- Johannes Bapst (1863–1869)
- Robert W. Brady (1869–1870)
- Robert Fulton (1870–1880)
- Jeremiah O'Connor (1880–1884)
- Edward V. Boursaud (1884–1887)
- Thomas H. Stack (1887)
- Nicholas Russo (1887–1888)
- Robert Fulton (1888–1891)
- Edward I. Devitt (1891–1894)
- Timothy Brosnahan (1894–1898)
- W. G. Read Mullan (1898–1903)
- William F. Gannon (1903–1907)
- Thomas I. Gasson (1907–1914)
- Charles W. Lyons (1914–1919)
- William Devlin Devlin (1919–1925)
- James H. Dolan (1925–1932)
- William J. McGarry (1937–1939)
- William J. Murphy (1939–1945)
- William L. Keleher (1945–1951)
- Joseph R. N. Maxwell (1951–1958)
- Michael P. Walsh (1958–1968)
- W. Seavey Joyce (1968–1972)
- J. Donald Monan Monan (1972–1996)
- William P. Leahy (1996–present)
|