Uunartoq Qeqertaq

The new strait uncovered by a retreating ice shelf, taken from Warming Island (Uunartoq Qeqertaq) in 2006.

Uunartoq Qeqertaq, Greenlandic for "The Warming Island", is an island, that was only acknowledged as such in September 2005, by an American explorer Dennis Schmitt, off the east central coast of Greenland, 550 km (340 mi) north of the Arctic Circle. It was attached to the mainland of Liverpool Land by glacial ice even in 2002, when the ice shelves began retreating rapidly in this area, so that by 2005 it was no longer attached to the mainland. Members of the scientific community believe this newly discovered island is a direct result of global warming.[1] The island has three large peninsulas, and thus resembles the letter W.

Controversy

Patrick Michaels, a climatologist and prominent climate change skeptic, created a controversy over the history of Warming Island in a post on his website, World Climate Report, in which he argued that the island had been previously uncovered in the 1950s toward the end of a brief warm period in Greenland.[2]

Despite a general lack of suitably detailed maps, Michaels found a map published by Ernst Hofer, a photographer who did aerial surveys of the area in the early 1950s, which showed the Warming Island landmass unconnected to Greenland.[3] Michaels concluded therefore that Warming Island was also a separate island when observed by Hofer in the 1950s, and more broadly that Warming Island is an example of unjustified concern about the future outcomes of global warming.[2]

Dennis Schmitt countered Michaels' theory in an article by New York Times reporter Andy Revkin, contending that Hofer's map is inaccurate. Citing discrepancies such as the absence on Hofer's map of nearby Reynolds Island, he suggested that the discrepant features are consistent with an aerial view of the area when covered with fog, which has often obscured low-lying areas like Reynold's Island and the ice-bridge connecting Warming Island to the Greenlandic mainland. He further observed, "I see by the markings of the 1957 document that it is to be construed as indeed only schematic, that it is explicitly incomplete."[4]

Michaels explained that Hofer included the map in his book "so as to place his pictures and stories in context."[2]

No photographic evidence is available that would resolve the issue.

The island was also part of a 2011 controversy when it was included in the Times Atlas of the World, along with a revised depiction of the Greenland ice sheet that showed a 15% reduction. After being alerted through the media, the U.S. National Snow and Ice Data Center reported that the atlas editors must have used a 2001 map showing only the thickest segment of the ice sheet.[5]

A comparison of satellite pictures between 1985 and 2005.

References

  1. ↑ "Melting glacier uncovers island". Credit: USGS Landsat Project (CNET.com). 2007-04-26. Retrieved 2007-09-23.
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 Warming Island: another global warming myth exposed, World Climate Report
  3. ↑ Warming Island: another global warming myth exposed, Berne, Kümmerly & Frey, 1957, OCLC 486572
  4. ↑ Revkin, Andrew C. (2008-04-28), Arctic explorer rebuts critique of Warming Island, New York Times, retrieved 2010-05-27
  5. ↑ Sara Reardon (2011-09-19). "UPDATED: Atlas Shrugged? 'Outraged' Glaciologists Say Mappers Misrepresented Greenland Ice Melt". sciencemag.org. Retrieved 2011-09-19.

External links

Coordinates: 71°29′N 21°51′W / 71.483°N 21.850°W