Eastcliffe Hall

The Eastcliffe Hall was a Great Lakes bulk carrier which sank in the Saint Lawrence Seaway on the morning of 14 July 1970 with the loss of nine crewmen and family members.

History

The Eastcliffe Hall was built by Canadian Vickers Limited of Montreal, and used as a cargo carrier on the Great Lakes. Originally 252.5 ft in length with gross tonnage of 2140 she was subsequently lengthened to 342.5 ft and her tonnage increased to 3335 GRT with 5750 tons deadweight capacity. She was operated by the Hall Corporation and carried a variety of cargoes through the Great Lakes-Saint Lawrence Seaway system.

Last voyage

On her last voyage, she sailed southwest on the Saint Lawrence River from the port of Sorel Quebec, bound for Saginaw, Michigan with a cargo of 5661 long tons of pig iron ingots and 21 crewmen and family members under the command of Captain Richard Groulx, aboard. After passing Montreal, the ship made her way through the Snell and Eisenhower locks before running aground on the Gooseneck Island shoal in the early morning hours of 14 July. The captain and crew freed the ship from the shoal only to strike another underwater abutment near Crysler Shoal a short time later. The captain was repeatedly told that the ship had run aground but he refused to believe it. At one point, he remarked "It's alright. Apparently there is no damage to my barge". This was the final message received from Captain Groulx. ^[1] The ship sank in three minutes in about 70 feet of water with the loss of the captain, his son Alain and seven others including engineer William Demers, his wife Jacqueline and their six-year-old daughter Nathalie.^[2] Two of the surviving crew members reported that the ship sank so fast, the inrush of current compressed air in the engine room which blasted them through a hole in the skylight.^[3] The surviving crew members clung to wreckage until being rescued. Canadian and US Coast Guards rescued 12 crew members. ^[4]

Inquiry into sinking

On 26 August 1970 an official inquiry was begun to determine the cause of the ship's sinking. The inquiry was presided by Judge Francois Chevalier of Hull, Quebec. The inquiry was requested by Transport Minister Don Jamieson.^[5]

During the inquiry, it was revealed that blood tests from the body of the captain revealed a high alcohol content, 360 milligrams per 100 millilitres of alcohol or 0.36 percent weight by volume. This was concluded by chemist John Howes, employed by the Centre for Forensic Sciences, University of Toronto, who conducted the testing. Howes informed the inquiry of the high alcohol content in the captain's body. Howes was quoted as saying "There would be every indication of mental and physical drunkenness in the average person. The average person would be nearly unconscious. They would have difficulty walking, talking, muscular coordination and seeing... He wouldn't be able to act immediately to an emergency. It is possible he might not react at all." ^[6]

The inquiry was concluded with a 49 page report whereby Justice Francois Chevalier, of the Superior Court of Quebec, concluded the sinking of the Eastcliffe Hall was due to the captain's "state of plain drunkenness". Justice Chevalier also noted, "That the ship and all its contents, cargo, and human beings were in the hands of a blind man who did not know where he was nor what he was doing." ^[7]

Shipwreck

Following the sinking, the protruding masts and cargo were removed and the forward superstructure was dynamited back into the forward hold to clear the site as a navigational hazard. Though the surface currents are quick, the ship has since become a popular destination for recreational divers.

References