- Glen Adams (M) (1976-1977)
- Peter Baker (D) (1965–1967; 1970) 40 apps.
- Keith Blackburn (M) (1966–1967; 1969) 24 apps, 6 goals
- Jackie Carr (M) (1959-1960)
- Bobby Chalmers (F) (1966–1968) 60 apps, 50 goals (Only player in NFL history to surpass 300 goals)
- Lawrence Chelin (M) (1976-1977)
- Martin Chivers (F) (guest, 1975)
- Vic Dare (M) (1970-c1975)
- Ian Davidson (D) (1968–1970) 59 apps, 1 goal
- Trevor Dawkins (D) (1973–1974)
- Marty Deetlijfs (F) (1962)
- (John Donnelly (footballer)|John Donnelly]] (D) (1970) 2 apps.
- Jimmy Dudley (D) (guest, 1961)
- Neil Duffy (M) (1970)
- Cliff Durandt (M) (early 1969) 19 apps, 4 goals
- Francis Exall (F) (1965–1969) 82 apps, 27 goals
- Danny Ferguson (D) (1967–1968) 30 apps.
- Jerry Gibson (F) (1959–1961) 52 apps, 19 goals
- Johnny Giles (M) (guest, 1971) 5 apps, 1 goal
- Alan Gordon (F) (1967–1968) 19 apps, 10 goals
- Wally Gould (F) (1968) 26 apps, 26 goals
- Johnny Grant (M) (1967–1968) 18 apps, 2 goals
- Willie Hamilton (F) (1969) 2 apps.
- Brian Harman (M) (1969-1977)
- Spanner Hartmann (GK) (1967-1968) 4 apps.
- Allan Harvey (M) (1967) 1 app.
- Johnny Haynes (M) (early 1974)
- Tony Henderson (D) (1975)
- Willie Henderson (M) (1972) 3 apps.
- Eric Hodge (D) (1960–1970)
- Ivan Hollett (F) (1973) 21 apps, 14 goals
- Bobby Irvine (GK) (1967–1968) 13 apps.
- Mike James (D) (1977)
- John Kirkham (D) (1970) 2 apps.
- Rodney Kitchin (D) (1970-1977)
- Gavin Laing (D) (1963–1967) 67 apps, 9 goals
- Stan Lapot (D) (1970) 24 apps, 3 goals
- Danny Le Roux (M) (1962–1965) 96 apps, 71 goals
- Arthur Lightening (GK) (1962; 1963–1969) 134 apps.
- John Little (D) (1967) 1 app.
- Chookie Louw (D) (1966) 3 apps.
- Robin Lowe (D) (1965–1968) 77 apps, 1 goal (Footballer of the Year 1966)
|
- Frankie McGuigan (M) (1966; 1967) 33 apps, 12 goals
- Vic McKinney (M) (1962; 1970–1971) 46 apps, 10 goals (2nd spell)
- Ron McKinnon (D) (1973)
- Jackie McManus (M) (1969–1970) 26 apps, 5 goals
- Jimmy McQuade (M) (1967) 2 apps.
- Ronnie Mann (F) (1962-1969; 1973-1975; 1977-1978) 53 goals (1st spell)
- George Martin (D) (1962-1964)
- Stanley Matthews (M) (guest, July 1968) 1 app.
- Andy Milne (M) (1976)
- Colin Neal (M) (1966–1968) 23 apps, 5 goals
- Bryan Orritt (M) (1968-1969) 35 apps, 11 goals
- Calvin Palmer (M) (1972)
- Stan Palmer (F) (1960) 22 goals
- Brian Peterson (M) (1962–1968; 1970) 173 apps, 71 goals
- Keith Peterson (D) (1959; 1963; 1964-1972; 1973)
- Octavio de Sa (GK) (1966) 3 apps.
- Les Salton (F) (1962–1967) 131 apps, 144 goals
- Jackie Scott (F) (1959–1961) 69 apps, 31 goals
- Jim Scott (F) (1971–1973) 39 apps, 22 goals
- Billy Semple (M) (1972)
- Colin Shaw (F) (1962; 1970) 22 apps, 23 goals (2nd spell)
- Jackie Sinclair (M) (1973) 6 apps, 3 goals
- Peter Smethurst (F) (1959) 11 apps, 9 goals
- Tony Smith (D) (1970–1973) 79 apps, 13 goals
- Dennis Snowden (M) (1963) 8 apps, 6 goals
- Alan Stephenson (D) (1975)
- Gordon Stewart (M) (1960–1961)
- Barry Stobart (F) (1970) 2 apps, 1 goal
- Neville Walters (M) (1968) 3 apps, 3 goals
- Len Wilkinson (GK) (1977-1978)
- Lionel Williams (D) (1966) 1 app.
- Fred Zackey (F) (1961) 29 apps, 37 goals
|