Great Church

For the "Great Church of Christ" in Byzantine usage, see Ecumenical Patriarchate of Constantinople.
The Church Fathers in an 11th-century depiction from Kiev

The term "Great Church" (Latin Ecclesia magna) refers to a concept in the historiography of early Christianity, primarily associated with the Roman Catholic account of the history of Christian theology, but also used by non-Catholic historians. The term generally derives from the rapid growth and structural development of the Church in the period 180-313 and its claim to universally represent Christianity within the Roman Empire.[1]

In modern Catholic usage, the "Great Church" broadly means the majority united Catholic and Orthodox Christian church continuing in authority from the Twelve Apostles to today in the West and all bishops that remained in fellowship with the Bishop of Rome.[2]

The "epoch of the Great Church" is counted as beginning about the end of the 2nd century when, despite the persecution of Christians, the religion became established numerically and organisationally,[3] eventually becoming the State church of the Roman Empire in 380.[1] However, at the Council of Chalcedon in 451 the Western and Eastern branches of the Great Church parted ways based on seemingly small Christological differences.[4][5][6]

Historical references

Justin Martyr (100-165) wrote (Tertullian, Prescription Against Heretics 30 and Adv. Marcionem, 4.4) that when in 144 AD Marcion was excommunicated from the fellowship of the "Great Church" he had to return the funds he had gathered.[7]

Towards the end of the 2nd century, Irenaeus wrote about the heretical office holders in the "Great Church".[8] In Contra Celsum 5.61 Church Father Origen mentions Celsus' late 2nd century use of the term "church of the multitudes" or the "great church" to refer to the emerging consensus traditions among Christians at the time, as Christianity was taking shape.[9][10]

In the 4th century, as he commented on Psalm XXII Saint Augustine interpreted the term to mean the whole world, writing: "The great Church, Brethren, what is it? Is a scanty portion of the earth the great Church? The great church means the whole world."[11] Augustine continued to expound on how various churches all considered themselves "the great Church" but that only the whole world could be seen as the great Church.[11]

Emergence of the Great Church

Irenaeus (2nd century - c. 202)

Cunningham and separately Krugel and Rowan state that Irenaeus's statement in Against Heresies Chapter X 1-2 (written c. 180) is the first recorded reference to the existence of a worldwide Christian church with a core set of shared beliefs that can be called the "Great Church".[12][13] Irenaeus states:[12]

“ The Church, though dispersed through our the whole world, even to the ends of the earth, has received from the apostles and their disciples this faith: ... As I have already observed, the Church, having received this preaching and this faith, although scattered throughout the whole world, yet, as if occupying but one house, carefully preserves it... For the churches which have been planted in Germany do not believe or hand down anything different, nor do those in Spain, nor those in Gaul, nor those in the East, nor those in Egypt, nor those in Libya, nor those which have been established in the central regions of the world. But as the sun, that creature of God, is one and the same throughout the whole world, so also the preaching of the truth shineth everywhere, and enlightens all men that are willing to come to a knowledge of the truth. ”

Cunningham states that two points in Irenaeus' writing deserve attention. First that Irenaeus distinguished the Church in singular from "the churches" plural, and more importantly that Irenaeus holds that only in the larger single Church does one find the truth handed down by the apostles of Christ.[12]

At the beginning of the third century the great Church that Irenaeus and Celsus had referred to had spread across a significant portion of the world; most of its members living in cities.[14] The growth was less than uniform across the world, the Chronicle of Arbela stating that in 225 there were 20 bishops in all of Persia, while at approximately the same timeframe surrounding areas of Rome had over 60 bishops.[14] But the great Church of the third century was not monolithic and consisted of a network of churches connected across cultural zones via lines of communication which at times included personal relationships.[14]

The great Church grew in the 2nd century and entered the 3rd century mainly in two empires: the Roman and the Persian; the network of bishops across the cultural zones usually acting as the cohesive element.[15] In 313, the Edict of Milan ended the persecution of Christians and by 380 the Great Church had gathered enough followers to become the State church of the Roman Empire by virtue of the Edict of Thessalonica.[1]

Theological underpinnings and separation

Emperor Constantine and bishops with the Creed of 381.

The epoch of the Great Church witnessed the development of key theological concepts which now form the fabric of the religious beliefs of the large majority of Christians.[1]

Relying on Scripture, prevailing mysticism and popular piety, Irenaeus formalized some of the attributes of God writing in Against Heresis Book IV, Chapter 19: "His greatness lacks nothing, but contains all things".[16] Irenaeus also referred to the early use of the "Father, Son and Holy Spirit" formula which appeared as part of Christian Creeds, writing in Against Heresies (Book I Chapter X):[17]

“ "The Church ... believes in one God, the Father Almighty, Maker of heaven, and earth, and the sea, and all things that are in them; and in one Christ Jesus, the Son of God, who became incarnate for our salvation; and in the Holy Spirit". ”

Around AD 213 in Adversus Praxeas (chapter 3) Tertullian provided a formal representation of the concept of the Trinity, i.e., that God exists as one "substance" but three "Persons": The Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit.[18][19] Tertullian also discussed how the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father and the Son.[18] The First Council of Nicaea in AD 325 and later the First Council of Constantinople in AD 381 then formalized these elements.[20]

In 451 all the bishops of the Great Church were ordered to attend the Council of Chalcedon to discuss theological issues that had emerged.[4] This turned out to be a turning point at which the Western and Eastern churches parted ways based on seemingly small Christological differences, and began the fracturing of the claim to the term Great Church by both sides.[4][5][6]

Modern theories on the formation of the concept

Official Catholic publications, and other writers, sometimes consider that the concept of the "Great Church" can be found already in the Epistles of Paul, such as in "This is my rule in all the churches" (1 Corinthians 17:7) and in the Apostolic Fathers such as the letters of Ignatius of Antioch.[21] Exegesis has even located the ecclesia magna in the Latin Vulgate translations of the "great congregation" (kahal rab) of the Hebrew Bible.[22] This interpretation was offered also by Pope Benedict XVI.[23] The interpretation was also offered by Martin Luther.[24]

Dennis Minns (2010) considers that the concept of a 'Great Church' was developed by polemical heresiologists such as Irenaeus.[25] The presentation of early Christianity unity and orthodoxy (see Proto-orthodox Christianity), and counter presentation of groups such as those sects labelled "Gnostic", by early heresiologists such as Irenaeus is questioned by modern historians.[26]

Roger E. Olson (1999) uses the term to refer to the Great Church at the time of the Council of Chalcedon (451) when the Patriarch of Constantinople and Bishop of Rome were in fellowship with each other.[27]

In contrast to "Jewish Christianity"

The term is contrasted with Jewish Christians who came to be more and more clearly separated from the Great Church.[28] Wilhelm Schneemelcher and others writing on New Testament Apocrypha distinguish writings as being sectarian or from the Great Church.[29][30]

Gabriele Waste (2005) is among German scholars using similar references, where the „Große Kirche" ("Great Church") is defined as "Ecclesia ex gentibus" (Church of the Gentiles) in comparison to the „Ecclesia ex circumcisione" (Church of the Circumcision).[31]

In the anglophone world Bruce J. Malina (1976) contrasted what he calls "Christian Judaism" (usually termed "Jewish Christianity"), with "the historically perceived orthodox Christianity that undergirds the ideology of the emergent Great Church."[32][33]

In francophone scholarship the term Grande Église (French: Ecclesia magna) has also been equated with the "more hellenized" as opposed to "Judaizing" sections of the early church.[34] and to see the Bar Kokhba revolt as a definitive stage in the separation between Judaism and the Christianity of the «Grande Église».[35] Those stressing this binary view of early Christianity include Simon Claude Mimouni and François Blanchetière.

See also

References

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 Peter Stockmeier in the Encyclopedia of Theology: A Concise Sacramentum Mundi edited by Karl Rahner ISBN 0860120066 (New York: Seabury Press, 1975) page 375-376 "In the following period, c. 180-313, these structures already determine essentially the image of the Church which claims a universal mission in the Roman Empire. It has rightly been termed the period of the Great Church, in view of its numerical growth, its constitutional development and its intense theological activity."
  2. ↑ Roger E. Olson The Story of Christian Theology: Twenty Centuries of Tradition & ... 1999p278 "According to the Roman Catholic account of the history of Christian theology, the Great Church catholic and orthodox lived on from the apostles to today in the West and all bishops that remained in fellowship with the bishop of Rome have"
  3. ↑ Peter Stockmeier in the Encyclopedia of Theology: A Concise Sacramentum Mundi edited by Karl Rahner ISBN 0860120066 (New York: Seabury Press, 1975) p 378: "The epoch of the Great Church began about the end of the 2nd century. In spite of oppressive measures Christianity became firmly established numerically and structurally and so paved the way for the Church of the empire"
  4. ↑ 4.0 4.1 4.2 Pocket History of Theology by Roger E. Olson and Adam C. English (Nov 14, 2005) ISBN 0830827048 Intervarsity Press pages 46-47
  5. ↑ 5.0 5.1 Christ in Christian Tradition by Aloys Grillmeier, Theresia Hainthaler and Pauline Allen (Aug 1995) ISBN 0664219977 pages 1-2
  6. ↑ 6.0 6.1 Christian Community in History Volume 1 by Roger D. Haight (Sep 16, 2004) ISBN 0826416306 pages 212-213
  7. ↑ Christians at Rome in the First Two Centuries: From Paul to Valentinus by Peter Lampe (Jun 1, 2006) ISBN 0826481027 page 101
  8. ↑ Christians at Rome in the First Two Centuries by Peter Lampe (Jun 1, 2006) ISBN 0826481027 page 389
  9. ↑ Birth of the Church by I. Davidson (Apr 22, 2005) ISBN 1854246585 page 381
  10. ↑ History of the World Christian Movement: Volume 1: Earliest Christianity To 1453 by Dale T. Irvin and Scott Sunquist(Jan 10, 2002) ISBN 0567088669 pages 102-103
  11. ↑ 11.0 11.1 Expositions on the Book of Psalms Volume I by Augustine of Hippo Henry Parker, Oxford, 1847 page 159
  12. ↑ 12.0 12.1 12.2 An Introduction to Catholicism by Lawrence S. Cunningham (Feb 16, 2009) ISBN 0521846072 page 4-5
  13. ↑ Early Biblical Interpretation by James L. Kugel and Rowan A. Greer (Jan 1, 1986) ISBN 0664250130 page 109
  14. ↑ 14.0 14.1 14.2 History of the World Christian Movement: Volume 1: Earliest Christianity To 1453 by Dale T. Irvin and Scott Sunquist(Jan 10, 2002) ISBN 0567088669 pages 103-107
  15. ↑ History of the World Christian Movement: Volume 1: Earliest Christianity To 1453 by Dale T. Irvin and Scott Sunquist(Jan 10, 2002) ISBN 0567088669 pages 107-109
  16. ↑ Irenaeus of Lyons by Eric Francis Osborn (Nov 26, 2001) ISBN 0521800064 pages 27-29
  17. ↑ Vickers, Jason E. Invocation and Assent: The Making and the Remaking of Trinitarian Theology. Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing, 2008. ISBN 0-8028-6269-1 pages 2-5
  18. ↑ 18.0 18.1 The Trinity by Roger E. Olson, Christopher Alan Hall 2002 ISBN 0802848273 pages 29-31
  19. ↑ Tertullian, First Theologian of the West by Eric Osborn (4 Dec 2003) ISBN 0521524954 pages 116-117
  20. ↑ Life in the Trinity: An Introduction to Theology with the Help of the Church Fathers by Donald Fairbairn (Sep 28, 2009) ISBN 0830838732 pages 48-50
  21. ↑ Monsignor David Bohr, Archbishop Timothy M. Dolan The Diocesan Priest: Consecrated and Sent Collegeville, Minnesota: Liturgical Press, 2009)2010 p42 "The term ordinatio was originally used in Rome for appointing civil 17 Certainly the concept of the "Great Church" can be found already in the epistles of St. Paul (e.g., 1 Cor 17:7) and in the letters of St. Ignatius of Antioch."
  22. ↑ Telesphor Smyth-Vaudry Peter's name: or, A divine credential in a name 1909 p84 "26) — "I will give thanks to thee in a great Church." (Ps. 34. 18.) — "I have declared thy justice in a great Church" (Ps. 39. 10). So divinely universal is the "great Church" — the Ecclesia magna — prophesied by David, that her very enemies ..."
  23. ↑ Joseph Ratzinger, Pope Benedict XVI, Michael J. Miller -Dogma and Preaching: Applying Christian Doctrine to Daily Life 2011 p18 "... which the ecclesia, or perhaps the ecclesia magna (Ps 22 [21]:25) constitutes the audience. In the New Testament there is a change—necessarily so, inasmuch as now the psalm with its situation emerges from the hypothetical and indefinite ..."
  24. ↑ Gregory of Tours: History and Society in the Sixth Century 2001 -p164 "The 'ecclesia magna' (according to Luther, the 'great commonality' Cgro8e Gemeine')) of Hist, n 34 refers to Psalm 35, v. 18; on the 'universalis aeclesia' of Hist, rv 42: 474, 1, see p. 166, n. 44, below. 36 Hist, n 23: 68, 17f.; see also Chapter 3 ..."
  25. ↑ Denis Minns Irenaeus: An Introduction 2010 p17 "In this book I have presumed that there was a reality corresponding to the term 'the Great Church', and that, by and large, Irenaeus represents it. This is a convenient simplification, but a simplification nonetheless. If we can speak of a 'Great Church' at all, this is at least partly because polemical theologians like Irenaeus identified certain views as incompatible with Christian truth and declared those who held them to be beyond Christian fellowship."
  26. ↑ James L. Kugel, Rowan A. Greer Early Biblical interpretation 1986 p119 "The Gnostics are thought of as a perverse mirror image of the Great Church with their own succession of teachers and their own Rule of faith. ... Instead, we must understand what happened as the gradual emergence of unity out of diversity."
  27. ↑ Roger E. Olson The Story of Christian Theology: Twenty Centuries of Tradition & ... 1999 Page 251 "PART V A Tale of Two Churches The Great Tradition Divides Between East & West Up to this point the story of Christian theology has been the story of a relatively unified Great Church, both catholic and orthodox. We have seen how heresies ... After the council, the Great Church was identified with the bishops in fellowship with the emperor and patriarch of Constantinople in the East and the bishop of Rome (also considered a patriarch) in the West, and these three usually maintained ..." p278 "According to the Roman Catholic account of the history of Christian theology, the Great Church catholic and orthodox lived on from the apostles to today in the West and all bishops that remained in fellowship with the bishop of Rome have"
  28. ↑ Theological dictionary of the New Testament. Gerhard Kittel, Gerhard Friedrich - 1966 Vol. 3 - Page 518 EKKLESIA "48 As Jewish Christians came to be more and more clearly separated from the Great Church, it is probable that they called both their assemblies and their places of assembly auvccycoyi!|. In the very earliest period all Christians, both Jew and ..."
  29. ↑ Wilhelm Schneemelcher, R. McL. Wilson New Testament Apocrypha: Writings Relating to the Apostles ...- 2003 - Page 414 Acts of Peter and The Twelve Apostles "... of consideration: a) from the content and tenor of the text it is difficult to understand it as a product of the Great Church; it is ... The special way in which the ideal of poverty is presented in ActPt makes one instinctively think of the Ebionites. b) ..."
  30. ↑ Alois Grillmeier Christ in Christian tradition 1965 Volume 1 - Page 45 "Besides such Targumim, it seems that the existence of Jewish-Christian Midrashim, paraphrases of the Old Testament, can also be proven. It is further claimed that the early Christian sources, whether Jewish-Christian or from the great Church,"
  31. ↑ Minemosyne - Page 251 "Diese bildeten die „Ecclesia ex circumcisione", der später die aus den Heidenvölkern herkommende „Große Kirche" oder „Ecclesia ex gentibus" gegenüberstand. Die Judenchristen, zu denen die Edelsten der Nation gehörten, umfaßten ..."
  32. ↑ Edwin K. Broadhead Jewish Ways of Following Jesus: Redrawing the Religious Map of ... 2010 - Page 33 "1) Jewish Christianity is "the historically perceived orthodox Christianity that undergirds the ideology of the emergent Great Church."16 2) Judaism refers to rabbinic, Pharisaic Judaism. 3) Christian Judaism is, in a first century context, "a phase ...
  33. ↑ B. J. Malina, Jewish Christianity or Christian Judaism: Toward a hypothetical Definition', JSJ 8 (1976), pp.
  34. ↑ Revue théologique de Louvain Fondation universitaire de Belgique 2005- 36 p 229 "Plutôt que des membres de la Grande Église séduits par le prosélytisme juif, ces chrétiens sont vraisemblablement les héritiers ..."
  35. ↑ Revue des études juives: 2004 v163 p 43 "... la révolte de Bar Kokhba a donc constitué une étape définitive dans la séparation entre le judaïsme et la «Grande Église». ... S.C. Mimouni, Le judéo-christianisme ancien, op. cit., et D. Marguerat, «Juifs et chrétiens: la séparation», in J.-M."