Concussions in American football

Debate regarding the health effects of concussions on American football players has caused considerable controversy. Concussions and other types of play-related traumatic brain injuries have been proposed as a major cause of player suicides and other symptoms after retirement, including memory loss, depression and chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE).

The list of ex-NFL players that have either presented post-mortem with CTE, or otherwise have either reported symptoms or been diagnosed with CTE, continues to grow.

Concussions in the National Football League

There has been a problem for about 20 years regarding the longterm damage of repeated concussions among National Football League (NFL) players, often as a result of contradicting study results published by the NFL. However, by 2010, the NFL finally acknowledged that many of its ex-players were suffering from Chronic traumatic encephalopathy ('CTE').[1]

On September 30th, 2014, it was announced that 76 of the 79 brains of former NFL players studied by Dr. Ann McKee and her colleagues tested positive for CTE. The study conducted was the largest brain bank study to date and was a twofold increase in the number of confirmed cases of CTE. [2]

In 1994, then NFL Commissioner Paul Tagliabue approved the creation of the MTBI Committee with the stated goal of studying the effects of concussions and sub-concussive injury in NFL players. Tagliabue appointed rheumatologist Dr. Elliot Pellman to chair the committee.[3] Pellman's appointment was met with harsh criticism, because he is not a neurologist or neuropsychologist and often admitted ignorance about head injuries.[3]

The same year, the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) reported a statistically significant increase in the risk of neurological disorders such as amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) in retired football players, which furthered public knowledge about the risk of long-term neurocognitive disease related to repeated head impacts.[4] Despite the NIOSH study, Pellman and the MTBI Committee drew their own conclusions that continued to contradict these findings and those of other organizations. Biomechanical engineers and neurosurgeons informed the Committee that the helmet safety standard at that time was insufficient to minimize the risk of concussions.[5]

The MTBI Committee began studying the nature of tackle plays resulting in concussive impacts and developing its own biomechanical analysis of the effect of these forces on the brain.[6] It started publishing study results in 2003 that stated there were no long-term negative health consequences associated with concussions sustained by NFL players. A six-year study by the Committee concluded that, "Players who are concussed and return to the same game have fewer initial signs and symptoms than those removed from play. Return to play does not involve a significant risk of a second injury either in the same game or during the season."[7]

Other organizations continued to publish study results that linked repeated concussions and long-term health problems contrary to reports by the MTBI Committee. A 2003 report by the Center for the Study of Retired Athletes at the University of North Carolina, for example, found a connection between numerous concussions and depression among former professional football players. Further, the Center's follow-up study in 2005 associated both brain impairment and Alzheimer's disease with retired NFL players who had histories of concussions.[8]

A 2004 doctoral dissertation by Don Brady examined NFL Players’ knowledge of concussions, studying both active and retired National Football League Players' knowledge of concussions. Dr. Brady's findings concluded: that many NFL players lacked accurate and essential knowledge pertaining to various aspects of a concussion; that the preponderance of credible experimental and clinical evidence pertaining to the adverse effects of concussion indicates that the brain is injured as a result of a concussion; that the altered cell functioning and cell death along with subtle to more visible neurological, neurocognitive, psychological, and other medical problems reflect a diverse range of lifelong negative consequences of a concussion / brain injury; and that sports team health-care personnel need to focus primarily on the athletes’ health and well-being, and not minimize an injury or primarily concentrate on the players’ capacity to perform on the field. This expanded focus of health care is necessary in order to avoid any real or perceived conflicts of interest emerging in the concussion research, concussion management and related return to play decision-making process. .[9]

During November 2014 Don Brady, PhD, PsyD, NCSP filed Objections to the Proposed NFL Concussion Settlement Offer. Dr. Brady sent a Cover letter and detailed Objections on behalf of NFL Retired players to the presiding US District Court Judge, Anita Brody. Copies of both the Cover letter and Objections may be obtained at the following website: http://www.footballvets.org/blog/2014/11/dr-don-brady-files-objection/.

In addition to the studies that continued to contradict the work of the MTBI Committee, renowned experts and sports journalists wrote critical reviews of the Committee's studies. Dr. Robert Cantu of the American College of Sports Medicine noted bias in the committee's extremely small sample size and held that no conclusions should be drawn from the NFL's studies.[10] In an ESPN Magazine article titled "Doctor Yes," Peter Keating criticized Pellman and the MTBI Committee's work and argued that the "... Committee has drawn a number of important conclusions about head trauma and how to treat it that contradict the research and experiences of many other doctors who treat sports concussions, not to mention the players who have suffered them."[3]

More studies continued to associate repetitive head injuries with neurological problems later in life. Dr. Kevin Guskiewicz, Director of the Center for the Study of Retired Athletes in the Department of Exercise and Sport Science at the University of North Carolina, analyzed data from a 2007 study of nearly 2,500 former NFL players. He found about 11 percent of the study participants suffered from clinical depression, with a threefold increased risk in former players who had a history of three or four concussions.[11] The following year, the NFL commissioned the University of Michigan Institute for Social Research to conduct a study involving more than 1,000 former NFL players. The results reported that Alzheimer's disease or similar diseases appear to have been diagnosed in former NFL players vastly more often than in the general population at a rate of 19 times the normal rate for men ages 30 through 49. The NFL responded to these results by claiming the study was incomplete.[12]

In October 2009, NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell and the NFL Concussion Committee were called before Congress to defend their policies against allegations of neglect.[13][14] Goodell provided testimony, but was unable to answer many questions, as none of the primary authors of the league’s research, Dr. Ira Casson, David Viano, or Dr. Elliot Pellman were present.[13][14] As a result of this incident and pressure from the NFL Players Association, The NFL released a comprehensive overhaul of the league concussion policy in November and December 2009.[15] The policy expanded the list of symptoms that would prevent a player from returning to a game or practice on the same day their injury occurred.[15][16][17]

With continued pressure to protect players, the NFL began preventing players knocked unconscious by a concussion from returning to a game or practice, a policy that applied to Detroit Lions running back Jahvid Best in 2009.[18] Various players have filed lawsuits against the league for the concussions, accusing the league of hiding information that linked head trauma to permanent brain damage, Alzheimer's disease, and dementia.[19][20] Some teams chose not to draft certain players in the NFL Draft due to their past concussion history. According to an Outside the Lines report, the head impact telemetry system (HITS) was in question by the League, although Dr. University, a professor at the University of North Carolina, said the system is functional.[21] The technology could detect and measure the impact of blows to the head in real time during a game, but no such measurement exists in the league at this time.[22] Former Pittsburgh Steelers receiver and current NBC Sports analyst Hines Ward stated the use of the system would be "opening a Pandora's Box," and that the data recorded by the system could be used by team owners to give players lower salaries.[21]

In November 2011, the Cleveland Clinic Center for Spine Health created an online study released by the Journal of Neurosurgery in which various football helmets were compared with each other via crash test dummies. It was also found that leather helmets provided similar results to modern helmets, and in some cases, the leather helmets proved to have superior protection against concussive blows. However, the leather helmets did not provide as much protection against skull fractures.[23][24][25]

Federal NFL Concussion Litigation

In April 2011, attorneys Sol H. Weiss and Larry E. Coben from the Philadelphia law firm of Anapol Schwartz filed a federal lawsuit on behalf of Ray Easterling, Jim McMahon and five other players. Thousands of former NFL players have since filed lawsuits against the League after suffering repeated concussions throughout their careers.

The multidistrict litigation (MDL) titled In re: National Football League Players' Concussion Injury Litigation (MDL 2323) was filed on January 31, 2012 in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania. Judge Anita B. Brody presides over the matter.[26] The master administrative long-form complaint, filed by Plaintiff's Co-Lead Counsel Sol Weiss and Christopher Seeger on June 7, 2012, alleges the League "... was aware of the evidence and the risks associated with repetitive traumatic brain injuries virtually at the inception, but deliberately ignored and actively concealed the information from the Plaintiffs and all others who participated in organized football at all levels." The master complaint argues the NFL knew or should have known players who sustain repetitive head injuries are at risk of suffering "... early-onset of Alzheimer's Disease, dementia, depression, deficits in cognitive functioning, reduced processing speed, attention, and reasoning, loss of memory, sleeplessness, moods swings, personality changes, and the debilitating and latent disease known as Chronic traumatic encephalopathy ('CTE')."[27]

In April 2012, Easterling was found dead from a self-inflicted gunshot wound in his home.[28] An autopsy report concluded Easterling's brain had evidence of CTE, a degenerative brain disease associated with frequent blows to the head.[29]

One month later, former San Diego Chargers player Junior Seau also died of a self-inflicted gunshot wound, and a brain autopsy showed he suffered from CTE.[30]

Like Easterling and Seau, an autopsy of Bears safety Dave Duerson's brain after he committed suicide earlier that year revealed he also suffered from the same degenerative brain disease.[31]

The autopsy results following these players' suicides heightened existing concerns regarding the connection between player deaths and concussions. Neurosurgeon Julian Bailes has identified CTE in the autopsies of former players Mike Webster, Terry Long, Justin Strzelczyk, Andre Waters, and Chris Henry.[32][33] One of the difficult issues facing doctors is attempting to identify mental health effects from concussions during the lives of former players rather than after their deaths.[34] In April 2012, a group of former Dallas Cowboys—including Pro Football Hall of Fame inductees Randy White, Bob Lilly, and Rayfield Wright (among other retired players from around the league)—filed a lawsuit against the NFL, again accusing it of ignoring a link between concussions and brain injury.[35]

In August 2012, the number of players involved in suits against the NFL increased to 3,402, and the League sued three dozen insurance companies in an attempt to force them to cover the costs of defending claims of not protecting players. However, Travelers ultimately sued the League on August 21 in a lawsuit called Discover Property & Casualty Co. et al. vs. National Football League et al., New York State Supreme Court, New York County, No. 652933/2012. The company provided liability coverage for the League's merchandising arm (NFL Properties), and the insurer also pointed out that the above-mentioned lawsuit has allegedly 14 counts against the League, while only two against NFL Properties.[36]

After quarterbacks Jay Cutler, Michael Vick and Alex Smith sustained concussions in Week 10 of the 2012 season, the National Football League Players Association (NFLPA) reiterated their plans to have independent neurologists on the sidelines at every game.[37] The 2013-14 NFL season involved an independent neurological consultant per team on the sideline of every game.[38] Concussion guidelines released by the NFL in 2013, mandated a four-stage protocol for concussions, including examinations, treatment and monitoring prior to a return to play.[39][40][41] In March 2013, the League proposed a rule to reduce concussions by making it illegal for a ball carrier or tackler to "initiate forcible contact by delivering a blow with the top crown of his helmet against an opponent when both players are clearly outside of the tackle box." However, the proposal was met with criticism from players like running backs Matt Forte, Emmitt Smith and Marshall Faulk.[42]

A federal hearing was held on April 9, 2013 in Philadelphia to discuss the League's motion to dismiss the lawsuits brought on behalf of more than 4,500 former players On July 8, 2013, Judge Brody ordered representatives of both sides of the litigation to explore a possible settlement in the litigation. Judge Brody ordered a report on or before September 3, 2013 regarding the results of the mediation.[43]

A proposed settlement was reached in the litigation on August 29, 2013. Under the agreement, the NFL will contribute $765 million to provide medical help to more than 18,000 former players. Retired players who suffer severe neurological conditions such as Alzheimer's and amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) diseases in the future will also be eligible to apply for medical help. In addition, $10 million will fund brain injury research as well as safety and education programs.[44]

The settlement says it should not be interpreted as a statement of legal liability on the part of the NFL.[45]

The settlement, which is projected to protect retired players for nearly 65 years, will compensate injured former players who need immediate help and will provide baseline assessments and medical benefits to those who are symptom-free or beginning to show signs of neurological problems.

"I think it's more important that the players have finality, that they're vindicated, and that as soon as the court approves the settlement they can begin to get screening, and those that are injured can get their compensation. I think that's more important than looking at some documents," attorney Weiss said.[46]

The settlement also allows a player diagnosed with CTE the eligibility to up to 4 million dollars in compensation. This has been met with criticism of the settlement's structure as it only players diagnosed before the settlements preliminary agreement and disallows those diagnosed after the approval of the deal in July.[47]

Kansas City Chiefs concussion lawsuit

On December 3, 2013, 5 former NFL players filed a lawsuit against the Kansas City Chiefs organization: former Chiefs players Alexander Cooper, Leonard Griffin, Christopher Martin, Joe Phillips, and Kevin Porter. They wish to know what the Chiefs knew about concussions and when they knew it.

"I would like to have had the opportunity to know that going back on the field (after concussions) would cause me to have severe disabilities later in life ..." said Chris Martin, a former Kansas City Chiefs Linebacker.[48]

This lawsuit is unique and different from the thousands of lawsuits previously filed against the NFL. These players are not suing the NFL, and are instead suing the Chiefs.

From 1987 to 1993 there was no Collective Bargaining Agreement established in the NFL. With no existence of a CBA in these years, players who played during this time for the Chiefs can sue the team for many of the same reasons the NFL has been sued. The $765 million settlement in August 2013 between the NFL and former players only protected the NFL. "I think all of our clients were disappointed," McClain said of his clients reaction to the settlement with the NFL.[49] The players currently suing the Chiefs have all opted-out of the settlement from the previous mediation with the NFL.

A law unique to Missouri allows certain former NFL players to sue the individual team. The current Missouri law states that employees can sue employers in civil court if the employees declined worker's compensation. The Independence attorney for the five ex-Chiefs, Ken McClain said, "The lawsuit is allowed in Missouri after a state workers' compensation statute was amended in 2005 to exclude cases of occupational injury that occur over an extended time."[50]

The amendment of the 2005 law is set to be changed at the end of December 2013. Martin and McClain have both encouraged former players who are eligible to join the lawsuit before the their window of opportunity expires.

On December 1st, 2012, Jovan Belcher, current member of the Kansas City Chiefs, shot and killed his fiancee, Kassandra Perkins, before committing suicide in the Arrowhead practice facility parking lot. On behalf of Belcher’s and Perkin’s daughter, lawyers have filed a wrongful death lawsuit against the Chiefs. Belcher’s mother has filed a similar suit accusing the Chiefs of ignoring Belcher’s cries for help as he complained of concussion like symptoms. The first occurrence came against Jacksonville in 2009 where Belcher was knocked unconscious and failed to receive adequate treatment. The second occurrence was against the Bengals in November 2012. The lawsuits allege, Belcher "suffered what should have been recognized as an acute concussion." However, one lawsuit continues, "despite exhibiting obvious symptoms, Decedent was never removed from play for evaluation and recovery." The lawsuits also claims Belcher exhibited signs of CTE, including changes in his mood and behavior.[51]

On September 30, 2014, it was announced that the brain of former Kansas City Chiefs player, Javon Belcher, contained neurofibrillary tangles of tau protein; which is associated with Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy. The tangles were distributed throughout Belcher's hippocampus, an area of the brain involved with memory, learning and emotion. If the findings of CTE come to be true, Belcher’s daughter and mother are eligible for up to $4 million under the National Football League’s current Collective Bargaining Agreement.[52]

Concussions in college football

Self Reported Concussions among NCAA Student Athletes[53]
Sport One Multiple None
Women's Ice Hockey 20.9 8.3 70.8
Men's Wrestling 19.5 8.2 72.3
Men's Ice Hockey 18.6 7.1 74.3
American football 17.9 9.5 72.6
Men's Lacrosse 17.8 7.8 74.4

The NCAA, like the NFL, has been criticized for its handling of concussions, with numerous players having retired from football due to concussions, or have filed lawsuits against the association for failing to protect student-athletes from concussions.[54] In 2011, former players Derek Owens and Alex Rucks filed lawsuits against the association for failing to cover the players' safety. Both Owens and Rucks claimed that they had suffered brain trauma which could have been prevented.[55] In 2012, the Southeastern Conference and Big Ten Conference began work on preventing concussions, and appointed University of Mississippi Chancellor Dan Jones to evaluate and review existing research and various diagnoses from past analyses.[56] In 2009, an NCAA panel created and recommended a rule that prevents an athlete from returning to a game after he/she has sustained a concussion. The panel also had recommended for an athlete to be sidelined after any concussion-related injury until he/she has been cleared by a doctor.[57] Under the new plan, all student-athletes must sign statements saying that they will report all signs and symptoms of concussions to their coaches. In addition, all athletes must have baseline cognitive testing while the post-injury cognitive testing is strongly recommended. The athletes diagnosed with concussions must be removed from sports for a minimum of one day and can only return when decided by a team physician.

"There's been less focus on college players who don't go on to play professional sports, but I think you'll see that getting more attention and go down to people who play it at every level. From time to time we have all had concerns of what we ask student-athletes to do and what the long-term health may be."[58]
—University of Mississippi Chancellor Dan Jones

Concussions in other leagues

Canadian Football League

In the 2010 season for the Canadian Football League, there have been 50 reported concussions; 44.8 percent of players reported having a concussion or concussion-like symptoms, 16.9 percent had confirmed that they had a concussion, and 69.6 percent of all players who suffered from concussions that year suffered from more than one.[59] However, the average of 0.59 concussions per game is lower than the 0.67 recorded by the NFL in 2010.[60] The league eventually started a concussion-awareness program with the help of Football Canada, Canadian Interuniversity Sport (CIS), the Canadian School Sport Federation, the Canadian Football League Players Association (CFLPA), the Canadian Football League Alumni Association (CFLAA), and the ThinkFirst program.[61] The league eventually pointed out eight protocols:[62]

In 2012, ThinkFirst founder and Toronto Western Hospital neurosurgeon Charles Tator led a study that was conducted by the University of Toronto, which examined the brains of 20 former players with a history of concussions, and compared them to 20 other players without a history of head injury. A separate group of 20 without football experience served as a control group. Also in 2012, the league and Tator announced a partnership to work in a study that would perform postmortem tests on former CFL players to look for signs of CTE.[63]

Arena Football League

In the Arena Football League, despite the league's intense play, very few lawsuits have been filed for concussions. The most notable lawsuit against the league was a lawsuit filed by former Colorado Crush kicker Clay Rush in 2010, who claimed that he suffered from permanent brain damage due to repeated blows to the head during games.[64] Like the NFL, the AFL prohibits players who suffered from concussions from practicing.[65] In 2008, during the original league's final season, the "Shockometer" made its debut at two season-opening games (Dallas Desperados vs. Georgia Force/San Jose SaberCats vs. Chicago Rush) on 40 player helmets. The device is projected to sell for $30 if it is to become available on the market.[66] The players that were given the device play positions that are suspectible to hard hits, such as wide receivers, defensive backs, running backs and linebackers. AFL Players Association regional director James Guidry stated that the red light doesn't mean that the player has a concussion, but as a warning for team examiners to inspect the player. Guidry also said that the device could be used to prevent players who don't want to show any signs of weakness after sustaining any concussion-like symptoms from continuing to play.[67]

"What happens in a game is much different than what happens in lab situations. To be able to have a partner like the AFL that values this project as much as we do is fantastic. We can learn an awful lot and make this product as good as it can be before it's winding up on the field in widespread use."[66]
—Dave Rossi of Schutt Sports on the Shockometer

Youth football

Youth athletes make up 70% of football players in the United States. One of the first studies of its kind was performed during the Fall 2011 football season when researchers from Virginia Tech, receiving permission from parents, placed accelerometers (which measure g forces) inside the helmets of seven youth players. These seven players were 7- and 8-year-old boys participating in a community youth league who were chosen because they were expected to have high participation and also because they wore at least a youth medium Riddell Revolution helmet (enabling the accelerometers, battery, and wireless transmitter to fit inside the helmet between the padding). That is, these seven were not a random selecting of players. Rather, the purpose of this study was to establish a baseline of what range of hits are generally expected.[68]

As way of comparison, a collision of 80g is a big hit in a college football game of which there might be only six per game. And the range of 80, 90, or 100g is generally where risk of acute injury and concussion begins to occur (concussion being symptoms such as feeling foggy or woozy and not necessarily loss of consciousness). An example of a lesser force of 40g is heading a soccer ball, and even with blows in this 30 to 40g range, it is not known whether these pose a cumulative risk of injury.[68]

This 2011 study measured a total 753 impacts among these seven players with a median impact of 15g. It did, however, observe 38 impacts of 40g or greater, and six impacts of greater than 80g. Fortunately, none of these youth players experienced a concussion. There is also a concern that since many young players have less developed chest and neck muscles than older players, almost every impact potentially acts likes a surprise hit.[68]

A Virginia Tech doctor stated that reducing the number of higher hits during practice sessions constitutes a real opportunity. Of the 38 impacts of 40g or greater, 29 took place during practice. And of the six impacts greater than 80g, all took place during practice.[68]

Concussions in high school football

Concussions are prevalent in high school football. Football has the highest rate of concussion among high school sports, with about 11 concussions occurring per 10,000 athletic exposures. [69] About 50 high school or younger football players across the country were killed or sustained serious head injuries on the field since 1997.[70]

A 2013 study by Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center found that despite knowing the risk of serious injury from continuing to play with a concussion, half of high school football players would still play if they had a headache from an injury sustained on the field. Researchers surveyed 120 high school football players. Of those students, 30 reported having suffered a concussion. More than 90 percent recognized the risk of serious injury if they returned to play too quickly, but more than half of those aware of the risks responded they would "always or sometimes continue to play with a headache sustained from an injury," and only 54 percent indicated they would "always or sometimes report symptoms of a concussion to their coach."[71] Another study found that 15.8% of football players who sustain a concussion severe enough to cause loss of consciousness return to play the same day. Due to the fact that only 42% of high schools have access to athletic training services, there has been a large debate regarding the risks that high school football players face. [72]

Prevention efforts

Numerous efforts have attempted to identify potential concussions early. Helmet shock data loggers and impact sensors help monitor impacts a player receives. One example is a device created by Schutt Sports during the Arena Football League's 2008 season known as the "Shockometer"—a triangle-shaped object with adhesive on its side that sticks to players' helmets. When a player gets hit by a g-force which exceeds 98, a capsule with a green light in it will change to a red light. Doctors have determined that a g-force of approximately 100 will increase the risk of a concussion, even though a quarterback that gets sacked would normally register a g-force of 150 g. A possible flaw to the Shockometer is that fan activity could accidentally trigger the device.[73] Riddell created the Head Impact Telemetry System (HITS) and Sideline Response System (SRS) to help record the frequency and severity of player impacts during practices and games. Every HITS helmet features MX Encoders, which would automatically record every hit.[74] Eight NFL teams had planned to use the system in the 2010 season, but it was ultimately not used.[21] In 2013, Reebok developed the Head Impact Indicator, which is a quarter-sized device placed on a player's skull, which activates a red/yellow light if the player is hit too hard.[75] Similarly to Reebok's Impact Indicator, Battle Sport Science has released the Impact Indicator 2.0. The Impact Indicator 2.0 looks to increase long-term brain safety for all those who play football.[76] On February 3, 2013, the NFL and General Electric partnered on a five-year, $50 million project to develop technology to predict brain injuries, show injury severity and the rate of recovery, and to create more protective material.[77]

NFL

The National Football League has made numerous rule changes to reduce the number of concussions suffered by players while making the game safer.

In 2010, the NFL reworded the League's rules to prohibit a player from "launching himself off the ground and using his helmet to strike a player in a defenseless posture in the head or neck." Violations of this rule only result in the imposition of a 15-yard unnecessary roughness penalty. In the same season, the NFL mandated that once a player loses his helmet on the playing field, the current play must immediately be whistled dead.[78]

Also in 2010, the NFL mandated that during field goals or extra point attempts, defenders must line up with their entire bodies on the outside of the snapper's body to protect the snapper while he is in a position of vulnerability. Violations of this rule, however, result in only a five-yard penalty for illegal formation.[79]

To reinforce the seriousness of the rule changes, in the middle of the 2010 season, Commissioner Goodell issued a memo to all NFL teams stating that "more significant discipline, including suspensions, will be imposed on players that strike an opponent in the head or neck area in violation of the rules."[80]

The most drastic step the NFL has taken to reduce head injuries was the 2010 change to the NFL kickoff rules. To reduce what has been referred to as one of the most violent plays in the game, the kickoff was moved up from the 30-yard line to the 35-yard line. The NFL also outlawed the use of the three-man wedge on kickoffs, while allowing the two-man wedge to remain a legal play. Consequently, players on the kicking team must now line up closer to the end zone, reducing the amount of space the players have in which to get a running start.[81]

In 2011, the NFL also mandated that certified athletic trainers be available in press boxes during all NFL games. These athletic trainers assist medical personnel located on the sidelines in identifying potential concussions because the symptoms are often difficult to spot and assess from the field level.[82]

On March 20, 2013, the NFL voted to introduce yet another new rule aimed at player safety. Starting in the 2013-2014 season, if a running back lowers the crown of his helmet while he is inside the tackle box or while he is less than three yards downfield and makes contact with a defender, the team will be given a 15-yard penalty.[83]

Screening procedures

As of February 2015, Dr. Gary Small and colleagues have been called in to question by the FDA for their overzealous commercialization and promotion of clinically unproven screening that fellow peer researchers deem fit only for research and they have responded by withdrawing related materials from their website. [84][85]

To date, all screening procedures that examine football players for brain damage have been post mortem. In 2013, Dr. Gary Small and colleagues developed an in vivo chemical tracer that can detect tau protein build up in living players. Dr. Small and his team invented this new chemical tracer, 2-(1-{6-[(2-[F-18]fluoroethyl)(methyl)amino]-2-naphthyl}ethylidene)malononitrile, or FDDNP, that could be used in positron emission tomography (PET).[86] This new tracer measures for tau protein and amyloid plaque accumulation in human brains; symptoms of repetitive brain trauma among other things. Although tracers have been developed to screen for the build-up of tau proteins in the human brain, FDDNP is the first PET tracer that can be used in vivo in human trails. FDDNP was originally developed in an effort to detect Alzheimer’s in elderly individuals, thus the article was published in the journal of the American Association for Geriatric Psychiatry. However, because there are similarities between Alzheimer’s and the effects of chronic traumatic encephelopathy (CTE), FDDNP was used to study the extent of brain trauma in consenting, retired NFL players.

Dr. Small and colleagues performed a controlled experiment on retired NFL players and an equal number of control participants. Unfortunately the sample size was very small as only 5 players of the 19 contacted were eligible for the study. Though the sample size was small, a good range of positions were represented (linebacker, quarterback, offensive lineman, defensive lineman, and a center) and all players had played in the league at least 10 years. The players had to be at least 45 years of age and currently exhibit symptoms of cognitive and mood disruption. Control participants had to meet certain criteria as well to ensure that they were as similar as possible to the NFL players in order to eliminate any biases or confounding variables. Age, Body Mass Index (BMI), years of education, and family history of dementia were all selected as the selection criteria for control participants. All participants received intravenous injections of the FDDNP tracer and were tested over 4 weeks using PET imaging technology.

The injection of the FDDNP tracer was successful, and the results of the study showed significant differences between the NFL players and control participants. The NFL players had significantly higher FDDNP signals than control participants, indicating a greater amount of tau protein accumulation. The cortical regions of all the participants studied showed no significant difference, but the NFL players had FDDNP levels that were significantly higher in the caudate, putamen, thalamus, sub thalamus, midbrain, and cerebellar white matter regions of the brain as compared to the control participants.[86] In addition, a positive correlation was found between the number of head injuries the players sustained and the levels of FDDNP binding. This suggests that players with a more severe history of head trauma will likely have significantly more accumulation of tau protein. This, in turn, gives rise to the suggestion that a more sever history of head trauma will result in greater deterioration of the brain, cognitive functioning, and mood regulation.

The findings of the study were consistent with previous autopsy studies of individuals with CTE. The important distinction to make, however, is that the patients in Dr. Small’s study were not on the slab and walked out after testing was completed. This is monumental in the field of brain trauma and concussion research.

Recovery efforts

Concussions are proven to cause loss of brain functioning that can lead to physical and emotional symptoms, attention disorders, depression, headaches, nausea, and amnesia. These symptoms can last for days or week and even after the symptoms have gone, the brain still won't be completely normal. Players with multiple concussions can have drastically worsened symptoms and exponentially increased recovery time.

Researchers at UCLA have for the first time used a brain-imaging tool to identify a certain protein found in five retired NFL players. The presence and accumulation of tau proteins found in the five living players, are associated with Alzheimer's disease. Previously, this type of exam could only be performed with an autopsy. Scientists at UCLA created a chemical marker that binds to the abnormal proteins and they are able to view this with Positron Emission Tomography (PET) scan. Researcher at UCLA, Gary Small explains, "Providing a non-invasive method for early detection is a critical first step in developing interventions to prevent symptom onset and progression in CTE".[87]

Information

See also

Further reading

References

  1. ↑ Schwarz, Alan (20 December 2009). "N.F.L. Acknowledges Long-Term Concussion Effects". The New York Times. Retrieved 6 January 2014.
  2. ↑ Breslow, Jason (30 September 2014). "76 of 79 Deceased NFL Players Found to Have Brain Disease". PBS. Retrieved 13 November 2014.
  3. ↑ 3.0 3.1 3.2 Peter, Peter. "Elliot Pellman, the NFL's top medical adviser, claims it's okay for players with concussions to get back in the game. Time for a second choice". ESPN Sports. Retrieved 2013-09-03.
  4. ↑ "Concussion in professional football: helmet testing to assess impact performance--part 11." (PDF). United States Public Health Service Centers for Disease Control and Prevention National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health. 2004-01-10. Retrieved 2013-09-03.
  5. ↑ "Concussion in professional football: helmet testing to assess impact performance--part 11.". Mild Traumatic Brain Injury Committee, National Football League. January 2006. Retrieved 2013-09-03.
  6. ↑ "The management of concussion in sports (summary statement)". Neurology Journal. March 1997. Retrieved 2013-09-03.
  7. ↑ "Concussion in professional football: players returning to the same game--part 7.". University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, North Carolina. Retrieved 2013-09-03.
  8. ↑ "Association between recurrent concussion and late-life cognitive impairment in retired professional football players.". Mild Traumatic Brain Injury Committee, National Football League. Retrieved 2013-09-03.
  9. ↑ Brady, Don (2004). A Preliminary Investigation of Active and Retired NFL Players’ Knowledge of Concussions (Ph.D.). The Union Institute and University.
  10. ↑ "Plaintiffs' Master Long-Form Complaint" (PDF). Anapol Schwartz Law Firm. 2013-06-07. Retrieved 2013-09-03.
  11. ↑ Associated Press (2007-09-29). "NFL Study Links Concussions, Depression". Washington Post. Retrieved 2013-09-03.
  12. ↑ Alan Schwartz (2009-09-29). "Dementia Risk Seen in Players in N.F.L. Study". New York Times. Retrieved 2013-09-03.
  13. ↑ 13.0 13.1 "Conyers wants review of all data". ESPN. 28 October 2009. Retrieved 6 January 2014.
  14. ↑ 14.0 14.1 Schwarz, Alan (28 October 2009). "N.F.L. Scolded Over Injuries to Its Players". The New York Times. Retrieved 6 January 2014.
  15. ↑ 15.0 15.1 Neale, Todd (5 December 2009). "NFL Institutes New Concussion Policy". ABC News. Retrieved 6 January 2014.
  16. ↑ Storrs, Carina (27 November 2009). "NFL gains yards in its treatment of players' head injuries". Scientific American. Retrieved 16 January 2014.
  17. ↑ Farmer, Sam (11 September 2010). "NFL is taking the long-term impact of concussions seriously". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved 16 January 2014.
  18. ↑ "Lions RB Jahvid Best misses second practice with concussion". The Sporting News. Associated Press. 2011-08-22. Retrieved 2012-06-27.
  19. ↑ "NFL Concussions Mega-Lawsuit Claims League Hid Brain Injury Links From Players". Huffingtonpost.com. 2012-06-07. Retrieved 2012-06-27.
  20. ↑ Freeman, Mike (2012-05-18). "Concussion lawsuit plaintiffs an eye- opening cross section of NFL past". Cbssports.com. Retrieved 2012-06-27.
  21. ↑ 21.0 21.1 21.2 "Failure to use HIT system exposes league to future concussion liability". Profootballtalk.nbcsports.com. June 24, 2012. Retrieved 2012-06-26.
  22. ↑ "OTL: Football At A Crossroads: The Hit System". ESPN. 22 June 2012. Retrieved 6 January 2014.
  23. ↑ Study reveals leather helmets may help reduce concussions, USA Today, Erik Brady, 11/4/2011.
  24. ↑ Why Leather Football Helmets Could Provide a Better Defense Against Concussion, Time magazine, Sean Gregory, November 7, 2011.
  25. ↑ Impact test comparisons of 20th and 21st century American football helmets, ABSTRACT, Journal of Neurosurgery, Adam Bartsch, Ph.D., Edward Benzel, M.D., Vincent Miele, M.D., and Vikas Prakash, Ph.D., Jan. 2012 (published online November 4, 2011).
  26. ↑ "MDL-2323 IN RE: NATIONAL FOOTBALL LEAGUE PLAYERS' CONCUSSION INJURY LITIGATION". 2012-01-31. Retrieved 2013-09-03.
  27. ↑ "Plaintiffs' Master Long-Form Complaint" (PDF). 2013-06-07. Retrieved 2013-09-03.
  28. ↑ "Five NFL Players Who've Died from a Self-Inflicted Gunshot Wound". Yahoo Sports. 2012-07-30. Retrieved 2013-09-03.
  29. ↑ Tierney, Mike (2012-07-26). "Football Player Who Killed Himself Had Brain Disease". The New York Times. Retrieved 2013-09-03.
  30. ↑ "Doctors: Junior Seau's brain had CTE". espn. 2013-01-13. Retrieved 2013-09-03.
  31. ↑ Schwarz, Alan (2011-05-13). "Duerson's Brain Trauma Diagnosed". New York Times. Retrieved 2013-09-03.
  32. ↑ "Neurosurgeon: Junior Seau's death fuels concussion concerns". USA Today. 2012-05-02.
  33. ↑ Habib, Hal (2012-05-08). "Seau's death heightens concerns over concussions". Canada.com. Retrieved 2012-06-27.
  34. ↑ "Junior Seau dies at 43". ESPN. May 2, 2012. Retrieved February 28, 2014.
  35. ↑ Ex-Cowboys sue over concussions, ESPN, Associated Press, April 24, 2012.
  36. ↑ Ax, Joseph (2012-08-22). "Travelers sues NFL over brain injury lawsuits". Yahoo! Sports. Retrieved 2012-09-15.
  37. ↑ Breer, Albert (2012-11-16). "NFLPA plans to reiterate desire to have neurologists at games". National Football League. Retrieved 2012-11-16.
  38. ↑ Bill Bradley (September 3, 2013). "Independent concussion specialists ready to work NFL sidelines". NFL.com. Retrieved February 28, 2014.
  39. ↑ Bill Bradley (October 1, 2013). "NFL's 2013 protocol for players with concussions". NFL.com. Retrieved February 28, 2014.
  40. ↑ Josh Weinfuss (December 20, 2013). "What exactly is the concussion protocol?". ESPN. Retrieved February 28, 2014.
  41. ↑ "Head, Neck and Spine Committee provides protocol". NFLEvolution.com. January 6, 2014. Retrieved February 28, 2014.
  42. ↑ Mayer, Larry (2013-03-18). "Matt Forte calls proposed new rule absurd". Chicago Bears. Retrieved 2013-03-18.
  43. ↑ "Mediation Order" (PDF). Retrieved 2013-03-18.
  44. ↑ Martin, John (2013-08-29). "NFL ex-players reach $765 million deal in concussion case". Philly.com. Retrieved 2013-03-18.
  45. ↑ "NFL, Retired Players Resolve Concussion Litigation; Court-Appointed Mediator Hails Historic Agreement" (PDF) (Press release). Alternative Dispute Resolution Center. August 29, 2013. Retrieved 29 August 2013.
  46. ↑ "NFL players reach proposed $765M settlement of concussion-related lawsuits". Fox News. 2013-08-29. Retrieved 2013-03-18.
  47. ↑ Breslow, Jason (30 September 2014). "76 of 79 Deceased NFL Players Found to Have Brain Disease". PBS. Retrieved 13 November 2014.
  48. ↑ Paylor, Terez. "Five Former Players Sue Chiefs over Consusisons". The Kansas City Star. Retrieved 3 December 2013.
  49. ↑ Paylor, Terez. "Five Former Players Suing Chiefs over Concussions". Retrieved 3 December 2013.
  50. ↑ Drapper, Bill. "Five ex-Chiefs sue Kansas City over concussions". Daily Times. Retrieved 3 December 2013.
  51. ↑ Delsohn, Steve. "OTL:Belcher's Brain Had CTE Signs". ESPN. Retrieved 30 September 2014.
  52. ↑ Delsohn, Steve. "OTL:Belcher's Brain Had CTE Signs". ESPN. Retrieved 30 September 2014.
  53. ↑ http://www.ncaa.org/sites/default/files/Concussion%20%20GOALS%20Exec%20Summary_Feb_12_2014_FINALpost_0.pdf
  54. ↑ Post Comment (2011-09-16). "Former college football player sues NCAA in federal court over concussions". Fox Sports. Retrieved 2012-06-27.
  55. ↑ "Two former college football players sue NCAA over concussion rules". ESPN.com. 2011-09-28. Retrieved 2012-06-27.
  56. ↑ "SEC taking steps to learn more about concussions". Sports Illustrated. 2012-06-01. Retrieved 2012-06-27.
  57. ↑ "NCAA recommends stricter rules on concussions". ESPN.com. 2009-12-15. Retrieved 2012-06-27.
  58. ↑ "College Football: Concussion Study Is Nice, but the Game Needs Action a Lot More". Bleacher Report. 2012-06-08. Retrieved 2012-06-27.
  59. ↑ "Concussions During the 1997 Canadian Football League Season" (PDF). Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine. Retrieved 14 June 2012.
  60. ↑ "CFL concussions not always revealed to fans". The Star (Toronto). 2011-04-07. Retrieved 2012-06-27.
  61. ↑ "Canadian football tackles concussions head-on". The Star (Toronto). 2011-05-03. Retrieved 2012-06-27.
  62. ↑ "Official Site of the Canadian Football League". CFL.ca. 2011-05-03. Retrieved 2012-06-27.
  63. ↑ "Former CFL players to be studied for long term concussion effects". Canadian Football League Alumni Association. May 5, 2012. Retrieved 2012-06-27.
  64. ↑ Alan Schwarz (18 March 2010). "Lawsuit Cites Mishandling of Football Concussions". The New York Times. Retrieved 14 June 2012.
  65. ↑ "Arena Football League adopts strict guidelines on concussions". Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. 2012-03-29. Retrieved 2012-06-27.
  66. ↑ 66.0 66.1 "Indicator on AFL helmets to warn of potentially dangerous hits". ESPN.com. 2008-02-28. Retrieved 2012-06-26.
  67. ↑ "AFL-Test-Drives-Schutt's-Shockometer / News". NFLPlayers.com. 2008-05-22. Retrieved 2012-06-26.
  68. ↑ 68.0 68.1 68.2 68.3 Daniel, R. W.; Rowson, S.; Duma, S. M. (2012). "Head Impact Exposure in Youth Football". Annals of Biomedical Engineering 40 (4): 976–981. doi:10.1007/s10439-012-0530-7. PMC 3310979. PMID 22350665. Lay summary – PBS (2 April 2012).
  69. ↑ Breslow, Jason. "High School Football Players Face Bigger Concussion Risk". Frontline. PBS. Retrieved 2 December 2014.
  70. ↑ "Young Players, Serious Injuries". New York Times. 2007-09-16. Retrieved 2013-09-03.
  71. ↑ "Study raises concerns that teen athletes continue to play with concussion symptoms" (Press release). Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center. 2013-05-06. Retrieved 2013-09-03.
  72. ↑ "Statistics on Youth Sports Safety". Cleared to Play. Retrieved 2 December 2014.
  73. ↑ "AFL to test device designed to warn of possible concussions". Orlando Sentinel. 2008-03-06. Retrieved 2012-06-27.
  74. ↑ "HITS™ Technology". Riddell. Retrieved 2012-06-26.
  75. ↑ Bradley, Bill (2013-01-10). "Titans QB Hasselbeck helps Reebok promote Impact Indicator". National Football League. Retrieved 2013-01-22.
  76. ↑ Goldman, Tom. "Can That Mouth Guard Really Prevent a Concussion?". Retrieved 2013-11-14.
  77. ↑ Copeland, Kareem (2013-02-03). "Report: NFL partners with GE for concussion research". National Football League. Retrieved 2013-02-03.
  78. ↑ Thomas, Drysdale (13 December 2013). "Helmet-to-Helmet Contact: Avoiding a Lifetime Penalty by Creating a Duty to Scan Active NFL Players for Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy". Journal of Legal Medicine (Taylor & Francis ltd) 34 (4): 425–452. doi:10.1080/01947648.2013.859969.
  79. ↑ Thomas, Drysdale (13 December 2013). "Helmet-to-Helmet Contact: Avoiding a Lifetime Penalty by Creating a Duty to Scan Active NFL Players for Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy". Journal of Legal Medicine (Taylor & Francis ltd) 34 (4): 425–452. doi:10.1080/01947648.2013.859969.
  80. ↑ "Goodell issues memo enforcing player safety rules". National Football League. 2012-07-26. Retrieved 2014-11-11.
  81. ↑ Thomas, Drysdale (13 December 2013). "Helmet-to-Helmet Contact: Avoiding a Lifetime Penalty by Creating a Duty to Scan Active NFL Players for Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy". Journal of Legal Medicine (Taylor & Francis ltd) 34 (4): 425–452. doi:10.1080/01947648.2013.859969.
  82. ↑ Thomas, Drysdale (13 December 2013). "Helmet-to-Helmet Contact: Avoiding a Lifetime Penalty by Creating a Duty to Scan Active NFL Players for Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy". Journal of Legal Medicine (Taylor & Francis ltd) 34 (4): 425–452. doi:10.1080/01947648.2013.859969.
  83. ↑ Thomas, Drysdale (13 December 2013). "Helmet-to-Helmet Contact: Avoiding a Lifetime Penalty by Creating a Duty to Scan Active NFL Players for Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy". Journal of Legal Medicine (Taylor & Francis ltd) 34 (4): 425–452. doi:10.1080/01947648.2013.859969.
  84. ↑ Zarembo, Alan (Apr 10, 2015). "FDA forces UCLA researchers to stop touting experimental dementia scan". LA Times.
  85. ↑ "Warning Letters and Notice of Violation Letters" (PDF). FDA. Feb 15, 2015. Restrict promotional claims of safety or effectiveness of the drug for a use for which it is under investigation and to preclude commercialization of the drug before it is approved for commercial distribution
  86. ↑ 86.0 86.1 Small, G.W. (2013). "PET Scanning of Brain Tau in Retired National League Football Players: Preliminary Findings". American Association for Geriatric Psychiatry 21 (2): 138–144.
  87. ↑ "First Imaging Study of Concussion-Related Abnormal Brain Proteins In Retired NFL Players". Medical News Today. Retrieved 1 December 2013.

External links