2010 Chatham Cup

2010 Chatham Cup
Dates September 12, 2010
Championship venue North Harbour Stadium, North Shore
Champions Miramar Rangers (4th title)
Runners-up Bay Olympic
Championship match score 3 – 1
Jack Batty Memorial Cup Phil Imray (Miramar Rangers)
← 2009 2011 →

The 2010 Chatham Cup is New Zealand's 83rd knockout football competition.

The 2010 competition had a preliminary round, a qualification round, and four rounds proper before quarter-finals, semi-finals, and a final. In all, 135 teams took part in the 2010 competition.

Draw controversies

There were several problems with the draw of teams for specific ties in the 2010 Chatham Cup.

The neutrality of the allotment of teams to specific ties was drawn into question by some observers in the Second Round.[1] A coincidence and a computer glitch combined to produce an "early draft" of the ties which included one of the fixtures later replicated in the live draw.

The third round also saw controversy when the draw had to be re-made. Initially, teams were not divided geographically for the Third Round draw, despite the competition rules stating that draws would remain regionally based until the fourth round, and some teams found themselves facing long trips which had not been budgeted for. This forced a re-draw and an apology from NZ Football.[2]

Suspicions about the validity of the draw were not assuaged when the Quarter-Final draw resulted in four matches which tallied with the boundaries of New Zealand's three football regions, as would have been the case had the draw still been done on regional lines. This produced two Auckland derbies, one all-Wellington match, and one featuring the two remaining South Island teams.[3]

The 2010 final

When the semi-final draw was made, it became apparent that a final between two non-Auckland area sides was possible. As a result, it was announced that if neither finalist was from Auckland, the final would be played in either Wellington or Dunedin.[4] This did not eventuate, with Bay Olympic beating Caversham in the first semi-final to ensure that the final would be at North Harbour Stadium.

In the final, Rangers took an early lead through a Tim Schaeffers goal in the 12th minute, the goal coming after Olympic goalkeeper Danny Robinson parried a shot from Danny Cheriton which fell kindly for the Miramar defender. Campbell Parkin doubled the lead with a close-range effort from a corner in the twentieth minute. It was Parkin's second final, as he had played in the losing Dunedin Technical side in the 2008 final. Nathan Strom reduced the deficit with a 34th-minute header, and Bay olympic continued to push for the rest of the half and the first few minutes of the second spell. With fifteen minutes remaining, it was Miramar who gained their third however, with a run by Michael White through the Bay defence. Olympic had a chance to reduce the deficit shortly afterwards when an ill-timed challenge on Joe Edwards by Schaeffers gave them a penalty. Goalkeeper Phil Imray kept out Strom's spot kick, and the score remained 3–1.

The Jack Batty Memorial Cup is awarded to the player adjudged to have made to most positive impact in the Chatham Cup final. The winner of the 2010 Jack Batty Memorial Cup was Phil Imray of Miramar Rangers.

Results

Second Round

7 June 2010
Eastern Suburbs 8 – 0 Whakatane Town

7 June 2010
Brew Town 1 – 4 Waitakere City

7 June 2010
Taradale 1 – 2 New Plymouth Rangers

7 June 2010
Inglewood 1 – 7 Napier City Rovers

7 June 2010
Palmerston North Marist 1 – 0 Palmerston North End

7 June 2010
Upper Hutt City 3 – 1 Wellington Marist

7 June 2010
Ferrymead Bays 4 – 2 Mid-Canterbury United

7 June 2010
Southend United 0 – 5 Roslyn-Wakari

7 June 2010
Northern Hearts 3 – 2 Old Boys (Invercargill)

7 June 2010
Mosgiel 2 – 1 Green Island
* Won on penalties by Lower Hutt (4-2)

Third Round

19 June 2010
East Coast Bays AFC 9 - 0 Auckland Grammar School
Edington
Suri
Bola
Bresnahan
Hitchen 		report
Bay City Park, North Shore

19 June 2010
Takapuna AFC 0 - 5 Bay Olympic
McKenzie (pen.)
Norris
Beeston
Tanabe
Taharoto Park, North Shore

19 June 2010
Metro F.C. 1 - 2 Waitakere City F.C.
Mason (pen.) Solly
Linderboom
Phyllis Street Reserve, Auckland

19 June 2010
Albany United 3 - 1 Hamilton Wanderers
Danks
Pitt 		Gibson
Rosedale Park, North Shore

19 June 2010
Glenfield Rovers 2 - 1 Ellerslie AFC
Green, Mulrooney (pen.) Palmer
McFetridge Park, Auckland

19 June 2010
Upper Hutt City SC 2 - 1 Palmerston North Marist
Higgins, Gasper report Milne
Harcourt Park, Upper Hutt

19 June 2010
New Plymouth Rangers 0 - 4 Wellington United
report Groom, Little (pen.), Pumpido, Tade
Merrilands Domain, New Plymouth
Referee: I. Trevis

19 June 2010
Miramar Rangers 3 - 2 (a.e.t.) Lower Hutt City AFC
Cheriton, Howe (o.g.), Sutherland report Watson, Te Anau
David Farrington Park, Wellington

19 June 2010
Ferrymead Bays 6 - 0 Cashmere Wanderers
C. Murphy 2, Piercy, Draper, Samson, N. Murphy report
Barnett Park, Christchurch

19 June 2010
Northern Hearts 2 - 5 Roslyn-Wakari
Hewson, Bernard report Dalman 3, Conner 2
Aorangi Park, Timaru

19 June 2010
Caversham 8 - 0 Mosgiel
Jackson 3, Fleming 3, Deeley 2 report
Caledonian Ground, Dunedin
Referee: J. Clamp

20 June 2010
Melville United 0 - 1 Forrest Hill Milford
report Bale
Gower Park, Hamilton
Referee: B. Chibnall

20 June 2010
Napier City Rovers 12 - 2 Red Sox Manawatu
Smith 6, Wilson 3, Thomas 2, Pickering report Tuck 2

20 June 2010
Nelson Suburbs 0 - 1 Western A.F.C.
report Pak
Saxton Field, Nelson

Fourth Round

3 July 2010
Bay Olympic 3 - 1 Waitakere City FC
Tanabe
Wylie
Edwards 		Linderboom
Olympic Park, Auckland
Referee: M. Vincent

3 July 2010
Forrest Hill Milford 3 - 1 Albany United
De Vries Hicks
Becroft Park, Auckland

3 July 2010
Upper Hutt City SC 0 - 4 Wellington United
Watson
Tade
Harcourt Park, Upper Hutt

3 July 2010
Western A.F.C. 1 - 1 (aet)* Ferrymead Bays
McDermott  117' report Draper  110'
  Penalties  
Weiclawski
Willis
Harris
Jones
3 – 4 Christidis
Piercey
Draper
Collins
Walter Park, Christchurch

3 July 2010
Caversham AFC 8 - 2 Roslyn-Wakari
Hancock  19'
Jackson  20'
Fleming
Ryder 		report Dalman
Rae
Tonga Park, Dunedin
Referee: D. Langley

4 July 2010
Napier City Rovers 1 - 2 Miramar Rangers
Pickering report McDermott
Sutherland
Park Island, Napier
Referee: B. Chisholm

4 July 2010
Glenfield Rovers 3 - 1 Birkenhead United
Gwyther Lee
McFetridge Park, Auckland

Quarter-finals

25 July 2010
Forrest Hill Milford 0 - 2 Bay Olympic
McKenzie  22'  46'
Becroft Park, Auckland
Referee: Mirko Benischke

25 July 2010
Ferrymead Bays 3 - 7 (aet) Caversham AFC
Sherman  3'  75' (pen.)
Murphy  95' 		report Deeley  30' (pen.)  91' (pen.)
Fleming  88'  100'
Ryder  104'  114'
Barnett Park, Christchurch
Referee: Darren Sundborn

24 July 2010
East Coast Bays 2 - 1 Glenfield Rovers
Morgan-Howell 6'
Beguely  90+3' 		report Seaman  21'
Bay City Park, North Shore
Referee: Nick Waldron

25 July 2010
Miramar Rangers 3 - 1 Wellington United
Parkin  20'
Sutherland  37' (pen.)
Johnston  78'
Sutherland Yellow cardYellow cardRed card 70' 		report Schaeffers  53' (o.g.)
Alderdice Red card 70'
Watson Yellow cardYellow cardRed card
David Farrington Park, Wellington
Attendance: 1000
Referee: Matt Conger

Semi-finals

14 August 2010
Caversham AFC 3 – 3 (aet) Bay Olympic
Jackson  21'
Hancock  88'
Ryder  94' 		report Tanabe  5' 69'
Beeston  101'
Wylie Red card 55'
  Penalties  
1 – 4
Caledonian Ground, Dunedin
Referee: Jamie Cross

15 August 2010
Miramar Rangers 2 – 1 East Coast Bays
Imray Red card 19'
Eager  35' (pen)
Parkin  55' 		report D Peat  19' (pen.)
David Farrington Park, Wellington
Referee: Antony Riley

Final

12 September 2010
Miramar Rangers 3 – 1 Bay Olympic
Schaeffers  12'
Parkin  20'
White  75' 		report Strom  34'
North Harbour Stadium, Auckland
Referee: Mirko Benischke

References

  1. ↑
  2. ↑ Page, Jacob (11 June 2010). "Draw mix-up ups Hearts chances". The Timaru Herald. Retrieved 14 September 2011.
  3. ↑ Seconi, A. (July 7, 2010) Questions over draw but Cavvy fares well. Otago Daily Times. p. 27
  4. ↑
This article is issued from Wikipedia - version of the Thursday, September 10, 2015. The text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution/Share Alike but additional terms may apply for the media files.