Live'r Than You'll Ever Be

For The Kleptones album, see Live'r Than You'll Ever Be – Bestival 2007.
Live'r Than You'll Ever Be

A white cover with a blue stamp reading "LIVE / R THAN / YOU'LL / EVER BE" with the word "LIVE" being as tall as the other three lines of text to its right.

The original cover to the album from TMOQ
Live album (bootleg) by The Rolling Stones
Released December 1969
Recorded 9 November 1969, Oakland County Coliseum, Oakland, California, United States
Genre Rock
Length 48:36
Language English
Label Trademark of Quality
2001 Tarantura Records Compact Disc release
A pair of blue jeans are mocked up with the Rolling Stones lips logo on the pocket and the tag "Liver" made to resemble the Levi's jeans logo. On the jeans are stamped "ORIGINAL MASTER BOOTLEG / THE ROLLING STONES / XX / LIVE'R THAN YOU'LL EVER BE".
This double-Compact Disc has become the standard release of this bootleg

Live'r Than You'll Ever Be is a bootleg recording of the Rolling Stones' concert in Oakland, California, from 9 November 1969. It was one of the first live rock music bootlegs and was made notorious as a document of their 1969 tour of the United States. The popularity of the bootleg forced the Stones' label Decca Records to release the live album Get Yer Ya-Yas Out! The Rolling Stones in Concert in 1970.[1] Live'r is also one of the earliest commercial bootleg recordings in rock history, released in December 1969, just two months after the Beatles' Kum Back and five months after Bob Dylan's Great White Wonder. Like the two earlier records, Live'r's outer sleeve is plain white, with its name stamped on in black ink.

Recording and release

A photograph of the outfield at a baseball game shot from the upper deck
The Oakland County Coliseum was built three years prior to the recordings featured on Live'r Than You'll Ever Be and has continued to host baseball games, concerts, and other large outdoor events since
Mick Taylor playing electric guitar onstage in a blue shirt and yellow pants
Mick Taylor had joined the Rolling Stones only four months prior to these concerts at the age of 20

Live'r Than You'll Ever Be was recorded by "Dub" Taylor from Trademark of Quality using a Sennheiser shotgun microphone and a Uher "Report 4000" reel-to-reel tape recorder.[2] It was the first audience-recorded rock bootleg to be mastered and distributed;[3] some sources consider it the first live bootleg.[4] Though the sound is not nearly as clear as the official release of Get Yer Ya-Ya's Out!, the recording is considered to be very strong for an audience recording, especially one of that era.[2] The Rolling Stones performed two sets that night and it is the second concert that was more heavily bootlegged and has sharper sound. Bootleggers had collaborated to record Stones shows across the United States, recording them on two-track Sony recorders for months prior to the release of the album.[5] At least one source claims that the recordings initially came from rock promoter Bill Graham's staff, who used the tapes for broadcast on KSAN and released their edit on Lurch Records in early 1970.[6]

The recording was made available about one month after the concert, and it became popular enough to spur speculation that the Stones released Ya-Ya's as a response to the bootleg[7] and the quality was high enough that it was rumoured that the band had even released the bootleg themselves.[8] The recording has been released through several bootleg labels, including the original release by Trademark of Quality (catalogue number 71002), Swingin' Pig, and Sister Morphine, usually documenting only the second set.[7] The Swingin' Pig release even replace performances of "Jumpin' Jack Flash" and "Under My Thumb" with different recordings from the band's 10 November performance in San Diego and their two-night stint in New York City[9] and attempted to enhance the sound quality by using de-clicking technology—both changes have drawn criticism in comparison to the original TMOQ release.[10]

Reception and influence

Marcus standing behind a podium
A review of the bootleg by Greil Marcus of Rolling Stone helped to promote and legitimise the bootleg
A golden vinyl LP
Live'r Than You'll Ever Be is a rare example of a golden record sales award granted to a bootleg

Live'r Than You'll Ever Be was reviewed by Greil Marcus in the 7 February 1970, issue of Rolling Stone. In his review, Marcus praises the sound of the album and speculates that it may have been recorded from the stage; footage from this concert was recorded by ABKCO Records for the film Gimme Shelter. The album also received praise as a more authentic example of the Stones on stage[11] because Get Yer Ya-Ya's Out! was heavily overdubbed[8] in many places. Richie Unterberger has noted that the recording is inferior to the sound quality of Ya-Ya's, but displays a spontaneity that the official recording lacks and this helps to explain its long-lasting appeal to fans.[12] Reviewing the album in 1970, Wim Wenders called it "the best Rolling Stones record."[13] The album would eventually sell enough copies to qualify for a gold record RIAA certification,[8] with TMOQ sources claiming that it had sold 250,000 copies by November 1970—150,000 of which were produced by other bootleggers.[5] Although the album did not chart on the Billboard 200, the magazine did include it in a list of best-selling bootlegs in 1971, noting that hard sales figures were impossible to confirm, but six-figure sales had been routinely discussed.[14] The sleeve's generic design was later copied by The Who's 1970 album Live at Leeds.[15]

Track listing

A black-and-white photo of Berry holding a guitar, seated
The Stones' set for this concert included covers of two Chuck Berry songs

All songs written by Jagger/Richards, except where noted

Side one
  1. "Carol" (Chuck Berry) – 3:44
  2. "Gimme Shelter" – 4:18
  3. "Sympathy for the Devil" – 6:23
  4. "I'm Free" – 5:07
  5. "Live with Me" – 3:33
Side two
  1. "Love in Vain" (Robert Johnson) – 5:24
  2. "Midnight Rambler" – 7:40
  3. "Little Queenie" (Berry) – 4:13
  4. "Honky Tonk Women" – 4:04
  5. "Street Fighting Man" – 4:10
Different versions of the bootleg include different track listings. The Tarantura Records release includes both concerts performed on this date in their entirety and is represented here:
Disc 1 – Early Show
  1. Band introduction – 1:36
  2. "Jumpin' Jack Flash" – 4:51
  3. "Prodigal Son" (Robert Wilkins) – 4:03
  4. "You Gotta Move" (Fred McDowell and Reverend Gary Davis) – 3:18
  5. "Carol" (Berry) – 3:33
  6. "Sympathy for the Devil" – 6:55
  7. "Stray Cat Blues" – 4:18
  8. "Love in Vain" (Johnson) – 5:13
  9. "I'm Free" – 5:08
  10. "Under My Thumb" – 3:15
  11. "Midnight Rambler" – 8:17
  12. "Live with Me" – 4:00
  13. "Little Queenie" (Berry) – 3:56
  14. "(I Can't Get No) Satisfaction" – 6:56
  15. "Honky Tonk Women" – 4:17
  16. "Street Fighting Man" – 4:03
Disc 2 – Late Show
  1. "Jumpin' Jack Flash" – 4:05
  2. "Carol" (Berry) – 3:44
  3. "Sympathy for the Devil" – 6:23
  4. "Stray Cat Blues" – 4:13
  5. "Prodigal Son" (Wilkins) – 3:59
  6. "You Gotta Move" (McDowell and Davis) – 3:12
  7. "Love in Vain" (Johnson) – 5:24
  8. "I'm Free" – 5:07
  9. "Under My Thumb" – 3:23
  10. "Midnight Rambler" – 7:40
  11. "Live with Me" – 3:33
  12. "Gimme Shelter" – 4:18
  13. "Little Queenie" (Berry) – 4:13
  14. "(I Can't Get No) Satisfaction" – 6:04
  15. "Honky Tonk Women" – 4:04
  16. "Street Fighting Man" – 4:10

Personnel

The Rolling Stones
Additional musicians

References

  1. ↑ Thompson, Dave (1 September 2002), The Music Lover's Guide to Record Collecting (Paperback) (illustrated ed.), Backbeat Books, p. 32, ISBN 0-87930-713-7
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 Heylin, Clinton (1996), Bootleg: The Secret History of the Other Recording Industry (Paperback) (1st ed.), New York City, New York, United States: St. Martin's Griffin, p. 46, ISBN 0-312-14289-7
  3. ↑ Parker, Scott (11 February 2010), Strictly Genteel: The Recordings of Frank Zappa Volume Two 1970–1971 (Volume 2) (Paperback) (1st ed.), CreateSpace, p. 138, ISBN 1-4505-7339-8
  4. ↑ Marshall, Lee (10 August 2005), Bootlegging: Romanticism and Copyright in the Music Industry (Hardcover) (1st ed.), Sage Publications Ltd, p. 115, ISBN 0-7619-4490-7
  5. ↑ 5.0 5.1 Yorke, Ritchie (14 November 1970), "Maple Leaf Rock", Billboard (Nielsen Business Media, Inc.) 82 (46): R–18, ISSN 0006-2510 |chapter= ignored (help)
  6. ↑ Davis, Stephen (1 November 2001), Old Gods Almost Dead: The 40-Year Odyssey of the Rolling Stones (1st ed.), Random House Digital, Inc., p. 310
  7. ↑ 7.0 7.1 Liner notes to the 2001 Tarantura Records release
  8. ↑ 8.0 8.1 8.2 Clayson, Adam (August 2004), Keith Richards (Paperback) (1st ed.), Sanctuary Publishing, Ltd., p. 111, ISBN 1-86074-590-3
  9. ↑ Bob, Walker (1 October 1997), Hot WACKS Book: Supplement 5 (Paperback) (1st ed.), Collector's Guide Publishing Inc, p. 16, ISBN 0-9698080-8-9
  10. ↑ Heylin, Clinton (15 June 1996), Bootleg: The Secret History of the Other Recording Industry, Macmillan Publishers, p. 288
  11. ↑ Heylin, Clinton (1996), Bootleg: The Secret History of the Other Recording Industry (Paperback) (1st ed.), New York City, New York, United States: St. Martin's Griffin, p. 9, ISBN 0-312-14289-7
  12. ↑ terberger. "Live'r Than You'll Ever Be > Overview". Allmusic. Retrieved 15 September 2010.
  13. ↑ Wenders, Wim (12 December 2001), Wim Wenders: On Film: Essays and Conversations, Faber & Faber, p. 57, ISBN 0-571-20718-9
  14. ↑ "Bootleggers' Top Sellers or—The 'Secret Hit' LPs", Billboard (Nielsen Business Media, Inc.) 83 (45), 6 November 1971: R–49, ISSN 0006-2510
  15. ↑ Neill, Andrew; Kent, Matthew (2 June 2009), Anyway, Anyhow, Anywhere: The Complete Chronicle of the Who 1958–1978, Sterling Publishing Company, Inc., p. 181

External links