Childs Restaurants (Coney Island Boardwalk location)

Childs Restaurant Building
landmark
Facade from Coney Island Boardwalk
Country	United States
State	New York
Borough	Brooklyn
Coordinates	40°34′21″N 73°59′15″W / 40.5725°N 73.9876°W / 40.5725; -73.9876Coordinates: 40°34′21″N 73°59′15″W / 40.5725°N 73.9876°W / 40.5725; -73.9876
Width	100 ft (30 m)
Depth	248 ft (76 m)
Architect	Frederic Charles Hirons & Ethan Allen Dennison
Style	Spanish Revival
Completed	1923
Status	New York City designated landmark[1]
Address	2102 Boardwalk, Brooklyn, NY
Location within New York City

The Childs Restaurants building on the Coney Island Boardwalk is a New York City designated landmark on the Boardwalk at West 21st Street in Coney Island, Brooklyn. It was completed in 1923 for Childs Restaurants, an early restaurant chain and one of the largest in the United States at that time. It was designed in a "resort style with Spanish Revival influence" with colorful exterior terra cotta ornamentation that references its seaside location, with depictions of Poseidon, sailing ships, and sea creatures. It was a very large restaurant, with three stories and a roof garden.^[1]

Childs vacated the property in 1952. The building was used as a candy factory for over 50 years but was vacant and in a state of bad repair in late 2013, when the New York City Council approved plans to redevelop the building as part of a new entertainment venue called the "Seaside Park and Community Arts Center".^[2] The city expects completion of the project by the summer of 2015.^[3]

A considerably smaller prior Childs location in Coney Island, built in 1917 at Surf Avenue and West 12th Street and also a designated New York City landmark, survived as a Childs until 1943. Today it is owned by Coney Island USA, an arts organization.

Description

The building is very large for a restaurant building, stretching for about 100 feet along the Boardwalk and for about 250 feet along West 21st Street and having three stories plus a roof garden. According to property records, it has a total of about 60,000 square feet of floor space.^[1][4] It was built in 1923 to provide reasonably-priced meals to the millions of city dwellers who came to Coney Island to enjoy its beaches and amusements, and to stroll along its Boardwalk, which was constructed the same year. Most visitors arrived on the New York City Subway, which reached Coney Island in 1920.

Operation

From its earliest days, Childs' interiors were characterized by high-quality materials such as white tile walls and floors, marble communal tables, and modern electric lighting and fans. Most locations were in storefronts and other rented quarters that the company did not control, but when the company started to build locations specifically to be Childs restaurants the company demanded similar quality in its exterior architecture. To design its Boardwalk location, the company chose the firm of Hirons and Dennison, which was well-regarded for its prior works, mostly bank buildings, in the Neoclassical and Beaux-Arts styles. The firm often worked with a sculptor and with the Atlantic Terra Cotta Company to produce decorative terra cotta panels that they incorporated into their designs. It used these techniques for its design of the Boardwalk building too, though the "Spanish Revival" style was something of a departure for it.^[1]

The Boardwalk restaurant and its design proved so popular that it was used as a model for subsequent Childs locations, especially for one built in 1927 on Atlantic City's boardwalk.^[1] Though Childs had long operated in urban environments in Manhattan and elsewhere, the public came to associate the Childs name with the seashore, due largely to the size and prominence of the Coney Island Boardwalk location. Childs furthered this association in the late 1920s and early 1930s by using a nautical motif for new buildings that were far from the seashore, such as one in Manhattan,^[5] and two in Woodside, Queens.^[6][7]

Coney Island became less popular in the 1940s and 1950s as new trends in travel and entertainment made other areas more attractive. Many Coney Island businesses closed in this period, and Childs closed the Boardwalk location in 1952. The building itself was then purchased by the Ricci family for use as a candy factory.^[1] At that time it was just one of several candy factories in the area, and one of the products made over the years in the old Childs building were the Peeps line of marshmallow candies.^[8] In 2002, the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission designated the building a landmark, affording it a high degree of protection against demolition. The Ricci family originally opposed the designation, and then rescinded that opposition.^[1]

The landmark designation report states that candy making was still going on within the building at the time of designation in 2002,^[1] however this activity had apparently ceased by 2008, when the building began to be used as a roller skating rink.^[9] The owners of the building decided to discontinue that new use in 2010, and the building has been unused since then^[10]

Redevelopment plans

Marty Markowitz, who was Borough President of Brooklyn from 2002 through 2013, championed a plan for adaptive reuse of the Childs building that was ultimately approved by the city government and appears to be proceeding as of early 2014. Markowitz had long sought a permanent venue for the series of summer concerts that he had sponsored for 35 years, since his time in the New York State Senate. According to the plan put forth by Markowitz and supported by iStar Financial, which now controls the property, an amphitheater stage would be built along the western side of the building, and the building itself would house a backstage area. The building would also house a restaurant for the first time in over sixty years. Adjacent lots, which are now vacant and used for what the city calls an unauthorized community garden, would be turned into a park. The theater would be operated by a non-profit organization, but the restaurant would be a private-sector venture. The plan was approved by the City Council just days before Markowitz left office on the last day of 2013.^[3][11]

The redevelopment plan has faced some community opposition. In early 2014, after they had been excluded from the land they had been using for 16 years, the community gardeners sued the city, asserting that the land had been previously designated a city park, so that the city's taking of the land for other purposes was illegal. The city has stated that the park was decommissioned in 2004.^[12] Other critics of the plan are concerned about increased noise and traffic, and point out that the area has yet to fully recover from Hurricane Sandy. Coney Island's community board, responding to these complaints and pressing for a "community benefits contract" that would guarantee good jobs for area residents, rejected the plan, though the board does not have the power to stop the project.^[13]

Despite these issues, the city continues to project completion of construction by the summer of 2015, and expects that 2016 would be the first full year of operation for the new entertainment venue.^[3]

Gallery

• 

  Poseidon and trident

• 

  Sailing ship

• 

  Sea creatures

• 

  Terra cotta panels and archways

• 

  Building from slightly to the east

References