	Crovan dynasty (Uí Ímair)

Godred Crovan (died 1095), known in Gaelic as Gofraid Crobán, Gofraid Meránach, and Gofraid Méránach,^{[note 1]} was a Norse-Gaelic ruler of the kingdoms of Dublin and the Isles. Although his precise parentage is uncertain, he was very likely an Uí Ímair dynast, and probably a descendant of Amlaíb Cuarán, King of Northumbria and Dublin.

Godred first appears on record in the context of supporting the Norwegian invasion of England in 1066. Following the collapse of this campaign, Godred is recorded to have arrived on Mann, at the court of Gofraid mac Sitriuc, King of the Isles, a likely kinsman of his. During the 1070s, the latter died and was succeeded by his son, Fingal. Within the decade, Godred violently seized the kingship for himself, although the exact circumstances surrounding this takeover are uncertain. By 1091, Godred seized the kingship of Dublin, and thereby secured complete control of the valuable trade routes through the Irish Sea region. Godred's expansion may be further perceptible in the Clyde estuary and Galloway, and may well have forced the English to consolidate control of Cumberland in an effort to secure their western maritime flank. Godred appears to have drawn his power from the Hebrides; and archaeological evidence from Mann reveals that, in comparison to the decades previous to his takeover, the island seems to have enjoyed a period of relative peace.

During his reign, Godred appears to have lent military assistance to Gruffudd ap Cynan, King of Gwynedd, a probable kinsman, who was then locked in continuous conflicts with Welsh rivals and encroaching English magnates. The earliest known Bishops of the Isles date from about the time of Godred's reign, although it is almost certain that earlier ecclesiastes held this position. It may have been just prior to Godred's accession in the Isles, whilst Dublin was under the ultimate control of Toirdelbach Ua Briain, King of Munster, that Dublin and the Isles were ecclesiasticly separated once and for all. Godred's rule in Dublin came to an abrupt end in 1094 with his expulsion at the hands of Muirchertach Ua Briain, King of Munster, a man who may have even driven Godred from Mann as well. Documentary evidence reveals that the last decade of the eleventh century saw an upsurge in plague and famine. According to Irish sources, one quarter of Ireland perished from pestilence in 1095 alone. One of the fatalities was Godred himself, who died on Islay, an apparent power centre in the Isles.

Godred's greatest impact on history may have been his founding of the Crovan dynasty, his patrilineal descendants who ruled in the Isles for almost two centuries. Godred was an important maternal ancestor of Clann Somairle, a family that held power in the Isles centuries after the final extinction of the Crovan dynasty. As such, he may be identical to Gofraid mac Fergusa, an apparent genealogical construct claimed as a Clann Somairle ancestor. Godred may well be identical to the celebrated King Orry of Manx legend, a figure traditionally credited with instituting the Manx legal system. Godred and King Orry are associated with numerous historic and prehistoric sites on Mann and Islay.

Familial origins

Map of locations mentioned in the article

The familial origins of Godred Crovan are uncertain.^[17] Although the Chronicle of Mann calls him in Latin "filius Haraldi nigri de Ysland",^[18] implying that his father was named Aralt,^[19] the Annals of Tigernach instead calls him in Gaelic "mac mic Arailt",^[20] contrarily implying that it was Godred's grandfather who was named Aralt.^[19] Godred, therefore, may have been either a son,^[21] nephew,^[22] or brother of Ímar mac Arailt, King of Dublin (died 1054).^{[23][note 2]} As such, Godred was likely a descendant of Amlaíb Cuarán, King of Northumbria and Dublin (died 981), and a member of the Uí Ímair.^[26] The chronicle's aforesaid passage may further cast light on Godred's familial origins. Although "Ysland" may represent Iceland,^[27] there is no other evidence linking Godred to this island.^[19] Alternately, the word may instead represent the Hebridean island of Islay,^[28] where he is otherwise known to have ended his life.^[29] Another possibility is that "Ysland" represents Ireland,^[30] which, if correct, would evidence Godred's close familial links with that particular island.^{[31][note 3]} Whatever the case, according to the same source, he had been brought up on Mann.^{[33][note 4]}

When Godred is first noted by the Latin Chronicle of Mann, he is accorded the epithet "Crouan" or "Crovan".^[36] The origin and meaning of this name are uncertain. It may well be derived from the Gaelic crob bhán ("white-handed").^[37] Another Gaelic origin may be cró bán ("white-blooded"), in reference to being very pale.^[38] Alternately, it could originate from the Gaelic crúbach ("claw"). If the epithet is instead Old Norse in origin, it could be derived from kruppin ("cripple").^[39] In several Irish annals, Godred is accorded the epithet meranach. This word could represent either the Gaelic meránach ("mad", "confused", "giddy"); or else méránach (which can also be rendered mérach), a word derived from mér ("finger" or "toe"). If meranach indeed corresponds to the latter meaning, the epithet would appear to mirror Crouan/Crovan, and imply something remarkable about Godred's hands.^{[40][note 5]} Godred and his patrilineal royal descendants, who reigned in the Isles for about two centuries, are known to modern scholars as the Crovan dynasty, a name coined after Godred himself.^[44] The combination of Old Norse personal names and Gaelic epithets accorded to Godred, and his dynastic descendants, partly evidence the hybrid nature of the Norse-Gaelic Kingdom of the Isles.^[45]

Background

Proposed mid nineteenth-century monument to King Orry, a legendary figure who may be identical to Godred.

One of the foremost leaders of the eleventh-century Norse world was Þorfinnr Sigurðarson, Earl of Orkney (died c. 1065), a man whose maritime empire, like that of his father before him, stretched from Orkney to the Isles, and perhaps even into Ireland as well.^[46] Þorfinnr died in about 1065, and was succeeded by his two sons, Páll (died 1098/9) and Erlendr (died 1098/9). Unfortunately for the brothers, the expansive island empire that their father had forged appears to have quickly disintegrated under their joint rule.^[47] Although there is no record of the brothers conducting military operations in the Isles and Ireland, Orkneyinga saga states that the peripheral regions of their father's lordship reverted to the control of local leaders.^[48] It was into this power vacuum that Godred first emerges into recorded history.^[49]

The ruler the Isles who appears to have suffered from Þorfinnr's southward expansion was Echmarcach mac Ragnaill, King of Dublin and the Isles (died 1064/1065).^[50] The turn of the mid eleventh century saw the gradual decline of Echmarcach's authority.^[51] In 1052, he was driven from Dublin by Diarmait mac Maíl na mBó, King of Leinster (died 1072).^[52] Although there is evidence to suggest that Diarmait reinstated the aforesaid Ímar as King of Dublin, the latter was dead within two years,^[53] and at some point Diarmait appears to have placed his own son, Murchad (died 1070), upon the throne.^[54] About a decade after Diarmait's conquest of Dublin, an invasion of Mann by Murchad appears to have resulted in the submission or expulsion of Echmarcach altogether,^[55] effectively giving Diarmait control over the Irish Sea region.^[56] When Murchad died in 1070, Diarmait assumed control of Dublin and perhaps Mann as well.^[57]

The ruler of Mann in about 1066 was Gofraid mac Sitriuc, King of the Isles (died 1070), a man who appears to have reigned under Diarmait's overlordship. Like Godred himself, Gofraid mac Sitriuc may have been a descendant of Amlaíb Cuarán.^{[58][note 6]} On Diarmait's unexpected death in 1072, Toirdelbach Ua Briain, King of Munster (died 1086) invaded Leinster, and acquired control of Dublin.^[59] Within a year of gaining lordship over the Dubliners, Toirdelbach appears to have installed, or at least recognised a certain Gofraid mac Amlaíb meic Ragnaill (died 1075) as their king.^[60] In fact, this man appears to have been a close kinsman of Echmarcach, possibly his nephew.^[61] As such, Gofraid mac Amlaíb meic Ragnaill was likely a member of the Meic Ragnaill, a Norse-Gaelic kindred possessing close marital links with the Uí Briain.^{[62][note 7]} Such links may well explain the remarkable rapidity with which the Uí Briain struck out at Dublin and the Isles after Diarmait's demise.^[62] In 1073, for instance, Mann was raided by a certain Sitriuc mac Amlaíb (died 1073) and two grandsons of the Uí Briain founder, Brian Bóruma, High King of Ireland (died 1014).^[65] There is reason to suspect that Sitriuc was a Meic Ragnaill, perhaps even a brother of Gofraid mac Amlaíb meic Ragnaill,^[66] whilst the two unidentified Uí Briain could have descended from the Meic Ragnaill as well.^[67] Whatever the case, the attack itself was almost certainly a continuation of the Uí Briain's conquest of Dublin the year before.^[65]

Emergence in the Isles

Romanticised nineteenth-century depictions of Godred Crovan. Vikings were first associated with unhistorical horned-helmets early that century.^[68]

Godred seems to have spent his early career as a mercenary of sorts.^[69] Certainly the Chronicle of Mann states that he took part in the ill-fated Norwegian invasion of England in 1066.^[70] This Norwegian campaign culminated in the Battle of Stamford Bridge, a bloody autumn encounter in which Harold Godwinson, King of England (died 1066) utterly destroyed the forces of Haraldr Sigurðarson, King of Norway (died 1066) in north-eastern England. The slaughter at Stamford resulted in the total destruction of Norwegian military power, and it took almost a generation before a king of this realm could reassert authority in the Norse colonies of the British Isles.^[71] If the eleventh-century chronicler Adam of Bremen (died c. 1081/1085) is to be believed, an Irish king was slain during the battle,^[72] which could indicate that Godred formed part of the Irish Sea contingent,^[73] a host perhaps led by the slain king.^[74] Whatever the case, it was in the aftermath of this defeat that the chronicle first notes Godred: stating that, following his flight from the battle, Godred sought sanctuary from Gofraid mac Sitriuc, and was honourably received by him.^[75] Godred's participation in the Norwegian enterprise, which was also supported by the aforesaid sons of Þorfinnr, partly evidences the far-flung connections and interactions of the contemporary Norse elite.^[76]

A depiction of English infantry and Norman cavalry on the eleventh-century Bayeux Tapestry. In the course of his career, Godred appears to have battled both Anglo-Saxon and Anglo-Norman forces. The depicted infantry are shown formed in a shield wall, a tactic employed by the Norwegian-backed forces at Stamford Bridge.

Godred's arrival on Mann, rather than Dublin, may well be explained by the varying political alignments in the Irish Sea region. Whilst he had allied himself to the cause of the invading Haraldr,^[77] the cause of the defending Harold was clearly adhered to by Diarmait, the contemporary overlord of Dublin. In fact, the latter had lent Harold's family—the Godwinsons—assistance in the decade before the Norwegian invasion,^[78] and sheltered Harold's sons in Dublin following the eventual English defeat at the hands of the Normans;^[79] and further gave the Godwinsons military assistance in their insurrections against the new Norman regime in 1068 and 1069.^[78] Regardless of Godred's possible ancestral links with Ireland and Dublin itself, his political leanings could have meant that the coastal town was unsafe for him in 1066.^[77] Another factor influencing Godred's arrival on Mann may have been the absence of Echmarcach—Gofraid mac Sitriuc's predecessor and Ímar's bitter adversary—at some point earlier in the decade.^[77] As for Gofraid mac Sitriuc himself, the generosity that he showed Godred could well be explained if the two were indeed kinsmen.^[80] Whatever the case, the former's death is recorded in 1070, after which his son, Fingal, apparently succeeded to the kingship.^[81] Possibly in about 1075,^[82] or 1079,^[83] the chronicle reveals that Godred succeeded in conquering Mann following three sea-borne invasions.^[84] On one hand, it is possible that Godred overthrew Fingal,^[85] who may have been weakened by the aforesaid Uí Briain assault on the island in 1073.^[86] On the other hand, the amiable relations between Godred and Fingal's father could suggest that, as long as Fingal lived his kingship was secure, and that it was only after his death that Godred attempted seize control.^[87]

Sky Hill, where Godred is said to have vanquished the Manx once and for all. According to the chronicle, some of his troops hid in the wood surrounding the hill, and his victory was achieved when they ambushed the unsuspecting Manx from the rear.^[88]

Godred's power base may have been located in the Hebrides, the northern reaches of the realm.^[89] After his takeover of Mann, a conquest that culminated in the Battle of Sky Hill, the chronicle claims that Godred offered his followers the choice of either plundering the island or of settling upon it. Only a few of his Islesmen are stated to have remained with him on Mann. According to the chronicle, Godred granted the incomers lands in the south of the island, and allowed the natives lands in the north, on the condition that the latter give up all heritable rights to these lands. It was through this act, alleges the chronicle, that Godred's later successors owned the entirety of the island.^[90] This portrayal of Godred's takeover—in which a conqueror establishes his dynasty's dominance over the traditional rights of a native landholding populace—parallels the traditional mediaeval accounts of Haraldr hárfagri (died c. 932),^[91] in which the latter was said to have deprived Norwegian landholders their heritable oðal rights.^[92]

Although several place names on Mann appear to date to the tenth- and eleventh-centuries, stemming from direct settlement from Norway or Norwegian colonies in Scotland and the Isles, place names that contain the Old Norse element -bý appear to have been coined by later settlers from Denmark or the Danelaw. Some of these settlers would have arrived on the island from the Danelaw in the tenth century, whilst others may well have arrived in the course of Godred's conquest.^[93] In fact, as late as the sixteenth century some of the island's most considerable lands contained this word element.^{[94][note 8]} Almost twenty mediaeval silver hoards have been uncovered on Mann. Almost a dozen date between the 1030s and the 1070s. The finds seem to suggest that the island suffered from power struggles until the establishment of Godred and his descendants.^[98]

Domination of Dublin and the Irish Sea

Image a

Image b

Maughold IV (image a), a Manx runestone displaying a contemporary sailing vessel (detail, image b). The power of the kings of the Isles laid in their armed galley-fleets.^{[note 9]}

The Annals of Tigernach and the Chronicle of Mann evidence Godred's conquest of the Kingdom of Dublin in about 1091.^[100] Specifically, the former source accords him the title "King of Dublin" that year,^[101] whilst the latter source claims that he subjugated all of Dublin and much of Leinster.^[102] Although the chronicle's statement regarding Leinster is almost certainly an exaggeration, it may well refer to the seizure of the full extent of Fine Gall, and the extension of royal authority over adjoining regions.^{[103][note 10]} Godred's acquisition of Dublin may well have been a strike of sheer opportunism in which he took advantage of the ongoing conflict between the kingdoms of Munster and Leinster.^[105] His probable familial links with Dublin could have contributed to his remarkable success as well, and it is possible that the Dubliners considered this conquest as a restoration of the kingdom's royal family.^[106] Certainly his conquests in the Irish Sea region amounted to the reunification of the Uí Ímair imperium.^[41]

Viking Age trade routes in north-west Europe.^[107] As the ruler of Dublin and the Isles, Godred dominated the routes through the Irish Sea region.

Despite Godred's apparent ancestral connections to the kingdoms of Dublin and the Isles, his rise to power may well have been driven by economic realities as much as royal aspirations.^[108] There appear to have been three main routes in the region: one ran from southern Wales to south-eastern Ireland (connecting such towns as Waterford and Wexford in Ireland, with Bristol and St Davids in Wales); another route ran from the river Dee in northern Wales to Mann itself, and to the rivers Liffey and Boyne in Ireland (thereby connecting the ports of Chester and Holyhead in Wales, with those of Dublin and Drogheda in Ireland); the third trade route ran perpendicular to the aforementioned, extending south to the Continent and north through the Hebrides to Iceland, Orkney, Shetland, Scandinavia, and the Baltic region.^[109] Godred's conquest of Dublin, therefore, could have been undertaken in the context of an Islesman securing possession of the region's southernmost routes, thereby giving him total control of the Irish Sea trade nexus.^[108] According to the Chronicle of Mann, Godred "held the Scots in such subjection that no one who built a vessel dared to insert more than three bolts",^[110] a statement implying his maritime dominance over contemporaries.^{[111][note 11]} The naval power of the Islesmen is perhaps evidenced in known military cooperation between the Islesmen—perhaps including Godred himself—and Gruffudd ap Cynan, King of Gwynedd (died 1137), in the last decade of the eleventh century.^[117]

Further expansion of Godred's authority may be perceptible in the Clyde estuary and Galloway, where place names and church dedications suggest Isles-based Norse-Gaelic influence and rule from the ninth- to eleventh centuries.^[118] There is also evidence suggesting that, following Fingal's disappearance from the historical record, Fingal's descendants ruled in parts of Galloway.^[87] Specifically, in 1094, the Annals of Inisfallen record the death of a certain King of the Rhinns named "Macc Congail",^[119] whose recorded patronym may represent confusion between the names Fingal and Congal. Whatever the case, it is unknown if Macc Congail was independent from, or dependent upon, Godred's authority.^[87] Godred's interference in this part of the Irish Sea region could explain an unsuccessful invasion on Mann in 1087.^[120] That year, the Annals of Ulster record that an unnamed Ulaid dynast, and two members of the Meic Ragnaill^[121]—perhaps sons of Echmaracach or Gofraid mac Amlaíb meic Ragnaill^[120]—lost their lives in the assault.^[121] On one hand, the Meic Ragnaill dimension to the attack appears to evidence an attempt to restore themselves on Mann,^[122] and the Ulaid's actions appear to mirror their own response to Dublin-based intrusion into the North Channel earlier in the century.^[120] On the other hand, it is possible that raid was actually an Uí Briain initiative, conducted in the context of an ongoing internal power struggle within the kindred. If so, the attack could have been undertaken by the Meic Ragnaill at the connivance of the Meic Teidc, a branch of the Uí Briain matrilineally related Meic Ragnaill, who may well have used the operation as an means of preventing Mann from falling into the hands of their rival uncle, Muirchertach Ua Briain, King of Munster (died 1119). Although the latter was certainly in the midst of securing control of Dublin,^[123] it is questionable whether he was in any position to contemplate operations in the Irish Sea at this point. In fact, Godred was nearing the height of his own power, and it is unclear if the Meic Taidc enjoyed more amiable relations with the Ulaid than Muirchertach himself.^{[124][note 12]} Whatever the case, Godred's aforesaid expansion into Dublin could well have been undertaken in the aftermath of his successful defence of the island.^[128]

Image a

Image b

Skuldelev II (image a), a contemporary Viking longboat uncovered in Denmark, was originally built of Dublin oak, and dates to about Godred's floruit.^[129] Havhingsten fra Glendalough (image b), a modern Danish reconstruction of Skuldelev II.^[130]

Godred's expansion in the Irish Sea may well have had serious repercussions on mainland politics. Certainly, in the eyes of Máel Coluim mac Donnchada, King of Scotland (died 1093), the prospect of Godred's expansion into the Solway region would have been a threatening development.^[131] Furthermore, in the last decades of the eleventh century there was a breakdown in relations between Máel Coluim and William II, King of England (died 1100). In 1091, Máel Coluim led the Scots across their southern border. Although peace was subsequently restored without bloodshed, the temporary truce fell apart the following year when William seized Cumberland, and established an English colony at Carlisle. Although this northern advance is sometimes regarded as an attempt to keep the Scots in check, the operation also established English control over Norse-Gaelic coastal populations, and secured England's vulnerable north-western maritime flank.^[132] Godred's conquest of Dublin the year before, therefore, may well have influenced William's strategy in the north-west.^[133]

The early dioceses of Dublin and the Isles

One of several ruinous keeills in the churchyard of Kirk Maughold. According to the chronicle, Roolwer was buried at the "church of St Maughold".^[134] Whether this was the site of his cathedral is unknown.^{[135][note 13]}

The ecclesiastical jurisdiction within the Isles during the reigns of Godred's mid-twelfth-century successors was the Diocese of the Isles. Little is known of the early history of the diocese, although its origins may well lie with the Uí Ímair imperium.^[141] Unfortunately, the Chronicle of Mann's coverage of the episcopal succession only starts at about the time of Godred's reign. The bishop first mentioned by this source is a certain "Roolwer",^[142] whose recorded name appears to be a garbled form of the Old Norse Hrólfr.^[143] The chronicle records that Roolwer was the bishop before Godred's reign,^[142] which could either mean that he died before the beginning of Godred's rule, or that Roolwer merely occupied the position at the time of Godred's accession.^[144] Roolwer's recorded name may be evidence that he is identical to one of the earliest bishops of Orkney. Specifically, either Thorulf (fl. 1050)^[145] or Radulf (fl. 1073).^[146] Considering the aforesaid early eleventh-century Orcadian influence in the Isles, it is not inconceivable that the near contemporaneous Church in the region was then under the authority of an Orcadian appointee.^[145]

A noted contemporary of Roolwer was Dúnán (died 1074), an ecclesiast generally assumed to have been the first Bishop of Dublin.^[147] In fact, the Annals of Ulster instead accords him the title "ardespoc Gall" ("high-bishop of the Foreigners"),^[148] and the first Bishop of Dublin solely associated with Dublin is Gilla Pátraic (died 1084),^[149] a man elected to the position by the Dubliners during the regime of Toirdelbach and Gofraid mac Amlaíb meic Ragnaill.^{[150][note 14]}

Roolwer's name as it appears on folio 50v of British Library Cotton MS Julius A VII (the Chronicle of Mann).^[1] The name appears to be a form of Hrólfr, which could be evidence that he is identical to one of the earliest known bishops of Orkney.

There is reason to suspect that Dúnán was Roolwer's antecessor in the Isles. When Dúnán died in 1074, only a few years after Toirdelbach's aforesaid takeover of Dublin, it is possible that the latter seized this opportunity and oversaw the ecclesiastical separation of Dublin from the Isles through the creation of a new episcopal see in Dublin. If so, Roolwer's episcopacy in the Isles may well have begun in 1074 after Dúnán's death, just like Gilla Pátraic's episcopacy in Dublin, and perhaps ended at some point during Godred's reign.^[149] Whatever the case, the chronicle reveals that Roolwer's successor was a certain William (died ×1095),^[152] whose Anglo-Norman or French name may cast light on his origins, and may in turn reveal Gofraid Crobán's links with the wider Anglo-Norman world.^[153] Indeed, such connections would seem to parallel those between Dublin and the Archbishop of Canterbury, forged by Godred's aforesaid contemporaries in Dublin, Toirdelbach and Gofraid mac Amlaíb meic Ragnaill.^[154] Whatever the case, William appears to have died in or before 1095, as the chronicle states that he was succeeded, during Godred's lifetime, by a Manxman named Hamond, son of "Iole".^[155]

Involvement in Wales

One of the most significant eleventh- and twelfth-century Welsh figures was the aforesaid Gruffudd, a man who fended off fellow dynasts and Anglo-Normans alike to establish himself in northern Wales.^[156] Throughout much of the last two decades of the eleventh century Gwynedd was occupied by ever encroaching Anglo-Normans;^[157] and it is apparent that Gruffudd enjoyed close connections with the Norse-Gaelic world.^[158] Specifically, Historia Gruffud vab Kenan reveals that, not only was Gruffudd born and raised in Dublin,^[159] he was yet another distinguished descendant of Amlaíb Cuarán,^[160] and that on several occasions Gruffudd availed himself of Norse-Gaelic military assistance.^[161] After an apparent lull of about two decades, there was a remarkable increase in Norse-Gaelic predatory raids upon Wales throughout the 1070s and 1080s.^[162] In fact, this resurgence coincides with Gruffudd's struggle for power, and may not be an unrelated coincidence.^[163]

Godred could well have assisted Gruffudd in attacking the Anglo-Norman fortress of Aberlleiniog on Anglesey.^[166]

At one point in his career, after briefly gaining power in 1081, Gruffudd was captured by Hugh d'Avranches, Earl of Chester (died 1101), and appears to have been held captive for over a decade, perhaps twelve years.^[167] According to Historia Gruffud vab Kenan, Gruffudd managed to escape his captors and sought military aid in the Isles from certain king named "Gothrei", and endured numerous perils together.^{[168][note 15]} In fact, Godred's reign in Dublin and the Isles at about this time suggests that he is identical to the Gothrei whom Gruffudd fled to.^[171] If Godred was indeed a descendant of Amlaíb Cuarán like Gruffudd, this shared ancestry could well explain the cooperation between the two.^[172] On the other hand, although Gothrei is described as Gruffudd's "friend" or "ally" ("gẏveillt" or "gyveillt"),^[173] no specific kinship is acclaimed by the source, which may indicate that Gruffudd's appeal was one of mere expediency.^[174] Whatever the case, having gained the aforesaid support from the Isles, in the form of an armed naval force of sixty ships, Historia Gruffud vab Kenan records that Gruffudd invaded Anglesey and defeated a force of Anglo-Normans, before the Islesmen returned home.^[175] Gruffudd and Gothrei appear to have directed their efforts against the Anglo-Norman castle of Aberlleiniog, before the former tackled other installations.^[176] A significant feature of the encroachment of English power into Gwynedd was the erection of a line of mottes along the northern Welsh coast. The strategic placement of these military sites suggests that they were constructed with the command of the sea in mind.^[177] As such, this fortified coastal network could have been perceived as a potential threat to Norse-Gaelic mercenarial operations and raiding expeditions in the region, and may partly explain Gothrei's cooperation with Gruffudd.^{[178][note 16]}

Great Orme, where Grithfridus is said to have made landfall before battling and killing Robert de Tilleul.

In 1093, at about the time of this cooperation between Gruffudd and Gothrei, Orderic Vitalis (died c. 1142) recorded the death of Robert de Tilleul (died c. 1093), an imminent Anglo-Norman based in Rhuddlan. According to Orderic, Robert was slain by a certain king named "Grithfridus". Although there is reason to suspect that the latter is identical to Gruffudd,^[181] this identification is by no means certain, as the less than impartial Historia Gruffud vab Kenan makes no mention of this episode at all.^[182] In fact, another possibility is that the sea-roving Grithfridus is identical to Gothrei, and thus Godred himself.^[183] Whatever the case, Orderic's account states that Robert was slain during a sea-borne predatory raid in which Grithfridus' three-ship-force made landfall under the cliffs of Great Orme. Orderic's account further relates that Grithfridus' troops ravished the surrounding countryside, loaded their ships with livestock and captives, after which they fought and crushed Robert's forces, and Grithfridus had the latter's decapitated head bound as a trophy to the top of his mast.^[181]

Just as Godred's rise in the Irish Sea region appear to have provoked William II to protect the north-western reaches of his realm,^[133] the participation of the Islesmen in war-wracked northern Wales may have provoked a similar response as the Islesmen's activity there, and the prospect of their consolidation on Anglesey, posed a potential threat to English interests in the area.^{[184][note 17]} Specifically, Historia Gruffud vab Kenan records that William II launched an utterly unsuccessfully campaign into the region, directed at Gruffudd himself, and that the English were forced to turn back having gained any plunder.^[187] That being said, an alternate possibility is that William II was lured into the region by the native resurgence throughout the Welsh Marches,^[188] an event in which Gruffudd's participation is uncertain.^[189] Whatever the reason, the English counter-operation appears to have been undertaken with mainly defensive objectives in mind.^[190]

Downfall and death

Late eleventh-century cross-slab found on Islay.

Godred's rule in Dublin lasted until 1094. That year the Annals of Inisfallen reveal that warfare broke out between Muirchertach and a northern Irish alliance that included Godred. This source and the Annals of Clonmacnoise, the Annals of the Four Masters, and the Annals of Ulster, reveal that Muirchertach marched upon Dublin where he was confronted by the alliance. Godred's maritime force in this campaign is numbered at ninety ships by the Annals of the Four Masters. Although all these sources indicate that Muirchertach's forces were at first forced to flee, Muirchertach soon returned after the alliance had dispersed, and succeeded in driving Godred from Dublin.^[191] The Annals of Inisfallen appears to indicate that warfare between Muirchertach and Godred was wrought throughout the year. The source also reveals that, during Dublin's fall, Muirchertach captured Conchobar Ua Conchobair Failge, King of Uí Failge.^[192] Although the Uí Failge had previously enjoyed the patronage of the Uí Briain, it is possible that Godred had forged an alliance with Conchobar.^[184] Following the Uí Briain conquest of Dublin, the Ua Conchobair kings of Uí Failge may have been the only Leinster lords who refused to acknowledge Muirchertach's overlordship.^[193]

From a late eleventh-century Irish perspective, dominance of Dublin appears to have been a virtual prerequisite of gaining the Irish high-kingship,^[194] and Muirchertach's quest for control of this coastal kingdom appears to have been undertaken in such a context. In fact, the aforesaid sources reveal that Godred had allied himself with Muirchertach's fiercest rival for the high-kingship, Domnall Mac Lochlainn, King of Cenél nEógain (died 1121),^[195] an alliance which may have contributed to Godred's successes in Dublin.^[196] Just as Godred's seizure of Dublin appears to taken place at a point when two superior powers were occupied elsewhere,^[105] Godred's expulsion from the kingdom appears to have taken place at a time when Muirchertach's hands were free, having temporarily settled matters with his rival half-brother, the aforesaid Diarmait Ua Briain,^[184] and having earned some success in extending Uí Briain power into Connacht.^[197]

Contemporary numismatic material concerning Dublin indicates that, starting in 1095, immediately following Godred's demise, the kingdom's coinage became drastically debased in terms of weight and stylistic quality. For about a generation previous, Dublin's coinage had imitated the near contemporary styles of the English and Anglo-Normans, albeit with varying consistency, but immediately after 1095 Dublin's coins dramatically degenerated into poor imitations of nearly century-old designs.^[198] This could be evidence that, in comparison to Muirchertach's immediate Norse-Gaelic predecessors in Dublin, his own regime lacked the expertise to ensure the vitality of the kingdom's commerce and currency.^[199]

Godred's name and title as it appears on folio 30v of Bodleian Library MS Rawlinson B 503 (the Annals of Inisfallen): "Gobraith, ríg Atha Cliath & Inse Gall".^[200] This title, describing him as king of both Dublin and the Isles, is quite rare and may further evidence Godred's Irish connections.^[201]

Annalistic evidence from throughout Europe indicates that the continent suffered from a resurgence of plague and famine during the first years of the 1090s.^[202] In fact, if the Annals of the Four Masters is to be believed, about a quarter of Ireland's population succumbed to pestilence in 1095. This source,^[203] and a host of others, such as the Annals of Clonmacnoise, the Annals of Inisfallen, the Annals of Tigernach, and the Annals of Ulster, all single him out as one of the many mortalities.^[204] The Chronicle of Mann, which also records Godred's death, reveals that he died on Islay.^[205] The fact that he met his end on the island could be evidence that Muirchertach not only drove him Dublin, but from Mann as well.^{[206][note 18]} The chronicle, however, may contradict this version of events since it states that Godred was succeeded by his eldest son, Lagmann.^[208]

On Godred's death, the Annals of Inisfallen accord him the title "ríg Atha Cliath & Inse Gall" (translated variously as "King of Dublin and of the Isles" and "king of Dublin and the Hebrides",^[209] a remarkable designation in the fact that it is quite rare,^[210] and perhaps only elsewhere accorded to the aforesaid Diarmait. In the case of the latter, the title may emphasise Diarmait's achievement of stretching his influence from Ireland into the Isles. In Godred's case, however, the title may instead underscore Godred's expansion into Ireland from the Isles.^[201] The chronicle's record of Godred's death on Islay could indicate that the island formed a secondary power centre in the Isles.^[211] The fact that Historia Gruffud vab Kenan notes that Gruffudd travelled into the Isles to obtain the aforesaid military assistance from Gothrei could also be evidence that Godred's headquarters was based there.^[212] The record of Godred's death on Islay further suggests that he may well have been buried on the nearby holy island of Iona, the burial place of his like-named grandson, Gofraid mac Amlaíb, King of Dublin and the Isles (died 1187).^[213]

Legacy

Síol nGofraidh and the Crovan dynasty

"The Landing of King Orry", an early twentieth-century railway poster depicting the legendary King Orry.^[214]

Godred's greatest impact on history may have been his foundation of the Crovan dynasty,^[215] a vigorous family of sea-kings that ruled in the Isles for almost two centuries, until its extinction in the mid thirteenth century, when the remaining kingdom was annexed by Alexander III, King of Scotland (died 1286).^[216] There is uncertainty concerning the political situation in the Isles in the last decade of the eleventh century.^[217] It is apparent, however, that the dynasty descended from him soon turned upon itself. Although Godred's eldest son, Lagmann, appears to have succeeded him during the decade, the latter was soon forced to fend off rivals factions supporting Godred's younger sons, Aralt in particular.^[218] Irish power appears to have encroached into the Isles at about this time as well,^[219] and it is evident that the political upheaval and dynastic instability in the wake of Godred's demise eventually provoked Magnús Óláfsson, King of Norway (died 1103) to forcibly take control of the Isles before the century's end.^[220] It wasn't until the about the second decade of the twelfth century that the Crovan dynasty re-established firm control, in the person of Amlaíb (died 1153), Godred's youngest son.^[221]

In the mid twelfth century, the Isles were partitioned between two rival power blocks. One faction, controlling Mann and the northern Hebrides, was led by the representative of the Crovan dynasty, the aforesaid Gofraid mac Amlaíb, grandson of Godred; the other faction, controlling the southern Hebrides, was ruled by Somairle mac Gilla Brigte, Lord of Argyll (died 1164), husband of Ragnailt ingen Amlaíb, Godred's granddaughter. Somairle eventually forced his aforesaid brother-in-law from power, and ruled the entire kingdom for almost a decade before the Crovan dynasty regained control of their permanently partitioned domain.^{[222][note 19]} Although the dynasty expired in the mid thirteenth century, Somairle's descendants—Clann Somairle—held power in the Hebrides for centuries to come.^[223] In fact, the later mediaeval Clann Somairle Lordship of the Isles, which survived into the late fifteenth century, was a direct successor of Godred's maritime imperium.^[224]

Image a

Image b

Forms of Gofraid mac Fergusa's name as they appear on folios 13r (image a) and 320v (image b) of the seventeenth-century Dublin Royal Irish Academy MS C iii 3 (the Annals of the Four Masters).

The Chronicle of Mann, Orkneyinga saga, and later tradition preserved in the eighteenth-century Book of Clanranald, reveal that it was through Ragnailt's descent that Clann Somairle, and Somairle himself, claimed kingship in the Isles.^[225] Godred's place at the royal apex of the two dynasties who contested the kingship of the Isles in the twelfth- and thirteenth centuries suggests that he is identical to the like-named man proclaimed as an immanent ancestral figure in two thirteenth-century poems concerning Clann Somairle dynasts.^[226] The professed descendants of this Gofraid were poetically conceptualised as Síol nGofraidh ("the seed of Gofraid"), a Gaelic term that conceivably originally applied to both the Crovan dynasty and Clann Somairle.^[227] Later unease with a matrilineal descendent from Godred may have led to the invention of a patrilineal descent of Clann Somairle from a like-named man with enviable, albeit concocted, Scottish connections. Godred, therefore, may be identical to the anachronistic Gofraid mac Fergusa,^[227] an alleged ninth-century figure dubiously noted in the Annals of the Four Masters,^[228] and otherwise only specifically attested in later genealogical accounts concerning Clann Somairle.^{[227][note 20]}

Memory in Manx and Hebridean tradition

Image a

Image b

Image c

Prehistoric sites linked to Godred Crovan in modern times: King Orry's Grave, Mann (image a), Cashtel yn Ard, Mann (image b), and Carragh Bhàn, Islay (image c).

Godred's arrival on Mann is commonly taken as a starting point of Manx history. This elevated place in the island's historiography is partly due to his position as an apical ancestral figure of later kings, and by his preeminent position in the historical account of the Isles preserved by the Chronicle of Mann. In fact, this source appears to have been commissioned by Godred's later descendants as a means to legitimize their claims to the kingship, and the later historiographical emphasis that separates Godred from his predecessors may well be unwarranted.^[229] That being said, Godred is possibly the historical prototype of the celebrated King Orry (Manx Gaelic Ree Gorree) of Manx folklore.^{[230][note 21]} This legendary figure appears in the earliest example of Manx literature, the so-called Manannan Ballad,^[233] an eighteenth-century text that appears to contain content of sixteenth-century provenance.^[234] This traditional account of Mann asserts that, following King Orry's arrival, and his subsequent introduction of the island's legal system, thirteen of his descendants ruled in turn as king before Alexander III's takeover.^[235] In fact, this tally appears to conform to the number of historical Manx rulers during the Crovan dynasty's floruit.^[233] King Orry, and thus Godred himself, is seemingly referred to in Manx legislation dating to the early fifteenth-century, as the term "in King Orryes Days" was recorded at the 1422 sitting of Tynwald.^[236] This phrase likely equates to "time immemorial", a time beyond memory, once defined under English law as the time before the reign of the celebrated Richard I, King of England (died 1199).^[231]

According to local tradition on Islay, Godred's grave is marked by Carragh Bhàn (grid reference NR32834781), a standing stone situated near the settlement of Kintra, on the island's Oa peninsula.^[237] The site itself is likely prehistoric,^[238] although there is a legitimate late eleventh-century cross-slab found on the island, near Port Ellen (grid reference NR357458), that appears to contain motifs from contemporary Scandinavian- and Irish art.^[239] As with Godred on Islay, supposed burial places of King Orry are traditionally marked by prehistoric burial sites on Mann.^[240] One such site is the now-mutilated tomb, known as King Orry's Grave (grid reference SC440844), located near Laxey; another is Cashtal yn Ard (grid reference SC463893), also known as Cashtal Ree Gorree, located near Maughold.^[241] Godred Crovan's Stone, a massive granite rock, once located in the Manx parish of Malew but destroyed in the nineteenth century, may have owed its name to eighteenth- or nineteenth-century romanticism.^[242]

The area surrounding Dùn Ghùaidhre, a ruinous mediaeval fortress on Islay, is traditionally associated with Godred.^[243]

The area surrounding Dùn Ghùaidhre (grid reference NR38926483),^[244] a ruinous mediaeval fortress on Islay, is traditionally associated with Godred,^[243] and overlooks some of the island's most fertile lands.^[244] The south-east ridge along Dùn Ghùaidhre is named in Gaelic Clac an Righ ("Ridge of the King").^[245] According to local tradition, Godred slew a dragon at Emaraconart, a site only about 2 kilometres (1.2 mi) from the fortress and ridge.^[243] Although the present form of the fort's name appears to refer to Godred himself, it is unknown if there is any historical connection between him and the site.^[246] A nearby site is Àiridh Ghutharaidh. The etymology of this place name is uncertain. It could be derived from the Gaelic àirigh ("shieling") and *Gutharaidh (a hypothesised Gaelic form of the Old Norse personal name Guðrøðr). The fact that this site is only about 2 kilometres (1.2 mi) from Dùn Ghùaidhre could suggest that the names of both locations refer to Godred.^[247] On the other hand, it is possible that the names of the fort, ridge, and shieling are merely the result of folk etymology.^[248] Another Islay site associated with Godred is Conisby (grid reference NR262618). This place name is derived from the Old Norse *Konungsbýr ("king's farm"), a prestigious designation that appears to echo the district's not insignificant size and quality of lands. Whether the site was ever owned by a king is unknown, although local tradition certainly associates it with Godred himself.^[249]

Detail of a proposed mid nineteenth-century Manx monument to King Orry.

The eighteenth-century poet Thomas Chatterton (died 1770) composed Godred Crovan, a poem that appeared in print in 1769, under the full title Godred Crovan. A poem. Composed by Dopnal Syrric, Scheld of Godred Crovan, King of the Isle of Man, published in the Town and Country Magazine.^[250] The poem appears to have influenced the work of the contemporaneous poet William Blake (died 1827), particularly Blake's first piece of revolutionary poetry, Gwin, King of Norway.^[251] Whilst Chatterton's composition tells the tale of an invasion of Mann by a tyrannous Norseman named Godred Crovan,^[252] Blake's ballad is about a tyrannous Norse king who is slain by a native giant named Gordred.^[253] Chatterton's compositions in Town and Country Magazine were strongly influenced by, and imitative of, the so-called Ossianic poetry of the contemporaneous poet James Macpherson (died 1796). In fact, it was likely through Chatterton's work that Blake was most influenced by Macpherson.^[254] Unlike Macpherson, who deceptively insisted that his epic Ossianic corpus was translated from the work of an ancient Celtic bard,^[255] Chatterton did not claim his Ossianic inspired compositions were the remnants of ancient literature.^{[256][note 22]}

In the wake of Macpherson's publications, several examples of Manx volkslied appear to have first come to light. One particular piece, a Manx Gaelic song called Fin as Oshin, is the only example of Fíanaigecht existing in Manx musical tradition.^{[257][note 23]} Surviving in three eighteenth-century manuscripts,^[257] Fin as Oshin tells a tale similar to other poems recounting the story of the burning of Finn's house.^[259] A central character in the song is a certain Orree/Orree Beg, a hero who corresponds to Garadh/Garaidh in cognate tales. The spelling of this hero's name in Fin as Oshin suggests that he represents Godred himself, thereby giving the story a native slant.^{[260][note 24]} In Vindication of the Celtic Character, the nineteenth-century Gaelic poet William Livingstone (died 1870) offered imaginative accounts of Viking incursions on Islay. One such tale, alleged by Livingstone to have been "handed down from the Danish mythologists of those days", concerns exploits of Godred in the island's Loch Indaal vicinity. Livingstone's versions of such local traditions appear to be the inspiration behind his epic Gaelic battle-poem Na Lochlannaich an Ile ("The Norsemen in Islay").^[262] The Gaelic folk song Birlinn Ghoraidh Chróbhain, sometimes called Birlinn Ghoraidh Chrobhain and Godred Crovan's Galley, was composed by Duncan Johnston (died 1947), and released in part one of his 1938 book Cronan nan Tonn. Johnston's song describes the journey of Godred's royal birlinn from Mann to Islay in 1095, and commemorates the sea-power of the Crovan dynasty.^[263]

Notes

Citations

References

Primary sources

Secondary sources

External links

• How Goraidh Crobhan slayed a dragon @ Tobar an Dualchais – Kist o Riches, recording of an account of Godred slaying a dragon on Islay
• Bìrlinn Ghoraidh Chrobhain @ Tobar an Dualchais – Kist o Riches, recording of a song concerning Godred
• Bìrlinn Ghoraidh Chròbhain @ Tobar an Dualchais – Kist o Riches, recording of a song concerning Godred
• Bìrlinn Ghoraidh Chròbhain @ Tobar an Dualchais – Kist o Riches, recording of a song concerning Godred

Media related to King Orry at Wikimedia Commons

Media related to Godred Crovan at Wikimedia Commons

Kings of Dublin 9th century Amlaíb Ímar Auisle Albann^ Oistin mac Amlaíb* Bárid mac Ímair Sichfrith mac Ímair Sitriuc mac Ímair Sichfrith Jarl^ Glúniarann* Ímar ua Ímair 10th century Sitric Cáech Gofraid Amlaíb mac Gofraid Blácaire Gofraid mac Sitriuc Amlaíb Cuarán Glúniairn Ímar Sigtrygg Silkbeard 11th century Echmarcach Ímar mac Arailt Echmarcach Murchad mac Diarmata Diarmait Toirdelbach Ua Briain Gofraid mac Amlaíb meic Ragnaill Domnall mac Murchada Muirchertach Donnchad Muirchertach? Gofraid Crobán Domnall mac Taidc? Domnall Gerrlámhach? 12th century Magnús berfœttr? Domnall Gerrlámhach Diarmait mac Énna Domnall Gerrlámhach Toirdelbach Ua Conchobair Énna Mac Murchada Conchobar Ua Conchobair Conchobar Ua Briain Ottir Ragnall? Ottir Brodar Gofraid mac Amlaíb Ascall ^ Disputed * Speculative