Two Men Contemplating the Moon

Two Men Contemplating the Moon, Galerie Neue Meister, 1819/20
Two Men Contemplating the Moon, Metropolitan Museum of Art, 1825–30

Two Men Contemplating the Moon (German: Zwei Männer in Betrachtung des Mondes) is one of the best known paintings by Caspar David Friedrich.[1] Friedrich painted several versions, and also a variant in which the two figures are a man and a woman (1835). The 1819/20 version in the Galerie Neue Meister in Dresden is thought to be the original.

Image description and composition

The painting depicts a foreground scene of two men on a mountain path, which leads up from the centre bottom of the picture to the left. The man on the right is wearing a grey-green cape and the black beret of the altdeutsche Tracht and has a stick in his right hand. The man on the left is somewhat higher on the path and is leaning on his companion's shoulder; he is slimmer and is wearing a grey-green frock-coat, from which a white collar protrudes, and the black cap of an early Burschenschaft, its ribbon tied under his chin. They are both looking at the sickle of the waxing moon and the evening star. The moon's night side is lit by earthshine. The scene is framed by an uprooted and moss-grown oak on their right, whose branches reach out to those of a spruce on their left; a boulder prevents the oak from falling, and there is another boulder on the left. In the background the landscape falls away; the tops of pine trees suggest a forest. In the immediate foreground are a tree stump and a large dry branch lying on the ground. The painting is almost monochromatic in shades of brown and grey, depicting nightfall.

The Dresden version is generally held to be the original, because it most perfectly exemplifies the golden section in the ratios between the central vertical axis, the perpendicular axis between it and the star, and the other axis running through the older man's eye.[2] The German art historian Werner Busch sees the geometric layout as signalling the transcendent message of the two figures' experience of nature.[3] As in many paintings by Friedrich, there is no middle ground; the foreground earthly scene is contrasted with the lighted sky and the abyss at the two men's feet made perceptible through this contrast, which exemplifies the antithetical relationship of rational, palpable earthly space and irrational and sublime infinity explored by the Romantic painters. The composition places these in a harmonious relationship.[4] It has been described as a defining image of German Romanticism.[5]

Versions

Man and Woman Contemplating the Moon, Alte Nationalgalerie, 1835

According to Johan Christian Dahl, the first owner of the (presumed) earliest version, Friedrich painted an unknown number of copies, and others also copied the picture.[6] Several versions are extant today, but their dating and authorship has not been positively determined; discussion of the question was revived in 1991.[7] Apart from Dahl's copy (now in Dresden) there is a version in the Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, dated 1825-1830. In addition to the closer adherence to the golden section, the Dresden version is truer to Friedrich's preparatory sketches from nature.

Paintings of the variant image of a man and woman observing the moon (Mann und Frau den Mond betrachtend), dated between 1830 and 1835, are located in the Alte Nationalgalerie in Berlin and in a private collection in Switzerland. The art historian Kaspar Monrad suggests that this may be the first version of the theme, and thus would predate early 1818, when the Danish writer Peder Hjort reported obtaining such a painting from Friedrich.[7] In addition to substituting the figure of a woman for the man on the left, the Berlin version differs from Two Men Contemplating the Moon in many details: the stump is broken rather than sawed, as it is in the Dresden version, the dead branch has been omitted, the tops of the trees on the right are higher, and decisively, the walking stick has been omitted, although X-ray examination reveals two lines indicating where the artist had planned to include it.[8]

Provenance

The painting in the Galerie Neue Meister in Dresden was included in 1830 in Johan Christian Dahl's collection under the title Mondscheinlandschaft. Zwei männliche Figuren betrachten den aufgehenden Halbmond (Moonlit Landscape: Two Male Figures Observing the Rising Half-Moon); he sold it to the Royal Art Gallery in Dresden in 1840 for 80 talers.[9] Dahl had obtained the painting from Friedrich in exchange for a work of his own. The painting in Berlin of a man and a woman was at the Salomon art dealership in Dresden in 1922. In 1932 it was shown at the Paul Cassirer gallery in Berlin on loan from the collection of Lulu Böhler in Lucerne, and it was bought that year by the Alte Nationalgalerie from the Fritz Nathan Gallery of Lucerne.[10]

Interpretations

With its softly melancholy mood, the painting epitomises the Romantic view of nature. The two meditative figures, seen almost entirely from the rear, serve as representatives of the observer, who is left to contemplate what they are seeing and supply a meaning.[11] In addition to the Romantic mysticism of the tension between the palpable world and the unending cosmos, three additional contrasting interpretations have been presented, in terms of religion, politics and biography.

Religion

The German art historian Helmut Börsch-Supan interprets the evergreen spruce and the dead oak as symbols of the Christian worldview and defeated paganism, respectively, the path as the path of life and the waxing moon as Christ. The oak has traditionally represented history and transience, the evergreen fir-tree, the constantly renewing power of nature.[12]

Politics

The altdeutsche Tracht worn by both men was banned under the Carlsbad decrees of 1819, coinciding with the creation of the work. Friedrich himself pointed to the importance of this political aspect in interpreting the work; Karl Förster recounts in his memoirs that on a visit to the artist's studio in Dresden on 9 April 1820, Friedrich showed him the painting and "said, ironically as if in explanation, 'They are fomenting demagogic intrigues'."[13] Many of Friedrich's paintings feature people in this political costume, suggesting he intended a political message against their suppression; however, the sketches and most of the paintings predate the ban.

Biography

The two men depicted may be Friedrich himself, on the right, and his pupil August Heinrich (1794–1822) on the left;[1] Friedrich's friend Wilhelm Wegener gave this interpretation.[14] Dahl agreed that the younger man was Heinrich but identified the older as Christian Wilhelm Bommer, the brother of Friedrich's wife Caroline;[6] however, in 1819 Heinrich was 25 but Bommer only 18.[14] In the variant with a man and a woman, Caroline Friedrich would then be the woman. Two art historians of the early twentieth century also proposed locations: Max Semrau, Friedrich and his friend Benjamin Friedrich Gotthelf Kummer on a cliff on the island of Rügen.[15] Max Sauerlandt, the same two men in the Harz Mountains.

Detlef Stapf has interpreted the painting as a memorial for Pastor Franz Christian Boll, who died in February 1818;[16] the figure on the left would be Friedrich Ludwig Jahn, who always wore a white shirt collar; the white stripe of the collar stands out in the otherwise dark picture. The location would then probably be the cliffs on the north side of the Tollensesee near Neubrandenburg, a favourite of the two. Their political views accord well with the "demagogue" political aspect of the painting. If this is correct, the woman in the alternate version would be Boll's wife Friederike; in both versions the evergreen tree would be on the side of the living person, the dead tree on that of the dead person.

References

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 "Heilbronn Timeline of Art History". metmuseum.org. The Metropolitan Museum of Art. Retrieved 21 September 2014.
  2. ↑ Werner Busch, Caspar David Friedrich. Ästhetik und Religion Munich: Beck, 2003, p. 179 (German).
  3. ↑ Busch, p. 185.
  4. ↑ Willi Geismeier, Caspar David Friedrich, 5th ed. Leipzig: Seemann, 1990, ISBN 9783363003406 (German).
  5. ↑ Busch, p. 172.
  6. ↑ 6.0 6.1 Johan Christian Dahl, letter to the Saxon Royal Gallery, Acta der Königl. Gemäldegallerie betr. 1840-1844, VII, No. 35, pp. 66–67 (German).
  7. ↑ 7.0 7.1 Kasper Monrad, "Friedrich and Two Danish Moonwatchers", in Caspar David Friedrich: Moonwatchers, ed. Sabine Rewald, Exhibition catalogue, New York: The Metropolitan Museum of Art / New Haven, Connecticut: Yale University, 2001, ISBN 9780300092981, pp. 23–29.
  8. ↑ Birgit Verwiebe, Caspar David Friedrich: Der Watzmann, Exhibition catalogue, Berlin State Museums, Cologne: DuMont, 2004, ISBN 9783832174842, p. 111 (German).
  9. ↑ Helmut Börsch-Supan and Karl Wilhelm Jähnig, Caspar David Friedrich. Gemälde, Druckgraphik und bildmäßige Zeichnungen, Munich: Prestel, 1973, ISBN 3-7913-0053-9, p. 356 (German)
  10. ↑ Börsch-Supan and Jähnig, p. 433.
  11. ↑ Werner Busch, "Zum Verständnis und Interpretation romantischer Kunst", in: Werner Busch et al., Romantik, Arte Fakten, Annweiler: Plöger, 1987, ISBN 9783924574130, p. 48 (German).
  12. ↑ Busch, p. 177.
  13. ↑ Karl Förster, Biographische und literarische Skizzen aus dem Leben und der Zeit Karl Förster's, Dresden 1846, p. 157: "'Die machen demagogische Umtriebe', sagte Friedrich ironisch, wie zur Erklärung."
  14. ↑ 14.0 14.1 Börsch-Supan and Jähnig, p. 356.
  15. ↑ Max Semrau, Caspar David Friedrich, der Greifswalder Maler. Bilder aus Greifswalds Vergangenheit, Greifswald, 1917, p. 19 (German).
  16. ↑ Detlef Stapf, Caspar David Friedrichs verborgene Landschaften. Die Neubrandenburger Kontexte. Greifswald, 2014, p. 153 (German); online edition.