B'Tselem

B'Tselem
Founded 1989
Type Non-profit
NGO
Focus "acts primarily to change Israeli policy in the Occupied Territories and ensure that its government, which rules the Occupied Territories, protects the human rights of residents there and complies with its obligations under international law."[1]
Location
Area served
Israel and the Palestinian territories[1]
Key people
Jessica Montell
Employees
38[2]
Mission "to document and educate the Israeli public and policymakers about human rights violations in the Occupied Territories, combat the phenomenon of denial prevalent among the Israeli public, and help create a human rights culture in Israel."[1]
Website http://btselem.org

B'Tselem (Hebrew: בצלם, "in the image of [God]") is an Israeli non-governmental organization (NGO) founded on February 3, 1989 by a group of prominent Israeli lawyers, academics, journalists, and members of the Knesset.[1] B'Tselem's stated goals are to document human rights violations in the occupied territories, combat denial and help to create a human rights culture in Israel.[1] In December 1989, B'Tselem shared the Carter-Menil Human Rights Prize with the Palestinian group, Al-Haq.[3][4] Its executive director is Jessica Montell.[2]

B'Tselem has been harshly criticized by Israeli nationalists. In 2011, Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman charged the group with abetting terrorism and weakening Israel's defense forces.[5]

History

B'Tselem was founded on February 3, 1989. The name comes from Genesis 1:27, which states that all mankind was created "b'tselem elohim" (in the image of God), which the organization says is in line with the UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights that all humans are equal in dignity and so deserve the same fundamental rights.[6]

Key founders were Daphna Golan-Agnon (academic and founding director of feminist peace group Bat Shalom), David Zucker (Knesset member for the Ratz party, one of the founders of the Peace Now movement), Haim Oron (Knesset member for the Mapam party, one of the founders of the Peace Now movement), Zehava Gal-On (Ratz party activist and future Knesset member for the Meretz party formed through the merger of Ratz and Mapam), Avigdor Feldman (civil liberties lawyer), and Edy Kaufman, a civil liberties activist)

On May 9, 2013, The Jerusalem Post reported a "legal sea change," and said that the positions of B'Tselem and the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) were now closer than ever. It noted that B'Tselem's 2012 report on Operation Pillar of Defense "meticulously acknowledges the challenges the IDF faces when Hamas mixes in with civilians. It records the army’s efforts, both general and specific—with narratives recounting telephone calls from security personnel to get civilians to evacuate their houses—to avoid civilian casualties." The Post said the sea change was also due to the "evolved position" of the IDF, which "significantly adjusted its procedures in Pillar of Defense" after taking internal and external critiques of past military operations into account.[7]

Main activities

The focus on documentation reflects B'Tselem's objective of providing as much information as possible to the Israeli public, since information is indispensable to taking action and making choices.

Activity in the Knesset

B'Tselem regularly provides Knesset members with information on alleged human rights violations in the West Bank, and alleged injustices caused by Israeli authorities. Several Knesset members, from various factions, assist B'Tselem in placing human rights matters on the public agenda and in safeguarding human rights.

Public action

B'Tselem has hundreds of supporters and volunteers who work to improve the human rights situation in the West Bank. These activities include, in part, setting up information stands, distributing printed material, addressing problems and requests to decision-makers, and participating in protests in the West Bank.

Reports

B'Tselem publishes reports on various issues such as torture, fatal shootings by security forces, restrictions on movement, expropriation of land and discrimination in planning and building in East Jerusalem, administrative detention, house demolitions, and violence by Israeli settlers. Over one hundred reports have been published so far. The organization serves as a source of information for journalists, researchers and the diplomatic community at the national and international level. B'Tselem's activities receive extensive media coverage.

B'Tselem also campaigns against the death penalty and the human rights record of the Palestinian Authority. On 17 February 2005, the organization called on Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas to commute the sentences of Palestinians condemned to death and abolish the death penalty. Abbas had shortly before ratified the death sentences of a number of Palestinians accused of collaborating with Israel or of other criminal charges.

Environment

Gaza

Were civilian objects the target of attacks?
Did the military respect the principle of proportionality?
Did the military use prohibited weapons including white-phosphorus shells and indiscriminate weapons?
Did soldiers shoot civilians who were not endangering their lives?
Did Israeli soldiers use civilians as human shields?
Were ambulances and medical teams attacked while performing their duties?
Was there unjustified delay in evacuation and treatment of wounded persons?[11]

House Demolition

Human Rights

Israeli army

Jerusalem

Settlements

- The army, police and Civilian Administration should enforce the law on settlers, with respect to un-authorized taking of land and violence against Palestinians.
- Dismantle fences and physical obstructions placed without official approval.
- Protect Palestinians from settler violence.[31]

Torture

Video

B'Tselem has expanded its operations in recent years to increasingly include video-based footage.[36] The expansion of its video project began in August 2007 with the launching of MySpace, Facebook and YouTube sites which are to act as an alternative area for the showcasing of the organisation's films - aimed at expanding the group's presence amongst a younger age category and attracting people to its main website. Other video sharing websites were following.[37]

B'Tselem USA

B'Tselem also maintains a branch of the organization in Washington, D.C., called B'Tselem USA. B'Tselem USA states that its mission is "to inform the political and public discourse" in the US, ensuring that "human rights are a centerpiece of both the bilateral relationship [between the US and Israel] as well as diplomatic efforts" by the US to work toward peace in the region.[38] The group's director was Uri Zaki, a former IDF officer and member of the Meretz party in Israel.[39] In 2013, Zaki, who is tenth on the Meretz party list, left Washington for Israel, where he planned to take an active role in politics.[40]

Main research areas

B'Tselem investigates in a number of aspects related to the Arab-Israeli conflict. In particular the following:

Report on rockets from Gaza

A B'Tselem report devoted to Palestinian attacks on Israeli civilians reported that from June 2004 to 17 January 2009, 19 civilians and 2 soldiers were killed in Israel by rockets and mortar fire by Palestinians. Four of them were minors.

According to the UN, cited by B'Tselem, the number of rockets fired at Israel was as follows:

Board members

B'Tselem board members are:[42]

Board members have changed over the past 10 years. Four board members from 1998 remain on the board in 2008.[44][45]

Staff

The group's executive director is Jessica Montell. In 2011 the group staff has 38 employees in a Research Department, a Data Coordination department, a communications department, and an administration department.[2] Field data research in the West Bank and Gaza Strip for B'Tselem was, until the Second Intifada, performed by Israeli Arabs. Data analysis and dissemination was conducted at the Jerusalem office. Because of restriction on entry to these areas for Israeli citizens, the Israeli Arab field workers were replaced with similarly qualified Palestinian Arabs who transmit research data to the office via fax or phone, sometimes negotiating checkpoints to reach the Jerusalem office for debriefings.[46]

Attacks on staff

B'Tselem staff members have been both verbally and physically attacked by both Israeli settlers and Israeli military/police, including the assault of two of its fieldworker staff. According to B'Tselem, in one such incident, captured on film on 19 January 2008, a fieldworker was beaten by Israeli soldiers, then arrested for attacking them.[47] In another, on 20 June 2008, according to the organization, a worker was beaten and had his film confiscated after filming IDF troops ignoring violent crimes by Israeli settlers. Following B’Tselem’s complaint, Israeli military police opened an investigation.[48] The group also claims to have been the victim of other kinds of harassment, such as the slashing of tires on the organisation's jeep.

Funding

B'Tselem is independent and is funded by contributions from foundations in Europe and North America and by private individuals in Israel and abroad, and by the governments of some EU countries and the European Commission.[49]

According to B'Tselem's 2010 financial report, they received donations from those listed in the table below.[50] (As required by Israeli law, all donations of 20,000 New Israeli Shekels (NIS) must be reported.)

Name of Donor Amount as contributed Amount in NIS
Annenberg Foundation $24,987 93,001
Commission of the European Communities €157,990 787,661
British Embassy 589,113NIS 589,113
Iris O'brien Foundation $45,595 168,973
Craig Fulton 144,750NIS 144,750
Bequeathed by Prof. Amos Matan 721,946NIS 721,946
New Israel Fund - Ford Israel Fund $70,000 + 380,030NIS 633,311
Naomi and Nehemia Cohen Foundation $20,000 + 95,050NIS 173,175
Thomas C. Hoegh $10,000 38,640
Diakonia $84,307 310,444
EED - Evangelischer Entwicklungsdienst €204,070 990,777
ICCO - Interchurch Organisation for Development Co-operation €120,000 614,000
Spunk Foundation International $35,000 131,950
Royal Norwegian Embassy 561,963NIS 561,963
SIVMO €12,624 62,885
Trocaire €49,979 249,795
Catholic Relief Services $175,000 650,950
Dan Church Aid $78,629 291,817
Christian Aid €39,984 193,123
Samuel Sebba Charitable Trust 300,000NIS 300,000
Stiftung Open Society Institute $96,956 370,905
NGO Development Center (NDC) $179,860 643,419
Pro Victimis Foundation $176,000 640,100
Sigrid Rausing Trust £281,981 1,689,868
Other donations (under 20,000NIS) 507,234
Total 9,349,724

Award Nominations

Together with two other human rights organizations, B'Tselem is a nominee for the 2014 Václav Havel Human Rights Prize selected by a panel of six independent experts chaired by Anne Brasseur, President of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe.[51]

Criticism

B'Tselem has come under intense fire for what its critics describe as misrepresenting and distorting facts.

According to the IDF's reply (1992) :

The latest Betzelem Organization Report ... addresses the activities of the (IDF's) special undercover units. Although the Report is voluminous, a large portion of the incidents cited are attributed to vague, anonymous sources - often rumors or stories gleaned from the press.
The Report ignores the prevailing situation in the area, in which armed, hard-core terrorists, who do not adhere to any code of law, have engaged in terror attacks... [1]

  1. ^ IDF Activities Against Armed Terrorists in Judea, Samaria and the Gaza District. Reply to a Report by the Betzelem Organization, May 1992

Critics of B'tselem have challenged the accuracy of its reports. The Committee for Accuracy in Middle East Reporting in America (CAMERA) and the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs charged that B'tselem repeatedly classified Arab combatants and terrorists as civilian casualties.[52][53][54][55][56] NGO Monitor said that B'tselem distorts its data and uses "abusive and demonizing rhetoric designed to elicit political support for Palestinians".[57] Caroline B. Glick, deputy managing editor of The Jerusalem Post and former advisor to Benjamin Netanyahu, pointed to several instances where she alleged B'tselem had misrepresented Palestinian rioters or terrorists as innocent victims, or where she said B'tselem failed to report when an Arab allegedly changed his testimony about an attack by settlers.[58][59] B'tselem and another human rights group are "radical leftist organizations with documented histories of falsifying and distorting data," charged Glick in an editorial.[58] She charged fellow journalists who covered B'tselem's reports with "professional malpractice... As long as we continue to base our national debates and policies on enemy propaganda, it should surprise no one that Israel finds itself in its current dire predicament."[58]

In 2011, Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman called for a parliamentary investigation of B'Tselem and other human rights organizations. These groups, he said, "are clearly not concerned with human rights. They spread lies, they slander and incite against the state of Israel and against Israeli soldiers... Clearly these organizations are abetting terrorism and their only objective is to undermine Israel," he said in a speech to fellow members of his right-wing Yisrael Beiteinu ("Israel our home") party.[5]

In each of these cases, B'tselem issued detailed rebuttals, based on its own research, as well as statistics and information from the Israeli army and international organizations.[60][61][62] Although CAMERA challenges the reliability of B'Tselem's statistics and describes them as "grossly deceptive", CAMERA commentator Tamar Sternthal notes that B'Tselem's statistics on casualty figures are "cited widely by Western news organizations".[63]

In August 2014, the Executive Director Hagai El-Ad attracted criticism in Israel for refusing to call Hamas a 'terror organization' on a radio interview.[64][65]

In late 2014, Tuvia Tenenbom wrote in his book Catch the Jew that one of B'Tselem's researchers had made what Haaretz described as "a vague comment ... to the effect that he doesn’t believe that the Germans killed Jews".[66][67] B'Tselem said the researcher "was translating a conversation between the Palestinian resident and the author" and called for release of the full interview, which they said would exonerate the researcher.[68]

Representative publications

See also

References

  1. 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 "About B'Tselem". B'Tselem. Archived from the original on 29 January 2010. Retrieved 2 February 2010.
  2. 2.0 2.1 2.2 Staff, B'Tselem.
  3. A Special Prize of the Carter-Menil Human Rights Foundation
  4. "Carter-Menil Rights Award For Israeli and Arab Groups". The New York Times. Reuters. 16 November 1989.
  5. 5.0 5.1 Bender, Arik (10 January 2011). "הוועדה הפרלמנטרית תחקור את בצלם, עדאלה ופרופיל חדש" [Parliamentary commission will investigate B'Tselem, Adalah and New Profile] (in Hebrew). NRG (Maariv). Retrieved 15 June 2011. ברור שהארגונים האלו לא עוסקים בזכויות אדם. הארגונים האלו מפיצים שקרים, מכפישים ומסיתים נגד מדינת ישראל ונגד חיילי צה"ל. מעולם, אף אחד מהארגונים האלו לא אמרו שישראל צדקה. ברור שמדובר בארגונים סייעני טרור נטו, שכל מטרתם להחליש את צה"ל." "שר החוץ אביגדור ליברמן יוצא במתקפה חריפה נגד ארגוני זכויות אדם ישראלים שיעמדו במרכז עבודתה של ועדת החקירה הפרלמנטרית שתקים הכנסת, וטען כי שורה של אי-סדרים כלכליים שלדבריו מאפיינים אותם עשויה להצביע על סיוע לפעילות טרור.
  6. "B'Tselem Brochure" (PDF). B'Tselem. Retrieved 16 April 2013.
  7. Yonah Jeremy Bob (2013-05-09). "Analysis: B'Tselem, IDF positions closer than ever". The Jerusalem Post. Retrieved 2013-05-30.
  8. June 2009. Pages 41-42.
  9. March 2005. ISSN 0793-520X. Pages 80,81.
  10. Status Report September 2006. ISSN 156-8325. Pages 34,35.
  11. February 2009. ISSN 1565-1746. Page 23.
  12. February 2002. Pages 41,42. Also questions effectiveness.
  13. Information Sheet November 2004. Pages 57,58. Heshin cites the Torah; "senior defense establishment official": As for those who carry out the suicide attacks, the supply is greater than demand.
  14. Information sheet December 2000. Pages 39, 40.
  15. Information Sheet January 2001. Page 32.
  16. Information Sheet June 2001. ISSN 0792-8114. Page 14.
  17. Position Paper, Jerusalem March 2003. Page 36.
  18. Information Sheet September 2006. ISSN 0792-8114. Pages 41-43.
  19. July 2006. ISSN 0793-520X. Page 46.
  20. October 2009. ISSN 0793-520X. Page 65.
  21. December 2010. ISSN 0793-520X. Pages 31,32.
  22. Information Sheet March 2002. Page 28.
  23. Information Sheet May 2005. ISSN 0792-8114. Page 30.
  24. October 2010. ISSN 0793-520X. Page 49.
  25. April 1997. Page 33.
  26. Status report September 2003. Page 24.
  27. March 2001, ISSN 0792-8114. Page 37.
  28. Status report August 2003. Page 35.
  29. Information sheet August 2004. ISSN 0792-8114. Pages 36,37.
  30. December 2008. ISSN 0792-8114. Pages 32,33.
  31. September 2008. Page 79.
  32. The Interrogation of Palestinians During the Intifada: Ill-Treatment, "Moderate Physical Pressure" or Torture?, March 1991 | B'Tselem
  33. January 2000, Position Paper ISSN 1565-1746. Page 75.
  34. Information Sheet July 2001. Page 20.
  35. http://www.btselem.org/english/publications/summaries/201010_kept_in_the_dark.asp: Page 60
  36. B'Tselem (Contributor) (2007-01-11). Sharmouta ("whore" in Arabic). Event occurs at 01:03 minutes. Retrieved 2007-12-30.
  37. B'Tselem at YouTube
    B'Tselem at MySpace
    B'Tselem at Facebook
    B'Tselem at Dailymotion
    B'Tselem at Sevenload
    B'Tselem-Videos at Yahoo! Video
  38. "B'Tselem USA". B'Tselem. Retrieved 16 April 2013.
  39. "Staff Bios". B'Tselem USA. B'Tselem. Retrieved 16 April 2013.
  40. Ben Zehavi (May 29, 2013). "Human rights activist trades DC for Israeli politics". Times of Israel.
  41. Ha'aretz 14 August 2008 B'tselem: IDF only launched 4 probes into 189 Palestinian deaths By Yuval Azoulay
  42. Board members, B'Tselem.
  43. Journalist, B'Tselem founder Amnon Kapeliouk dies aged 78, By Ofri Ilani, Haaretz Correspondent, 28/06/2009
  44. B'Tselem Quarterly for Human Rights in the Occupied Territories, December 1998
  45. List of Btselem board members, 2008
  46. Tamar Hausman, Haaretz, B'Tselem chooses its first Anglo director, 17.07.01
  47. B'Tselem: Soldiers assault and arrest B'Tselem worker in Hebron
  48. B'Tselem: Soldier assaults B'Tselem worker filming settler violence, takes the cassette
  49. "List of donors to B'Tselem". B'Tselem. Archived from the original on 29 January 2010. Retrieved 2 February 2010.
  50. Btselem 2010 Financial Statement
  51. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe website, "Three Nominees for the Václav Havel Human Rights Prize 2014," 26 August 2014, http://www.assembly.coe.int/nw/xml/News/News-View-EN.asp?newsid=5163&lang=2&cat=37
  52. B'Tselem, Los Angeles Times Redefine "Civilian", CAMERA Media Analyses, 7 July 2003.
  53. Sternthal, Tamar (2008-09-24). "Bending the truth". Ynetnews. Archived from the original on 25 September 2008. Retrieved 2008-09-26.
  54. Researcher Slams B'Tselem as Inflating Arab Civilian Casualties, by Gil Ronen, Published: 10/26/08
  55. B'Tselem's Annual Casualty Figures Questioned, CAMERA Media Analyses, January 3, 2007.
  56. Amos Harel, מחקר: "בצלם" מפרסם מידע שגוי ומשמיט פרטים חיוניים, Haaretz, October 26, 2008.
  57. Betselem: Report Uses Outdated Sources and the Rhetoric of Demonization, NGO Monitor Analysis (Vol. 2 No. 12), 15 August 2004.
  58. 58.0 58.1 58.2 Column one: What is Israel's problem? , , The Jerusalem Post, May 10, 2007.
  59. Column One: Agents of influence
  60. B'Tselem Official written response to the CAMERA Organisation, Fax & Press Release, 22nd August 2007
  61. Jessica Montell, B’Tselem chief: “Caroline Glick a hack who parrots any drivel”, +972 Magazine, January 21, 2011
  62. "Explanation of statistics on fatalities" from the B'Tselem website.
  63. Tamar Sternthal, "Bending the Truth", Ynet, August 24, 2009.
  64. http://www.nrg.co.il/online/1/ART2/607/207.html
  65. http://www.globes.co.il/news/article.aspx?did=1000963157
  66. Tenenbom, Tuvia. Catch The Jew. New York: Gefen Publishing House.
  67. Sfard, Michael (March 19, 2015). "Catch the Jew! - An 'Investigation' as an Unintended Parody". Haaretz. Retrieved April 19, 2015.
  68. Goodman, Alana (September 8, 2014). "B’Tselem Sticking by Staffer Accused of Holocaust Denial". The Washington Free Beacon. Retrieved April 19, 2015.

External links