Litchfield Law School

Tapping Reeve House and Law School
U.S. National Register of Historic Places
U.S. National Historic Landmark
East elevation and north profile of house, 2010
Location	Litchfield, CT
Coordinates	41°44′37.86″N 73°11′19.52″W / 41.7438500°N 73.1887556°W / 41.7438500; -73.1887556Coordinates: 41°44′37.86″N 73°11′19.52″W / 41.7438500°N 73.1887556°W / 41.7438500; -73.1887556
Built	1773
Governing body	Private
NRHP Reference #	66000879
Significant dates
Added to NRHP	October 15, 1966[1]
Designated NHL	December 21, 1965[2]

The Litchfield Law School of Litchfield, Connecticut, was the second formal school offering training for the legal profession founded in the United States of America, after the William & Mary School of Law. It was established in 1784 by Tapping Reeve, who later became the Chief Justice of the Connecticut Supreme Court. By the time the school closed in 1833, over 1,100 young men from throughout the country had attended, many of whom went on to have significant influence on political, economic, and legal development of the United States during the antebellum period. Some of the school's most notable students include John C. Calhoun and Aaron Burr.

The law school, including Reeve's house, was declared a National Historic Landmark in 1965 as the Tapping Reeve House and Law School.^[2][3] The Tapping Reeve House and Law School are owned and operated by the Litchfield Historical Society as a museum and contains the interpretive exhibit The Noblest Study which illustrates the lives and studies of the students who traveled to Litchfield to study at the Litchfield Law School and Litchfield Female Academy.

The Society also operates the Litchfield History Museum, and admission includes both sites.

Tapping Reeve

Tapping Reeve, the founder of the Litchfield Law School, was born in 1744, son of the Rev. Abner Reeve, a Presbyterian minister who had graduated from Yale in 1731, and his wife Deborah. Tapping Reeve attended the College of New Jersey, later Princeton, graduating in 1763. He remained in Elizabethtown to teach at a grammar school associated with the college. Reeve then tutored at Princeton and was hired to privately teach the orphaned children of the Rev. Aaron Burr, Sr., the former President of the college, and his wife Esther Edwards Burr. Tapping Reeve taught young Aaron Burr and his sister Sally for several years. By 1771 Reeve had moved to Hartford, Connecticut, where he studied law with Judge Jesse Root, passing the bar there in 1772.

Reeve moved to Litchfield the same year and established a practice, marrying his former pupil Sally Burr. He built a home on South Street and established a legal practice. In 1774 his brother-in-law, Aaron Burr, left his ministerial studies with the Reverend Joseph Bellamy for the ministry and moved to Litchfield to study the law with Reeve. Burr left a year later to join the Continental Army on the outbreak of the Revolutionary War, but Reeve continued to take law students.

Law School

In the early years Reeve continued the clerking or apprenticeship system of having the young men work for him while they studied his law books. He also presented talks on the principles of law. In 1784, as the number of young men in his office increased following the close of the Revolution, Reeve built a small building (similar to a one room school house) next to his house where he gave his lectures. He based them upon Blackstone’s Commentaries, which he refined into a 14 month-long course of study. The curriculum covered all areas of legal practice, noting developing changes in the new nation’s adaptation of British Common Law. Students took rough notes during the lectures, copying them carefully after checking citations, which were put in the margins. Many students had their notes carefully bound into leather volumes, which became important reference works for them in their future practice.

Reeve was the sole proprietor of the school until 1798, when he was elected to the Connecticut State Supreme Court. At that point, he hired James Gould, a former student, as a partner. Gould built his own small lecture room next to his home on North Street and men attended lectures there as well as at Reeve’s. Both men lectured to the students until Reeve’s retirement in 1820, after which Gould continued the school on his own until retiring in 1833.

The Litchfield Law School was the first formal school of law in the United States offering a vocational curriculum for future attorneys. William and Mary College in Virginia offered lectures on the law, but they provided a brief introduction to the law believed to be a part of a “liberal education” for the gentleman scholars who would later assume political responsibilities.

The Litchfield Law School was never chartered by the state, remaining a proprietary effort of Reeve and Gould. It therefore never offered degrees as a credential. At the conclusion of their studies, many of the students took the Bar exam in Litchfield, even though they would be required to clerk in the office of a lawyer on returning to their homes and take the local Bar exam. The students would also obtain letters of reference from Reeve or Gould, stating their attendance and completion of the Litchfield course of lectures. In the apprenticeship tradition, these letters usually attested to the young man having “read law” with Reeve or Gould.

The Litchfield Law School was unique among the proprietary law schools of the period in that its students came from every part of the United States. Only one third of the students enrolled from Connecticut and one quarter from the adjacent states of New York and Massachusetts. A fifth of the students were from southern states, including 60 from Georgia, 40 from South Carolina and 21 from North Carolina. The Litchfield Law School had no educational entrance requirements. Two-thirds of the known students had attended college, with one quarter of them being Yale graduates. In the tradition of apprenticeship training, the school also admitted non-college men from a variety of socio-economic backgrounds.

Between 1774 and 1833, 945 young men who attended the school have been identified. An additional 200 or more men are believed to have attended the school in the early years when no lists of students were kept. The number of students was notable, given that in 1800 there were only 100 practicing lawyers in the state of Connecticut. Peak enrollment at the school was reached in 1813, when 55 men attended.

The Litchfield Law School’s greatest influence was in shaping future legal education in the United States. Reeve distinguished the study of the law as based upon general principles and methods, and upon a national level, not as they pertained to specific states. The school established the formal study of law as graduate education, distinct from an undergraduate curriculum. However, the school left the more practical or clinical aspects of learning the law to further apprenticeship.

The primary reason for the end of the Litchfield Law School was competition from new courses at Yale, Harvard, Columbia, the University of Virginia and other university law schools. Equally important was the boom in legal publishing by 1830, which made the lecture model obsolete. The new law schools replaced the lecture method with text reading and recitations and, much later, with the case method. The growth in legal theory and practice made it impossible to be covered by one person in a 14 month series of lectures. Other factors which kept the school from flourishing in the 1830s were the inability of a proprietary institution to attract philanthropy to endow facilities, libraries and faculty, as well as the general decline of Litchfield as an intellectual, economic and cultural center.

Alumni settled in 34 states and three territories, where many served as legal and political reporters, clerks of courts and legislatures. Others published legal texts and treatises. Litchfield trained lawyers were instrumental in developing laws to deal with the economic and industrial boom of the nineteenth century. Each new technological advance created a need for new laws, while the growth of corporate law greatly increased the importance of lawyers in the economy.

The influence of the Litchfield Law School students on American politics is largely unknown. Ninety-seven students, more than 10%, later served in the United States House of Representatives and 28 were United States Senators. These alumni played major roles in every important national political issue of the pre-Civil War period. At the state level, 15 alumni were elected governors of states and territories. Large numbers served as state senator and representatives and many were city and county office holders. Others became prominent in fields such as education, religion and the arts. The influence of alumni of the Litchfield Law School as individuals is well known. Their collective influence and the impact of their experiences at the school have yet to be analyzed.

Notable students

The list of students who attended Tapping Reeve's law school includes two Vice Presidents of the United States (Aaron Burr and John C. Calhoun), 101 members of the United States House of Representatives, 28 United States senators, six United States cabinet secretaries, three justices of the United States Supreme Court, 14 state governors and 13 state supreme court chief justices. Litchfield Law School students also held state and local political office and became business leaders. Students went on to found university law schools and become university presidents.^[4] Framed pictures of students are still hung in the school, including George Catlin, Horace Mann (the educator), Aaron Burr, Jr., Oliver Wolcott, Jr., and US Senator & Connecticut Governor Roger Sherman Baldwin. Each name in this list is followed by the year that the student finished, when known.

• John Allen, 1784^[5]
• Ezekiel Bacon, 1794^[6]
• William J. Bacon, 1823^[7]
• Joshua Baker, 1821, Governor of Louisiana^[8]
• Henry Baldwin, 1797, Associate Justice of the U. S. Supreme Court^[9]
• Roger Sherman Baldwin, 1812 (son of Simeon Baldwin and the grandson of Roger Sherman)^[10]
• James Bell, 1824^[11]
• Edmund H. Bennett^{[citation needed]}
• Aaron Burr, Jr., 1774, U.S. Vice President, U.S. Senator^[12]
• Chester Pierce Butler, 1818^[13]
• John Caldwell Calhoun, 1805, U.S. Vice-President, U.S. Senator, Secretary of State, Secretary of War^[14]
• George Catlin, 1817^[15]
• John M. Clayton, 1817, U. S. Senator and Secretary of State^[16]
• John A. Collier, 1805^[17]
• Joel Crawford, 1806^[18]
• William Crosby Dawson, 1817^[19]
• Thomas Day, 1797^[20]
• John Stark Edwards, 1796^{[citation needed]}
• Amos Ellmaker, 1806^[21]
• Henry Leavitt Ellsworth, 1811^[22]
• John Myers Felder, 1806^[23]
• Thomas Flournoy Foster, 1816^[24]
• Samuel A. Foot, 1797, Connecticut Governor, U.S. Representative and Senator^[25]
• John Brown Francis, 1813, U.S. Senator from Rhode Island 1844-45, Governor of Rhode Island 1833-38^[26]
• Hopkins Holsey^[27]
• Ward Hunt, 1830, Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States^[28]
• James G. King (1791–1853), businessman and politician who represented New Jersey's 5th congressional district from 1849 to 1851.^[29]
• Lucius Quintus Cincinnatus Lamar (I), 1817^[30]
• Horace Mann, 1822^[31]
• Rutger B. Miller, 1824^[32]
• Eugenius Aristides Nisbet, 1823^[33]
• Elisha Phelps, 1801^[34]
• Horatio Seymour, 1798^[35]
• Roger Minott Sherman, 1794 (son of Rev. Josiah Sherman, the brother of Roger Sherman)^[36]
• Richard Skinner, 1798 ^[37]
• Perry Smith, 1807, U. S. Senator^[38]
• Truman Smith, 1817, U. S. Senator^[39]
• Frederick A. Tallmadge,^[40] 1811
• Uriah Tracy, 1778^[41]
• Stephen Upson, 1805^[42]
• Nicholas Ware, 1792^[43]
• Lemuel Whitman, 1805^[44]
• Elisha Dana Whittlesey, 1813^[45]
• Frederick Whittlesey, 1819^[46]
• Thomas T. Whittlesey, 1818^[47]
• Oliver Wolcott, Jr., 1778^[48]
• Levi Woodbury, 1809, U. S. Supreme Court Justice, Senator, Secretary of the Treasury and Navy, and Governor of New Hampshire^[49]
• Augustus Romaldus Wright, 1833^[50]

See also

• List of National Historic Landmarks in Connecticut
• National Register of Historic Places listings in Litchfield County, Connecticut
• Tapping Reeve

Bibliography

Baldwin, Simeon Eben. James Gould: A Sketch. Philadelphia: John C. Winston Co., 1909.

Beecher, Lyman. A Sermon Preached at the Funeral of the Hon. Tapping Reeve: Late Chief Justice of the State of Connecticut, who Died December Thirteen, Eighteen Hundred and Twenty-Three, in the Eightieth Year of His Age, with Explanatory Notes. Litchfield, CT: S.S. Smith, 1827.

Blondel-Libardi, Catherine, “Rediscovering the Litchfield Law School Notebooks,” Connecticut History 46 (Spring 2007): 70-82.

Calder, Jacqueline. 1978. Life and Times of Tapping Reeve and his Law School. Typescript.

Collier, Christopher. “Tapping Reeve, The Connecticut Common Law, and America’s First Law School.” Connecticut Supreme Court History 1 (2006): 13-25.

Farnham, Thomas J. “Tapping Reeve and America’s First Law School.” New England Galaxy 17 (1975): 3-13.

Fisher, Samuel H. The Litchfield Law School: Address by Samuel Fisher. Litchfield, CT: Litchfield Enquirer Press, 1930.

Fisher, Samuel H. Litchfield Law School, 1774-1833: A Biographical Catalogue of Students. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1946.

Halow, D. Brooke. Litchfield’s Legacy in Law: A Study of the Litchfield Law School’s Influence on Legal Training in America, 1784-1833. American Studies 493, Yale Law School, 1996.

Kilbourn, Dwight C. The Bench and Bar of Litchfield County, Connecticut, 1709-1909: Biographical Sketches of Members, History and Catalogue of the Litchfield Law School, Historical Notes. Litchfield, CT: Self Published, 1909.

Kronman, Anthony, ed. History of the Yale Law School. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2004.

Litchfield Historical Society. The Litchfield Law School, Litchfield, Connecticut: A Brief Historical Sketch. Litchfield,CT: Litchfield Historical Society, 1952.

Litchfield Historical Society. Presentation of the Reeve Law School building to the Litchfield Historical Society at Litchfield, Conn., August 22d, 1911. Litchfield, CT: Litchfield Enquirer Press, 1911.

Litchfield Historical Society. The Noblest Study: The Legacy of America’s First School of Law. Permanent Exhibition, Tapping Reeve House, Litchfield, CT.

Litchfield Law School. Catalogue: Reprint of 1900. Litchfield, CT: Litchfield Enquirer Press, 1900.

Litchfield Law School Students. Catalogue of the Litchfield Law School From 1798 to 1827 Inclusive. Litchfield, CT: S.S. Smith, 1828.

McKenna, Marian C. Tapping Reeve and the Litchfield Law School. New York: Oceana, 1986.

Pruitt, Jr., Paul M. and David I. Durham. Commonplace Books of Law: A Selection of Law Related Notebooks from the Seventeenth Century to the Mid-Twentieth Century. Tuscaloosa, AL: University of Alabama Law Library, 2005.

Sheppard, Steve, ed.. The History of Legal Education in the United States. 2vols. Pasadena, CA: Salem Press, Inc., 1999.

References

External links

• Reeve House and Litchfield Law School - Litchfield Historical Society
• Helga J. Ingraham Memorial Library Finding Aids - Archon - Litchfield Historical Society
• The Ledger - Litchfield Historical Society
• Law School, South Street, Litchfield, Litchfield County, CT: 1 photo and supplemental material, at Historic American Building Survey

v t e Law schools in New England Connecticut University of Connecticut School of Law Quinnipiac University School of Law Yale Law School Maine University of Maine School of Law Massachusetts Boston College Law School Boston University School of Law Harvard Law School University of Massachusetts School of Law Massachusetts School of Law New England School of Law Northeastern University School of Law Southern New England School of Law (closed) Suffolk University Law School Western New England University School of Law New Hampshire University of New Hampshire School of Law Rhode Island Roger Williams University School of Law Vermont Vermont Law School

v t e U.S. National Register of Historic Places in Connecticut Lists by county Fairfield Hartford Litchfield Middlesex New Haven New London Tolland Windham Lists by city or town Bridgeport Greenwich Hartford Middletown New Haven Southington Stamford West Hartford Windsor Other lists Bridges National Historic Landmarks Keeper of the Register History of the National Register of Historic Places Property types Historic district Contributing property