United States presidential election, 1852

United States presidential election, 1852
United States
November 2, 1852
All 296 electoral votes of the Electoral College
149 electoral votes needed to win
Turnout 69.6%[1]
 
Nominee Franklin Pierce Winfield Scott John P. Hale
Party Democratic Whig Free Soil
Home state New Hampshire New Jersey New Hampshire
Running mate William R. King William A. Graham George W. Julian
Electoral vote 254 42 0
States carried 27 4 0
Popular vote 1,607,510 1,386,942 155,210
Percentage 50.8% 43.9% 4.9%

Presidential election results map. Blue denotes states won by Pierce/King, Orange denotes those won by Scott/Graham. Numbers indicate the number of electoral votes allotted to each state.
President before election

Millard Fillmore
Whig

 Elected President

Franklin Pierce
Democratic

The United States presidential election of 1852 was the 17th quadrennial presidential election, held on Tuesday, November 2, 1852. It bore important similarities to the election of 1844. Once again, the incumbent president was a Whig who had succeeded to the presidency upon the death of his war-hero predecessor. In this case, it was Millard Fillmore who followed General Zachary Taylor. The Whig party passed over the incumbent for nomination — casting aside Fillmore in favor of General Winfield Scott. The Democrats nominated a "dark horse" candidate, this time Franklin Pierce. The Whigs again campaigned on the obscurity of the Democratic candidate, and again, the strategy failed.

Pierce and his running mate William R. King went on to win what was at the time one of the nation's largest electoral victories, trouncing Scott and his vice-presidential nominee, William Alexander Graham of North Carolina, 254 electoral votes to 42. After the 1852 election, the Whig Party quickly collapsed, and the members of the declining party failed to nominate a candidate for the next presidential race due to the uproar over the Kansas-Nebraska Act. It was soon replaced as the Democratic Party's primary opposition by the new Republican Party. In spite of the appearance of Democratic triumph, no presidential candidate from the Democratic party would again win both a majority of the popular and electoral vote until 1932, when Franklin D. Roosevelt won a larger majority against Republican Herbert Hoover. This is the last presidential election in which the Whig Party participated. In 1854, the Whig Party effectively collapsed as a national political force, largely because of tensions over slavery.

Nominations

Whig Party nomination

Whig candidates

Scott/Graham campaign poster

The 1852 Whig National Convention, held in Baltimore, Maryland, was bitterly divided. Supporters of President Fillmore pointed to the successful Compromise of 1850 and the failure of a nascent secession movement in the Southern states in 1850–1851. The northern Whigs believed that the Compromise of 1850 favored the slaveholding South over the North. Northern Whigs favored heroic Mexican-American War General Winfield Scott of New Jersey. Scott had earned the nickname of "Old Fuss and Feathers" in the military due to his insistence on appearance and discipline, and while respected, was also seen by the people as somewhat foppish. A deadlock occurred because most New England delegates supported Daniel Webster. On the first ballot, Fillmore received all delegate votes from the South save four, but only received 18 northern delegate votes. The vote was 133 for Fillmore, 131 for Scott, and 29 for Webster. Scott was nominated on the 53rd ballot by a margin of 159–112 (with 21 for Webster), again with a highly sectional vote; Scott won the North by a 142–11 vote (with 21 for Webster) while Fillmore won the South by a margin of 101–17.

William Alexander Graham was chosen as the vice-presidential nominee. 1852 would be the penultimate time the Whig Party would nominate a candidate for president. Within the decade, the party fell apart and ceased to exist, principally due to regional divisions caused by the slavery issue.

Democratic Party nomination

Democratic candidates:

Candidates gallery

Pierce/King campaign poster

As Democrats convened in Baltimore in June 1852, four major candidates vied for the nomination: Lewis Cass of Michigan, the nominee in 1848, who had the backing of northerners in support of the Compromise of 1850; James Buchanan of Pennsylvania, popular in the South as well as in his home state; Stephen A. Douglas of Illinois, candidate of the expansionists and the railroad interests; and William L. Marcy of New York, whose strength was centered in his home state. Throughout the balloting, numerous favorite son candidates received a few votes.

Cass led on the first 19 ballots, with Buchanan second, and Douglas and Marcy exchanging third and fourth places. Buchanan took the lead on the 20th ballot and retained it on each of the next nine tallies. Douglas managed a narrow lead on the 30th and 31st ballots. Cass then recaptured first place through the 44th ballot. Marcy carried the next four ballots. Franklin Pierce of New Hampshire, a former Congressman and Senator, did not get on the board until the 35th ballot, when the Virginia delegation brought him forward as a compromise choice. He consolidated his support in subsequent voting and was nominated nearly unanimously on the 49th ballot.[2]

In a peace gesture to the Buchanan wing of the party, Pierce's supporters allowed Buchanan's allies to fill the second position, knowing that they would select Alabama Senator William R. King. On the second ballot, with only minor opposition, King finally obtained the Democratic vice-presidential nomination. During the ensuing campaign, King's tuberculosis, which he believed he had contracted while in Paris, France, denied him the active behind-the-scenes role that he might otherwise have played, although he worked hard to assure his region's voters that New Hampshire's Pierce was a "northern man with southern principles." King died little after his inauguration on April 18, 1853.

Presidential Ballot
Ballot1st 2nd 3rd 4th 5th 6th 7th 8th 9th 10th 11th 12th 13th 14th 15th 16th 17th 18th 19th 20th 21st 22nd 23rd 24th 25th
Franklin Pierce 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Lewis Cass 116 118 119 115 114 114 113 113 112 111 101 98 98 99 99 99 99 96 89 81 60 43 37 33 34
James Buchanan 93 95 94 89 88 88 88 88 87 86 87 88 88 87 87 87 87 85 85 92 102 104 104 103 101
William L. Marcy 27 27 26 25 26 26 26 26 27 27 27 27 26 26 26 26 26 25 26 26 26 26 27 26 26
Stephen A. Douglas 20 23 21 33 34 34 34 34 39 40 50 51 51 51 51 51 50 56 63 64 64 77 78 80 79
Others 40 33 36 34 34 34 35 35 31 32 31 32 33 33 33 33 34 34 33 33 44 46 50 54 56
Presidential Ballot
Ballot26th 27th 28th 29th 30th 31st 32nd 33rd 34th 35th 36th 37th 38th 39th 40th 41st 42nd 43rd 44th 45th 46th 47th 48th 49th
Franklin Pierce 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 15 30 29 29 29 29 29 29 29 29 29 44 49 55 282
Lewis Cass 33 32 28 27 33 65 93 123 130 131 122 120 107 106 107 107 101 101 101 96 78 75 72 2
James Buchanan 101 98 96 98 91 83 74 72 49 39 28 28 28 28 27 27 27 27 27 27 28 28 28 0
William L. Marcy 26 26 26 26 26 26 26 25 33 34 58 70 84 85 85 85 91 91 91 97 98 95 89 0
Stephen A. Douglas 80 85 88 91 92 92 80 60 53 52 43 34 33 33 33 33 33 33 33 32 32 33 33 2
Others 56 55 58 54 54 30 23 16 31 25 15 15 15 15 15 15 15 15 15 15 16 16 19 10

Source: US President – D Convention. Our Campaigns. (August 24, 2009).

Vice Presidential Ballot
Ballot1st 2nd
William R. King 125 277
Solomon W. Downs 30 0
John B. Weller 28 0
David R. Atchison 25 0
Gideon J. Pillow 25 0
Robert Strange 23 0
William O. Butler 13 0
Thomas J. Rusk 13 0
Jefferson Davis 2 11
Howell Cobb 2 0
Abstaining 2 0

Source: US Vice President – D Convention. Our Campaigns. (August 25, 2009).

Free Soil Party nomination

Free Soil candidate:

Candidates gallery

The Free Soil Party was still the strongest third party in 1852, though many of the "Barnburners" who supported it in 1848 had returned to the Democratic Party. The second Free Soil National Convention assembled in the Masonic Hall in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. New Hampshire Senator John P. Hale was nominated for president with 192 delegate votes (16 votes were cast for a smattering of candidates). George Washington Julian of Indiana was nominated for vice-president over Samuel Lewis of Ohio and Joshua R. Giddings of Ohio.

Liberty Party nomination

The Liberty Party had ceased to become a significant political force after most of its members joined the Free Soil Party in 1848. Nonetheless, some of those who rejected the fusion strategy held a Liberty Party National Convention in Buffalo, New York. There were few delegates present, so a ticket was recommended and a later convention called. The Convention recommended Gerrit Smith of New York for president and Charles Durkee of Wisconsin for vice-president. A second convention was held in Syracuse, New York, in early September 1852, but it too failed to draw enough delegates to select a nominee. Yet a third convention gathered in Syracuse later that month and nominated William Goodell of New York for president and S.M. Bell of Virginia for vice-president.

Union Party nomination

Union candidate:

Candidates gallery

The Union party was formed in 1851, an offshoot of the Whig party in several Southern states, including Georgia. As the 1852 presidential election approached, Union party leaders decided to wait and see who was nominated by the two major parties. The movement to nominate Daniel Webster as a third-party candidate began in earnest following the Whig Convention, largely driven by those who had been strenuously opposed to Winfield Scott's nomination, among them Alexander Stephens, Robert Toombs, and George Curtis. While Webster was against what he perceived as a "revolt" from the Whig Party and preferred not to be nominated, he endeavored to let Americans vote for him should the Party chose to nominate him.

The Union Party held its Georgia state convention on August 7, 1852, and nominated Webster for president and Charles J. Jenkins of Georgia for vice-president. A formal convention was held at Faneuil Hall in Boston, Massachusetts on September 15, affirming the nominations made at the state convention in Georgia and rejecting Winfield Scott as nothing more than a military figure. The Webster/Jenkins ticket received nationwide support, particularly among Southern Whigs, but also in Massachusetts and New York, though it was largely perceived by many as nothing more than draw for many voters who would in different circumstances support Winfield Scott, and that Webster didn't realistically have any chance of winning the election. Even the new Know-Nothing party endorsed Webster, even nominating him without his own permission. Unfortunately, Webster died before the election of a cerebral hemorrhage on October 24, 1852.

Native American Party nomination

Native American candidates:

Candidates gallery

Around the mid-1840s, nativists were present in various New York politics, under the American Republican Party. The American Republican party was formed in 1843 in major opposition to immigration and Catholicism. In 1845, the party changed its name to the Native American Party. Their opponents nicknamed them the "Know Nothings" and the party liked the name and it became the nickname of the party after that until it collapsed in 1860. In 1852, the original candidate planned by the Native American Party was Daniel Webster, the nominee of the Union party as well as Secretary of State. They nominated Webster without his own permission, with George C. Washington (grandnephew of George Washington) as his running mate. Webster died of natural causes a little more than a week before the election, and the Know Nothings quickly replaced Webster by nominating Jacob Broom as president and replaced Washington with Reynell Coates. With Webster collecting a few thousand votes, Broom received too few, and lost the election. In the future, former president Millard Fillmore would be their candidate in 1856.

Southern Rights Party nomination

Southern Rights candidate:

Candidates gallery

The Southern Rights Party was an offshoot of the Democratic party in several Southern states which advocated secession from the Union, electing a number of Congressmen and holding referendums on secession in a number of southern states (none of which were successful).

It was unclear in early 1852 if the Party would contest the presidential election. When the Alabama state convention was held in early March, only nine counties were represented. The party decided to see who was nominated by the two major national parties and support one of them if possible. When Georgia held its state convention, it acted as the state Democratic Party and sent delegates to the national convention.

After the Democratic National Convention, the Party was not sure that it wanted to support Franklin Pierce, the Democratic nominee. Alabama held a state convention from July 13 to the 15th and discussed at length the options of running a separate ticket or supporting Pierce. The convention was unable to arrive at a decision, deciding to appoint a committee to review the positions of Scott and Pierce with the option of calling a “national” convention if the two major party candidates appeared deficient. The committee took its time reviewing the positions of Pierce and Scott, finally deciding on August 25 to call a convention for a Southern Rights Party ticket.

The convention assembled in Montgomery, Alabama, with 62 delegates being present a committee to recommend a ticket being appointed while listening to speeches in the interim. The committee eventually recommended former Senator George Troup of Georgia for President, and former Governor John Quitman of Mississippi for the Vice President; they were unanimously nominated.

The two nominees accepted their nominations soon after the convention, which was held rather late in the season. Troup stated in his letter, dated September 27 and printed in the New York Times on October 16, that he had planned to vote for Pierce and had always wholeheartedly supported William R.D. King. He indicated in the letter that he preferred to decline the honor, as he was rather ill at the time and feared that he would die before the election. The Party's executive committee edited the letter to excise those portions which indicated that Troup preferred to decline, a fact which was revealed after the election.

General election

The Fall Campaign

Political cartoon favoring Winfield Scott

The Whigs' platform was almost indistinguishable from that of the Democrats, reducing the campaign to a contest between the personalities of the two candidates. The lack of clear-cut issues between the two parties helped drive voter turnout down to its lowest level since 1836. The decline was further exacerbated by Scott's anti-slavery reputation, which decimated the Southern Whig vote at the same time as the pro-slavery Whig platform undermined the Northern Whig vote. After the Compromise of 1850 was passed, many of the southern Whig Party members broke with the party's key figure, Henry Clay.[3] Finally, Scott's status as a war hero was somewhat offset by the fact that Pierce was himself a Mexican-American War brigadier general.

Shortly before the election, Union Party candidate Daniel Webster died, causing many Union state parties to remove their slates of electors. The Union ticket did appear on the ballot in Georgia and Massachusetts, however.

Results

Results by county explicitly indicating the percentage of the winning candidate in each county. Shades of blue are for Pierce (Democratic), shades of yellow are for Scott (Whig), shades of red are for Hale (Free Soil), shades of orange are for Webster (Union), shades of green are for (Independent Democrats), and shades of purple are for Troup (Southern Rights).

When American voters went to the polls, Pierce won in a landslide; Scott won only the states of Kentucky, Tennessee, Massachusetts, and Vermont, while the Free Soil vote collapsed to less than half of what Martin Van Buren had earned in the previous election, with the party taking no states. The fact that Daniel Webster received a substantial share of the vote in Georgia and Massachusetts, even though he was dead, shows how disenchanted voters were with the two main-party candidates.

As a result of this devastating defeat, and because of the growing tensions within the party between pro-slavery Southerners and anti-slavery Northerners, the Whig Party quickly fell apart after the 1852 election and ceased to exist. Some Southern Whigs would join the Democratic Party, and many Northern Whigs would help to form the new Republican Party in 1854. Some Whigs in both sections would support the so-called "Know-Nothing" party in the 1856 presidential election. Similarly, the Free Soil Party rapidly fell away into obscurity after the election, and the remaining members mostly opted to join the former Northern Whigs in forming the Republic Party.

The Southern Rights Party effectively collapsed following the election, only attaining five percent of the vote in Alabama, and a few hundred in its nominees home state of Georgia. It would elect a number of Congressmen in 1853, but they would shortly after join the Democratic Party upon taking their seats in Congress.

Presidential candidate Party Home state Popular vote(a) Electoral
vote		 Running mate
Count Pct Vice-presidential candidate Home state Elect. vote
Franklin Pierce Democratic New Hampshire 1,607,510 50.8% 254 William R. King Alabama 254
Winfield Scott Whig New Jersey 1,386,942 43.9% 42 William Alexander Graham North Carolina 42
John P. Hale Free Soil New Hampshire 155,210 4.9% 0 George Washington Julian Indiana 0
Daniel Webster(b) Union (c) Massachusetts 6,994 0.2% 0 Charles J. Jenkins Georgia 0
Jacob Broom Native American Pennsylvania 2,566 0.1% 0 Reynell Coates New Jersey 0
George Troup Southern Rights Georgia 2,331 0.1% 0 John A. Quitman Mississippi 0
Other 277 0.0% — Other —
Total 3,161,830 100% 296 296
Needed to win 149 149

Source (Popular Vote): Leip, David. 1852 Presidential Election Results. Dave Leip's Atlas of U.S. Presidential Elections (July 27, 2005).
Source (Electoral Vote): Electoral College Box Scores 1789–1996. Official website of the National Archives. (July 31, 2005).(a) The popular vote figures exclude South Carolina where the Electors were chosen by the state legislature rather than by popular vote.
(b)Daniel Webster died on October 24, 1852, one week before the election. However, his name remained on the ballot in Massachusetts and Georgia, and he still managed to poll nearly seven thousand votes. He was also the original candidate of the Native American Party but was replaced on his death by Jacob Broom.
(c)For a detailed discussion of the Union Party formed by Pro-Union Whigs, see Michael F. Holt, The Rise and Fall of the Whig Party: Jacksonian Politics and the Onset of the Civil War (New York: Oxford University Press, 1999), Chapters 19 and 20.

Popular vote
Pierce
  
 50.84%
Scott
  
 43.87%
Hale
  
 4.91%
Others
  
 0.38%
Electoral vote
Pierce
  
 85.81%
Scott
  
 14.19%

Results by state

Franklin Pierce
Democratic		 Winfield Scott
Whig		 John P. Hale
Free Soil		 State Total
State electoral
votes		 # % electoral
votes		 # % electoral
votes		 # % electoral
votes		 #
style"text-align:left" | Alabama 9 26,881 60.89 9 15,061 34.12 - no ballots 44,147 AL
style"text-align:left" | Arkansas 4 12,173 62.18 4 7,404 37.82 - no ballots 19,577 AR
style"text-align:left" | California 4 40,721 53.02 4 35,972 46.83 - no ballots 76,810 CA
style"text-align:left" | Connecticut 6 33,249 49.79 6 30,359 45.56 - 3,161 4.73 - 66,781 CT
style"text-align:left" | Delaware 3 6,318 49.85 3 6,293 49.66 - 62 0.49 - 12,673 DE
style"text-align:left" | Florida 3 4,318 60.03 3 2,875 39.97 - no ballots 7,193 FL
style"text-align:left" | Georgia 10 40,516 64.70 10 16,660 26.60 - no ballots 62,626 GA
style"text-align:left" | Illinois 11 80,378 51.87 11 64,733 41.77 - 9,863 6.36 - 154,974 IL
style"text-align:left" | Indiana 13 95,340 52.05 13 80,901 44.17 - 6,929 3.78 - 183,170 IN
style"text-align:left" | Iowa 4 17,763 50.23 4 15,856 44.84 - 1,606 4.54 - 35,364 IA
style"text-align:left" | Kentucky 12 53,494 48.32 - 57,428 51.44 12 266 0.24 - 111,148 KY
style"text-align:left" | Louisiana 6 18,647 51.94 6 17,255 48.06 - no ballots 42,873 LA
style"text-align:left" | Maine 8 41,609 50.63 8 32,543 39.60 - 8,030 9.77 - 82,182 ME
style"text-align:left" | Maryland 8 40,022 53.28 8 35,077 46.69 - 21 0.03 - 75,120 MD
style"text-align:left" | Massachusetts 13 44,569 35.07 - 52,683 41.45 13 28,203 22.05 - 127,103 MA
style"text-align:left" | Michigan 6 41,842 50.45 6 33,860 40.83 - 7,237 8.73 - 82,939 MI
style"text-align:left" | Mississippi 7 26,896 60.50 7 17,558 39.50 - no ballots 44,454 MS
style"text-align:left" | Missouri 9 38,817 56.42 9 29,984 43.58 - no ballots 68,801 MO
style"text-align:left" | New Hampshire 5 28,503 56.40 5 15,486 30.64 - 6,546 12.95 - 50,535 NH
style"text-align:left" | New Jersey 7 44,305 53.24 7 38,556 46.33 - 359 0.43 - 83,220 NJ
style"text-align:left" | New York 35 262,083 50.18 35 234,882 44.97 - 25,329 4.85 - 522,294 NY
style"text-align:left" | North Carolina 10 39,778 50.43 10 39,043 49.49 - no ballots 78,881 NC
style"text-align:left" | Ohio 23 168,933 47.83 23 152,523 43.18 - 31,732 8.98 - 353,188 OH
style"text-align:left" | Pennsylvania 27 198,562 51.20 27 179,104 46.18 - 8,495 2.19 - 387,389 PA
style"text-align:left" | Rhode Island 4 8,735 51.37 4 7,626 44.85 - 644 3.79 - 17,005 RI
style"text-align:left" | South Carolina 8 no popular vote 8 no popular vote no popular vote - SC
style"text-align:left" | Tennessee 12 56,900 49.27 - 58,586 50.73 12 no ballots 115,486 TN
style"text-align:left" | Texas 4 13,552 73.07 4 4,995 26.93 - no ballots 18,547 TX
style"text-align:left" | Vermont 5 13,044 29.72 - 22,173 50.52 5 8,621 19.64 - 43,890 VT
style"text-align:left" | Virginia 15 73,872 55.71 15 58,732 44.29 - no ballots 132,604 VA
style"text-align:left" | Wisconsin 5 33,658 52.04 5 22,210 34.34 - 8,814 13.63 - 64,682 WI
TOTALS: 296 1,605,943 50.83 254 1,386,418 43.88 42 155,799 4.93 - 3,159,640 US
TO WIN: 149

Electoral college selection

Method of choosing Electors State(s)
Each Elector appointed by state legislature South Carolina
Each Elector chosen by voters statewide (all other States)

See also

References

  1. ↑ "Voter Turnout in Presidential Elections". The American Presidency Project. UC Santa Barbara.
  2. ↑ William DeGregorio, The Complete Book of U.S. Presidents, Gramercy 1997
  3. ↑ Biography of Franklin Pierce
Books
  • Holt, Michael F. The Rise and Fall of the American Whig Party: Jacksonian Politics and the Onset of the Civil War. Oxford University Press, New York, New York: 1999.
Web sites

External links

Navigation