Escort Group

Not to be confused with Escorts Group or Special Escort Group (disambiguation).

An Escort Group consisted of several small warships organized and trained to operate together providing protection for trade convoys. Escort groups were a second world war tactical innovation in anti-submarine warfare by the Royal Navy to combat the threat of the Kriegsmarine‍ '​s "wolfpack" tactics. Early escort groups often contained destroyers, sloops, naval trawlers and, later, corvettes of differing specifications lacking the ability to maneuver together as a flotilla of similar warships, but rigorously trained in anti-submarine tactics to use teamwork emphasizing the unique sensors, weapons, speed and turning radius of each ship. The development of these 'escort groups' proved an effective means of defending shipping convoys through the Battle of the Atlantic.

HMS Skate was one of the oldest destroyers in the Royal Navy when assigned convoy protection duty for the Western Approaches Command.

Background

On the basis of experience during World War I, the Admiralty instituted trade convoys in United Kingdom coastal waters from September 1939.[1] During the first year of the Battle of the Atlantic British convoy protection was the responsibility of the Western Approaches Command (WAC), based first in Plymouth, then, as the focus of the campaign moved after the Fall of France, in Liverpool.[2] The newest and most capable destroyers were assigned to screen capital ships of the Home Fleet; so, to augment the inadequate number of purpose-designed sloops, WAC was allocated a leftover array of limited production prototypes, ships built to foreign specifications, minesweepers, militarized yachts and fishing trawlers, and survivors of elderly destroyer classes no longer considered suitable for operation with the Home Fleet. These escorts were not numerous enough or sufficiently long ranged to accompany convoys across the Atlantic, but would screen convoys to and from meeting points thought to be beyond U-boat range defining the edge of the Western Approaches.

Convoy escorts were initially assigned on an ad hoc basis, dispatched as and when available, and arrived singly or in small groups. Command of the escort force fell to the senior officer present, and could change as each new ship arrived. Any tactical arrangements had to be made on the spot, and communicated by signal lamp to each ship in turn. The ships were unaccustomed to working together, and often had no common battle plan or tactics.

These deficiencies led to a major defeat in October 1940 when Convoy HX 79 from Halifax to Liverpool was attacked by a wolfpack of five U-boats remaining after an attack on convoy SC 7. Initially unprotected, a force of 11 warships were assembled but 12 ships in the convoy were sunk from attacks during the night while none of the U-boats were damaged.

The loss of ships from both SC 7 and HX 79 gave the impetus for Admiral Percy Noble, the commander-in-chief of WAC, to form discrete groups.[3] These Escort Groups often consisted of mixed types of small warships, but later were sometimes formed from a single class (e.g. the 1st, 3rd, 4th, 5th, 15th and 21st Escort Groups were composed entirely of Captain-class frigates when these ships became available to replace the older ships originally assigned to those groups.)[4]

Service history

In 1941 WAC had 8 escort groups formed.[3] These typically comprised four to eight ships, under the command of an RN officer, usually a Commander or Lieutenant Commander. By operating together under a single leader, groups were able to develop group tactics and practice their use; with the issue of a single short command the various ships of the group, often out of sight of each other, could be relied upon to act in a co-ordinated fashion. Later these tactics were standardized and taught to all escort group commanders at the Western Approaches Tactical Unit. In a ten-day period in 1941, four U-boats were sunk with the loss of three of Germany's top U-boat commanders.

This level of teamwork was never achieved by the attacking U-Boats. Although the wolfpack was co-ordinated in that a number of boats would be concentrated on a target convoy, once gathered the boats would attack individually without any attempt at further co-operation. It was not unknown for U-boats to get in each other's way whilst attacking, or collide with each other. Time and again during the Battle of the Atlantic relatively small, well-handled escort groups were able to frustrate attacks by more numerous groups of U-boats, and ensure the "safe and timely arrival" of their charges. In one example, in November 1942, Convoy ON 144 of 33 ships from Britain to North America protected by the Mid-Ocean Escort Force B6 of five Flower-class corvettes, was attacked by a group of ten U-boats. Over the next three days they fought off attacks by the wolfpack for the loss of five ships and one corvette; 28 ships arrived safely.[5][6] Following this action the Senior Officer Escort (SOE) - commander of the group - was "warmly congratulated" for preventing what could have been a major disaster,[6] and the contrast with HX 79 was apparent.

In practice, escort group cohesion was impaired by frequent changes of escort personnel and transferring ships between groups.[7] Personnel shuffling was inevitable as trained crewmen with combat experience were promoted and transferred to the expanding fleet of new ships.[8] Shuffling of ships from one escort group to another was often necessary to maintain escort group strength by replacing ships temporarily disabled by battle damage or the frequent machinery breakdowns of older warships.[9] The following list includes some duplication reflecting reassignments at the time of compilation. The original eight escort groups and the Canadian 14th through 25th escort groups were reorganized into the Mid-Ocean Escort Force (MOEF) in February and March 1942 with ships of the 9th Escort Group serving as leaders of MOEF groups B1 through B5. The ships of the earlier groups which had only a short range and were unsuitable for MOEF duty were reassigned to the Western Local Escort Force or duty with coastal convoys or the arctic convoys supplying the Soviet Union. The 36th through 44th escort groups remained relatively unchanged escorting convoys between Liverpool and Gibraltar and Sierra Leone.[10]

Organization

The following escort groups had been formed prior to United States Navy escort participation in the autumn of 1941:[11]

1st Escort Group

HMS Keppel was a World War I flotilla leader.

2nd Escort Group

Town-class destroyers received in the Destroyers for Bases Agreement were widely distributed among the escort groups.

3rd Escort Group

HMS Amazon was a unique prototype.

4th Escort Group

5th Escort Group

Flower-class corvettes became the most numerous of the ship types assigned to escort groups.

6th Escort Group

7th Escort Group

8th Escort Group

9th Escort Group

The homogeneous 9th Escort Group of Havant-class destroyers was broken up to provide group leaders for the Mid-Ocean Escort Force.

10th Escort Group

V and W-class destroyers of the homogeneous 10th Escort Group represented the most common class of World War I veteran destroyers in the escort groups.

11th Escort Group

Ships with Polish crews were assigned to the 11th Escort Group.

12th Escort Group

Hunt-class destroyers were assigned to the homogeneous 12th Escort Group.

14th Escort Group

Canadian ships like HMCS Saguenay served with Royal Navy ships in the Canadian 14th through 24th escort groups screening convoys through the western North Atlantic.

15th Escort Group

16th Escort Group

17th Escort Group

18th Escort Group

19th Escort Group

20th Escort Group

21st Escort Group

22nd Escort Group

23rd Escort Group

24th Escort Group

25th Escort Group

36th Escort Group

Black Swan-class sloops were among the best of the various classes forming the 36th through 44th escort groups.

37th Escort Group

Hastings-class sloops were designed and constructed between the world wars for use as convoy escorts.

40th Escort Group

Banff-class sloops were former United States Coast Guard cutters loaned to the Royal Navy in 1941.

41st Escort Group

42nd Escort Group

43rd Escort Group

44th Escort Group

See also

References

Citations

  1. ↑ Hague 2000 p.23
  2. ↑ Roskill 1954, p. 00.
  3. ↑ 3.0 3.1 Elliott 1977, p. 59
  4. ↑ Collingwood 1998, p. 00.
  5. ↑ Blair 1996, p. 118.
  6. ↑ 6.0 6.1 Blair 1996, p. 119
  7. ↑ Milner, p.192
  8. ↑ Milner, p.56
  9. ↑ Milner, p.98
  10. ↑ Mason, Geoffrey B. "HMS Malcolm (D 19) - Scott-class Flotilla Leader". Service Histories of Royal Navy Warships in World War 2. edited by Gordon Smith. naval-history.net. Retrieved 18 January 2014.
  11. ↑ Rohwer & Hummelchen, pp.83 & 89

Bibliography