Freddie Lindstrom

Freddie Lindstrom
Third baseman / Outfielder
Born: (1905-11-21)November 21, 1905 Chicago, Illinois
Died: October 4, 1981(1981-10-04) (aged 75) Chicago, Illinois
Batted: Right	Threw: Right
MLB debut
April 15, 1924 for the New York Giants
Last MLB appearance
May 15, 1936 for the Brooklyn Dodgers
Career statistics
Batting average	.311
Hits	1,747
Home runs	103
Runs scored	895
Runs batted in	779
Teams
New York Giants (1924–1932) Pittsburgh Pirates (1933–1934) Chicago Cubs (1935) Brooklyn Dodgers (1936)
Member of the National Baseball Hall of Fame
Induction	1976
Election Method	Veteran's Committee

Frederick Charles Lindstrom (November 21, 1905 – October 4, 1981) was a National League baseball player with the New York Giants, Pittsburgh Pirates, Chicago Cubs and Brooklyn Dodgers from 1924 until 1936. He was inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1976.

At the age of 23, Lindstrom hit .358 for the Giants and was named The Sporting News Major League All Star team’s third baseman ahead of Pittsburgh’s Harold “Pie” Traynor.^[1] Two years later, he repeated the honor while scoring 127 runs and batting .379, second only to Rogers Hornsby among right-handed batters in National League history.^[2]

In 1930, Giants manager John McGraw ranked Lindstrom ninth among the top 20 players of the previous quarter century.^[3] Babe Ruth picked him as his NL all-star third baseman over Traynor for the decade leading up to the first inter-league All Star game in 1933.^[4] Modern-day statistics guru Bill James, who rates Lindstrom No. 43 on his all-time third basemen list, placed him among the top three under-21 players at that position and called the 1927 Giant infield of Lindstrom, Hornsby, Travis Jackson and Bill Terry the decade’s best.^[5] From his rookie season in 1924 through 1930 as a Giants third baseman, a span of seven years during which he batted .328 and played brilliantly in the field, Lindstrom seemed headed for a place among the game’s all-time greatest players. “Those hands of his (Lindstrom’s) are the talk of the baseball world. Sensational playing places him among greatest in game,” wrote sports writer Pat Robinson of the New York Daily News in the spring of 1929, after Lindstrom finished second the previous year to St. Louis Cardinal first baseman Jim Bottomley in the National League’s Most Valuable Player balloting.^[6] “The best third sacker in the National League, one of the greatest third basemen the game has ever produced,” gushed William Hennigan in the New York World.^[7] “Lindstrom hit peaks of third basing never before attained during the final month of last season,” added Ken Smith in the New York Evening Graphic. “An outstanding individual of the game, another Hornsby, Wagner, Cobb, or Speaker, this kid, ace fielder, hitter, thinker and runner.” ^[8]

Joe Foley, in This Sporting Life, echoed a common theme among baseball writers during that stretch of Lindstrom’s career when he named his perfect team: “Sisler on first, Lajoie at second, Wagner at short, Lindstrom at third, Ruth, Speaker and Cobb in the outfield, Kling catching and Brown, Walsh, Bender and Mathewson taking turns pitching.” ^[9]

In 1931, though, injuries including a chronic bad back and broken leg, brought about his switch to the outfield where for several years he remained an above-average but no longer All Star player until his retirement after 13 seasons in 1936.^[10]

Early life

Born on Chicago’s South Side not far from Comiskey Park, Lindstrom as a youngster was an ardent White Sox fan, often playing hooky from school to watch their games. He was devastated when his hero, Shoeless Joe Jackson, and other teammates were banned from baseball for allegedly throwing the 1919 World Series.^[11] Three years later, after a tryout with the Cubs didn’t pan out, he signed a contract at the age of 16 with the New York Giants. A sophomore at Chicago’s Loyola Academy at the time, he was assigned to the Toledo Mudhens where he played for two years with such future Giant teammates as Travis Jackson and Bill Terry.^[12]

New York Giants

Called up in 1924 and eventually replacing the injured Heinie Groh at third base, 18-year-old Lindstrom batted .333 in the World Series including four hits in one game against Washington’s Walter Johnson while playing errorless in the field.^[13] The youngest player ever in a post-season game, he was described by Johnson after the fifth game as “a wonder, easily the brightest star in this series.”^[14] But a bad-hop bouncer over his head in the 12th inning of the seventh game gave the series to the Senators and became an enduring moment in baseball lore. “So they won it,” Lindstrom later recalled. “(Giants pitcher) Jack Bentley, who was something of a philosopher, I think summed it up after the game. ‘Walter Johnson,’ Bentley said, ‘is such a loveable character that the good Lord didn’t want to see him get beat again.’”^[15]

Playing in an era when fielders’ gloves were little more than padded strips of leather with a baseball-sized pocket in the palm, Lindstrom for three of the next four seasons led National League third basemen in fielding percentage. He also topped the league in assists in 1928, finishing second with 34 double plays and 506 total chances. All while posting 231 hits in both 1928 and 1930 including nine hits in a double header, a record never surpassed to this day.^[16] A million-dollar infield,” said writer Arnold Hano of the late-1920s Giant quartet. “Fans would come early just to watch their fielding-practice magic.” In an essay on Willie Mays’ famous 1954 back-to-the-plate catch off Cleveland’s Vic Wertz, Hano claimed that an even more sensational play was Lindstrom’s full-length, leaping grab before crashing into the outfield wall in a 1932 Giants-Pirates game that the New York Herald Tribune later called “the greatest catch ever made in the Polo Grounds.”^[17] During his nine seasons with the Giants, Lindstrom batted .318 (fourth on the team’s all-time list in the 20th century), while demonstrating his ability to come through in the clutch with pennant-chasing hitting streaks in September 1928 that raised his average from .342 to .358 and in 1930 from .354 to .379.^[18] As late as 1935 while playing center field for the Chicago Cubs, his .427 batting average during a stretch of 21 consecutive victories was credited by such Chicago newsmen as John P. Carmichael and Warren Brown as the main factor in the Cubs’ drive for the NL championship.^[19]

Often referred to as “the last of the great place hitters” on McGraw teams that emphasized advancing runners into scoring position rather than relying on the long ball,^[20] Lindstrom in 1931 was led to believe that he would succeed the long-time Giants manager. “We’re making that change we spoke about next year,” Lindstrom, recuperating from a broken leg, said he was told by Giants’ club secretary Jim Tierney. “McGraw is going out and we want to make you manager.”^[21] Instead, for reasons that some traced to Lindstrom’s leadership role in a player revolt against their often dictatorial manager (a charge he consistently denied, although admitting that he often spoke out against the feisty skipper nicknamed Little Napoleon), club owner Horace Stoneham chose first baseman Bill Terry to replace McGraw.^[22] Although the two remained friends, Terry traded Lindstrom to Pittsburgh in 1933 because, Terry said, "Fred no longer has that burst of speed he used to have."^[23]

Pirates, Cubs, and Dodgers

Playing in the outfield between Lloyd and Paul Waner, Lindstrom regained his elite status as a player by finishing second on the Pirates to shortstop Arky Vaughan by four percentage points with a .310 batting average (eighth highest in the National League), hitting 39 doubles and leading the league’s center fielders with a .986 fielding average.^[16]

But after one outstanding season, Lindstrom again found himself involved with a team expected to contend for a pennant struggling with controversy. First, George Gibson was fired as manager 51 games into the season with the Pirates mired in fourth place. His replacement, Pie Traynor, moved Lindstrom to left field and then to the bench after breaking his finger in a fungo game.^[24] At season’s end, despite fielding .990 and again outhitting Lloyd Waner while playing in 43 fewer games, Lindstrom was traded to the Chicago Cubs where he quickly became what Cubs manager Charley Grimm later called “a vital asset” in the team’s 1935 league championship.^[25] Starting at third base ahead of Stan Hack, he was later shifted to fill a void in center field. There, Grimm said, as boss of the outfield he allowed only seven pop flies to fall safely during that 21-game streak. He also drove in the winning run, or scored it, in seven of the games including three singles and a double off Dizzy Dean of the St. Louis Cardinals in the pennant-clinching contest. “And why isn’t Lindstrom in the Hall of Fame?” Grimm asked in a 1968 interview.^[26]

After the Cubs lost to the Detroit Tigers in the World Series, however, the following January he was released and later signed by the Brooklyn Dodgers. After only 26 games and a .264 batting average on a Casey Stengel-led team known as the Daffy Dodgers for their often inept play (Stengel was fired at season’s end), the onetime Boy Wonder turned Silver Fox at the age of 30 for his prematurely graying hair abruptly retired from baseball following a collision with infielder Jimmy Jordan while going for a routine pop fly. “I have been in this league 12 years,” Lindstrom reportedly said, “and it never happened to me until I put on a Brooklyn uniform.” ^[27]

Later career and personal life

In later years, Lindstrom managed minor league teams at Fort Smith, Arkansas, and Knoxville, Tennessee. After coaching the Northwestern University baseball team for 13 seasons, he was appointed postmaster of Evanston, Illinois, a position he held until 1972. He died nine years later and is buried with his wife, Irene, in Chicago’s All Saints Cemetery.^[28] The youngest of their three sons, Chuck Lindstrom, played briefly for the 1958 Chicago White Sox, hitting a sacrifice fly, walking and tripling for a perfect 1.000 batting average in three plate appearances.^[29]

Legacy

Although many modern-day baseball historians refer to Traynor as the era’s premier fielding third baseman, the Pirate Hall of Famer led the league in errors five times including 37 in 1931 and 27 in both 1932 and 1933. Lindstrom’s high mark was 21 errors in both 1928 and 1930. For the seven comparable seasons that Lindstrom played third base, his fielding percentage tops that of Traynor each year. ^[30]

McGraw’s list shows no bias for Giants, naming only Hornsby at No. 7 in the Top 10 and the great Christy Mathewson at No. 16. The first five, in order, were Honus Wagner, Ty Cobb, Willie Keeler, Eddie Collins and Babe Ruth. No other third baseman was cited.

Donald Dewey and Nick Acocella (All Time All Star Baseball Book, Elysian Fields Press, 1992) list Lindstrom as the New York Giants all-time third baseman. The esteemed sportswriter, Red Smith, placed him at third base on an all-time New York all-star team that had no room for the likes of Mickey Mantle, Duke Snider or Mel Ott^[31]

John Kieran (Sports of the Times), reported the following: “Arthur Nehf was sitting in the Chicago dugout talking about the Giant hitters. He talked of Roush, Jackson, Terry and Hogan and then remarked decisively that Freddie Lindstrom was the cleverest of them all at the plate and the hardest man to fool in the clutch.” ^[32]

Lindstrom’s four hits stood as the rookie record until matched by San Francisco’s Buster Posey in the 2010 series.

Along with a 24-game hitting streak in 1930 and a 25-game streak in 1933, Lindstrom also ranks among the all-time top 10 in lifetime strikeouts to batting average ratio, 276 strikeouts to .311 batting average in 6,104 plate appearances. Lloyd Waner, Pie Traynor and Arky Vaughan are also on the list. (Graham Womack, Baseball Past & Present, May 25, 2011.)

Lindstrom led the league in outfield assists in 1932 and putouts in 1933. He came to the Pirates as “a strong defensive player and even better right-handed line drive hitter.” (Dave Finoli and Bill Rainer: The Pittsburgh Pirates Encyclopedia, 1933.)

Lindstrom was included in the balloting for the National Baseball Hall of Fame starting in 1949, but he never received more than 4.4% of the vote from the Baseball Writers Association of America (BBWAA).^[33] Former Giants teammates Terry and Frankie Frisch joined the Veterans Committee in 1967, and aided the elections of several of their former teammates, including Jesse Haines in 1970, Dave Bancroft and Chick Hafey in 1971, Ross Youngs in 1972, George Kelly in 1973, Jim Bottomley in 1974, and Lindstrom in 1976.^[34][35]

Lindstrom's selection, along with some of the other selections made by Terry and Frisch, has been considered one of the weakest in some circles.^[36] According to the BBWAA, the Veterans Committee was not selective enough in choosing members.^[37] Charges of cronyism were levied against the Veterans Committee.^[38] This led to the Veterans Committee having its powers reduced in subsequent years.^[39] In 2001, baseball writer Bill James ranked Lindstrom as the worst third baseman in the Hall of Fame.^[40]

References

External links

Wikimedia Commons has media related to Freddie Lindstrom.

• Freddie Lindstrom at the Baseball Hall of Fame
• Career statistics and player information from Baseball-Reference, or Fangraphs, or The Baseball Cube, or Baseball-Reference (Minors)