Enzyme potentiated desensitization

Enzyme potentiated desensitization, or EPD, is a treatment for allergies developed in the 1960s by Dr. Len McEwen in the United Kingdom. EPD uses much lower doses of antigens than conventional treatment, with the addition of an enzyme, β-glucuronidase. EPD is available in the United Kingdom, Canada for the treatment of hay fever, food allergy and intolerance and environmental allergies.

EPD was under development for the treatment of autoimmune disease by a United Kingdom company called Epidyme also owned by Dr. McEwen which has been granted a United Kingdom patent. Despite encouraging results[1] in an experimental model of rheumatoid arthritis the company was placed into liquidation in April 2010.[2]

United States use

EPD was available in the United States until 2001, when the Food and Drug Administration revoked approval for an investigative study which it had previously sanctioned which had allowed EPD to be imported into the USA without being licensed. The reason given for revoking approval was that complex mixtures of allergens used in EPD treatments were not allowed under FDA rules. Since then the FDA has banned importation of EPD[3] for the following reasons:-.

A related treatment, Low Dose Allergens (LDA), has been developed in the US by Dr. Shrader, which, being a compounding rather than a drug, is not regulated by the FDA, and uses a different allergen mix for the US environment. However, LDA is considered by many in the field to just be a repackaging of EPD that allows its use to not be subject to the same FDA guidelines that caused EPD to be revoked.[4][5][6]

EPD treatment

The enzyme beta glucuronidase appears to potentiate the desensitizing effect of a small dose of allergen. The quantities of both are smaller than those occurring naturally in the body, but not so small that they can be regarded as homeopathic. Intradermal injections are used. The treatment takes 3–4 weeks before any effect is seen. For food and environmental allergies and intolerances treatments are typically given at two monthly intervals at first, but the interval between treatments is gradually lengthened. Hay fever is treated with two shots of EPD outside the pollen season.

Mechanism for EPD

The treatment uses dilutions of allergen and enzyme to which T-regulatory lymphocytes are believed to respond by favouring desensitization, or down-regulation, rather than sensitization. Once activated these lymphocytes travel to lymph nodes and reproduce or stimulate similar T-lymphocytes.

Evidence for the Effectiveness of EPD

EPD is considered experimental by some doctors and allergists. However, there is evidence for the efficacy of EPD in the treatment of hay fever and other conditions as a result of nine placebo-controlled, double-blind trials involving 271 patients. These trials showed a significant improvement in the symptoms with probabilities of 0.001 to 0.01 (a chance of one in a thousand to one in a hundred that the results of the trial would be seen by chance alone assuming EPD had no effect).[7][8][9][10][11][12][13][14] However, one trial involving 183 patients published in the British Medical Journal showed no overall effect.[15] Dr Len McEwen, inventor of EPD, speculated[16] that the reason for the failure might have been that the beta glucuronidase enzyme preparation was inadvertently heated or frozen during storage in the hospital pharmacy, as it is sensitive to the storage temperature and enzyme from the same manufactured batch had been used to treat a number of patients successfully. However, there is no evidence available after the event to test this theory as the remaining trial materials were destroyed immediately after the trial ended.

Safety of EPD

While the efficacy of EPD is sometimes the subject of controversy among the medical community, the safety of EPD is demonstrated in one study under the control of an Investigational Review Board and reported by the American EPD Society. 5,400 patients received at least 3 doses of EPD with no severe reactions reported.[17] However, there is at least one known person who has had very serious health complication due to EPD. He went through the treatment in the 90's, and his health was devastated from it. He was relatively healthy before the EPD, with only minor to moderate allergies that he was dealing with, but within hours of the first EPD treatment became seriously ill and was never the same again. Clearly this person was not included in the above study described above, and therefore one may question where this study was done in an unbiased way, since the author was quite aware of this person whose life was devastated by EPD, but somehow managed to find a reason not to include this negative data into the study.

Comparison of EPD with conventional escalating-dose immunotherapy (hyposensitization)

By contrast uncontrolled use of conventional (escalating dose) immunotherapy (hyposensitization not EPD) for general allergic conditions was believed to be responsible for at least 29 deaths in the UK, and is now banned in the United Kingdom except in hospital under close observation.[18] A working party of the British Society for Allergy and Clinical Immunology reviewed the role of conventional high dose specific allergen immunotherapy (not EPD) in the treatment of allergic disease and recommends high dose specific allergen immunotherapy for treating summer hay fever uncontrolled by conventional medication and for wasp and bee venom hypersensitivity. For the recommended indications the risk:benefit ratio was found to be acceptable for conventional immunotherapy provided patients are carefully selected; in particular, patients with asthma should be excluded and injections should be given only by allergists experienced in this form of treatment in a clinic where resuscitative facilities are available and patients remain symptom free for an observation period after injection which is sufficient to detect all serious adverse reactions.[19]

Conventional escalating-dose immunotherapy (not EPD) has been used to treat tens of millions of people in the United States with appropriate medical supervision with a death rate of less than one in one million according to the American Academy of Allergy, Asthma, and Immunology.

Restrictions on EPD

EPD has not been developed for treatment of allergy to insect stings (for which convenventional immunotherapy is recommended), nor for contact dermatitis and allergy to drugs.[20] It is not FDA approved.

EPD protocol includes high doses of folic acid that may increase blood histamine levels. EPD may be contraindicated for patients diagnosed with high blood histamine (histadelia). To screen for high blood histamine, look for an elevated basophil count. If the basophil level is elevated, high blood histamine can be confirmed with a blood histamine test.

If blood histamine becomes elevated during the course of EPD treatments, the patient may develop new or increased sensitivity to any environmental agent, including food, inhalant and even clothing fiber. Increased sensitivity may present as acute, rapid-onset headaches and/or asthma attacks.

An elevated blood histamine level may also introduce or increase suicidal tendencies.

References

  1. ↑ EPD treatment of rheumatoid arthritis proof of concept results on Epidyme website use of EPD to treat autoimmune diseases.
  2. ↑ Insolvency List
  3. ↑ FDA Import Alert
  4. ↑ EPD & LDA
  5. ↑ LDA Therapy
  6. ↑ Low Dose Immunotherapy
  7. ↑ Brostoff J., Fell P. (1990). "A single dose desensitisation for summer hay fever". Eur. J. Clin Pharmacol. 38 (1): 77–9. doi:10.1007/BF00314808. PMID 2328752.
  8. ↑ Astarita C., Scala G., Spoviero S., Franseze A. (1996). "Effect of enzyme potentiated desensitisation in the treatment of pollenosis : A double-blind placebo-controlled trial". J Investig Allergol Clin Immunol 6 (4): 248–255. PMID 8844502.
  9. ↑ Longo G., PoIi F., Bertoli G. (1992). "Clinical efficacy of a new hyposensitising treatment, EPD (Enzyme Potentiated Desensitisation) in the therapy of pollenosis". Riforma Med. (107): 171–6.
  10. ↑ Angelini G., Curatoli G., D’Argento V., Vena G. A. Pollinosi (1993). "Una nuova metodica di immunoterapia". Med. J. Surg. Med.: 253–6.
  11. ↑ Di Stanislao C. Di Berardino L., Bianchi I., Bologna G. (1997). "A double-blind, placebo-controlled study of preventive immunotherapy with EPD in the treatment of seasonal allergic disease". Allergie et lmmunologie 30 (2): 39–42.
  12. ↑ Caramia G., Franceschini F., Cimarelli Z.A., Ciucchi M.S., Gagliardini R., Rufllni E. (1996). "The efficacy of EPD, a new immunotherapy, in the treatment of allergic diseases in children". Allergie et lmmunologie. 28 (9): 308–310.
  13. ↑ Di Stanislao C., Angelini F. et al. (2002). "Beta glucuronidase short-term immunotherapy prevents seasonal rhinoconjunctivitis in grass pollen allergic patients by modifying dendritic cell phenotype". Allergy 57 (Suppl 73): 76–7. doi:10.1034/j.1398-9995.57.s73.81.x.
  14. ↑ Boscolo M. A., Brivio G. "E.P.D. preventive therapy (McEwen method) vs. placebo: a double-blind trial". Poster presentation. European Congress of Allergy & Clinical Immunology. Brussels, July 1999.
  15. ↑ Radcliffe M. J., Lewith G. T., Turner R. G., Prescott P., Church M. K., Holgate S. T. (August 2003). "Enzyme potentiated desensitisation in treatment of seasonal allergic rhinitis: double blind randomised controlled study". British Medical Journal. 327 (7409): 251–4. doi:10.1136/bmj.327.7409.251. PMC 167158. PMID 12896934.
  16. ↑ Epidyme website Enzyme Potentiated Desensitisation (EPD) A promising low-dose method of immunotherapy. Dr. Len McEwen BM., BCh. unpublished paper.
  17. ↑ Shrader, W A; Wilkinson R E (September 2001). "The American EPD Study: 1993–2000" (PDF). White Paper for United States Senators and Representatives. Enzyme Potentiated Desensitization (EPD). p. 14. Retrieved 2006-09-16.
  18. ↑ JA Douglass, FC Thien and RE O'Hehir (1997). "Immunotherapy in asthma". Thorax (52): 22–29.
  19. ↑ AJ Frew (1993). "Injection immunotherapy. British Society for Allergy and Clinical Immunology Working Party". BMJ 307 (6909): 919–23. doi:10.1136/bmj.307.6909.919. PMC 1679037. PMID 8241857.
  20. ↑ L.M. McEwen "Enzyme Potentiated Desensistization" (patient pink handbook) 1993