Vivartavada

Part of a series on
Hindu philosophy
Schools Samkhya Yoga Nyaya Vaisheshika Mīmāṃsā Vedanta Advaita Vedanta Vishishtadvaita Dvaita Dvaitadvaita Achintya Bheda Abheda Bhedabheda Shaiva Pratyabhijña Pashupata Siddhanta Tantra
Personalities Philosophers-Acharyas Samkhya Kapila Yoga Patanjali Nyaya Akṣapāda Gotama Jayanta Bhatta Raghunatha Siromani Vaiseshika Kanada Mimamsa Jaimini Kumārila Bhaṭṭa Prabhākara Dayananda Saraswati (Arsha Vidya) Advaita Vedanta Gaudapada Adi Shankara Vācaspati Miśra Vidyaranya Sadananda Madhusūdana Sarasvatī Ramakrishna Swami Vivekananda Bhagawan Nityananda Ramana Maharshi Siddharudha Swami Narayana Guru Sivananda Saraswati Chinmayananda Saraswati Nisargadatta Maharaj Dayanand Saraswati Nigamananda Paramahansa Vishishta-Advaita Nammalvar Alvars Yamunacharya Ramanuja Vedanta Desika Pillai Lokacharya Manavala Mamunigal Lakshmi Kumara Thathachariar Dvaita Madhvacharya Jayatirtha Vyasatirtha Sripadaraja Vadirajatirtha Raghavendra Swami Dvaita-Advaita Nimbarka Shuddha-Advaita Vallabha Acharya Achintya-Bhedabheda Chaitanya Mahaprabhu Prabhupada Tantra / Shakta Abhinavagupta Nigamananda Paramahansa Ramprasad Sen Kamalakanta Bhattacharya Bamakhepa Anandamayi Ma Poet-Saints Purandara Dasa Kanaka Dasa Jagannatha Dasa Vijaya Dasa Gopala Dasa Basava Dnyaneshwar Sankardev Jayadeva Namdev Ramananda Kabir Tulsidas Guru Ravidass Mira Bai Narsinh Mehta Surdas Samarth Ramdas Tukaram Eknath Janabai Brahmanand Swami Tukdoji Maharaj Tyagaraja Annamacharya Kancherla Gopanna Nayanars Muthuswami Dikshitar Syama Sastri Yoga-Guru Nigamananda Paramahansa Integral-Yoga Sri Aurobindo Kriya-Yoga Paramahansa Yogananda Siddha-Yoga Muktananda Academician-Philosophers Ananda Coomaraswamy Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan Swami Gahanananda Ravi Shankar
v t e

Part of a series on
Buddhism
History Timeline Gautama Buddha Councils Later Buddhists
Dharma Concepts Four Noble Truths Five Aggregates Impermanence Suffering Non-self Dependent Origination Middle Way Emptiness Karma Rebirth Saṃsāra Cosmology
Practices Three Jewels Buddhist Paths to liberation Morality Perfections Meditation Mindfulness Wisdom Compassion Aids to Enlightenment Monasticism Laity
Nirvāṇa Four Stages Arahant Buddha Bodhisattva
Traditions Canons Theravāda Pāli Mahāyāna Hinayana Chinese Vajrayāna Tibetan Navayana
Outline Buddhism portal
v t e

Vivartavada is the term derived from the Sanskrit word - vivarta which means illusive, not real, appearance or false-belief. It is a philosophical term that means 'the origin of the universe from the manifestation or appearance of the unique Brahman'; it is juxtaposed to the term parinamvada.^[1] It denotes the Advaita theory of Superimposition (adhyasa) which is in concurrence with the statements of the Upanishads to the effect that when ignorance is ended by right knowledge the true nature of an object becomes known. The relation that obtains between Brahman and the world has in its background the general theory of Satkaryavada, the theory that the effect pre-exists in its cause, and vivartavada, the theory that the effect, the world, is merely an unreal (vivarta) transformation of its cause, Brahman. Creation is only apparent change and not a modification of Brahman in reality. Brahman is reality and reality is non-dual.^[2] Sankara in his Vivekachudamani Sloka 261 reiterates - एकमेव सदनेककारणं – That which exists as one only, is the cause of multiplicity, superimposed.^[3]

Buddhist thinkers and teachers have expressed their views on the concept of Duality developed by the Vedic thinkers and teachers. Zen teaches that we should be free from dualities in order to be what we are meant to be, and that duality is due to ego which veils reality from its true essence (explained by Buddhists in terms of non-essence); ego, which is an artificial condition not having a true identity because it is a creation of the mind, distorts reality in an attempt to perceive what it wants to perceive, and not what it is. Taoism teaches that reality is like the un- carved block (the symbol of Tao), one must not carve the block lest Tao is changed. Sankara considers Maya as a temporary or phenomenal reality and Brahman as the Ultimate reality; and that living in Maya the Jiva (the 'ego-self') superimposes its own interpretation of reality onto reality, and thus Brahman remains hidden or concealed and Maya is viewed as the ultimate reality.^[4]

There are broadly seven basics of the Advaita philosophy advocated by Adi Shankara, which are:

1. There are three levels of Truth – a) the 'Transcendental' or the Paramarthika level, in which Brahman is the only reality and nothing else, b) the 'Pragmatic' or the Vyavaharika level, in which both Jiva and Ishwara are true and, c) the 'Apparent' or the Prathibhasika level, in which even the material world is false, an illusion.
2. Brahman (Nirguna) is visible as the material world and its objects, due to ignorance (avidya).
3. Maya is the complex illusionary power of Brahman that causes Brahman to be seen in many forms.
4. Ishwara or the Saguna Brahman is the reflection of the Self falling upon the mirror of Maya, it is ignorance which is the cause of unhappiness and sin in the mortal world.
5. Atman is the soul or the self identical with Brahman, it is not part of Brahman that ultimately dissolves into Brahman but the whole Brahman itself; Atman is alone, when its reflection falls on Avidya it becomes the Jiva and experiences the world existence through the senses.
6. Moksha or Liberation results when Maya is removed when there ultimately exists no difference between the Jiva and the Atman.
7. 'Creation' – Though the karana named Brahman, due to vivarta, appears as the karya named jagat, there is actually no separate karya in reality – Brahman is the only reality and jagat is mithya ('illusion').^[5]

Advaita denies real creation from the level of the highest truth, at ordinary level it accepts the world just as it appears to common sense. Ajativada (the theory of no origination of Gaudapada) is associated with Vivartavada (the theory of manifestation of Sankara), they are the same teaching at the parmartha basis but from two different angles – a) when the focus is kept on the changeless Brahman, and as a consequence of that perspective the world is seen to be merely an unreal appearance, the teaching is ajativada; but b) when the focus shifts to the empirical fact of the world-appearance, and specifically onto the relation between the world-appearance and Brahman, the teaching is vivartavada, the former finds the world to be a dream and a magic, whereas to the latter, the world existence is illusory.^[6] Aurobindo considers Vivartavada to be the denial of causation and the assertion of identity presupposing parinama or 'effectual transformation'.^[7]

The 'Theory of Manifestation' propounded by the Advaita Vedanta is not without its opponents. Vijnanabhiksu portrays casual relation as having three terms – unchangeable locus cause, changeable locus cause and effect – the locus cause is inseparable from and does not inhere in the changeable cause and the effect .^[8] and, the Pratyabhijna philosophy of Somananda refutes the Arambhvada (the 'Realistic view' of the Nyaya-Vaisesika), the Parinamavada (the theory of Transformation of the Sankhya-Yoga) and the Vivartavada (the theory of Manifestation of the Advaita), by postulating the theory of Svatantravada (the 'Universal voluntarism') which states that it is due to the sovereignty of God’s Will that Effect evolves from Cause.^[9] Whereas Ramanuja accepts Prakrti as the material cause but Madhava rejects this contention since material cause does not mean that which controls and superintends; Madhava also rejects the Vivartavada because it does not accept any effect that has got to be accounted for.^[10]

References