E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial (video game)

E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial (also referred to simply as E.T.) is a 1982 adventure video game developed and published by Atari, Inc. for the Atari 2600 video game console. It is based on the film of the same name, and was designed by Howard Scott Warshaw. The objective of the game is to guide the eponymous character through various screens to collect three pieces of an interplanetary telephone that will allow him to contact his home planet.

Warshaw intended the game to be an innovative adaptation of the film, and Atari thought it would achieve high sales figures based on its connection with the film, which was extremely popular throughout the world. Negotiations to secure the rights to make the game ended in late July 1982, giving Warshaw only five and a half weeks^[2] to develop the game in time for the 1982 Christmas season. The result is often cited as one of the worst video games released and was one of the biggest commercial failures in video gaming history. The game's commercial failure and resulting effects on Atari are frequently cited as a contributing factor to the video game industry crash of 1983.

It was generally believed that as a result of overproduction and returns, millions of unsold cartridges were buried in an Alamogordo, New Mexico landfill. In 2013, plans were revealed to conduct an excavation to determine the accuracy of reports about the burial,^[3] and in April of the following year, the diggers confirmed that the Alamogordo Burial did include E.T. cartridges among other titles.^[4][5] James Heller, the former Atari manager who was in charge of the original burial, was also on hand at the excavation and revealed to the Associated Press that 728,000 cartridges of various titles were buried.^[6]

Gameplay

One of the screens in the game. E.T. meets Elliott in a field of wells. Reese's Pieces are scattered throughout the world and are represented by dark dots.

E.T. is an adventure game in which players control an alien (E.T.) from a top-down perspective. The objective of the game is to collect three pieces of an interplanetary telephone. The pieces are found scattered randomly throughout various pits (also referred to as wells). The player is provided with an on-screen energy bar, which decreases when E.T. performs any actions (including moving, teleporting, or falling into a pit, as well as levitating back to the top). To prevent this, E.T. can collect Reese's Pieces, which are used to restore his energy or, when nine are collected, E.T. can call Elliott to obtain a piece of the telephone, or the player can save the candy pieces for bonus points at the end. After the three phone pieces have been collected, the player must guide E.T. to an area where he can use the phone, which allows him to call his home planet. When the call is made, E.T. must reach the spaceship in a given time limit. Once E.T. gets to the forest where his ship abandoned him and stands and waits in the designated area for the ship to come, the ship will appear on screen and take him back to his home planet. Then the game starts over, with the same difficulty level, while changing the location of the telephone pieces. The score obtained during the round is carried over to the next iteration. The game ends when the energy bar depletes.^[7] E.T. has three lives and if he dies within those three lives Elliot will come in and revive him. E.T. can get a fourth life if the player is lucky enough to find a geranium in one of the wells. It turns into a sprite from some games that Howard Scott Warshaw made, such as Raiders of the Lost Ark.

The game is divided into six environments, each representing a different setting from the film. To accomplish the objective of the game, the player must guide E.T. into the wells. Once all items found in a well are collected, the player must levitate E.T. out of them.^[8] An icon at the top of each screen represents the current area, each area enabling the player to perform different actions. Antagonists include a scientist who takes E.T. for observation and an FBI agent who chases the alien to confiscate one of the collected telephone pieces, or candy.^[7] The game offers diverse difficulty settings that affect the number and speed of humans present, and the conditions needed to accomplish the objective.

Development

The process began in July 1982 and was completed before the end of the year. Following the commercial success of the film in June 1982, Steve Ross, chief executive officer (CEO) of Atari's parent company Warner Communications, started negotiations with Steven Spielberg and Universal Pictures to acquire the license to produce a video game based on the film. In late July, Warner announced its exclusive worldwide rights to market coin-operated and console games based on the movie.^[9] Although the exact details of the transaction were not disclosed in the announcement, it was later reported that Atari had paid US$20–25 million for the rights, a high figure for video game licensing at the time.^[10][11][12] When asked by Ross what he thought about making an E.T.-based video game, Atari CEO Ray Kassar replied, "I think it's a dumb idea. We've never really made an action game out of a movie."^[11] An arcade game based on the E.T. property had also been planned, but this was deemed to be impossible given the short deadline.^[13]

After negotiations completed, Kassar called Howard Scott Warshaw on July 27, 1982 to commission him as developer of the video game.^[14][15] Kassar informed him that Spielberg asked for Warshaw specifically and that development needed to be completed by September 1 to meet a production schedule for the Christmas holiday. Though Warshaw had spent over a year working on consecutive development schedules for games (seven months working on Yars' Revenge and then six months on Raiders of the Lost Ark), he accepted the offer based on the challenge of completing a game in a short time frame and at Spielberg's request.^[13][15] Warshaw considered it an opportunity to develop an innovative Atari 2600 game based on a movie he enjoyed, "provided we reach the right arrangement".^{[15][16]:9:34} Kassar reportedly offered Warshaw US$200,000 and an all-expenses-paid vacation to Hawaii in compensation.^[13] Kassar then told him to arrive at the San Jose Airport a few days later to have a meeting with Spielberg.^[15]

Warshaw used those days to design the structure of the game and segmented the concept into four ideas: world, objective, path to achieve the objective, and obstacles. He envisioned a three-dimensional cube world as the setting and adapted part of the film's plot, E.T. phoning home, as the goal. Warshaw then conceived that E.T. would need to assemble a special phone to call his ship and arrive at a special landing site to achieve this goal. He considered obstacles as an element that would determine the success of a game, and experienced difficulties when taking into account the time constraints and technical limitations of the console. Inspired by the movie, adults were implemented as antagonists that would chase the alien. Feeling more adversity was needed, Warshaw included a time limit for players to accomplish the goal. Pits were devised as an element to hide the pieces of the phone as well as expand the game's world.^[15]

Warshaw and other Atari executives presented this design to Spielberg, who did not express enthusiasm.^[14] Spielberg instead asked him to create a game similar to Namco's Pac-Man.^[15] Believing the concept too derivative of a common game design, Warshaw proceeded with his concept, which he felt would capture the sentimentality he saw in the original film.^[10][14] In retrospect, however, Warshaw stated that Spielberg's idea might have had merit.^[14][15] He spent the remaining time programming the game. Atari anticipated enormous sales based on the popularity of the film, as well as the stability the video game industry was experiencing in 1982. Due to time limitations, Atari decided to skip audience testing for the product.^[17] Emanual Gerard, co-chief operating officer of Warner at the time, later suggested that the company had fallen into a false sense of security by the success of its previous releases, particularly its console version of Pac-Man, which was commercially successful despite poor critical reaction.^[18][19]

Reception

The player must navigate E.T. into wells to search for pieces of the interplanetary telephone. This aspect of the game was negatively received by players and critics.

Anticipation for E.T. was high in 1982, and it was a sought-after Christmas gift.^[15] In early December 1982, the New York Times reported that video games based on successful movies, specifically E.T., would become "an increasingly profitable source" for video game development.^[20] At first, retailers ordered more supplies than what was expected to be sold, but Atari received an increasing number of order cancellations as new competitors entered the market, an event the company had not anticipated.^[18][21][22] John Hubner and William Kistner of InfoWorld attribute the cancellations to changes Atari initiated between its relationship between distributors. On November 1, 1982, Atari informed them that their contracts were canceled and that exclusive deals would be established with select distributors. Hubner and Kistner believed the action prompted retailers to cancel orders, which Atari had not properly tracked.^[23]

E.T. met with initial commercial success. It was among the top four on Billboard magazine's "Top 15 Video Games" sales list in December 1982 and January 1983.^[24] The game eventually sold 1.5 million units, becoming one of the best-selling Atari 2600 titles.^[19][25] However, between 2.5 and 3.5 million cartridges went unsold.^[8][25][26] Hubner and Kistner commented that the large number of produced cartridges may have resulted in excess inventory regardless of E.T.'s success.^[23] Even though the game was a best seller during the holiday season, retailers still stated that its sales figures did not meet expectations. Warner Communications also expressed disappointment at the number of sales.^[12] Lower than expected sales figures combined with excess inventory, which produced a negative supply and demand event, prompted retailers to repeatedly discount price. According to Ray Kassar, about 3.5 million of the 4 million produced were sent back to the company as unsold inventory or customer returns.^[27] Despite sales figures, the quantity of unsold merchandise, coupled with the expensive movie license and the large amount of returns, made E.T. a major financial failure for Atari.^[26] By 2004, the cartridges were still very common and priced at very low amounts.^[28]

Critical response

While reviews of the movie version of E.T. were highly positive, the game was negatively received by critics, with common complaints focused on the plot, gameplay, and visuals. New York magazine's Nicholas Pileggi described it as a loser when compared to other games Atari could have released like Donkey Kong and Frogger.^[22] Video Games called the game "really for kids (the littler ones)."^[29] Kevin Bowen of GameSpy's Classic Gaming called the gameplay "convoluted and inane", also criticizing its story for departing from the serious tone of the film.^[7] Author Steven Kent described the game as "infamous" within the industry, citing "primitive" graphics, "dull" gameplay, and a "disappointing story".^[11] In 1984 Softline readers named the game the second-worst Atari program of 1983, after Congo Bongo.^[30]

Nevertheless, the game also received some more positive reviews. An editor for The Miami Herald described it as a difficult game to learn to play, but felt it was worth dedicating the time.^[31] Vidiot's Kevin Christopher criticized the protagonist's repeated falling down back into holes, but considered it "about the only flaw with an otherwise A-1 game."^[32] Arcade Express scored it 6 out of 10 in December 1982.^[33]

Critics bemoaned the gameplay's repetitive use of falling down holes.^[11][34] Emru Townsend of PC World discussed the game with a group, and found a universal dislike for the pits that E.T. falls into, describing it as "monotonous".^[34] Writer Sean "Seanbaby" Reiley also criticized the pits, claiming that they are "time-consuming" and "difficult to leave without falling back in".^[35] Trent Ward, a former Next Generation Magazine reviewer, commented that this element prompted him to immediately return the game for a refund after purchasing it in his youth,^[36] and the children who found games in the New Mexico landfill gave the E.T. cartridges away because, as one later said, the "game sucked ... you couldn't finish it".^[37][38] Classic Gaming argued that despite the negative reception, the game can be enjoyable after the player has learned to navigate the pits.^[39]

In published materials written over a decade after its initial release, E.T. has been universally panned by critics and is frequently listed as the worst video game ever.^[15] Reiley ranked it number one in a list of the 20 worst games of all time in Electronic Gaming Monthly's 150th issue.^[35] Michael Dolan, deputy editor of FHM magazine, has also listed the game as his pick for the worst video game of all time.^[40] Townsend placed E.T. at the top of his list of worst video games, noting that, "about a third of the people I quizzed came up with this title almost instantly, and it's not hard to see why."^[34] GameTrailers ranked the game the second worst on their "Top Ten Best and Worst Games of All Time" list.^[41]

Critics often attribute the poor quality to the short development time.^[42][43] Townsend commented that the rushed development was very apparent after playing the game.^[34] Warshaw's contributions to the game have been met with mixed responses. Classic Gaming called the game poorly designed, while IGN's Levi Buchanan stated the "impossibly tight schedule" given to Warshaw absolves him of blame.^[19] Warshaw does not express regret for his part in E.T., and feels he created a good game given the time available to him.^[10][15]

Impact and legacy

E.T. is one of the earliest video games based on a movie.^[44] GamePro, GameTrailers, and Bowen cite the game as the first poor quality film–video game tie-in.^[7][41][45] Patrick O'Luanaigh of SCi Games called it the most famous disaster story among film-inspired video games as well as within the industry.^[46] Describing it as one of the "games that changed the world", GamePro stated that E.T. established a standard of subpar quality video games based on movies. They further commented that other publishers adopted similar marketing and production practices with licensed movie properties.^[47] The publication listed the game as the second "worst movie game ever", citing it as an example of how poor gameplay can bring negative reception to strong licenses.^[45]

Effect on the industry

The game is often cited as one of the most important titles in the industry's history.^[48][49][50] Billboard magazine's Earl Paige reported that the large number of unsold E.T. games along with an increase in competition prompted retailers to demand official return programs from video game manufacturers.^[51] The game is also considered to be one of the causes of the video game industry crisis of 1983.^[52][53][54] By the end of 1982, Atari had begun to lose dominance as more competitors entered the market.^[12] Poor critical reception and lack of a profitable marketing strategy made this game one of many cited decisions that led Atari to report a $536 million loss in 1983 and led to the company being divided and sold in 1984.^[26] GameSpy's Classic Gaming called E.T. Atari's biggest mistake, as well as the largest financial failure in the industry.^[39][55] Reiley commented that the game's poor quality was responsible for ending the product life of the Atari 2600.^[35] Occurring soon after Pac-Man's negative critical response on the Atari 2600, E.T.'s poor reception was attributed by Kent to a negative impact on Atari's reputation and profitability.^[11] Authors Nick Montfort and Ian Bogost echoed similar comments about Pac-Man and E.T.'s combined effect on the company's reputation and the industry's reaction.^[56] Buchanan also cited the game as a factor to Atari and the industry's crash. He stated that the large amount of unsold merchandise was a financial burden to Atari, which pushed the company into debt.^[19]

On December 7, 1982, Kassar announced that Atari's revenue forecasts for 1982 were cut from a 50 percent increase over 1981 to a 15 percent increase.^[57] Immediately following the announcement, Warner Communications' stock value dropped by around 35 percent—from US$54 to US$35—resulting in the company losing US$1.3 billion in market valuation.^[58] Kassar sold five thousand of his Warner shares a half hour before the announcement.^[57] This prompted an investigation for insider trading against him by U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission.^[57] Atari attempted to regain their market share by licensing popular arcade games for the Atari consoles. The games, however, did not reverse Atari's decline and they went further into debt. In 1983, the company had decreased its workforce by 30 percent and lost US$356 million. Other companies—Activision, Bally Manufacturing, and Mattel—experienced similar results as the industry declined.^[11]

Atari video game burial

Evidence of E.T., Centipede, and other Atari materials uncovered during the excavation.

In September 1983, the Alamogordo Daily News of Alamogordo, New Mexico, reported in a series of articles that between ten and twenty^[59] semi-trailer truckloads of Atari boxes, cartridges, and systems from an Atari storehouse in El Paso, Texas, were crushed and buried at the landfill within the city. It was Atari's first dealings with the landfill, which was chosen because no scavenging was allowed and its garbage was crushed and buried nightly. Atari officials and others gave differing reports of what was buried,^[60][61][62] but it has been speculated that most unsold copies of E.T. are buried in this landfill, crushed and encased in cement.^[63] The story of the buried cartridges was regarded by some as an urban legend, with skeptics—including Warshaw—disregarding the official accounts.^[10][43][46]

On May 28, 2013, the Alamogordo City Commission approved Fuel Industries, an Ottawa-based entertainment company, for six months of landfill access both to create a documentary about the legend and to excavate the burial site.^[64] On April 26, 2014, remnants of E.T. and other Atari games were discovered in the early hours of the excavation.^[5][65]

A fictional account of the game's disposal is the main basis for James Rolfe's 2014 independent film Angry Video Game Nerd: The Movie.^[66]

In December 2014, The Smithsonian Institution added an excavated cartridge of E.T. to their collection.^[67] In 2015, The Henry Ford museum added several excavated cartridges and a video touchpad, a sample of landfill dirt taken from the site of the burial, and items of clothing worn by the excavation team to their collection. A selection of these items are on permanent display.^[68][69]

Attempts at fixing the game

In 2006 the game was decompiled by Dennis Debro and a source code variant reconstructed.^[70][71]

In February 2013, several unofficial fixes for the game were released by Neocomputer.org, a small personal website unrelated to Atari.^[72] The website details and provides commentary on the game's shortcomings, including instruction on fixing it. According to Neocomputer, the infamous "bug" of E.T. falling into the pits was simply due to pixel-perfect collision detection; if any portion of E.T.'s sprite overlapped a pit, E.T. would then fall into the pit. The website also details certain other problems that were resolved.^[72]

Re-release

In October 2013 the Internet Archive provided a browser-playable version via MESS.^[73]

In Q4 2014, KHAN Games ported the original Atari game to the Nintendo Entertainment System (NES). Some changes were made, including providing some more detailed instructions on how to play. The original Atari version was often cited as having very little instruction on gameplay.^[74] Later the game went "out of stock" on the store.^[75]

See also

• E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial in video games
• List of commercial failures in video gaming
• List of video games notable for negative reception

References

Bibliography

Books

Periodicals

External links

• E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial at MobyGames
• E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial at the Internet Archive

Atari 2600 Games 1977 launch titles Air-Sea Battle Basic Math Blackjack Combat Indy 500 Star Ship Street Racer Surround Video Olympics Best-selling games Pac-Man Pitfall! Asteroids Missile Command Space Invaders Demon Attack Atlantis Adventure River Raid Kaboom! Game lists List of Atari 2600 games List of Atari 2600 prototype games Atari 2600 games List of cancelled Atari 2600 games Game developers Atari, Inc. Activision Imagic Coleco Data Age M Network Parker Brothers Sega Xonox Nintendo Hardware and emulation Atari 2600 hardware Television Interface Adaptor Spectravideo CompuMate(Home computer expansion) Atari Flashback Coleco Gemini GameLine Starpath Supercharger Cuttle Cart Stella z26 PC Atari Emulator Related articles Atari 2600 homebrew Atari 2500 Atari 2800 Atari Age Racing the Beam: The Atari Video Computer System Category