| Season | Position | All-Defensive Team |
|---|
| 1985 | Guard | Robert Jaworski (Ginebra) |
| Guard | Abe King (Great Taste) |
| Center | Yoyoy Villamin (Manila Beer) |
| Forward | Chito Loyzaga (Ginebra) |
| Forward | Philip Cezar (Shell) |
| 1986 | Guard | Ricky Relosa (Alaska) |
| Guard | Padim Israel (Tanduay) |
| Center | Yoyoy Villamin (Manila Beer) |
| Forward | Chito Loyzaga (Ginebra) |
| Forward | Philip Cezar (Shell) |
| 1987 | Guard | Ricky Relosa (Hills Bros.) |
| Guard | Biboy Ravenes (Shell) |
| Center | Yoyoy Villamin (Hills Bros.) |
| Forward | Chito Loyzaga (Ginebra) |
| Forward | Philip Cezar (Shell) |
| 1988 | Guard | Ricky Relosa (Hills Bros.) |
| Guard | Biboy Ravenes (Shell) |
| Center | Yoyoy Villamin (Hills Bros.) |
| Forward | Chito Loyzaga (Ginebra) |
| Forward | Philip Cezar (Shell) |
| 1989 | Guard | Glenn Capacio (Purefoods) |
| Guard | Alvin Teng (San Miguel) |
| Center | Yoyoy Villamin (Alaska) |
| Forward | Chito Loyzaga (Añejo) |
| Forward | Jerry Codiñera (Purefoods) |
| 1990 | Guard | Glenn Capacio (Purefoods) |
| Guard | Alvin Teng (San Miguel) |
| Center | Yoyoy Villamin (Alaska) |
| Forward | Chito Loyzaga (Añejo) |
| Forward | Jerry Codiñera (Purefoods) |
| 1991 | Guard | Glenn Capacio (Purefoods) |
| Guard | Biboy Ravanes (Alaska) |
| Center | Jerry Codiñera (Purefoods) |
| Forward | Alvin Teng (San Miguel) |
| Forward | Chito Loyzaga (Ginebra) |
| 1992 | Guard | Glenn Capacio (Purefoods) |
| Guard | Art dela Cruz (San Miguel) |
| Center | Jerry Codiñera (Purefoods) |
| Forward | Alvin Teng (San Miguel) |
| Forward | Chito Loyzaga (Ginebra) |
| 1993 | Guard | Glenn Capacio (Purefoods) |
| Guard | Art dela Cruz (San Miguel) |
| Center | Jun Limpot (Sta. Lucia) |
| Forward | Jerry Codiñera (Purefoods) |
| Forward | Alvin Teng (San Miguel) |
| 1994 | Guard | Glenn Capacio (Purefoods) |
| Guard | Johnny Abarrientos (Alaska) |
| Center | Jerry Codiñera (Purefoods) |
| Forward | Bong Hawkins (Alaska) |
| Forward | Alvin Teng (San Miguel) |
| 1995 | Guard | Glenn Capacio (Purefoods) |
| Guard | Art dela Cruz (San Miguel) |
| Center | Yoyoy Villamin (Sunkist) |
| Forward | Chris Jackson (Sta. Lucia) |
| Forward | Jerry Codiñera (Purefoods) |
| 1996 | Guard | Johnny Abarrientos (Alaska) |
| Guard | Jeffrey Cariaso (Alaska) |
| Center | Marlou Aquino (Ginebra) |
| Forward | Chris Jackson (Sta. Lucia) |
| Forward | Jerry Codiñera (Purefoods) |
| 1997 | Guard | Johnny Abarrientos (Alaska) |
| Guard | Jeffrey Cariaso (Alaska) |
| Center | Marlou Aquino (Gordon's Gin) |
| Forward | Freddie Abuda (San Miguel) |
| Forward | Jerry Codiñera (Purefoods) |
| 1998 | Guard | Glenn Capacio (Mobiline) |
| Guard | Patrick Fran (Mobiline) |
| Center | Jerry Codiñera (Purefoods) |
| Forward | Freddie Abuda (San Miguel) |
| Forward | Chris Jackson (Formula Shell) |
| 1999 | Guard | Johnny Abarrientos (Alaska) |
| Guard | Dindo Pumaren (Purefoods) |
| Center | Eric Menk (Tanduay) |
| Forward | Freddie Abuda (San Miguel) |
| Forward | Chris Jackson (Shell) |
| 2000 | Guard | Jeffrey Cariaso (Tanduay) |
| Guard | Dindo Pumaren (Purefoods) |
| Center | Chris Jackson (Shell) |
| Forward | Rey Evangelista (Purefoods) |
| Forward | Freddie Abuda (San Miguel) |
| 2001 | Guard | Rey Evangelista (Purefoods) |
| Guard | Patrick Fran (Talk 'N Text) |
| Center | Marlou Aquino (Sta. Lucia) |
| Forward | Dennis Espino (Sta. Lucia) |
| Forward | Chris Jackson (Shell) |
| 2002 | Guard | Rey Evangelista (Purefoods) |
| Guard | Jeffrey Cariaso (Coca-Cola) |
| Center | Davonn Harp (Red Bull) |
| Forward | Rudy Hatfield (Coca-Cola) |
| Forward | Chris Jackson (Shell) |
| 2003 | Guard | Patrick Fran (Talk 'N Text) |
| Guard | Willie Miller (Red Bull) |
| Center | Asi Taulava (Talk 'N Text) |
| Forward | Rudy Hatfield (Coca-Cola) |
| Forward | Marlou Aquino (Sta. Lucia) |
| 2004-05 | Guard | Rich Alvarez (Shell) |
| Guard | Johnny Abarrientos (Coca-Cola) |
| Center | Enrico Villanueva (Red Bull) |
| Forward | Junthy Valenzuela (Red Bull) |
| Forward | Dennis Espino (Sta. Lucia) |
| 2005-06 | Guard | Wynne Arboleda (Air21) |
| Guard | Topex Robinson (Red Bull) |
| Center | Dorian Peña (San Miguel) |
| Forward | Marc Pingris (Purefoods) |
| Forward | Nic Belasco (Alaska) |
| 2006-07 | Guard | Wynne Arboleda (Air21) |
| Guard | Gary David (Air21) |
| Center | Harvey Carey (Talk 'N Text) |
| Forward | Nelbert Omolon (Sta. Lucia) |
| Forward | Arwind Santos (Air21) |
| 2007-08 | Guard | Kelly Williams (Sta. Lucia) |
| Guard | Wynne Arboleda (Air21) |
| Center | Arwind Santos (Air21) |
| Forward | Marc Pingris (Magnolia) |
| Forward | Ryan Reyes (Sta. Lucia) |
| 2008-09 | Guard | Wynne Arboleda (Burger King) |
| Guard | Ronald Tubid (Brgy. Ginebra) |
| Center | Asi Taulava (Coca Cola) |
| Forward | Billy Mamaril (Brgy. Ginebra) |
| Forward | Arwind Santos (Burger King) |
| 2009-10 | Guard | Gabe Norwood (Rain or Shine) |
| Guard | Roger Yap (Purefoods/B-Meg Derby Ace) |
| Center | Arwind Santos (San Miguel) |
| Forward | Marc Pingris (Purefoods/B-Meg Derby Ace) |
| Forward | Ryan Reyes (Talk 'N Text) |
| 2010-11 | Guard | John Wilson (Barangay Ginebra) |
| Guard | Willy Wilson (Barangay Ginebra) |
| Center | Arwind Santos (Petron Blaze) |
| Forward | Marc Pingris (B-Meg) |
| Forward | Ryan Reyes (Talk 'N Text) |
| 2011-12 | Guard | Ryan Reyes (Talk 'N Text) |
| Guard | Jireh Ibañes (Rain or Shine) |
| Center | Arwind Santos (Petron Blaze) |
| Forward | Marc Pingris (B-Meg) |
| Forward | Doug Kramer (Barako Bull) |
| 2012-13 | Guard | Marcio Lassiter (Petron Blaze) |
| Guard | Gabe Norwood (Rain or Shine) |
| Center | Sonny Thoss (Alaska) |
| Forward | Arwind Santos (Petron Blaze) |
| Forward | Marc Pingris (San Mig Coffee) |
| 2013-14 | Guard | Mark Barroca (San Mig Super Coffee) |
| Guard | Gabe Norwood (Rain or Shine) |
| Center | Junmar Fajardo (San Miguel) |
| Forward | Jireh Ibañes (Rain or Shine) |
| Forward | Marc Pingris (San Mig Super Coffee) |