E. Fuller Torrey

E. Fuller Torrey
Born Edwin Fuller Torrey
September 6, 1937
Utica, New York
Nationality American
Fields Psychiatry
Institutions Stanley Medical Research Institute (SMRI), Treatment Advocacy Center (TAC)

Edwin Fuller Torrey (born September 6, 1937), is an American psychiatrist and schizophrenia researcher. He is executive director of the Stanley Medical Research Institute (SMRI) and founder of the Treatment Advocacy Center (TAC), a nonprofit organization whose principal activity is promoting the passage and implementation of outpatient commitment laws and civil commitment laws and standards in individual states that allow people diagnosed with mental illness to be forcibly committed and medicated easily throughout the United States.[1][2]

Torrey has conducted numerous research studies, particularly on possible infectious causes of schizophrenia. He has become well known as an advocate of the idea that severe mental illness is due to biological factors and not social factors.[3] He has appeared on national radio and television outlets and written for many newspapers. He has received two Commendation Medals by the U.S. Public Health Service and numerous other awards and tributes. He has been criticized by a range of people, including federal researchers and others for some of his attacks on de-institutionalization and his support for forced medication as a method of treatment.[4]

Torrey is on the board of the Treatment Advocacy Center (TAC), which describes itself as being "a national nonprofit advocacy organization.[5] TAC supports involuntary treatment when deemed appropriate by a judge (at the urging of the person's psychiatrist and family members). Torrey has written several best-selling books on mental illness, including Surviving Schizophrenia. He is also a distant relative of abolitionist Charles Turner Torrey and has written his biography.

Education and early career

Torrey earned his bachelor's degree, magna cum laude, from Princeton University, and his medical doctor's degree from the McGill University School of Medicine. Torrey also earned a master's degree in anthropology from Stanford University, and was trained in psychiatry at Stanford University School of Medicine. At McGill and later at Stanford, he was exposed to a biological approach and recalls that one of his first-year instructors at McGill was Heinz Lehmann, the first clinician in North America to use the first antipsychotic, chlorpromazine. The medical school was housed next door to the Montreal Neurological Institute, a premier neuroscience center.[6]

Torrey then practiced general medicine in Ethiopia for two years as a Peace Corps physician and in the South Bronx. From 1970 to 1975, he was a special administrative assistant to the NIMH director. He then worked for year in Alaska in the Indian Health Service. He then became a ward physician at St. Elizabeth’s psychiatric hospital in Washington, D.C.[4] for nine years, where he reportedly worked with the most challenging patients and aimed to avoid the use of seclusion or restraints on the acute admission units.[6] He also volunteered at Washington homeless clinics.[7]

Stanley Medical Research Institute

Torrey is the founder and Executive Director of the Stanley Medical Research Institute (SMRI), a large, private provider of research on schizophrenia and bipolar disorder in the US. SMRI also maintains a collection of postmortem brain tissue from individuals with schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, and major depression and from unaffected controls, which are made available to researchers without charge.

After reading Torrey's book Surviving Schizophrenia, Theodore Stanley, a businessman who had made a fortune in direct-mail marketing and whose son had been diagnosed in the late 1980s with bipolar disorder, contacted Torrey and he and his wife provided the funds for the new institute.[8]

As of 2004 the Stanley Institute had 30 employees and funded half of all U.S. research on bipolar disorder and about a quarter of all schizophrenia research. In 2003 the institute's rapidly growing research budget exceeded $40 million, 74 percent of which was given out to other researchers through grants.[8] It reports that 75% of its expenditure goes towards the development of new treatments.[9]

The Stanley Medical Institute in Bethesda Maryland has collected in excess of 600 brains.[10] In ARCH GEN PSYCHIATRY/VOL 61, NOV 2004, in a report called, "Brain Anatomy in Adults With Velocardiofacial Syndrome With and Without Schizophrenia", SMRI published results of a Structural Magnetic Resonance Imaging Study showing difference in brain structure of people with and without schizophrenia.

The SMRI has been sued for allegedly taking brains for use in research without proper consent. One lawsuit was settled out of court.[11][12]

As of 2008 SMRI was also supporting the Stanley Center for Psychiatric Research at the Broad Institute, which plans to scan the entire genome for variants that predispose to schizophrenia and bipolar disorder, and screen hundreds of thousands of compounds against new molecular targets prior to clinical testing.[13] The center was co-founded by Pamela Sklar, who published the first statistically meaningful gene identifications in schizophrenia and has demonstrated that schizophrenia is likely caused by many rare genetic variants.[14][15]

SMRI reports that it has a close relationship with and is the supporting organization for the Treatment Advocacy Center (TAC).[9]

Treatment Advocacy Center

Torrey is a founder of the Treatment Advocacy Center, a national organization that supports outpatient commitment for certain people with mental illness who, in his view of their treatment history and present circumstances, are judged unlikely to survive safely in the community without supervision. TAC has been credited by New York State Attorney General Eliot Spitzer and others with helping pass Kendra's Law in the state. Kendra's Law allows court-ordered involuntary treatment of people diagnosed with schizophrenia or other severe mental illness who have a history of not following psychiatric advice, i.e., individuals who are, "as a result of his or her mental illness, unlikely to voluntarily participate in the recommended treatment pursuant to the treatment plan."[16] Previously, only inpatient programs were available to submit a person to involuntary treatment. TAC's efforts to pass Kendra's Law led to similar successful passage of Laura's Law in California, and similar laws in Florida and elsewhere. Torrey has testified numerous times in front of Congress.

National Alliance on Mental Illness

Torrey was for many years an active advisor for the National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI). Parents felt that he spoke up for them when much of the medical establishment had previously held that parenting was responsible for schizophrenia. Torrey helped build NAMI into a powerful political force through campaigning and donating the hardcover royalties from the sale of his book Surviving Schizophrenia.[7]

Although Torrey, TAC, and NAMI remain aligned, NAMI may have tried to distance itself from TAC in 1998. One source The Psychiatric Times, reported that TAC was designed from the start to be "a separate support organization with its own source of funding."[17] According to MindFreedom International, an association of survivors of psychiatric treatment opposed to involuntary treatment, NAMI severed its relationship with TAC because of pressure from groups opposed to Torrey both from within NAMI and outside NAMI. Torrey is, according to MindFreedom, one of 'the most feverishly pro-force psychiatrists in the world'. MindFreedom suggests that the 'links between NAMI and TAC are simply going from overt to covert.'[18]

In 2002, NAMI's Executive Director issued a statement highly critical of 60 Minutes for producing a piece entitled "Dr. Torrey's War." In the statement, NAMI alternately criticized and backed various positions espoused by Torrey while aiming its criticism at 60 Minutes for what NAMI called "sound bite journalism."[19]

Torrey was also the keynote speaker at the 23rd annual NAMI convention in 2002.[20]

In 2005, NAMI gave Torrey a tribute on its 25th Anniversary Celebratory Donor Wall, for those who have donated over $25,000. It called him a groundbreaking researcher, a ferociously resolute advocate, a prominent and admired author of dozens of books and a dedicated practicing clinician, and said that he had "touched the lives of countless NAMI members throughout this nation."[21]

NAMI has some continuing links to TAC via their board of directors. One individual, Frederick Frese, is presently on both the NAMI and TAC boards. TAC has two other former NAMI board members on their board and Laurie Flynn, the former NAMI executive director, is part of the TAC Honorary Advisory Committee.

In 2008, Torrey disagreed with a NAMI view on second-generation antipsychotics and accused the medical director and executive director of failing to disclose conflicts of interest, because they are employees of an organization that receives more than half its budget from pharmaceutical companies. He argued they were not representing the views of many members of NAMI including himself.[22]

Scientific research and views

In the 1950s, it was commonly thought that schizophrenia was caused by 'bad parenting'. Torrey has argued that this theory had a toxic effect on parents. His sister had severe schizophrenia and spent most of five decades in hospitals and nursing homes until her death.[6]

Torrey has been a fierce opponent of the influence of Sigmund Freud and psychoanalysis. He has also argued that psychiatry should focus only on severe mental illness, conceived as neurological disorders, rather than other mental issues that he viewed as non-medical.[23][24]

Torrey was principal investigator of a NIMH Schizophrenia/Bipolar Disorder Twin Study conducted at the Neuroscience center of St Elizabeth's Hospital in the late 1980s/early 1990s, and copublished more than a dozen studies on structural brain differences between affected and unaffected siblings.[6] He differed from his collaborators in arguing that the genetic heritability of schizophrenia was lower than typically estimated.[23][25] A review of Torrey's data analysis, however, suggested he had erroneously compared different sorts of concordance statistics.[26]

In the early 1970s, Torrey became interested in viral infections as possible causes of schizophrenia or bipolar disorder, particularly a parasite Toxoplasma gondii whose definitive host is the cat, but whose intermediate host can be any mammal, including humans.[23] Up to one third of the world's human population is estimated to carry a Toxoplasma infection.[27] Since then he has published, often with Robert Yolken, more than 30 articles on seasonal variation and possible infectious causes of schizophrenia, focusing especially on Toxoplasma gondii. He is involved in five or six ongoing studies using anti-Toxoplasmosa gondii agents (e.g. antibiotics such as minocycline and azithromycin[28][29]) as an add-on treatment for schizophrenia. He believes that infectious causes will eventually explain the "vast majority" of schizophrenia cases.[6] Some of his collaborators have disagreed with the emphasis he has placed on infection as a direct causal factor.[23] Many of the research studies on links between schizophrenia and Toxoplasma gondii, by different authors in different countries, are funded and supported by the Stanley Medical Research Institute. The hypothesis is not prominent in current mainstream scientific views on the causes of schizophrenia, although infections may be seen as one possible risk factor that could lead to vulnerabilities in early neurodevelopment in some cases.

Torrey has generally been in favor of antipsychotic drugs. He has claimed that taking antipsychotics reduces the risk of violence, homelessness and prison. He has argued that "noncompliance" in about half of cases of schizophrenia and bipolar disorder is due to lack of "insight" into the illness because the part of the brain for self-awareness has been affected; and that in some who are aware it is due to adverse effects ranging from tremors or sedation to sexual dysfunction to substantial weight gain.[30] He has also reported that at least some antipsychotics cause medical conditions that can be fatal in some people, especially African Americans.[31] He has also argued that pharmaceutical companies have too much influence over psychiatric organizations and psychiatrists, effectively buying them off.[32]

Torrey has advocated in favor of a flexible well-funded range of community mental health services, including Assertive Community Treatment, clubhouses (staffed by professionals with consumers as members), supported housing and supported employment, emphasizing illness and medication compliance throughout.[30]

Recognition

Torrey has appeared on national radio and television (outlets like NPR, Oprah, 20/20, 60 Minutes, and Dateline) and has written for many newspapers. He has received a 1984 Special Families Award from NAMI, two Commendation Medals from the U.S. Public Health Service, a 1991 National Caring Award, and a humanitarian award from NARSAD (now known as the Brain & Behavior Research Foundation). In 1999, he received a research award from the International Congress of Schizophrenia. In 2005, a tribute to Torrey was included in NAMI's 25th Anniversary Celebratory Donor Wall.[33]

Criticism

Torrey has criticized many organizations. He has charged the National Institute of Mental Health with not concentrating its resources sufficiently on severe mental illness and directly applicable research; NIMH has disputed his statistics and viewpoint.[34]

Torrey has been charged with acting to limit the voice of those consumers, survivors and ex-patients that he disagrees with, opposing their civil rights and censoring and ridiculing their ideas and those of their supporters. Torrey has been a long-time critic of the Center for Mental Health Services that provides support and advocacy, on the grounds that they support anti-psychiatry groups and those opposed to outpatient commitment, claiming they neglect the seriously mentally ill due to a hippie 60s attitude, distribute funds on the basis of other factors such as "community cohesion" and ethnic minority involvement, and are more dysfunctional than the individuals they are supposed to help.[35] He has specifically opposed public funding for the National Empowerment Center, for rejecting the medical model and arguing for a recovery model without necessarily needing medication; it has since lost its funding from the CMHS.[36] Torrey has in general been instrumental in lobbying against, and undermining, community-based consumer projects because they promoted social and experiential recovery and questioned the standard medical model. Consumer organizations have protested that they are already economically disadvantaged and vulnerable to political whim while Torrey and his organizations have rich and powerful backers.[37] It has been argued that Torrey and other psychiatric and family member advocates do not necessarily have the same interests as consumers/survivors themselves. Differences in ideology sharpened after the development of NAMI.[38] In criticizing the New freedom commission on mental health for not recommending forced outpatient medicating, Torrey claimed that stigma against people with mental disorders was largely due to them committing violent acts due to not taking medication, and called the recovery model harmful for sending a cruel message of hope, or implicit blame, to those he believes cannot engage in a recovery process, despite being a laudable long-term vision for the Commission.[37][39] Torrey hopes to live long enough to see vaccines to prevent many or most cases of schizophrenia.[6]

Although Torrey described family members as "surviving schizophrenia" in his book of that title, in 1997 he said the term "psychiatric survivor" used by ex-patients to describe themselves was just political correctness and he blamed them, along with civil rights lawyers, for the deaths of half a million people due to suicides and deaths on the street.[40] His comments elicited a record number of letters in response, some in favour of Torrey but most against.[41] The accusations have been described as inflammatory and completely unsubstantiated, and issues of self-determination and self-identity said to be more complex than Torrey realizes.[41] In the same journal in 1999, Torrey and Miller of the Stanley Foundation Research Program argued for an incentivised schizophrenia treatment system backed by a credible threat of force, modelled on that used for the fatal infectious disease Tuberculosis;[42] replies criticized the logic of the analogy and resort to forced drugging rather than developing alliances and understanding, to which Torrey accused the director and members of MindFreedom International of living off federal funds while denying illness and not caring about the mentally ill on the streets and in prisons.[43][44]

Torrey has been a vocal critic of the failures of deinstitutionalization and inadequate community mental health services. He has generally linked this to issues of violence, homelessness and medication noncompliance, as well as lack of proper focus by the relevant governmental organizations.[45] He has been accused of gaining influence by sensationalizing and exaggerating the incidence of violence and its link to medication noncompliance, including disseminating unsubstantiated and unreliable statistics. When a California NAMI journal editor included a questioning of Torrey's statistics, the local board glued together the pages and effectively shut down the journal.[46][37] Others, while agreeing that public mental health care in the U.S. falls far short of what people with serious psychiatric disorders need and deserve, have argued that Torrey's solutions are outdated and that his book The Insanity Offense is based on unsubstantiated portrayals of certainty on the statistics on violence, outpatient commitment and medication, stigmatizing tens of thousands of people, deeply offending and insulting those who hold views differing from his own, and promulgating one-dimensional solutions. TAC's attempts to associate violent incidents in the news with lack of medication have been described as wild hyperbole, and the use of the term "assisted treatment" has been described as a euphemism for forced drugging.[47]

Torrey has been criticized by, and has criticized, Thomas Szasz, a libertarian psychiatrist and author of The Myth of Mental Illness who is opposed to involuntary treatment.[48][49] Torrey has said he admires Szasz for his outspoken criticisms of many psychiatric practices, including "diagnostic creep" (disease mongering) and the potential for the political abuse of psychiatric labels, but that when it comes to Szasz not seeing schizophrenia as a disease of the brain exactly like Parkinson's and Multiple Sclerosis then he is one of his most vocal critics.

Bibliography

Torrey has authored 20 books and more than 200 lay and professional papers.[50]

See also

References

  1. ↑ "Treatment Advocacy Center". Retrieved 2007-10-02.
  2. ↑ "Response to National Review article" (PDF). ncmhr.org. National Coalition for Mental Health Recovery. 16 August 2013.
  3. ↑ Princeton Alumni News, 11/5/2003
  4. ↑ 4.0 4.1 Tom Nugent (2003). "Renegade psychiatrist Fuller Torrey has taken on fiery critics, federal researchers and Freud in a decades-long search for the causes of schizophrenia". Stanford Alumni Magazine. Retrieved 2007-10-02.
  5. ↑
  6. ↑ 6.0 6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 Moran, M. (2007) Search for Schizophrenia's Roots Started at Home Psychiatr News July 6, Volume 42, Number 13, page 17
  7. ↑ 7.0 7.1 Winerip, M. (1998) Schizophrenia's Most Zealous Foe New York Times, February 22
  8. ↑ 8.0 8.1 Maine news, sports, weather & breaking news | The Portland Press Herald / Maine Sunday Telegram
  9. ↑ 9.0 9.1 Overview
  10. ↑ PDF
  11. ↑ A Dispute Over Brain Donations
  12. ↑ Stanley Medical Research Institute organ donation
  13. ↑ Overview Center for Psychiatric Research
  14. ↑ Studies show no smoking guns, or lots of them, in schizophrenia | BioWorld
  15. ↑ http://www.nytimes.com/2008/07/31/health/research/31gene.html
  16. ↑ AOT Summary
  17. ↑
  18. ↑
  19. ↑ NAMI | NAMI Condemns CBS's 60 MinutesFor
  20. ↑
  21. ↑ https://www.nami.org/customsource/donation/TorreyTribute.cfm
  22. ↑ Torrey, E.F. (2008) A Question of Disclosure Psychiatr Serv 59:935, August 2008 doi:10.1176/appi.ps.59.8.935
  23. ↑ 23.0 23.1 23.2 23.3 Mihm, S. (2001) Pet Theory: Do Cats Cause Schizophrenia? The New York Times Magazine on the Web
  24. ↑ Stevens, L. Why Psychiatry Should Be Abolished as a Medical Specialty Retrieved on Aug-10-2008
  25. ↑ Torrey, EF (1992). "Are we overestimating the genetic contribution to schizophrenia?". Schizophrenia bulletin 18 (2): 159–70. doi:10.1093/schbul/18.2.159. PMID 1621064.
  26. ↑ McGue, M. (1992). "When assessing twin concordance, use the probandwise not the pairwise rate". Schizophr Bull 18 (2): 171–6. doi:10.1093/schbul/18.2.171. PMID 1621065.
  27. ↑ Montoya J, Liesenfeld O (2004). "Toxoplasmosis". Lancet 363 (9425): 1965–76. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(04)16412-X. PMID 15194258.
  28. ↑ [Comparative activity of severa... [Enferm Infecc Microbiol Clin. 1993] - PubMed - NCBI
  29. ↑ The ketolide antibiotics HMR 3647 and HMR 3004 are active against Toxoplasma gondii in vitro and in murine models of infection
  30. ↑ 30.0 30.1 E. Fuller Torrey Reinventing Mental Health Care City Journal, Autumn 1999
  31. ↑
  32. ↑ E. Fuller Torrey (2002) The Going Rate on Shrinks: Big Pharma and the buying of psychiatry The American Prospect, July 14.
  33. ↑ Treatment Advocacy Center PRESIDENT, E. FULLER TORREY, M.D. Retrieved on Aug-10-2008
  34. ↑
  35. ↑ http://www.accessmylibrary.com/coms2/summary_0286-25288801_ITM
  36. ↑ 車見積＠ネット活用でここまで差が出る車の買取価格！
  37. ↑ 37.0 37.1 37.2 McLean, A. (2003) Recovering Consumers and a Broken Mental Health System in the United States: Ongoing Challenges for Consumers/ Survivors and the New Freedom Commission on Mental Health. Part II: Impact of Managed Care and Continuing Challenges International Journal of Psychosocial Rehabilitation. 8, 58-70.
  38. ↑ McLean, A. (2003). Recovering Consumers and a Broken Mental Health System in the United States: Ongoing Challenges for Consumers/ Survivors and the New Freedom Commission on Mental Health. Part I: Legitimization of the Consumer Movement and Obstacles to It. International Journal of Psychosocial Rehabilitation. 8, 47-57
  39. ↑ Torrey (2003) Treatment Advocacy Center Statement Newswire. Retrieved on Aug 12 2008
  40. ↑ E. Fuller Torrey (1997) Taking Issue: ‘Psychiatric Survivors’ and Non-Survivors, 48:2 Psychiatric Services 143
  41. ↑ 41.0 41.1 Reaume, G (2002). "Lunatic to patient to person: nomenclature in psychiatric history and the influence of patients' activism in North America.". International journal of law and psychiatry 25 (4): 405–26. doi:10.1016/S0160-2527(02)00130-9. PMID 12613052.
  42. ↑ E. Fuller Torrey, M.D and Judy Miller, B.A. Can Psychiatry Learn From Tuberculosis Treatment? Psychiatr Serv 50:1389, November 1999
  43. ↑ Hughes, W.C. (2001) Schizophrenia Is Not Contagious Psychiatr Serv 52:384, March 2001
  44. ↑ Letters to psychiatric services journal, March 2001
  45. ↑ Torrey, E.F. & Zdanowicz, M. (1998) Why deinstitutionalization turned deadly The Wall Street Journal August 4
  46. ↑
  47. ↑ Richard Gosden and Sharon Beder, Pharmaceutical Industry Agenda Setting in Mental Health Policies, Ethical Human Sciences and Services 3(3) Fall/Winter 2001, pp. 147-159.
  48. ↑ Szasz T.(2004) Psychiatric Fraud and Force: A Critique of E. Fuller Torrey J Humanist Psychol 2004;4:416-430. PDF
  49. ↑ Sullum, J. (2005) Thomas Szasz Takes on His Critics: Is mental illness an insane idea? Reason Online, May 2005
  50. ↑ List of publications on Google citations

External links