Greater Sudbury municipal election, 2014

The 2014 Greater Sudbury municipal election was held on October 27, 2014 to elect a mayor and 12 city councillors in Greater Sudbury, Ontario. In addition, school trustees were elected to the Rainbow District School Board, Sudbury Catholic District School Board, Conseil scolaire de district du Grand Nord de l'Ontario and Conseil scolaire de district catholique du Nouvel-Ontario.

The election was held in conjunction with those held in other municipalities in the province of Ontario. For other elections, see Ontario municipal elections, 2014.

Candidate registration opened on January 2, 2014. The last day for candidate registration was September 12, 2014; although the offices of mayor and all twelve city council seats saw contested elections, some candidates for election to the school boards were declared acclaimed to office on that date as no opposing candidates registered by the deadline.

For the first time in the city's history, the 2014 election included an online voting option as part of efforts to increase voter turnout.[1]

Issues

The predominant election issue was the functioning of Greater Sudbury City Council in the 2010-14 term. Under mayor Marianne Matichuk, who was widely criticized as lacking the leadership skills necessary to build a working coalition of support for her agenda,[2] the council's work frequently bogged down in a state of political gridlock.[3]

In addition, the council faced extensive criticism for its 2013 decision to refuse oversight from the Ontario Ombudsman's office,[4] as well as the management of community development funds, disbursed by city councillors, which have been widely criticized as having the potential to be misused as political slush funds.[5]

In conjunction with the election, a municipal referendum was held on the issue of deregulating retail store hours in Greater Sudbury, which is one of the few cities in Ontario where retail stores are still not permitted to open on Boxing Day.[6] Matichuk had pledged to deregulate store hours in the 2010 election, although her motion to do so failed when she presented it to council on February 9, 2011;[7] the referendum was approved by council in September 2012.[6]

A poll conducted by Oraclepoll Research for the city's Northern Life newspaper found that despite the transparency and government effectiveness issues that had dominated the municipal political scene over the previous term, basic pocketbook issues such as road maintenance and property taxes were most commonly identified by voters as their main priorities in the election, with integrity and ethics ranking as the top priority for only a small minority of voters.[8]

Mayoral race

In the early months of the campaign, Matichuk's silence about her reelection plans gave rise to media speculation that Premier Kathleen Wynne planned to appoint Matichuk as the Ontario Liberal Party's candidate in the provincial electoral district of Sudbury for the 2014 provincial election. Both Wynne and Matichuk denied the reports;[9][10] however, the speculation failed to die down because of Matichuk's continued lack of clarity about her plans, and the local Liberal riding association's inability to get a firm date commitment for its nomination meeting from the party's head office.[11] The party finally nominated Andrew Olivier as its candidate on May 8.[12] In addition, virtually all of the major figures from Matichuk's 2010 campaign team publicly declared that they would not participate in a 2014 campaign on her behalf.[13]

Matichuk announced on June 19 that she will not run for a second term as mayor.[14] Despite the controversies that marred her first term in office, however, Oraclepoll Research's first poll of the race, released on June 24, 2014, suggested that she still held a healthy lead over any of the declared candidates among decided voters, with 38.1 per cent support.[15]

Former mayor John Rodriguez, who was defeated by Matichuk in the 2010 election, registered as a candidate for mayor on May 9.[16] The other declared candidates were Jean-Raymond Audet; Jeanne Brohart; Brian Bigger, who took leave from his job as the city's auditor to mount his campaign; Ron Dupuis, the incumbent city councillor for Ward 5 (Valley East);[17] Jeff Huska, a biomedical engineering technologist at Health Sciences North;[18] Richard Majkot, a retired former staffer at Toronto City Hall;[19] Dan Melanson, the former president of a local taxpayers' lobby association who was himself an advisor to Matichuk's campaign in 2010;[20] and Ed Pokonzie and David Popescu, both perennial candidates in the Sudbury area.[21]

Opinion polls

Percentages of decided vote.

Polling firm Last date of polling Bigger Dupuis Huska Melanson Rodriguez Others Don't know/
Wouldn't vote		 Poll commissioned by Reference
Oraclepoll Research October 22, 2014 31 16 5 23 21 4 34.1 Northern Life [22]
Oraclepoll Research October 16, 2014 34.9 15.1 4.7 24.7 19.8 3.8 38.7 Northern Life [23]
PrimeContact October 10, 2014 44.7 7.1 7.1 15.3 17.6 8.2 15 Prime Contact [24]
Oraclepoll Research September 26, 2014 33.2 9.6 6.4 23.7 22.3 4.8 25 Northern Life [25]
September 19, 2014 31.1 13 6.4 22.5 26.5 0.5 30.4 CJTK-FM [26]

Election results

Candidate Votes %
Brian Bigger 27,303 46.32
Dan Melanson 11,345 19.25
John Rodriguez 10,243 17.38
Ron Dupuis 5,176 8.78
Jeff Huska 2,584 4.38
Richard Majkot 1,412 2.40
Jeanne Brohart 494 0.84
Jean-Raymond Audet 256 0.43
David Popescu 67 0.11
Ed Pokonzie 65 0.11
Total valid votes 58,945 100.0

Referendum

In conjunction with the municipal election, three referendum questions on store hours in the city were posed to voters.

The referendum results were not legally binding on the city, as participation on all three questions fell slightly short of 50 per cent of registered voters; although the overall election passed 50 per cent voter turnout, the referendum questions garnered only 47 per cent participation.[6] Mayor-elect Brian Bigger and several of the new councillors stated that they considered the result to be a sufficient mandate to proceed with deregulation of store hours,[6] and the city's store hours bylaw was repealed at the new council's first official business meeting on December 9, 2014.[27]

Question 1

Are you in favour of retail business establishments having the choice to open to the public on December 26?

Response Votes %
Yes 34,312 61.12
No 21,826 38.88

Question 2

Are you in favour of retail business establishments having the choice to open to the public on the Civic Holiday, the first Monday in August?

Response Votes %
Yes 34,894 62.38
No 21,047 37.62

Question 3

Are you in favour of allowing retail business establishments to choose the hours when they are open to the public?

Response Votes %
Yes 42,511 75.46
No 13,826 24.54

Council

Ward 1

Ward 1 was an open seat, as former councillor Joe Cimino was elected to the Legislative Assembly of Ontario in the 2014 provincial election.[28]

Candidate Votes %
Mark Signoretti 1,780 39.67
Chris Spry 1,125 25.07
Matt Alexander 589 13.13
Paul Soucie 274 6.11
Thomas Trainor 261 5.82
Denis Ferron 232 5.17
Mathieu Labonté 167 3.72
Sidney Shapiro 59 1.31
Total valid votes

Ward 2

Candidate Votes %
Michael Vagnini 2,752 49.36
(x) Jacques Barbeau 2,190 39.28
Daniel Xilon 398 7.14
Chad Odnokon 152 2.73
Joseph Palmateer 83 1.49
Total valid votes

Ward 3

Ward 3 was an open seat after Claude Berthiaume announced his retirement from politics.

Candidate Votes %
Gerry Montpellier 1,884 42.14
Marcel Montpellier 1,311 29.32
Matt Belanger 960 21.47
Jesse Gaudet 316 7.07
Total valid votes 4,471 100%

Ward 4

Candidate Votes %
(x) Evelyn Dutrisac 2,112 48.10
François Couture 1,713 39.01
Paul Lefebvre 566 12.89
Total valid votes

Richard Paquette was a registered candidate, but withdrew his candidacy for personal reasons in April.[19]

Ward 5

Ward 5 was an open seat, as incumbent councillor Ron Dupuis was a candidate in the mayoral race.

Candidate Votes %
Robert Kirwan 1,467 35.78
John Lundrigan 969 23.63
Richard Larcher 891 21.73
Joseph Berthelot 483 11.78
Kent MacNeill 290 7.07
Total valid votes

Ward 6

Candidate Votes %
René Lapierre 1,933 37.56
(x) André Rivest 1,663 32.31
Fernand Bidal 865 16.81
Kevin Brault 686 13.33
Total valid votes

Ward 7

Candidate Votes %
Mike Jakubo 2,486 50.90
(x) Dave Kilgour 1,525 31.22
Robin Auger 414 8.48
Gordon Drysdale 371 7.60
Walter Prus 88 1.80
Total valid votes

Frank Mazzuca, Jr. was a registered candidate, but withdrew on May 22, 2014.

Ward 8

Candidate Votes %
(x) Al Sizer 1,973 45.04
Stefano Presenza 1,042 23.78
Michael Cullen 1,013 23.12
Gerry Perras 219 5.00
Kerry Latham 134 3.06
Total valid votes

Ward 9

Candidate Votes %
Deb McIntosh 2,000 35.28
Les Lisk 1,037 18.29
Wyman MacKinnon 691 12.19
Lin Gibson 679 11.98
Paul Stopciati 657 11.59
Aaron Beaudry 353 6.23
Will Thomson 252 4.45
Total valid votes

Ward 10

Candidate Votes %
Fern Cormier 2,085 38.84
John Antonioni 1,200 22.35
Hannu Piironen 1,042 19.41
Mila Wong 794 14.79
Steve Ripley 247 4.60
Total valid votes

Ward 11

Candidate Votes %
Lynne Reynolds 2,194 40.86
(x) Terry Kett 1,700 31.73
Mike Bleskie 851 15.89
Chris Nerpin 356 6.65
Vincent Lacroix 256 4.78
Total valid votes

Ward 12

Candidate Votes %
(x) Joscelyne Landry-Altmann 2,179 52.98
Tay Butt 1,136 27.62
Shawn Ouimet 496 12.06
Robert McCarthy 302 7.34
Total valid votes

Rainbow District School Board

Zone 1

Zone 1 consists of Wards 1 and 2 in the city.

Candidate Votes %
(x) Gord Santala 2,483 42.58
Jennifer Michaud 1,477 25.33
John Hamalainen 982 16.84
Frank DeBurger 890 15.26
Total valid votes

Zone 2

Zone 2 consists of Wards 3 and 4 in the city, as well as much of the Unorganized North Sudbury District north of the city, including the townships of Cartier, Cascaden, Foy, Hart, Harty, Hess, Moncrieff, Shining Tree and Trill.

Candidate Votes %
(x) Tyler Campbell 1,711 57.49
Anita Gibson 1,265 42.51
Total valid votes

Zone 3

Zone 3 consists of Wards 5 and 6 in the city.

Candidate Votes %
Judy Kosmerly acclaimed

Zone 4

Zone 4 consists of Wards 7 and 8 in the city, as well as the outlying municipalities of French River, Killarney, Markstay-Warren and St. Charles, and the unorganized townships of Burwash, Cox, Davis, Eden, Hawley, Hendrie, Henry, James, Laura, Loughrin, Secord, Servos, Street and Tilton.

Candidate Votes %
(x) Dena Morrison acclaimed

Zone 5

Zone 5 consists of Wards 9 and 10 in the city.

Candidate Votes %
(x) Doreen Dewar 3,404 59.67
Jessica Joy 1,248 21.88
Dylan Gibson 1,053 18.46
Total valid votes

Zone 6

Zone 6 consists of Wards 11 and 12 in the city.

Candidate Votes %
(x) Judy Hunda acclaimed

Sudbury Catholic District School Board

Zone 1

Zone 1 consists of Wards 1 and 2 in the city.

Candidate Votes %
(x) Estelle Scappatura 1,197 54.21
Clara Steele 1,011 45.79
Total valid votes

Zone 2

Zone 2 consists of Wards 3 and 4 in the city, as well as much of the Unorganized North Sudbury District north of the city, including the townships of Cartier, Cascaden, Foy, Hart, Harty, Hess, Moncrieff, Shining Tree and Trill.

Candidate Votes %
(x) Raymond Desjardins acclaimed

Zone 3

Zone 3 consists of Wards 5 and 6 in the city.

Candidate Votes %
(x) Michael Bellmore acclaimed

Zone 4

Zone 4 consists of Wards 7 and 8 in the city, as well as the outlying municipalities of Markstay-Warren and St. Charles.

Candidate Votes %
Nancy Deni 1,241 53.38
(x) Barry MacDonald 1,084 46.62
Total valid votes

Zone 5

Zone 5 consists of Wards 9 and 10 in the city, as well as the outlying municipalities of French River and Killarney, and the unorganized townships of Burwash, Cox, Davis, Eden, Hawley, Henvey, Hendrie, Henry, James, Laura, Loughrin, Secord, Servos, Street, Tilton and Wallbridge.

Candidate Votes %
Tyler Peroni 1,477 52.38
Geraldine Meskell 1,343 47.62
Total valid votes

Zone 6

Zone 6 consists of Wards 11 and 12 in the city.

Candidate Votes %
(x) Jody Cameron acclaimed

Cameron was subsequently removed from office on March 30, 2015, after failing to file his financial statements from the 2014 election by the filing deadline of March 27.[29]

Conseil scolaire public du Grand Nord de l'Ontario

Zone 7

Candidate Votes %
Lynn Despatie 281 67.06
Françoise Monette 138 32.94
Total valid votes

Zone 8

Candidate Votes %
Robert Boileau acclaimed

Zone 9

Candidate Votes %
Claude Giroux acclaimed

Zone 10

Candidate Votes %
Jean-Marc Aubin acclaimed

Zone 11

Candidate Votes %
Raymond Labrecque acclaimed

Zone 12

Candidate Votes %
François Boudreau acclaimed

Conseil scolaire de district catholique du Nouvel-Ontario

Zone 4

Two to be elected.

Candidate Votes %
Paul Demers 1,955 40.54
Louise Dubé 1,702 35.30
Paul Marleau 1,165 24.16
Total valid votes

Zone 5

Two to be elected.

Candidate Votes %
André Bidal 2,728 33.83
Marc Larochelle 2,193 27.19
Normand Courtemanche 1,906 23.63
Pierre Beaumier 1,238 15.35
Total valid votes

Zone 6

Two to be elected.

Candidate Votes %
Louise Essiembre acclaimed
Marcel Legault acclaimed
Total valid votes

References

  1. ↑ "As nomination deadline passes, attention turns to getting out the vote". Northern Life, September 16, 2014.
  2. ↑ "Taxpayers deserve better: Matichuk". Northern Life, September 28, 2012.
  3. ↑ "Get past public spats, former mayor urges council". Northern Life, October 10, 2012.
  4. ↑ "Council fires 'unbelievably rude' Ontario ombudsman". CBC News, February 13, 2013.
  5. ↑ "Slush fund showdown". Sudbury Star, February 21, 2012.
  6. ↑ 6.0 6.1 6.2 6.3 "Sudburians to decide store hours". Northern Life, September 12, 2012.
  7. ↑ "Regulated store hours to stay in Greater Sudbury". Northern Life, February 10, 2011.
  8. ↑ "Roads most important issue for Sudburians, poll finds". Northern Life, September 28, 2014.
  9. ↑ "There will be a Sudbury race: Wynne". Sudbury Star, March 24, 2014.
  10. ↑ "False rumours tying her to Liberals part of election season, Matichuk says". Northern Life, February 25, 2014.
  11. ↑ "Nomination delays frustrate Sudbury Liberals". Sudbury Star, March 28, 2014.
  12. ↑ "Andrew Olivier named Sudbury Liberal riding candidate". CBC News, May 9, 2014.
  13. ↑ "Mayor's 2010 campaign team won't be back". Sudbury Star, March 31, 2014.
  14. ↑ "Matichuk will not seek re-election". Sudbury Star, June 19, 2014.
  15. ↑ "Matichuk had big lead before quitting mayoral race, poll finds". Northern Life, June 24, 2014.
  16. ↑ "John Rodriguez aims to reclaim Sudbury mayor job". CBC News, May 9, 2014.
  17. ↑ "Dupuis sets his sights on mayor's seat in next municipal election". Northern Life, March 18, 2014.
  18. ↑ "Mayoral candidate wants accountability". Sudbury Star, March 13, 2014.
  19. ↑ 19.0 19.1 "Majkot joins mayoral race". Sudbury Star, April 21, 2014.
  20. ↑ "'Our cherished city is broken': Melanson". Sudbury Star, April 8, 2014.
  21. ↑ "Sudbury mayors' race sees 3 candidates step forward so far". CBC News, March 19, 2014.
  22. ↑ "Pollster: It's now a two-person race". Northern Life, October 22, 2014.
  23. ↑ "Most are undecided over who they want as Sudbury's mayor". Northern Life, October 20, 2014.
  24. ↑ "Sudbury mayor's race Bigger's to lose: Pollster". Sudbury Star, October 14, 2014.
  25. ↑ "Brian Bigger has most widespread support, poll finds". Northern Life, September 28, 2014.
  26. ↑ "Poll shows three-way race for mayor in Sudbury". Sudbury Star, October 7, 2014.
  27. ↑ "Council repeals Sudbury's store hours bylaw". Sudbury Star, December 10, 2014.
  28. ↑ "It's official: Cimino paints Sudbury riding orange". Northern Life, June 12, 2014.
  29. ↑ "Sudbury Catholic District School Board searches for new chair". CBC Sudbury, April 1, 2015.

External links