Kugyō (Minamoto no Yoshinari)

The scene of the murder. Visible the shrine, the stairs and the giant ginkgo

Kugyō (公暁, 1200–February 13, 1219), also known as Minamoto no Zensai (源善哉) or Saemon Hokkyō Yoriaki (左衛門法橋頼暁), was the second son of the second Kamakura shogun of Japan, Minamoto no Yoriie.[1] At the age of six, after his father was killed in Shuzenji in Izu, he became his uncle Sanetomo's adopted son and, thanks to his grandmother Hōjō Masako's intercession, a disciple of Songyō, Tsurugaoka Hachiman-gū's bettō (head priest).[1] After his tonsure he was given the Buddhist name "Kugyō" replacing his childhood name Yoshinari.[1][2] He then went to Kyōto to take his vows, coming back at age 18 to become Tsurugaoka Hachiman-gū's new bettō,[1] the shrine's fourth.[3] In 1219 he murdered his uncle Sanetomo on the stone stairs at Tsurugaoka Hachiman-gū in the shogunal capital of Kamakura, an act for which he was himself slain on the same day.[4]

Shogun Sanetomo's assassination

Assassination

The assassination is chronicled in the Azuma Kagami[5][6] and in the Gukanshō. What follows is the Azuma Kagami's version of events.

At about six in the evening of February 12, 1219 (Jōkyū 1, 26th day of the 1st month),[7] on Buddhist New Year, shogun Sanetomo had just finished the Ceremony of Celebration for his nomination to Udaijin.[4] It had been snowing the whole day and there were more than 60 cm of snow on the ground.[8] The shogun left the shrine's gate and started descending the stone stairs accompanied only by the sword bearer, a man called Nakaakira.[4] Hōjō Yoshitoki, son of Regent Hōjō Tokimasa and a future Regent himself, should have been the sword-bearer, but had gone back to his mansion in Komachi early because he wasn't feeling well.[8] Unexpectedly Kugyō the bettō came up from near the stone stairs, yelled "I strike my father's enemy!" (父の敵を討つ) and struck him with a sword, cutting his head off.[8] The assassin then killed Nakaakira the swordbearer, and according to the Gukanshō he did this thinking he was Hōjō Yoshitoki, as he should have been.[1][8]

Sources do not always agree. Kugyō is for example described as wearing either a woman's clothes (in the Azuma Kagami) or his betto's uniform.[4] It is often said that he was hiding behind the great ginkgo tree, but the Azuma Kagami simply says he came "from the side of the stone stairs" (石段の際).[8] The detail of the ginkgo first appears in the Shinpen Kamakurashi and is therefore an Edo period invention.[9]

Kugyō's death

Having killed his uncle, Kugyō took his head, left the shrine and, without going back to his official residence, went to hide temporarily at the home of its guardian in Yukinoshita.[3] From there he sent a messenger to Miura Yoshimura's home in Nishi Mikado, explaining that he was now the new shogun and wanted to talk to him as soon as possible about what was to be done.[8] Yoshimura and his family had an extremely close relationship with Kugyō, whose milk-mother had been a Miura.[8] To buy time, Yoshimura sent back a message in which he asked Kugyō to stay where he was because he would send some soldiers to pick him up.[8] While Kugyō waited, knowing Yoshitoki was alive Yoshimura sent a messenger to Yoshitoki's residence in Komachi.[8] Yoshitoki immediately sent back the order to execute the assassin.[8] Yoshimura gathered the family council to decide how to do that.[8] Nagao Sadakage, a samurai known for his strength and reliability, was then entrusted with the task.[8] Left with a group of five men, on the way Sadakage met Kugyō himself who, unable to contain himself and wait for Yoshimura's escort, had left his refuge and was already in Nishi Mikado on his way to Yoshimura's mansion.[8] While one of the five men engaged him, Nagao Sadakage beheaded him.[8] His head was then brought to the Regent's residence in Komachi for identification.[8]

Debate about Kugyōs motives

According to the traditional interpretation of events, Kugyō's act had been instigated by Yoshitoki and the Hōjō, who wanted to get rid at one stroke of the last two male members of the Seiwa Genji line.[1][8] Historians however now see the theory as unsupported by facts and probably untrue.[1][8] Beyond the fact that the assassination undoubtedly ended up serving Yoshitoki's interests, it's unclear why Kugyō would have willingly helped the Hōjō family, who was responsible not only for his father's death, but also for that of his brother Ichiman and of the entire Hiki clan.[4] The killing of Nakaakira the sword-bearer makes it likely that Kugyō meant to kill Yoshitoki too.[1][4] His relationship with Yoshimura was extremely close (Yoshimura's wife had been Kugyō's wet nurse), and it seems more plausible that the two had planned together the assassination of both Sanetomo and Yoshitoki to get rid of the Hōjō and of their puppet Sanetomo to assume power.[1][4][8] Sanetomo's wet nurse had been Masako's younger sister, making the shogun emotionally close to the Hōjō, and this failed coup d'état was probably just an episode in the ongoing war between Hōjō and Miura, which continued until the Miura's defeat in 1247.[8] Realized that Yoshitoki had avoided death out of sheer luck and that their plan was doomed, Yoshimura could very well have decided that he had to betray Kugyō to save himself and his family.[1][8]

Notes

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 1.9 Yasuda (1990-156)
  2. ↑ At the time in Japan a child received a temporary name (osanana, yōmei or yōmyō (幼名)), which would be replaced by a definitive one at 15 or 17.
  3. ↑ 3.0 3.1 Kamiya Vol. 1 (2006:22)
  4. ↑ 4.0 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6 Kusumoto (2002: 70-73)
  5. ↑ 吾妻鏡本文データ (Azuma Kagami Honbun Data), retrieved on October 1, 2008.
  6. ↑ 吾妻鏡建保７年１月 (Azuma Kagami Kempō 7 First Month), retrieved on October 1, 2008.
  7. ↑ Gregorian date obtained directly from the original Nengō using Nengocalc
  8. ↑ 8.0 8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4 8.5 8.6 8.7 8.8 8.9 8.10 8.11 8.12 8.13 8.14 8.15 8.16 8.17 8.18 8.19 Kamiya Vol. 1 (2006:116-117)
  9. ↑ Kamakura Shōkō Kaigijo (2008:152)

References