| Year |  |  |  | Location |
| 2015 | | | | St. Catharines, ON |
| 2014 | Onondaga Redhawks (Can-Am) | Six Nations Rivermen (OLA) | St. Albert Miners (RMLL) |
Coquitlam, BC |
| 2013 | St. Catharines Saints (OLA) | Kahnawake Mohawks (QSLL) | Caughnawaga Indians (TNSLL) | Kahnawake,QC |
| 2012 | St. Regis Braves (TNSLL) | St. Catharines Saints (OLA) | Rocky View Knights (RMLL) | Spruce Grove, AB |
| 2011 | St. Regis Braves (TNSLL) | Snake Island Muskies (TNSLL) | St. Catharines Saints (OLA) | Akwesasne, ON |
| 2010 | Onondaga Redhawks (Can-Am) | Owen Sound Woodsmen (OLA) | Kahnawake Mohawks (QSLL) | Burnaby, BC |
| 2009 | Owen Sound Woodsmen (OLA) | Tri-City Bandits (WCSLA) | Six Nations Sting (Can-Am) | Hagersville, ON |
| 2008 | Owen Sound Woodsmen (OLA) | Sherwood Park Outlaws (RMLL) | Kahnawake Mohawks (QSLL) | Sherwood Park, AB |
| 2007 | Sherwood Park Outlaws (RMLL) | Ajax-Pickering Rock (OLA) | Owen Sound Woodsmen (OLA) | Owen Sound, ON |
| 2006 | Wellington Aces (OLA) | Sherwood Park Outlaws (RMLL) | Ladner Pioneers (WCSLA) | Ladner, BC |
| 2005 | Kitchener-Waterloo Kodiaks (OLA) | Tri-City Bandits (WCSLA) | Sherwood Park Outlaws (RMLL) | Waterloo, ON |
| 2004 | Ladner Pioneers (WCSLA) | Kahnawake Mohawks (ILA) | Langley Knights (WCSLA) | Langley, BC |
| 2003 | Kitchener-Waterloo Kodiaks (OLA) | Owen Sound Woodsmen (OLA) | Edmonton Outlaws (RMLL) | Owen Sound, ON |
| 2002 | Edmonton Outlaws (RMLL) | Snye Warriors (ILA) | Nanaimo Timbermen (WCSLA) | Edmonton, AB |
| 2001 | North Shore Indians (WCSLA) | Abbotsford Bandits (WCSLA) | Owen Sound Woodsmen (OLA) | New Westminster, BC |
| 2000 | Newtown Golden Eagles (Can-Am) | Brooklin Redmen (OLA) | Kahnawake Mohawks (ILA) | Kahnawake, QC |
| 1999 | Burnaby Bandits (WCSLA) | North Shore Indians (WCSLA) | Newtown Golden Eagles (Can-Am) | Burnaby, BC |
| 1998 | Ladner Pioneers (BC) | Newtown Golden Eagles (Can-Am) | Tuscarora Thunderhawks (ILA) | Tuscarora, NY |
| 1997 | Akwesasne Thunder (ILA) | Ohsweken Wolves (Ont) | Ladner Pioneers (WCSLA) | Ladner, BC |
| 1996 | Ohsweken Wolves (Ont) | Akwesasne Thunder (ILA) | Kahnawake Mohawks (ILA) | Cornwall, ON |
| 1995 | Akwesasne Thunder (ILA) | Burnaby Lakers (WCSLA) | Edmonton Miners (RMLL) | Prince George, BC |
| 1994 | Tuscarora Thunderhawks (ILA) | Burnaby Lakers (WCSLA) | Akwesasne Thunder(ILA) | Hamilton, ON |
| 1993 | North Shore Indians (WCSLA) | Edmonton Miners (RMLL) | Burnaby Lakers (WCSLA) |
| 1992 | Fergus Thistles (Ont) | Nanaimo Timbermen (WCSLA) | Edmonton Miners (RMLL) |
| 1991 | Owen Sound North Stars (Ont) | Edmonton Miners (RMLL) | -- |
| 1990 | Fergus Thistles (Ont) | Edmonton Miners (RMLL) | Owen Sound North Stars (Ont) | Fergus, ON |
| 1989 | Owen Sound North Stars (Ont) | Nanaimo Timbermen (WCSLA) | Edmonton Miners (RMLL) |
| 1988 | Fergus Thistles (Ont) | Surrey Rebels (WCSLA) | -- | Halifax, NS |
| 1987 | Fergus Thistles (Ont) | Sarnia Lumley Wrecking (Ont) | Kahnawake Mohawks (ILA) | Sarnia, ON |
| 1986 | Fergus Thistles (Ont) | Newtown Golden Eagles | Surrey Rebels (WCSLA) | Surrey, BC |
| 1985 | North Shore Indians (WCSLA) | Orangeville Northmen (Ont) | -- | Ladner, BC |
| 1984 | Orangeville Northmen (Ont) | -- | -- |
| 1983 | Calgary Mountaineers (Alberta) | -- | -- |
| 1982 | Orangeville Northmen (Ont) | -- | -- |
| 1981 | Orangeville Northmen (Ont) | -- | -- |
| 1980 | Owen Sound North Stars (Ont) | -- | -- |
| 1979 | Owen Sound North Stars (Ont) | Kahnawake Mohawks (ILA) | -- |
| 1978 | Vernon Tigers (Okanagan) | Six Nations Braves | Akwesasne Warriors | Edmonton, Alberta |
| 1977 | Vernon Tigers (Okanagan) | -- | -- |
| 1976 | Vernon Tigers (Okanagan) | Edmonton Fullers (Alberta) | Caughnawaga Indians | |
| 1975 | Edmonton Fullers (Alberta) | Nova Scotia | Prince George Canada Hotel (NCLA) | Verdun/Magog, QC |
| 1974 | Prince George Oldstylers (NCLA) | Winnipeg All-Stars (Alberta) | New Westminster Rebels (NCLA) | New Westminster, BC |
| 1973 | Windsor Warlocks (Ont) | Prince George Oldstylers (NCLA) | Nova Scotia | Halifax, NS |
| 1972 | Brampton Excelsiors (Ont) | New Westminster Blues (BC) | -- | |
| 1971 | Windsor Warlocks (Ont) | Burnaby Kokanee's (BC) | -- | Windsor, ON |
| 1970 | Windsor Clippers (Ont) | New Westminster Blues (BC) | none | Windsor, ON |
| 1969 | Nanaimo Luckies (BC) | Caughnawaga Indians | Wallaceburg Red Devils (Ont) | |
| 1968 | Brantford Supertests (Ont) | Kahnawake Mohawks (ILA) | -- |
| 1967 | Brantford Supertests (Ont) | -- | -- |
| 1966 | Nanaimo Luckies (BC) | -- | -- |
| 1965 | Fergus Thistles (Ont) | Cornwall Wildcats | none |
| 1964 | Ohsweken Warriors (Ont) | -- | -- |
