George Soule (Mayflower passenger)

George Soule (c. 1594/5). He died between September 20, 1677 and January 20, 1679/80 in Duxbury, Massachusetts Bay Colony.^[1] Soule was one of the indentured servants who traveled on the Mayflower in 1620 and established Plymouth Colony.^[1] He was one of the signers of the Mayflower Compact.

Early life

Nothing certain is known of his life in England other than that he came on the Mayflower being credited to the London contingent as an Edward Winslow manservant or apprentice, along with Elias Story and a little girl Ellen More, the latter two both died in the first winter.”^[2][3][4]

George Soule was mentioned in Bradford’s recollections of the Winslow group: Mr. Edward Winslow; Elizabeth, his wife; and *2* men servants, called Georg Sowle and Elias Story; also a little girle was put to him, called Ellen, sister of Richard More.^[5] He continues: Mr. Ed. Winslow his wife dyed the first winter; and he is maried with the widow of Mr. White, and hath *2* children living by her marigable besides sundry that are dead. One of his servants dyed, as also the little girle, soone after the ships arrival. But this man Georg Sowle, is still living and hath *8* children.^[6]

Nothing for certain is known of George Soule's origins. For five years, noted Mayflower researcher and biographer Caleb Johnson managed a fairly intensive search for the English origins of George Soule. Mr. Johnson examined a number of likely ‘George Soules’ in various parts of England. And after all his research, Mr. Johnson believes the most promising candidate of all the ‘George Soules’ he reviewed to be that of the Mayflower passenger George Soule of Tingrith, Bedfordshire, baptized in February 1594/5.^[7]

It is believed that George Soule was in London when he joined Winslow for the Mayflower voyage. Droitwich, in northern Worcestershire, the family home of the Winslows at that time, was a salt mining place connected in a business way with the Salters Company of London in trade. With that, it is believed the London association of Winslow and Soule was established.^[8]

Mayflower

The Mayflower departed Plymouth, England on September 6/16, 1620. The small, 100-foot ship had 102 passengers and a crew of about 30-40 in extremely cramped conditions. By the second month out, the ship was being buffeted by strong westerly gales, causing the ship‘s timbers to be badly shaken with caulking failing to keep out sea water, and with passengers, even in their berths, lying wet and ill. This, combined with a lack of proper rations and unsanitary conditions for several months, attributed to what would be fatal for many, especially the majority of women and children. On the way there were two deaths, a crew member and a passenger, but the worst was yet to come after arriving at their destination when, in the space of several months, almost half the passengers perished in cold, harsh, unfamiliar New England winter.^[9]

On November 9/19, 1620, after about 3 months at sea, including a month of delays in England, they spotted land, which was the Cape Cod Hook, now called Provincetown Harbor. After several days of trying to get south to their planned destination of the Colony of Virginia, strong winter seas forced them to return to the harbor at Cape Cod hook, where they anchored on November 11/21.^[9]

On November 11, 1620, Soule signed the Mayflower Compact.^[1]

In Plymouth Colony

In 1623, the Division of Land at Plymouth provided one acre for George Soule between the property of “Frances” Cooke and “Mr. Isaak” Allerton.^[2][10]

In 1626, George Soule married a woman by the name of Mary. It is known that the only Mary in Plymouth who was then unmarried was Mary Bucket (Buckett). In 1623, “Marie” Buckett, as a single woman, had received one acre of land.^[2][11]

In 1626 George Soule was one of twenty-seven Purchasers involved with the colony joint-stock company which afterwards was turned over to the control of senior colony members. That group was called Undertakers, and were made up of such Pilgrim leaders as Bradford, Standish and Allerton initially, who were later joined by other leaders Winslow, Brewster, Howland, Alden, Prence and others from London who were former Merchant Adventurers. On the agreement, dated October 26, 1626, his name appears as “Georg Soule.”^[12]

In the 1627 Division of Cattle, George and Mary Soule and their first son Zachariah (all with the recorded surname of “Sowle”) were listed with the Richard Warren family. They were allotted several animals that arrived on the ship Jacob, probably in 1625.^[2][13]

Historic records indicate Soule became a freeman prior to 1632/33 (Johnson) or was on the 1633 list of freemen.^[2][4]

In 1633/34 Soule (as “Sowle”) was taxed at the lowest rate which indicates that his estate was without much significance.^[2][14]

Per Plymouth records, Soule’s life with his family appears to have been lived quietly in a Puritan home – obtaining some land holdings through the years which he would later provide for his large family. He was never involved in any criminal or civil court dispute and did participate in a number of public service situations, one being his volunteering to fight in the Pequot War in 1637, which was over before the Plymouth company could get organized.^[4][15]

Land records note that in 1637 he was assigned "a garden place…on Duxbury side, by Samuel Nash’s, to lie to his ground at Powder Point".^[15]

The 1638 land records note that “one acre of land is granted to George Soule at the watering place…and also a parcel of Stony Marsh at Powder Point, containing two acres.” The land at the “watering place” in south Plymouth was sold the next year, possibly as he was living in Duxbury at that time and did not need his property in south Plymouth. In 1640 he was granted a meadow at Green’s Harbor – now Marshfield. His land holdings included property in several towns, those being Namaskett, Middleboro and Dartmouth.^[1][4][15]

First in 1642 and last in 1662, he was assigned to at least five grand and petty juries. He was deputy for Duxbury for several years.^[1][4][15]

In the 1643 Able to Bear Arms (ATBA) List, George and his son Zachariah (listed as “Georg” and “Zachary”) appear with those bearing arms from Duxbury (written as “Duxbarrow”).^[16]

In October 1645 the General Court granted to Duxbury inhabitants lands “about Saughtuckquett” and nominated “Captaine Miles Standish, Mr John Alden, George Soul…” and others for “equall devideing and laying forth of the said lands to their inhabitants.” The purpose of this committee was to divide property in the Duxbury area for its inhabitants. Soule was also on a similar committee in 1640.^[15][17]

On October 20, 1646 Soule, with Anthony Thatcher, was chosen to be on a “committee to draw up an order concerning disorderly drinking (smoking) of tobacco.” The law, as drawn up, provided strict limitations on where tobacco could be smoked and what fines could be levied against lawbreakers.^[15]

Family

Marie/Mary Buckett, wife of George Soule. The mysterious young woman known to Plymouth Colony history as “Marie Buckett” arrived in Plymouth in July 1623 as a single woman passenger on the ship Anne. She may have been about age 18 (born c.1605) and quite unusually seems to have traveled alone and or if with someone, whom, no one has determined. To date, researchers have been stymied in their efforts to prove her ancestry, or from where she came, whether Holland or England.^[18][19]

She first appears in Plymouth Colony records in the 1627 Division of Cattle with passengers of the Anne as “Marie Buckett” where she received one lot of her own “adioyning to Joseph Rogers” ..”on the other side of towne towards the eele-riuer.”^[18][19]

There are indications in the land record that she was unaccompanied and not in the company of her parents.^[20]

Author Caleb Johnson estimates she married George Soule about 1625 or 1626.^[21]

In the 1627 Division of Cattle she is listed with her husband George and young son “Zakariah” as “ Mary Sowle.”^[13]

Two hypotheses were recently published in The Mayflower Quarterly regarding the ancestry of ‘Marie Buckett”. Hypothesis No. 1 has her as Walloon coming from Leiden and Hypothesis No. 2 writes of research indicating a possibility of her being English:

Hypothesis No. 1:

In an article in the December 2012 issue of The Mayflower Quarterly, author Louise Walsh Throop writes that in Leiden records one name is phonetically quite similar to Buckett. Director of the American Mayflower Museum in Leiden Jeremy Bangs mentioned that a number of Mayflower passengers sold their Leiden properties in the summer of 1620, in particular a “Jan Allaert,” likely the Dutch version of the name “John Allerton” (brother of Isaac) who sold his house on July 15, 1620. One of the neighbors on the south side of his property was a Walloon family known as “the widow and heirs of Jan Bucque.” Author Throop states that it would appear that this Jan Bucquet was the grandfather of Marie/Mary Buckett/Bucquet.^[22]

Author Throop also reports that recently a marriage record was found in Leiden for a Jan Bucquet, born Brugge (now Bruges in Flemish Belgium) and Marye de Roucheau, born Turquoyn by Ryssel (now Tourcoing in French Flanders), who were married in the Waalse (Walloon) Church, Leiden on Dec. 21, 1604. Witness for the groom was his father Jan Bucquet and for the bride, her mother Margriete Holbeecke. Sometime in 1605 it seems this marriage produced a daughter, Marie, who the author believed to be the young woman who later married George Soule. This birth year fits with Mary Buckett’s expected age of 21 at her marriage about 1626, and with her first child born before May 22, 1627.^[22]

Huguenot immigrants were known for blending well into new environment, thus the surname Bucquet is found in 1604, Bucque in 1620 and Buckett in 1623. In 1623 Mary Buckett was blending into her new English environment in Plymouth Colony and must have felt she had something in common with George Sowle, who is believed to also have come from a Walloon family. His proposed father was born in Brussels, now capital of Belgium. George Soule signed his will “Gorge Sowle”, making a blend of the Dutch first name with the English-sounding surname. It is likely that before 1620 in the Dutch cities of Leiden and Haarlem he was known as “Joris Sol” or “Joris Jansz.”^[22]

Hypothesis No.2:

Noted Mayflower author Caleb H. Johnson writes in The Mayflower Quarterly of December 2013 that the origin of Mary Buckett, wife of Mayflower passenger George Soule, has not been conclusively proven by his, or any previous research. What Johnson did find in England, through extensive research and a lengthy process of elimination was a Mary Beckett in the parish of Watford, Hertfordshire. Mary was born about 1605 and fit the right age to have been on the Anne in 1623. Also she was in a family using the name Nathaniel, which is found in her own children. Her mother had a Mayflower-sounding name – Alden. She and her husband George were grouped with the Warrens in the 1627 Division of Cattle, with Mrs. Warren coming from Hertfordshire, as did Mary Beckett. Mary’s home parish register of St. Mary's Church, Watford, has a number of sixteenth-century Warren family entries of names which all appear in the Mayflower Warren family. Johnson considers the following to be among the most important information in considering Marie Buckett’s ancestry – Mary Beckett’s father died in 1619 when she was only about 14 years old. As a custom of the time, she and her siblings were likely apprenticed out to relatives, neighbors, acquaintances, etc. Her mother remained a widow until at least 1622 (listed in that year as “Widow Buckett) – further increasing the chance that her children would be sent to other families. Johnson concludes by stating that the following could have put Mary Beckett hypothetically on the ship Anne sailing to America in 1623: the right age, associated with families of Mayflower surnames, within a family using the name Nathaniel, and could have had the opportunity to be transferred to another family that would eventually sail to America on the ship Anne. Johnson notes after this time, Mary Beckett is not found again in Watford records, based on recent research.^[23]

Children of George and Mary Soule:

• Zachariah was born by May 1627 and died in Duxbury before December 11, 1663. He married Margaret _____ by 1663, but had no recorded children.

• John was born about 1632 and died in Duxbury before November 14, 1707. He married:

1. Rebecca Simmons about 1656 and had nine children. She died between 1675 and 1678.

2. Esther (Delano) Samson about 1678 and had three children. She died in Duxbury on September 12, 1735.^[1]

• Nathaniel was born between 1634 and 1646 and died in Dartmouth before October 12, 1699. He married Rose Thorn by 1680 and had five children.

Nathaniel may have caused the most colony trouble of any of his siblings. On March 5, 1667/8, he made an appearance in Plymouth court to “answer for his abusing of Mr. John Holmes, teacher of the church of Christ at Duxbury, by many false, scandalous and opprobrious speeches.” He was sentenced to make a public apology for his actions, find sureties for future good behavior and to sit in the stocks, with the stock sentence remitted. His father George and brother John had to pay surety for Nathaniel’s good behavior with he being bound for monies and to pay a fine. Three years later, on June 5, 1671, he was fined for “telling several lies which tended greatly to the hurt of the Colony in reference to some particulars about the Indians.” And then on March 1, 1674/5 he was sentenced to be whipped for “lying with an Indian woman,” and had to pay a fine in the form of bushels of corn to the Indian woman towards the keeping of her child.^[24]

• George was born about 1639 and died in Dartmouth before June 22, 1704. He married by 1671 Deborah _____ and had eight children. She died in Dartmouth about February 1709.

• Susanna was born about 1640 and died in Kingstowne, Rhode Island after 1684. She married Francis West by 1660 and had nine children.

• Mary was born about 1642 and died in Plymouth after 1720. She married John Peterson by 1665 and had nine children. He died between April 29, 1718 and March 26, 1720, probably in Plymouth.

• Elizabeth was born about 1644 and died after 1667. She married Francis Walker by July 23, 1668 and had one child. He died in probably Middleboro about 1701.^[1]

Elizabeth, like her brother Nathaniel, also had her share of problems with the Plymouth Court. On March 3, 1662/3, the Court fined Elizabeth and Nathaniel Church for committing fornication. Elizabeth then in turn sued Nathaniel Church “for committing an act of fornication with her... and then denying to marry her.” The jury awarded her damages plus court costs.^[25]

On July 2, 1667 Elizabeth was sentenced to be whipped at the post “for committing fornication the second time.” And although the man with whom she committed the act was not named, Elizabeth did marry Francis Walker within the following year.^[26]

• Patience was born about 1646 and died on March 11, 1705/6 in Middleboro. She married John Haskell in January 1666/7 in Middleboro and had eight children. He died on May 15, 1706 in Middleboro.

• Benjamin was born by about 1652 and died unmarried during King Philip's War on March 26, 1676.

Although George Soule became wealthy in Plymouth colony he still bound out at least one of his daughters to a John Winslow.^[27]

George Soule will, death and burial

George Soule made his will on August 11, 1677 and mentions his eldest son John “my eldest son John Soule and his family hath in my extreme old age and weakness been tender and careful of me and very helpful to me.” John was his executor and to whom was given nearly all of Soule’s estate. But after he wrote his will, on September 12, 1677 he seemed to have second thoughts and made a codicil to the will to the effect that if John or any family member were to trouble his daughter Patience or her heirs, the will would be void. And if such happened, then Patience would then become the executor of his last will and testament with virtually all that he owned becoming hers. To put his youngest daughter to inherit his estate ahead of his eldest son would have been a major humiliation for John Soule. But John must have done well in his father’s eyes since after his father’s death, he did inherit the Duxbury estate. Twenty years later Patience and her husband sold the Middleboro estate they had received from her father.^[26]

George Soule’s will was dated August 11, 1677, with a codicil dated September 20, 1677 and with the will proved in 1679. His will named his sons Nathaniel, George and John, and daughters Elizabeth, Patience, Susannah and Mary. His sons Zachariah and Benjamin had predeceased him.^[4]

George Soule died about 1679 and was buried at Myles Standish Burial Ground in Duxbury, Massachusetts as his wife Mary died in 1676.^[28]

It should be noted that per Stratton, the Soule family history compiled by Gideon T. Ridlon is not reliable.^[4]

Notable Descendants of George Soule
Notable descendants Joshua Soule, Methodist-Episcopal Bishop[29]

External links

• George Soule Kindred in the U.S.
• Soule Family in England

References

Mayflower passengers and related topics General Christopher Jones Cole's Hill List of Mayflower passengers List of Mayflower passengers who died in the winter of 1620–21 Mayflower Mayflower Compact List of Mayflower passengers who died at sea November/December 1620 Mayflower Compact signatories Pilgrim Fathers Plymouth Colony The Mayflower Society The More children and the Mayflower Separatists Priscilla (Mullins) Alden Isaac Allerton Mary Allerton William Bradford Dorothy Bradford Love Brewster William Brewster Peter Browne William Butten John Carver (Mayflower passenger) James Chilton Mary Chilton Francis Cooke Humility Cooper John Crackston Edward Doty Moses Fletcher Edward Fuller Samuel Fuller Constance Hopkins Oceanus Hopkins John Howland Degory Priest Thomas Rogers Henry Samson George Soule Edward Tilley John Tilley Thomas Tinker John Turner William White Resolved White Peregrine White Edward Winslow Other passengers John Alden John Billington Francis Eaton Stephen Hopkins Christopher Martin Elinor More Jasper More Mary More Richard More William Mullins Myles Standish Richard Warren Native American associates Squanto Samoset Hobbamock Massasoit Corbitant