Matthias McDonnell Bodkin

Matthias McDonnell Bodkin^[1] (8 October 1850 – 7 June 1933) was an Irish nationalist politician and MP. in the House of Commons of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland and Anti-Parnellite representative for North Roscommon, 1892–95, a noted author, journalist and newspaper editor, and barrister, King's Counsel (K.C.) and County Court Judge for County Clare, 1907–24.

Early life

Bodkin was the second son of a doctor, Thomas Bodkin, MD FRCSI, of Tuam, Co. Galway (a descendant of Tribes of Galway). His mother was Maria McDonnell of Westport, Co. Mayo, a cousin of the distinguished Irish administrator Antony (Lord) MacDonnell (1844–1925). Bodkin was educated at the Christian Brothers' school, Tuam and at Tullabeg Jesuit College. He wanted to go to Trinity College, Dublin but his family objected on religious grounds and he attended the Catholic University College Dublin instead. He was scathing about this experience:

It is true I entered the so-called Catholic University, which had neither charter or endowment, and even obtained an exhibition on matriculation, but the business was so wholly futile that I abandoned it before six months was over, sacrificing my exhibition. A smattering of Terence was the only asset derived from that wasted six months.’ ^[2]

Bodkin was called to the Irish Law Bar in 1877 and entered practice as a barrister on the Connaught circuit. In 1885 he married Arabella, third daughter of Francis Norman of Dublin. They had several children including Matthias Bodkin junior (b. 1896), who became a Jesuit priest and in his turn a well-known author mainly of religious works, and Thomas Bodkin, who was the Director of the National Gallery of Ireland and the Barber Institute of Fine Arts. Two daughters became nuns.

Journalistic career

Bodkin's journalistic career began with reporting work for the Freeman's Journal while he was still a law student. He became politically active at the time of the Coercion Act of 1887, and defended a number of Irish Nationalists at political trials. He first came to political prominence at the time of the split in the Irish Parliamentary Party over the leadership of Charles Stewart Parnell, when Bodkin was a major protagonist on the Anti-Parnellite Irish National Federation side. As deputy to William O'Brien, editor of the newspaper United Ireland, he was in charge of the paper in O'Brien's absence in the USA at the time of the split in December 1890, and brought it firmly out against Parnell. He was ousted from the editor's office by force when Parnell and his supporters reclaimed the paper. He then published an alternative Suppressed United Ireland and then The Insuppressible, which appeared up to 24 January 1891. Thereafter Bodkin was a leader writer on the Insuppressible's Anti-Parnellite successor, the National Press.

Political career

At Timothy Healy's urging, Bodkin stood for Parliament against the veteran Parnellite J. J. O'Kelly at North Roscommon in 1892, winning by 3,251 votes to 3,199, a margin of only 52. He later wrote an account of the election campaign (and of his legal experiences) in his novel White Magic (1897). He stood down at the end of his first term in 1895, saying that he could not afford to continue losing earnings from the Bar: ‘my poverty, and not my will, refused’.^[3] O’Kelly regained the seat. Thereafter Bodkin was chief leader writer on the Freeman’s Journal. Jointly with Thomas Sexton he founded The Irish Packet in 1903.

Legal career

Bodkin's appointment as a County Court judge in 1907 was controversial among Nationalists who thought that offices should not be accepted from the British regime. The appointment was subjected to an unsuccessful legal challenge on the ground that Bodkin had retired from the Bar at the time; when asked in Parliament what had induced the (illiterate) complainant to lodge his affidavit against Bodkin, the then Chief Secretary for Ireland, Augustine Birrell, replied, apparently with complete truth: ‘A pint of porter’.^[4] Maume (1999, p. 92) says Bodkin had ‘dubious legal qualifications’, but there is no doubt that he had wide experience as a barrister and on his own account had defended some twenty people on capital charges.^[5]

While a judge in 1921, Bodkin published accounts of abuses by the Black and Tans in Co. Clare which received wide publicity and led to a House of Commons debate.

Writings

Bodkin was a prolific author, in a wide range of genres, including history, novels (contemporary and historical), plays, and political campaigning texts. The catalogues of the British Library and National Library of Ireland list some 39 publications between them. Some books were published under the pseudonym 'Crom a Boo'. Bodkin earned a place in the history of the detective novel by virtue of his invention of the first detective family. His character Paul Beck, a private detective with comfortable lodgings in Chester, was an Irish Sherlock Holmes with a very original yet logical method for detecting crime. Beck first appeared in Paul Beck, the rule of thumb detective in 1899. In the following year Bodkin's creation Dora Myrl, the lady detective, made her first appearance. In The Capture of Paul Beck (1909), Bodkin had them marry each other and in 1911 their son appeared, in Paul Beck, a chip off the old block. Other titles in this series were The Quests of Paul Beck (1908), Pigeon Blood Rubies (1915) and Paul Beck, detective (1929).

Bodkin's historical novel Lord Edward Fitzgerald (1896) was dedicated to William Gladstone with the latter's permission. It was one of three novels set at the time of the Irish Rebellion of 1798.

Bodkin's autobiography Recollections of an Irish Judge is a valuable historical source, particularly on the Parnellite split, although being published when he was only 64 it does not cover the last 20 years of his life. Its title is misleading since it contains little on Bodkin's life as a judge, but a great deal on his experiences in politics and journalism.

Footnotes

Selected publications

• “The Devil's Work" on the Clanricarde Estate, London, Irish Press Agency, 1890
• Poteen Punch (Irish after-dinner stories, some reprinted from United Ireland), Dublin, M. H. Gill & Son, 1890
• Lord Edward Fitzgerald, An historical romance, Dublin, Talbot Press, 1896
• White Magic: a novel, London, Chapman & Hall, 1897
• Grattan’s Parliament, before and after, London, T. F. Unwin, 1912
• Recollections of an Irish Judge: Press, Bar and Parliament, London, Hurst & Blackett, 1914
• Ulster’s Opportunity: a united Ireland, by an Irish K.C., Dublin, Duffy, 1917
• Famous Irish Trials, Dublin & London, Maunsel, 1918
• When Youth Meets Youth, Dublin, Talbot Press; London, T. Fisher Unwin, 1920
• A Judicial Report on the devastation of County Clare, Dublin, Talbot Press, 1921
• Guilty or Not Guilty?, Dublin, Talbot Press, 1929

Sources

• Irish Independent, 8 June 1933
• F. S. L. Lyons, The Fall of Parnell 1890–91, London, Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1960
• Patrick Maume, The Long Gestation: Irish Nationalist Life 1891–1918, Dublin, Gill & MacMillan, 1999
• Brian M. Walker (ed.), Parliamentary Election Results in Ireland, 1801–1922, Dublin, Royal Irish Academy, 1978
• Who Was Who, 1929–1940

External links

• Catalogue of the Bodkin papers, National Archives of Ireland
• Works by or about Matthias McDonnell Bodkin in libraries (WorldCat catalog)
• Full text and facsimile of Lord Edward Fitzgerald
• Full text and facsimile of Grattan’s Parliament, before and after
• Full text and facsimile of Recollections of an Irish Judge
• Full text and facsimile of Famous Irish Trials
• Full text of "The Capture of Paul Beck" at manybooks.net