Communist state

Part of a series on
Communism
Concepts Marxist philosophy Marxist economics Historical materialism Dialectical materialism Surplus value Communist society From each according to his ability, to each according to his need Class struggle Dictatorship of the proletariat Classless society Collective leadership Common ownership Class consciousness Gift economy Commune Workers' self-management Proletarian internationalism World revolution
Aspects Communist state Communist party Communist revolution Communist symbolism Communism and religion History of communism
Variants Marxism Leninism Marxism–Leninism Anti-Revisionism Stalinism Maoism Marxism–Leninism–Maoism Hoxhaism Trotskyism Luxemburgism Titoism Juche Ho Chi Minh Thought Socialism with Chinese characteristics Castroism Guevarism Left Council Anarchist Religious (Christian) Euro World National Stateless List of communist parties
Internationals Communist League First Second Third Fourth
People Karl Marx Friedrich Engels Rosa Luxemburg Vladimir Lenin Leon Trotsky Joseph Stalin Mao Zedong Mikhail Bakunin Emma Goldman Peter Kropotkin
By country China Colombia Korea Peru Poland Vietnam
Related topics Anti-capitalism Anti-communism Third-Worldism Cold War Communitarianism Criticisms of communism Criticisms of communist party rule Left-wing politics New Class New Left Socialist mode of production Socialist economics
Communism portal

Map of countries that declared themselves to be socialist states under the Marxist–Leninist or Maoist definition - that is to say, "Communist states" - between 1979 and 1983. This period marked the greatest territorial extent of Communist states.

"Communist state" is a state that aims to achieve Socialism and then achieve Communism. Most communist states have been states with a form of government characterized by single-party rule or dominant-party system by a party which claims to follow communism, usually with a professed allegiance to Marxism-Leninism as the guiding ideology of the state. None of these states achieved communism, and the term is used no matter to what degree that state or the movement associated with it actually follows communism, if at all.^[1] The label is the source of controversy, especially among the left; according to many communist and Marxist tendencies, the system in use in the Soviet Union and the states modeled after it (i.e., "communist states") - which claimed to have reached socialism, not communism - was not socialism but rather state capitalism.^[2] Some argue that term "Communist state" is an oxymoron as a communist society is stateless,^[3] therefore the term Marxist-Leninist state usually is more appropriate, while "communist state" is a Western term.^[1]

The states called themselves socialist states, because they claimed to have established or aim at the establishing of the socialist society, i.e., a society based on the principles of scientific socialism.

Communist party as the leader of the state

In the theories of German philosopher Karl Marx, a state in any society is an instrument of oppression by one social class over another, historically a minority exploiter class ruling over a majority exploited class. Marx saw that in his contemporary time, the new nation states were characterized by increasingly intensified class contradiction between the capitalist class and the working class it ruled over. He predicted that if the class contradictions of the capitalist system continue to intensify, that the working class will ultimately become conscious of itself as an exploited collective and will overthrow the capitalists and establish collective ownership over the means of production, therein arriving at a new phase of development called Socialism (in Marxist understanding). The state ruled by the working class during the transition into classless society is called the Dictatorship of the Proletariat. Vladimir Lenin created revolutionary vanguard theory in an attempt to expand on the concept. Lenin saw that science is something that is initially practicable by only a minority of society who happen to be in a position free from distraction so that they may contemplate it, and believed that scientific socialism was no exception. He therefore advocated that the Communist party should be structured as a vanguard of those who have achieved full class consciousness to be at the forefront of the class struggle and lead the workers to expand class consciousness and replace the capitalist class as the ruling class, therein establishing the Proletarian state.

Development of communist states

During the 20th century, the world's first constitutionally socialist state was in Russia in 1917. In 1922, it joined other former territories of the empire to become the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics. After the Second World War, the Soviet Army occupied much of Eastern Europe and thus helped establish Communist states in these countries. Most Communist states in Eastern Europe were allied with the USSR, except for Yugoslavia which declared itself non-aligned. In 1949, after a war against Japanese occupation and a civil war resulting in a Communist victory, the People's Republic of China was established. Communist states were also established in Cuba, Vietnam, Laos, and Cambodia. A Communist state was established in North Korea, although it later withdrew from the Communist movement. In 1989, the Communist states in Eastern Europe collapsed under public pressure during a wave of non-violent movements which led to the dissolution of the Soviet Union in 1991. Today, the existing Communist states in the world are in China, Laos, Vietnam, and Cuba.

These communist states often do not claim to have achieved socialism or communism in their countries; rather, they claim to be building and working toward the establishment of socialism in their countries. For example, the preamble to the Socialist Republic of Vietnam's constitution states that Vietnam only entered a transition stage between capitalism and socialism after the country was re-unified under the Communist party in 1976,^[4] and the 1992 Constitution of the Republic of Cuba states that the role of the Communist Party is to "guide the common effort toward the goals and construction of socialism".^[5]

State institutions in Marxist-Leninist states

Marxist-Leninist states share similar institutions, which are organized on the premise that the communist party is a vanguard of the proletariat and represents the long-term interests of the people. The doctrine of democratic centralism, which was developed by Vladimir Lenin as a set of principles to be used in the internal affairs of the communist party, is extended to society at large.^[6]

According to democratic centralism, all leaders must be elected by the people and all proposals must be debated openly, but, once a decision has been reached, all people have a duty to obey that decision and all debate should end. When used within a political party, democratic centralism is meant to prevent factionalism and splits. When applied to an entire state, democratic centralism creates a one-party system.^[6]

The constitutions of most socialist states describe their political system as a form of democracy.^[7] Thus, they recognize the sovereignty of the people as embodied in a series of representative parliamentary institutions. Such states do not have a separation of powers; instead, they have one national legislative body (such as the Supreme Soviet in the Soviet Union) which is considered the highest organ of state power and which is legally superior to the executive and judicial branches of government.^[8]

Such national legislative politics in socialist states often have a similar structure to the parliaments that exist in liberal republics, with two significant differences: first, the deputies elected to these national legislative bodies are not expected to represent the interests of any particular constituency, but the long-term interests of the people as a whole; second, against Marx's advice, the legislative bodies of socialist states are not in permanent session. Rather, they convene once or several times per year in sessions which usually last only a few days.^[9]

When the national legislative body is not in session, its powers are transferred to a smaller council (often called a presidium) which combines legislative and executive power, and, in some socialist states (such as the Soviet Union before 1990), acts as a collective head of state. In some systems, the presidium is composed of important communist party members who vote the resolutions of the communist party into law.

State social institutions

A feature of socialist states is the existence of numerous state-sponsored social organizations (trade unions, youth organizations, women's organizations, associations of teachers, writers, journalists and other professionals, consumer cooperatives, sports clubs, etc.) which are integrated into the political system.

In some socialist states, representatives of these organizations are guaranteed a certain number of seats on the national legislative bodies. In socialist states, the social organizations are expected to promote social unity and cohesion, to serve as a link between the government and society, and to provide a forum for recruitment of new communist party members.^[10]

Political power

Historically, the political organization of many socialist states has been dominated by a single-party monopoly. Some communist governments, such as North Korea, East Germany or the Czechoslovak Socialist Republic have or had more than one political party, but all minor parties are or were required to follow the leadership of the communist party. In socialist states, the government may not tolerate criticism of policies that have already been implemented in the past or are being implemented in the present.^[11]

Nevertheless, communist parties have won elections and governed in the context of multi-party democracies, without seeking to establish a one-party state. Examples include San Marino, Republic of Nicaragua,^[12] Moldova, Nepal (presently), Cyprus,^[13] and the Indian states of Kerala, West Bengal and Tripura.^[14] However, for the purposes of this article, these entities do not fall under the definition of socialist state.

Criticism

From the liberal or conservative viewpoint

Marxist-Leninist states are usually one-party dictatorships, with totalitarian control of the economy and society and repression of civil liberties,^[15] economic focus on heavy industry at the expense of consumer goods, sometimes resulting in shortages of vital products or even famine,^[16] and militarism and propaganda to cover up the mistakes of the government .^[17]

In his critique of states run under Marxist-Leninist ideology, economist Michael Ellman of the University of Amsterdam notes that such states compared favorably with Western states in some health indicators such as infant mortality and life expectancy.^[18] Similarly, Amartya Sen's own analysis of international comparisons of life expectancy found that several Marxist-Leninist states made significant gains, and commented "one thought that is bound to occur is that communism is good for poverty removal."^[19]

From the communist and socialist viewpoints

Within the socialist and communist movements themselves, there are a number of criticisms of self-declared "socialist states". Many communist tendencies argue that their economic system actually was state capitalism.^[2]

Modern period

A map of the Communist states as of 2012

List of current communist states

The following countries are one-party states in which the institutions of the ruling communist party and the state have become intertwined. They are generally adherents of Marxism-Leninism in particular and as such represent a particular ideology that many communists may not share. They are listed here together with the year of their founding and their respective ruling parties:^[20]

Country	Since	Party	Leader(s)
People's Republic of China	1 October 1949	Communist Party of China	Xi–Li Administration: Xi Jinping Li Keqiang
Republic of Cuba	1 July 1961	Communist Party of Cuba	Raúl Castro
Lao People's Democratic Republic	2 December 1975	Lao People's Revolutionary Party	Choummaly Sayasone
Socialist Republic of Vietnam	2 September 1945 (in the north) 2 July 1976 (unified)	Communist Party of Vietnam	Tetrarchy: Nguyễn Phú Trọng Trương Tấn Sang Nguyễn Tấn Dũng Nguyễn Sinh Hùng

North Korea

•  Democratic People's Republic of Korea (since 1948) The DPRK asserts that its system is socialist. The government's official ideology, on the other hand, is now the Juche policy of Kim Il-sung, as opposed to traditional Marxism–Leninism. In 2009, the constitution of the DPRK was quietly amended so that not only did it disavow all Marxist-Leninist references present in the first draft, but it also dropped all reference to 'Communism'.^[21] Similar to officially Marxist-Leninist states, the Workers' Party governs the country as a single-party state.

Multi-party states with governing communist parties

These have been multi-party states with communist parties leading the government. Such states are not considered to be communist states as the countries themselves allow for multiple parties, and do not provide a constitutional role for their communist parties.

• The Guyanese democratically elected ruling party, the People's Progressive Party is officially Marxist-Leninist^[22] but is actually Democratic Socialist and Left-wing Nationalist.

See also

• Capitalist state
• Socialist state
• Socialism in one country
• Communist society
• List of socialist countries, which includes a list of current and former socialist states.
• List of communist parties
• Criticisms of communist party rule
• List of anti-capitalist and communist parties with national parliamentary representation
• People's democracy (Marxism–Leninism)

References