Logarithmic mean temperature difference

The logarithmic mean temperature difference (also known as log mean temperature difference or simply by its initialism LMTD) is used to determine the temperature driving force for heat transfer in flow systems, most notably in heat exchangers. The LMTD is a logarithmic average of the temperature difference between the hot and cold feeds at each end of the double pipe exchanger. The larger the LMTD, the more heat is transferred. The use of the LMTD arises straightforwardly from the analysis of a heat exchanger with constant flow rate and fluid thermal properties.

Definition

We assume that a generic heat exchanger has two ends (which we call "A" and "B") at which the hot and cold streams enter or exit on either side; then, the LMTD is defined by the logarithmic mean as follows:

LMTD =\frac{\Delta T_A - \Delta T_B}{\ln \left( \frac{\Delta T_A}{\Delta T_B} \right ) } =\frac{\Delta T_A - \Delta T_B}{\ln \Delta T_A - \ln \Delta T_B}

where ΔT_A is the temperature difference between the two streams at end A, and ΔT_B is the temperature difference between the two streams at end B. With this definition, the LMTD can be used to find the exchanged heat in a heat exchanger:

Q = U \times Ar \times LMTD

Where Q is the exchanged heat duty (in watts), U is the heat transfer coefficient (in watts per kelvin per square meter) and Ar is the exchange area. Note that estimating the heat transfer coefficient may be quite complicated.

This holds both for cocurrent flow, where the streams enter from the same end, and for counter-current flow, where they enter from different ends.

In a cross-flow, in which one system, usually the heat sink, has the same nominal temperature at all points on the heat transfer surface, a similar relation between exchanged heat and LMTD holds, but with a correction factor. A correction factor is also required for other more complex geometries, such as a shell and tube exchanger with baffles.

Derivation

Assume heat transfer is occurring in a heat exchanger along an axis z, from generic coordinate A to B, between two fluids, identified as 1 and 2, whose temperatures along z are T₁(z) and T₂(z).

The local exchanged heat flux at z is proportional to the temperature difference:

q(z) = U (T_2(z)-T_1(z))/D = U (\Delta\;T(z))/D,

where D is the distance between the two fluids.

The heat that leaves the fluids causes a temperature gradient according to Fourier's law:

\frac{\mathrm{d}\,T_1}{\mathrm{d}\,z}=k_a (T_1(z)-T_2(z))=-k_a\,\Delta T(z)

\frac{\mathrm{d}\,T_2}{\mathrm{d}\,z}=k_b (T_2(z)-T_1(z))=k_b\,\Delta T(z)

Summed together, this becomes

\frac{\mathrm{d}\,\Delta T}{\mathrm{d}\,z}=\frac{\mathrm{d}\,(T_2-T_1)}{\mathrm{d}\,z}=\frac{\mathrm{d}\,T_2}{\mathrm{d}\,z}-\frac{\mathrm{d}\,T_1}{\mathrm{d}\,z}=K\Delta T(z)

where K=k_a+k_b.

The total exchanged energy is found by integrating the local heat transfer q from A to B:

Q = \int^{B}_{A} q(z) dz = \frac{U}{D} \int^{B}_{A} \Delta T(z) dz = \frac{U}{D} \int^{B}_{A} \Delta T \,dz

Use the fact that the heat exchanger area Ar is the pipe length A-B multiplied by the interpipe distance D:

Q = \frac{U Ar}{(B-A)} \int^{B}_{A} \Delta T \,dz = \frac{U Ar \int^{B}_{A} \Delta T \,dz}{\int^{B}_{A} \,dz}

In both integrals, make a change of variables from z to Δ T:

Q = \frac{U Ar \int^{\Delta T(B)}_{\Delta T(A)} \Delta T \frac{\mathrm{d}\,z}{\mathrm{d}\,\Delta T}\,d(\Delta T)}{\int^{\Delta T(B)}_{\Delta T(A)} \frac{\mathrm{d}\,z}{\mathrm{d}\,\Delta T}\,d(\Delta T)}

With the relation for Δ T found above, this becomes

Q = \frac{U Ar \int^{\Delta T(B)}_{\Delta T(A)} \frac{1}{K}\,d(\Delta T)}{\int^{\Delta T(B)}_{\Delta T(A)} \frac{1}{K \Delta T}\,d(\Delta T)}

Integration is at this point trivial, and finally gives:

Q = U \times Ar \times \frac{\Delta T(B)-\Delta T(A)}{\ln [ \Delta T(B) / \Delta T(A) ]}

from which the definition of LMTD follows.

Assumptions and Limitations

It has been assumed that the rate of change for the temperature of both fluids is proportional to the temperature difference; this assumption is valid for fluids with a constant specific heat, which is a good description of fluids changing temperature over a relatively small range. However, if the specific heat changes, the LMTD approach will no longer be accurate.

A particular case where the LMTD is not applicable are condensers and reboilers, where the latent heat associated to phase change makes the hypothesis invalid.

It has also been assumed that the heat transfer coefficient (U) is constant, and not a function of temperature. If this is not the case, the LMTD approach will again be less valid

The LMTD is a steady-state concept, and cannot be used in dynamic analyses. In particular, if the LMTD were to be applied on a transient in which, for a brief time, the temperature differential had different signs on the two sides of the exchanger, the argument to the logarithm function would be negative, which is not allowable.

References

Kay J M & Nedderman R M (1985) Fluid Mechanics and Transfer Processes, Cambridge University Press