Texas Senate Bill 5

Texas Senate Bill 5 (or Texas SB 5) is a bill that was created on June 11, 2013, and was discussed during the First Special Session of the Eighty-third Texas Legislature and was signed into law by Governor Rick Perry on July 18, 2013.

Bill content

Texas Senate Bill 5 is a list of measures that would add and update abortion regulations in Texas. These measures include a ban on abortion at 20 weeks post-fertilization and recognize that the state has a compelling interest to protect fetuses from pain.^[1] The bill would mandate that a doctor who performs abortions have admitting privileges at a nearby hospital, and to require that clinics meet the same standards as other surgical health-care facilities in the state.^[2][3][4][5] Another provision would require oversight of women taking abortion-inducing drugs such as RU-486.^[6] The bill would not apply to abortions necessary to save the mother's life or to prevent permanent bodily damage from a pregnancy. ^{[7] [8]}

History

First Special Session

On June 25, 2013, Senator Wendy Davis began a filibuster in attempt to block the bill by maintaining the floor until midnight, when the Senate's special session ended, after which the state Senate would no longer be able to vote on the measure.^[9] After ten hours, Lieutenant Governor David Dewhurst ruled that Davis had gone off topic after Davis began talking about a sonogram bill, forcing a vote on whether the filibuster could continue.^[10] Despite efforts to pass the bill, parliamentary enquiries from Leticia R. Van de Putte and other senators, as well as disruption from the gallery caused the session to go on through midnight, the official closure of the special session.^[11] Following the deadline, Republicans indicated that a vote had taken place and passed 19–11, while Democrats declared that the vote had taken place after midnight, making the vote void.^[11] Dewhurst later conceded that the bill was passed after the deadline and was considered dead.^[12][13]

Timestamp issue

After the bill was thought to have been passed, a record was added to the official web page on the history of the bill. According to the page, the timestamp of the bill's passage was listed as the 26th.^[14] Later, the page was taken down and altered to say that the bill was passed on the 25th.^[15] According to Texas Penal Code, Section 37.10, it is a crime to make an alteration that is false in a government document or record.^[15][16] According to the Legislative Reference Library of Texas the Texas Legislature Online system "... is not the official record of those actions, and [the Legislative Reference Library staff] enters actions on TLO as a public service independently of the officers of the house or senate."^[17] The Public Integrity Unit has begun an investigation into the events after receiving complaints.^[18]

Second Special Session

On the 26th, Governor Rick Perry added the bill as part of three bills in a second special session, with the name Senate Bill 2.^[19][20] Perry stated that it was due to the "[...] breakdown of decorum and decency to prevent us from doing what the people of this state hired us to do."^[21]

The second session began on July 1, with supporters and opponents of the bill showing up in large crowds at the Texas Legislative building while wearing blue or orange shirts in support of their side.^[22][23]

The Texas House passed the bill on July 10, 2013, by a 96–49 margin and sent the measure to the Texas Senate.^[6]

The Texas Senate passed the bill on July 13, 2013 with a bipartisan vote with a 19-11 margin.^[24][25][26] The bill was signed by Gov. Rick Perry on July 18, 2013.^[27]

The bill was eventually passed by both the House and the Senate in the July 2013 second special session and was signed by Gov. Rick Perry,^[24][25][26] prompting one commentator to state that "Wendy Davis won the battle, but Rick Perry won the war."^[28]

Public response

Billy Joe and Tuesday's controversial placard, that went viral on the net.

Organizations and people on both sides used websites like Twitter and the Texas Tribune to share their side and learn more, with several hashtags becoming popular on Twitter.^[29][30][31] Coverage and a livestream of the Texas Legislature by the Texas Tribune has been said to have been the reason that the bill became national, and later international, news.^[32]

Images of the placard carried by pro-choice activists Billy Joe Cain, his daughter Tuesday, with the message "JESUS isn't a DICK; so keep him OUT of MY VAGINA!" went viral, the resultant controversy was reported nationally and internationally.^[33][34][35]

Debate

Many people who are against the bill have opposed the requirement that would force clinics to follow the same standards as surgical centers, since it could lead to the closure of the clinics and result in large areas of the state to not have access to a clinic.^[36] Supporters of the legislation have stated that the purpose of the new law is to protect women’s health and unborn children, citing precedents like the recent Kermit Gosnell case.^[36][37]

Abortion access in the state of Texas has seen a serious decline since the passage of Senate bill 5. There were 44 facilities that performed abortions in Texas in 2011, When the law is fully implemented in September, that number is expected to drop to six. Amy Hagstrom Miller, the chief executive of Whole Woman’s Health, which has challenged provisions of the law in court. "I tried everything I can. I just can’t keep the doors open.”^[38]

References

External links

• History of the Bill - First Session
• History of the Bill - Second Session