Rhamphorhynchus

Rhamphorhynchus Temporal range: Late Jurassic, 150.8–148.5Ma PreꞒ Ꞓ O S D C P T J K Pg N ↓
Cast of the first specimen found with wing membranes, Musée de sciences naturelles de Bruxelles
Scientific classification
Kingdom:	Animalia
Phylum:	Chordata
Order:	†Pterosauria
Family:	†Rhamphorhynchidae
Subfamily:	†Rhamphorhynchinae
Genus:	†Rhamphorhynchus Meyer, 1846
Type species
†Pterodactylus longicaudus Münster, 1839
Species
†Rhamphorhynchus muensteri (Goldfuss, 1831)
Synonyms
Genus synonymy Ornithopterus Meyer, 1838b Odontorhynchus Stolley, 1936 Pteromonodactylus Teryaev, 1967 Species synonymy Ornithocephalus giganteus Oken, 1819 Pterodactylus grandis Cuvier, 1824 Ornithocephalus muensteri Goldfuss, 1831 Pterodactylus longicaudus Münster, 1839 Pterodactylus lavateri Meyer, 1838a Pterodactylus secundarius Meyer, 1843 Pterodactylus gemmingi Meyer, 1846 Rhamphorhynchus suevicus O. Fraas, 1855 Pterodactylus hirundinaceus Wagner, 1857 Rhamphorhynchus curtimanus Wagner, 1858 Rhamphorhynchus longimanus Wagner, 1858 Rhamphorhynchus meyeri Owen, 1870 Rhamphorhynchus phyllurus Marsh, 1882 Rhamphorhynchus longiceps Woodward, 1902 Rhamphorhynchus kokeni F. Plieninger, 1907 Rhamphorhynchus megadactylus Koenigswald, 1931 Rhamphorhynchus carnegiei Koh, 1937

Rhamphorhynchus /ˌræmfəˈrɪŋkəs/, "beak snout", is a genus of long-tailed pterosaurs in the Jurassic period. Less specialized than contemporary, short-tailed pterodactyloid pterosaurs such as Pterodactylus, it had a long tail, stiffened with ligaments, which ended in a characteristic diamond-shaped vane. The jaws of Rhamphorhynchus housed needle-like teeth, which were angled forward, with a curved, sharp, beak-like tip lacking teeth, indicating a diet mainly of fish and insects.

Although fragmentary fossil remains possibly belonging to Rhamphorhynchus have been found in England, Tanzania, and Spain, the best preserved specimens come from the Solnhofen limestone of Bavaria, Germany. Many of these fossils preserve not only the bones but impressions of soft tissues such as wing membranes. Scattered teeth believed to belong to Rhamphorhynchus have been found in Portugal as well.^[1]

Description

Illustration of a specimen in flight

The largest known specimen of Rhamphorhynchus muensteri (catalog number BMNH 37002) measures 1.26 meters (4.1 ft) long with a wingspan of 1.81 m (5.9 ft).

Skull

Contrary to a 1927 report by pterosaur researcher Ferdinand Broili, Rhamphorhynchus lacked any bony or soft tissue crest, as seen in several species of contemporary small pterodactyloid pterosaurs. Broili claimed to have found a two millimeter tall crest made of thin bone that ran much of the skulls length in one Rhamphorhynchus specimen, evidenced by an impression in the surrounding rock and a few small fragments of the crest itself.^[2] However, subsequent examination of this specimen by Wellnhofer in 1975 and Bennett in 2002 using both visible and ultraviolet light found no trace of a crest, and both concluded that Broili was mistaken. The supposed crest, they concluded, was simply an artifact of preservation.^[3][4]

The teeth of Rhamphorhynchus intermesh when the jaw is closed and are suggestive of a piscivorous diet.^[1] There are twenty teeth in the upper jaws and fourteen in the lower jaws.^[1]

History and classification

One of the first ever restorations of Rhamphorhynchus from 1863, shown with tracks now known to belong to Mesolimulus

The classification and taxonomy of Rhamphorhynchus, like many pterosaur species known since the Victorian era, is complex, with a long history of reclassification under a variety of names, often for the same specimens.

The first named specimen of Rhamphorhynchus, was brought to the attention of Samuel Thomas von Soemmerring by the collector Georg Graf zu Münster in 1825. von Soermmerring concluded that it belonged to an ancient bird. When further preparation uncovered teeth, Graf zu Münster sent a cast to Professor Georg August Goldfuss who recognised it as a pterosaur. Like most pterosaurs described in the mid 19th century, Rhamphorhynchus was originally considered to be a species of Pterodactylus. However, at the time, many scientists incorrectly considered Ornithocephalus to be the valid name for Pterodactylus. This specimen of Rhamphorhynchus was therefore originally named Ornithocephalus Münsteri. This was first mentioned in 1830 by Graf zu Münster himself.^[5] However, the description making the name valid was given by Goldfuss in an 1831 follow-up to Münster's short paper.^[6] Note that the ICZN later ruled that non-standard Latin characters such as ü would not be allowed in scientific names, and the spelling münsteri was emended to muensteri by Richard Lydekker in 1888.

In 1839, Münster described another specimen he considered to belong to Ornithocephalus (i.e. Pterodactylus), with a distinctive long tail. He named it Ornithocephalus longicaudus, meaning "long tail", to differentiate it from the specimens with short tails (the true specimens of Pterodactylus).^[7]

Holotype R. munsteri skull as illustrated in 1851

In 1845, Hermann von Meyer officially emended the original species Ornithocephalus münsteri to Pterodactylus münsteri, since the name Pterodactylus had been by that point recognized as having priority over Ornithocephalus.^[8] In a subsequent 1846 paper describing a new species of long-tailed 'pterodactyl', von Meyer decided that the long-tailed forms of Pterodactylus were different enough from the short-tailed forms to warrant placement in a subgenus, and he named his new species Pterodactylus (Rhamphorhynchus) gemmingi after a specimen owned by collector Captain Carl Eming von Gemming that was later by von Gemming sold for three hundred guilders to the Teylers Museum in Haarlem.^[9] It was not until 1847 that von Meyer elevated Rhamphorhynchus to a full-fledged genus, and officially included in it both long-tailed species of Pterodactylus known at the time, R. longicaudus (the original species preserving a long tail) and R. gemmingi.^[10] The type species of Rhamphorhynchus is R. longicaudus; its type specimen or holotype also was sold to the Teylers Museum, where it still resides as TM 6924.

The original species, Pterodactylus muensteri, remained misclassified until a re-evaluation was published by Richard Owen in an 1861 book, in which he renamed it as Rhamphorhynchus münsteri.^[11] The type specimen of R. muensteri, described by Münster and Goldfuss, was lost during World War II. If available, a new specimen or neotype is designated the type if the original is lost or deemed too poorly preserved. Peter Wellnhofer declined to designate a neotype in his 1975 review of the genus, because a number of high quality casts of the original specimen were still available in museum collections.^[12] These can serve as plastotypes.

By the 1990s (and following Wellnfofer's consolidation of many previously named species), about five species of Rhamphorhynchus were recognized from the Solnhofen limestone of Germany, with a few others having been named from Africa, Spain, and the UK based on fragmentary remains.^[3][12] Most of the Solnhofen species were differentiated based on their relative size, and size-related features such as relative length of the skull.^[12]

Restored skull

In 1995, pterosaur researcher Chris Bennett published an extensive review of the currently recognized German species. Bennett concluded that all the supposedly distinct German species were actually different year-classes of a single species, R. muensteri, representing distinct age groups, with the smaller species being juveniles and the larger adults. Bennett's paper did not cover the British and African species, though he suggested these should be considered indeterminate members of the family Rhamphorhynchidae and not necessarily species of Rhamphorhynchus itself. Despite the reduction of the genus to a single species, the type species remains R. longicaudus.^[12]

The cladogram (family tree) of rhamphorhynchids below is the result of a large phylogenetic analysis published by Andres & Myers in 2013.^[13]

Paleobiology

Life history

Specimen with tail vane, Royal Ontario Museum

Traditionally, the large size variation between specimens of Rhamphorhynchus has been taken to represent species variation. However, in a 1995 paper, Bennett argued that these "species" actually represent year-classes of a single species, Rhamphorhynchus muensteri, from flaplings to adults. Following from this interpretation, Bennett found several notable changes that occurred in R. muensteri as the animal aged.^[12]

Juvenile Rhamphorhynchus had relatively short skulls with large eyes, and the toothless beak-like tips of the jaws were shorter in juveniles than adults, with rounded, blunt lower jaw tips eventually becoming slender and pointed as the animals grew. Adult Rhamphorhynchus also developed a strong upward "hook" at the end of the lower jaw. The number of teeth remained constant from juvenile to adult, though the teeth became relatively shorter and stockier as the animals grew, possibly to accommodate larger and more powerful prey. The pelvic and pectoral girdles fused as the animals aged, with full pectoral fusion attained by one year of age.^[12]

The shape of the tail vane also changed across various age classes of Rhamphorhynchus. In juveniles, the vane was shallow relative to the tail and roughly oval, or "lancet-shaped". As growth progressed, the tail vane became diamond-shaped, and finally triangular in the largest individuals.^[12]

R. intermedius, a small specimen that might be a juvenile of R. muensteri

The smallest known Rhamphorhynchus specimen has a wingspan of only 290 millimeters; however, it is likely that even such a small individual was capable of flight. Bennett examined two possibilities for hatchlings: that they were altricial, requiring some period of parental care before leaving the nest, or that they were precocial, hatching with sufficient size and ability for flight. If precocious, Bennett suggested that clutches would be small, with only one or two eggs laid per clutch, to compensate for the relatively large size of the hatchings. Bennett did not speculate on which possibility was more likely, though the discovery of a pterosaur embryo (Avgodectes) with strongly ossified bones suggests that pterosaurs in general were precocial, able to fly soon after hatching with minimal parental care.^[14] This theory was contested by a histological study of Rhamphorhynchus that showed the initial rapid growth was followed by a prolonged period of slow growth.^[15]

Metabolism

R. muensteri on display at the Museo Civico di Storia Naturale di Milano

Having determined that Rhamphorhynchus specimens fit into discrete year-classes, Bennett was able to estimate growth rate during one year by comparing the size of one-year-old specimens with two-year-old specimens. He found that the average growth rate during the first year of life for Rhamphorhynchus was 130% to 173%, slightly faster than the growth rate in alligators. Growth likely slowed considerably after sexual maturity, so it would have taken more than three years to attain maximum adult size.^[12]

This growth rate is much slower than the rate seen in large pterodactyloid pterosaurs such as Pteranodon, which attained near-adult size within the first year of life. Additionally, pterodactyloids had determinate growth, meaning that the animals reached a fixed maximum adult size and stopped growing. Previous assumptions of rapid growth rate in rhamphorhynchoids were based on the assumption that they needed to be warm-blooded to sustain active flight. Warm-blooded animals, like modern birds and bats, normally show rapid growth to adult size and determinate growth. Because there is no evidence for either in Rhamphorhynchus, Bennett considered his findings consistent with an ectothermic metabolism, though he recommended more studies needed to be done. Cold-blooded Rhamphorhynchus, Bennett suggested, may have basked in the sun or worked their muscles to accumulate enough energy for bouts of flight, and cooled to ambient temperature when not active to save energy, like modern reptiles.^[12]

Sexual dimorphism

Both Koh Ting-Pong and Peter Wellnhofer recognized two distinct groups among adult Rhamphorhynchus muensteri, differentiated by the proportions of the neck, wing, and hind limbs, but particularly in the ratio of skull to humerus length. Both researchers noted that these two groups of specimens were found in roughly a 1:1 ratio, and interpreted them as different sexes.^[3][16] Bennett tested for sexual dimorphism in Rhamphorhynchus by using a statistical analysis, and found that the specimens did indeed group together into small-headed and large-headed sets. However, without any known variation in the actual form of the bones or soft tissue (morphological differences), he found the case for sexual dimorphism inconclusive.^[12]

Head orientation

Depiction by John Conway

In 2003, a team of researchers led by Lawrence Witmer studied the brain anatomy of several types of pterosaurs, including Rhamphorhynchus muensteri, using endocasts of the brain they retrieved by performing CAT scans of fossil skulls. Using comparisons to modern animals, they were able to estimate various physical attributes of pterosaurs, including relative head orientation during flight and coordination of the wing membrane muscles. Witmer and his team found that Rhamphorhynchus held its head parallel to the ground due to the orientation of the osseous labyrinth of the inner ear, which helps animals detect balance. In contrast, pterodactyloid pterosaurs such as Anhanguera appear to have normally held their heads at a downward angle, both in flight and while on the ground.^[17]

Daily activity patterns

Comparisons between the scleral rings of Rhamphorhynchus and modern birds and reptiles suggest that it may have been nocturnal, and may have had activity patterns similar to those of modern nocturnal seabirds. This may also indicate niche partitioning with contemporary pterosaurs inferred to be diurnal, such as Scaphognathus and Pterodactylus.^[18]

Ecology

Fossil specimen WDC CSG 255, including a Rhamphorhynchus with a Leptolepides fish trapped in the pharynx and caught in the jaws of an Aspidorhynchus

Several limestone slabs have been discovered in which fossils of Rhamphorhynchus are found in close association with the ganoid fish Aspidorhynchus. In one of these specimens, the jaws of an Aspidorhynchus pass through the wings of the Rhamphorhynchus specimen. The Rhamphorhynchus also has the remains of a small fish, possibly Leptolepides, in its throat. This slab, cataloged as WDC CSG 255, may represent two levels of predation; one by Rhamphorhynchus and one by Aspidorhynchus. In a 2012 description of WDC CSG 255, researchers proposed that the Rhamphorhynchus individual had just caught a Leptolepides while it was flying low over a body of water. As the Leptolepides was travelling down its pharynx, a large Aspidorhynchus would have attacked from below the water, accidentally puncturing the left wing membrane of the Rhamphorhynchus with its sharp rostrum in the process. The teeth in its snout were ensnared in the fibrous tissue of the wing membrane, and as the fish thrashed to release itself the left wing of Rhamphorhynchus was pulled backward into the distorted position seen in the fossil. The encounter resulted in the death of both individuals, most likely because the two animals sank into an anoxic layer in the water body, depriving the fish of oxygen. The two may have been preserved together as the weight of the head of Aspidorhynchus held down the much lighter body of Rhamphorhynchus.^[19]

Species

Rhamphorhynchus sp., Houston Museum of Natural Science

Holotype of R. gemmingi, Teylers Museum, Haarlem

Specimen formerly assigned to R. intermedius with tail vane

Cast of a headless R. muensteri specimen originally attributed to R. longicaudus, Oxford University Museum of Natural History. The head has been reconstructed for the cast.

A large number of Rhamphorhynchus species have been named, but are currently considered year-classes of R. muensteri by most researchers. Currently recognized specimens of Rhamphorhynchus have previously been published on under the following junior synonyms:^[20]

Note that Rhamphorhynchus is also a genus of orchid, named in 1977 by botanist L.A. Garay. In biological nomenclature, the same name may be used for an animal that has already been used for a plant or vice versa.

Synonyms

Synonyms of Rhamphorhynchus muensteri:

• Ornithocephalus muensteri Goldfuss, 1831 emend. Lydekker, 1888
• Pterodactylus muensteri Goldfuss, 1831 emend. Lydekker, 1888
• Pterodactylus (Rhamphorhynchus) muensteri (Goldfuss, 1831)
• R. longicaudus (Münster, 1839) von Meyer, 1846
  • Pterodactylus longicaudus Münster, 1839
  • Odontorhynchus longicaudus (Münster, 1839) Olshevsky, 1978
  • Ornithocephalus longicaudus (Münster, 1839) Wagner, 1851
  • Rhamphorhynchus (Odontorhynchus) longicaudus (Münster, 1839) Stolley, 1936
• R. gemmingi (von Meyer, 1846) von Meyer, 1855
  • Pterodactylus lavateri von Meyer, 1838a
  • Ornithopterus lavateri (von Meyer, 1838a) von Meyer, 1838b
  • Pterodactylus gemmingi von Meyer, 1846
  • Pterodactylus (Rhamphorhynchus) gemmingi von Meyer, 1846
  • Pterodactylus (Ornithopterus) lavateri (von Meyer, 1838a) Owen, 1851
  • Ornithocephalus gemmingi (von Meyer, 1846) Wagner, 1851
  • Rhamphorhynchus (Pterodactylus) gemmingi (von Meyer, 1846) von Meyer, 1855
• R. suevicus O. Fraas, 1855
• Pterodactylus hirundinaceus Wagner, 1857
• Pterodactylus (Rhamphorhynchus) hirundinaceus Wagner, 1857
• R. hirundinaceus (Wagner, 1857) Wagner, 1858
• R. curtimanus Wagner, 1858
• R. longimanus Wagner, 1858
• R. meyeri Owen, 1870
• R. phyllurus Marsh, 1882
• Pteromonodactylus phyllurus (Marsh, 1882) Teryaev, 1967
• R. longiceps Woodward, 1902
  • Ornithocephalus giganteus Oken, 1819
  • Pterodactylus giganteus (Oken, 1819)
  • Pterodactylus grandis Cuvier, 1824
  • Ornithocephalus grandis (Cuvier, 1824) Wagner, 1851
  • R. grandis (Cuvier, 1824) Lydekker, 1888
  • Pterodactylus secundarius von Meyer, 1843
  • Ornithocephalus secundarius (von Meyer, 1843) Wagner, 1851
  • R. kokeni F. Plieninger, 1907
• R. megadactylus von Koenigswald, 1931
• R. carnegiei Koh, 1937

Dubious species

Dubious species of Rhamphorhynchus:

• R. jessoni (Lydekker, 1890)
• R. tendagurensis (Peck, 1931)
• R. intermedius Koh, 1937
• R. intermedius var. brevialata Koh, 1937

"Odontorhynchus"

"Odontorhynchus" aculeatus was based on a skull with lower jaw that is now lost. This set of jaws supposedly differed in having two teeth united at the tip of the lower jaw, and none at the tip of the upper jaw. The skull was 6.5–7.0 cm (2.56–2.76 in), making it a small form.^[21] Stolley, who described the specimen in 1936, argued that R. longicaudus also should be reclassified in the genus "Odontorhynchus". Both Koh and Wellnhofer rejected this idea, arguing instead that "Odontorhynchus" was a junior synonym of R. longicaudus.^[3][16] Bennett agreed with their assessments, and included both "Odontorhynchus" and R. longicaudus as synonyms of R. muensteri.^[12]

References