James Grierson

Sir James Grierson

Grierson as a Colonel
Born 27 January 1859
Died 17 August 1914 (aged 55)
Allegiance United Kingdom United Kingdom
Service/branch British Army
Rank Lieutenant General
Unit Anglo-Egyptian War
Boxer Rebellion
Second Boer War
World War I
Commands held 1st Division
Eastern Command
Awards Knight Commander of the Order of the Bath
Companion of the Order of St Michael and St George
Commander of the Royal Victorian Order

Lieutenant General Sir James Moncrieff Grierson KCB CMG CVO ADC(P) (27 January 1859 – 17 August 1914) was a British soldier.

Military career

Grierson was commissioned into the Royal Artillery in 1877.[1]

He served in the Egyptian War including the actions at Kassassin and Tel el Kebir, as Deputy Assistant Quartermaster General with the Indian contingent in 1882.[1] He was Deputy Assistant Adjutant and Quartermaster General for the Sudan expedition and was involved in actions at Suakin, Hasheen and Tamai in 1885.[1] He was Deputy Assistant Quartermaster General for 2nd Brigade during the Hazara expedition in 1888.[1] He was appointed Deputy Assistant Adjutant General, Intelligence, at Army Headquarters in 1890 and then became Brigade Major for the Royal Artillery at Aldershot from 1895 to 1896 when he became Military Attaché in Berlin[1] acquiring what Sir John French later described as "an intimate knowledge of the German army."[2]

He served in China during the Boxer Rebellion in 1900, and later the same year in the Second Boer War in South Africa. Lt-Col Grierson was in charge of army baggage during Roberts’ march on Bloemfontein.[3]

After returning from the war he became Assistant Quartermaster General for the 2nd Army Corps and Chief Staff Officer to Sir Evelyn Wood, commanding the corps;[4] and was promoted to the substantive rank of Colonel in October 1901.[5] In early 1902 he was ordered for temporary duty in the Remount Department.[6]

Grierson was appointed Director of Military Operations at Army Headquarters in 1904.[1] In January 1906, during the First Moroccan Crisis, Grierson (DMO) was tasked with drawing up detailed plans for deployment of an expeditionary force to Le Havre in the event of war. [7] He and his deputy Robertson organised a “strategic war game” to explore the options, which persuaded them that British intervention was necessary to avoid French defeat. They began talks with the French General Staff and with the French military attaché Colonel Victor Huguet, and that same year Grierson, Robertson and Huguet toured the Charleroi to Namur area. However, little further progress was made until after Wilson became DMO in 1910.[8][9]

Grierson was then appointed General Officer Commanding, 1st Division at Aldershot Command in 1906 and General Officer Commanding-in-Chief for Eastern Command in 1912.[1]

In the Army Manoeuvres of 1912, he made full use of aircraft reconnaissance to decisively beat Douglas Haig, despite Haig having the odds in his favour.

In the Army Manoeuvres of 1913, Grierson acted as Chief of the General Staff (CGS) for Sir John French. Douglas Haig noted in his diary, "Sir John French's instructions for moving along the front of his enemy (then halted on a fortified position) and subsequently attacking the latter's distant flank, were of such an unpractical nature that his Chief of the General Staff demurred. Some slight modifications in the orders were permitted, but Grierson ceased to be his CGS on mobilization, and was very soon transferred to another appointment in the BEF."[10] Even before leaving the field of the manoeuvres (26 September 1913), French told Wilson that he was not satisfied with Grierson’s performance. Murray was appointed chief of staff designate in his place.[11] French himself described Grierson as a "dear old friend and comrade", ..who astonished French soldiers by his knowledge of the history of their regiments and whose "military acquirements were brilliant and in every respect up to date."[2]

Grierson was very overweight, and used to go red in the face from bending over, due to high blood pressure, and Edmonds later claimed that his staff were issued with penknives to bleed him if necessary.[12] He died of an aneurism of the heart on a train, near Amiens at 7:00 a.m. on 17 August 1914. His replacement as commander of II Corps was Sir Horace Smith-Dorrien. Grierson spoke French fluently and was a personal friend of Haig, the commander of I Corps, so it is possible that relations over the next few days, both between the two British corps and with the French, might have been better had he lived.[13]

Grierson's body was repatriated, a practice allowed at that time, and is buried in the Glasgow Necropolis in PRIMUS 38 with his sister, father and mother. These were full interments.[14]

The Sir James Moncrieff Grierson prize for languages was later established at the Royal Military Academy Sandhurst.

Medals and Orders

Grierson at Rheims in 1909 (shown in the centre with hands behind back)

British decorations

Foreign decorations

Publications by Grierson

Family tree

Below is a family history of Sir James Moncrieff Grierson:

George Lyon of Garemount, Dumbartonshire, born 25 August 1793; died 21 February 1872; married at Falkland, 14 June 1825, Jane, daughter of Harry HOPE of Millfield, Fife, and had 9 children:

(issue 3) ALLISON LYON, born 12 February 1829; married, 31 March 1858, GEORGE MONCRIEFF GRIERSON, (Merchant), Glasgow, 2nd son of the (Reverend) JAMES GRIERSON, Doctor of Divinity, (Minister) of Errol, & his wife, MARGARET MONCRIEFF. George died 4 February 1896; issue (3) three sons and six daughters:

  1. (Lieutenant-General) James Moncrieff Grierson, born 27 January 1859; a large, polished-brass plaque is located in the Glasgow Cathedral, dedicated to his memory,
  2. (Captain) George Lyon Walker Grierson, of Royal Horse Artillery, born 6 February 1861; educated at Glasgow Academy and Woolwich; entered the Royal Artillery in 1880, served in the Afghanistan War of that year (medal) and in the Bikanir expedition; went to India in 1891 and died of cholera at Lucknow, India, 19 October 1892; a polished-brass plaque is located in the Glasgow Cathedral, dedicated to his memory,
  3. Jane Hope Grierson, born 2 February 1863
  4. Margaret Moncrieff Grierson, born 14 March 1865
  5. ALLISON Mary Grierson, born 23 January 1867; married, 28 April 1897, THOMAS HARVEY, and has issue a son, THOMAS BARNETT HARVEY, born 11 September 1899
  6. David Alexander Grierson, born 13 December 1869; died 9 January 1870
  7. Mary Hope Walker Grierson, born 14 June 1871; married 12 June 1895, JOHN TRAIL CARGILL, and has issue a daughter, ALLISON HOPE CARGILL, born 13 August 1896
  8. Jessie Moncrieff Grierson, born 13 April 1873; died 3 June 1877
  9. Robina Constance Grierson, born 31 July 1874.[17][18]

Further reading

The Life of Sir James Moncrieff Grierson by D.S. Macdiarmid (London: Constable, 1923)

References

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 Liddell Hart Centre for Military Archives
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 Sir John French (1919). 1914. London: Constable & Co. p. 37.
  3. ↑ Holmes 2004, p99
  4. ↑ "Naval & Military intelligence" The Times (London). Monday, 23 December 1901. (36645), p. 8.
  5. ↑ The London Gazette: no. 27387. p. 8840. 13 December 1901.
  6. ↑ "Naval & Military intelligence" The Times (London). Friday, 28 February 1902. (36703), p. 5.
  7. ↑ Holmes 2004, p139-41
  8. ↑ Jeffery 2006, p85-6
  9. ↑ Tuchman 1962, p55-6
  10. ↑ Warner, Philip Field-Marshal Earl Haig (London: Bodley Head, 1991; Cassell, 2001) pp110–111
  11. ↑ Holmes 2004, p149-50
  12. ↑ Travers 1987, p14
  13. ↑ Terraine 1960, p50-1
  14. ↑ CWGC record
  15. ↑ The London Gazette: no. 27385. p. 8715. 10 December 1901.
  16. ↑ The London Gazette: no. 27393. p. 1. 3 January 1902.
  17. ↑ David Alan Grierson (aka Lyon) RootsWeb: GRIERSON-L Compilations on Lyon, Walker,Grierson families of Scotland
  18. ↑ RootsWeb: GRIERSON-L David Alan Grierson (aka Lyon), & others

External links

Wikisource has original works written by or about:
James Moncrieff Grierson
Military offices
Preceded by
Arthur Paget		 General Officer Commanding the 1st Division
1906 – 1910 		Succeeded by
Samuel Lomax
Preceded by
Sir Arthur Paget		 GOC-in-C Eastern Command
1912–1914 		Succeeded by
Sir Charles Woollcombe
Preceded by
New Post		 GOC II Corps
August 1914 		Succeeded by
Horace Smith-Dorrien