Thicker Than Water (Under the Dome)

"Thicker Than Water" is the eighth episode of the first season of the CBS drama Under the Dome. The episode aired on August 12, 2013.^[1]

Plot

At night, Junior (Alexander Koch) comes home but Big Jim (Dean Norris) points a gun at him and tells him to leave. The next morning, Big Jim confronts Ollie (Leon Rippy) and gets Barbie (Mike Vogel), Linda (Natalie Martinez), Junior and a volunteer (Jimmy Gonzalez) to take the well from Ollie. However, when they arrive, a number of Ollie's men with guns appear and shoot the volunteer in the knee. Junior then betrays his father and joins Ollie's side. As Jim is rounding up volunteers to attack Ollie's farm, Barbie and Linda plan to blow the well up so that the other wells' water is returned. Barbie then tries to get Big Jim's approval, but he denies.

Meanwhile, Norrie (Mackenzie Lintz) blames Joe (Colin Ford) for finding the mini-dome and breaks up with him. Joe then tells Julia (Rachelle Lefevre) about the mini-dome and the egg, and they both go to see it. But this time the egg is pink and when Julia touches the dome, she sees another Joe who says, "the monarch will be crowned." Joe then thinks that something bad will happen to him.

Junior finds out from Ollie that his mother did not die because of an accidental car crash but as a suicide attempt. Junior then asks Ollie not to kill Jim, because he wants to. Before Big Jim and the volunteers attack, Barbie infiltrates Ollie's farm, creates a bomb and sticks it to the well. At night, Big Jim, Linda, Phil (Nicholas Strong), and the rest attack the farm. Jim then realizes that Barbie went along with his plan. In the following battle, many are shot and killed, except for Phil, who gets shot in the shoulder. Right before he detonates the bomb, Barbie is caught, but manages to overcome the attacker and destroy the well. While everyone realizes that the well has been destroyed, Junior appears and knocks Jim out with his gun.

As Joe and Julia exit the forest and into the street, Linda almost hits Joe while she's taking Phil to the hospital. Linda then reassures Joe that he will be fine. Angie (Britt Robertson) and Norrie bond, and she talks Norrie into getting back together with Joe. Norrie then tells Joe that she is ready to bury her mom, Alice (Samantha Mathis), who died in the previous episode.

Big Jim is dragged into Ollie's living room and his men leave saying that they no longer need his water. Ollie then lets Junior kill Big Jim but he asks Jim about his mother. When Junior starts to get soft, Ollie pulls out a gun and aims it at Jim, but Junior shoots and kills Ollie. Big Jim and Junior then reconcile and both part ways. Big Jim is later confronted by Barbie, with Barbie saying how fewer people could have died had they went with his plan. At the police station, Linda is surprised to see Junior back and he tells her what happened and that the cell is his home. At Julie's house, Julie asks Barbie if he knows what the other Joe meant but he says no. It is then revealed that Angie is also connected to the dome after a tattoo of a monarch is seen on her shoulder.

Production

Executive producer Neal Baer said with TV Guide regarding Big Jim and the events of the previous episode that "Boomer and Ollie were preventing the town from getting access to water, so was Big Jim being evil or was he doing this to save the town? That's always the wonderful part about Big Jim — that it's not like he gets off on killing people, but the only people he's killed have threatened Chester's Mill. Ollie was going to keep everyone from getting water and we'll get into that next week in a big way."^[2]

Reception

Ratings

The episode was watched by 10.36 million American viewers and received an 18-49 rating/share of 2.4/7, which was at the time the lowest rated episode of the series. The show placed first for the timeslot, with Siberia placing second in the same timeslot, and first for the night.^[3]

Critical reception

Ted Kindig of BuddyTV gave the episode a negative review, but also commented on Dean Norris's success, saying "We're all remembering what Norris can do with a good script and an assured authorial vision. We're engaging with stories that don't rely on mumbo-jumbo mystery phrases to build suspense. And while I'm not entirely proud to open this recap with a hacky, predictable bait-and-switch, Under the Dome isn't the least bit ashamed to end on one."^[4] Andrea Reiher of Zap2it said despite the ending with Angie gazing at Jim and Norrie being "creepy," she then said "It's also interesting to watch Big Jim and Junior be so separated, since in the book they are definitely partners in crime. Is the show on its way there?"^[5]

References