Anti-Serb sentiment

Anti-Serb sentiment is a generic term used to describe a sentiment of hostility or hatred towards Serbs, Serbia, Serbian language, or Serbian Orthodoxy (Serbian Orthodox Christians). The term Serbophobia has been used to describe the said sentiment, but the description has been controversial. According to those who use the term, Serbophobia can range from individual hatred to institutionalised persecution. Its opposite is Serbophilia.

Serbophobia is often claimed to be particularly widespread among Croats, Bosniaks, Montenegrins, Macedonians, Slovenes, Bulgarians and Kosovo's Albanians as a reaction to alienation of Serbs during the wars with those ethnic groups.[1][2]

Escalation of anti-Serb sentiment has sometimes resulted in persecution of Serbs on religious, political and ethnic grounds.

Contents

History

Islamization in the Ottoman Empire

As Christians, the Serbs were regarded as a "protected people" under Ottoman law, but were however referred to as Giaour (Serbian: Kaurin, English: Infidel). Many converted to Islam in viyalets where Islam was more powerful, notably in the Sandzak and Bosnia region, others converted in order to be more successful in the Ottoman Empire society and many were forced as part of Turkification or Islamisation and avoided persecution. The Janissaries (Serbian: Janjičari) were infantry units that served directly under the Sultan in the households and bodyguarding the higher people within the Ottoman Turkish government, they were composed of Islamicized Christian boys taken from the conquered countries through the Devşirme (Blood tribute) system, trained and schooled to serve the Ottoman Empire. Serbs, together with Greeks and Bulgarians were favored by the Sultans.

Catholicization in the Military Frontier

Serbs in the Roman Catholic Croatian Military Frontier were out of the jurisdiction of the Serbian Patriarchate of Peć and in 1611, after demands from the community, the Pope establishes the Eparchy of Marča (Vratanija) with seat at the Serbian-built Marča Monastery and instates a Byzantine vicar as bishop sub-ordinate to the Roman Catholic bishop of Zagreb, working to bring Serbian Orthodox Christians into communion with Rome which caused a power-struggle between the Catholics and the Serbs over the region. In 1695 the Serbian Orthodox Eparchy of Lika-Krbava and Zrinopolje was established by metropolitan Atanasije Ljubojevic and was certified by Emperor Josef I in 1707. In 1735, the Serbian Orthodox people protested in the Marča Monastery and became part of the Serbian Orthodox Church until 1753 when the Pope restored the Roman Catholic clergy. On June 17, 1777 the Eparchy of Križevci was permanently established by Pope Pius VI with a see at Križevci, near Zagreb, thus forming the Croatian Greek Catholic Church which would after World War I include other people; Rusyns and Ukrainians of Yugoslavia.[3][3][4][4]

Balkan Wars

Serbian socialist Dimitrije Tucović believes that the hatred of Serbia by the Albanian people was caused by the initial policy of the 1912 Serbian government that had planned to divide all Albanian inhabited territory between itself and Greece.[5] Tucović stated that Serbian occupation of Albania in the Balkan wars pushed the Albanian people to feel hatred of everything Serbian.[6]

Unlimited enmity of the Albanian people against Serbia is the foremost real result of the Albanian policies of the Serbian government.[7]
 

He concluded that Serbia wanted the sea and the colony, but left without getting the sea, and from the colony created a blood enemy.[8]

Albanization

The term Arnauti or Arnautaši was coined by ethnographers for "Albanized Serbs"; Serbs who had converted to Islam and went through a process of Albanisation.[9][10]

At the end of the 19th century, writer Branislav Nušić recorded that the Serb poturice (converts to Islam) of Orahovac began talking Albanian and marrying Albanian women.[10]

When Dr Jovan Hadži Vasiljević (l. 1866-1948) visited Orahovac in World War I, he could not distinguish Orthodox from Islamicized and Albanized Serbs.[10] They spoke Serbian, wore the same costumes, but claimed Serbian, Albanian or Turk ethnicity.[10] The Albanian starosedeoci (old urban families) were Slavophone; they did not speak Albanian but a Slavic dialect (naš govor, Our language) at home.[10]

In the 1921 census the majority of Muslim Albanians of Orahovac were registered under the category "Serbs and Croats".[10]

Mark Krasniqi, the Kosovo Albanian ethnographer, recalled in 1957: "During my own research, some of them told me that their tongue is similar to Macedonian rather than Serbian (it is clear that they want to dissociate themselves from everything Serbian). It is likely they are the last remnants of what is now known in Serbian sources as Arnautaši, Islamicised and half-way Albanianised Slavs."[10]

Early 20th century in Croatia

The term was used in the literary and cultural circles since before World War I. Croatian writers Antun Gustav Matoš and Miroslav Krleža had casually described some political and cultural figures as "Serbophobes" (Krleža in the four volume "Talks with Miroslav Krleža", 1985., edited by Enes Čengić), meaning that they perceived an anti-Serbian animus in a person's behavior.

Sarajevo assassination

Assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand of Austria and Sophie, Duchess of Hohenberg in 1914 led to angry Croats and Muslims in Sarajevo to engage in violent anti-Serb demonstrations during the evening of June 28 and much of the day on June 29, and this led to a deep division along ethnic lines. The crowd directed its anger principally at Serb shops and at residences of prominent Serbs. The mob attacked the cluster of structures near the New Serbian Orthodox Church, threw stones at the metropolitan's residence and sacked the Serbian Orthodox School. Other smaller groups stoned the building that housed the Serb cultural society Prosvjeta, sacked a Serb bank, and trashed the officies of the newspaper Srpska riječ. They singled out shops of Serb merchants including the family business of the assassin Neđeljko Čubrinović, and attacked Serb residences. Two Serbs were killed that day by crowd violence.[11] That night there were anti-Serb riots also in other parts of the Austro-Hungarian Empire.[12] In the aftermath of Sarajevo assassination anti-Serb sentiment ran high throughout the Habsburg Empire.[13]

Taking advantage of an international wave of revulsion against this act of "Serbian nationalist terrorism", Austro-Hungary gave Serbia an ultimatum which led to World War I.[14]

An example of Serbophobia is the jingle "Alle Serben müssen sterben" (All Serbs Must Die), which was popular in Vienna in 1914[15] (also occurring as: Serbien muß sterbien).

World War II

Miloš Acin-Kosta in his book Draža Mihailović i Ravna Gora (Draža Mihailović and Ravna Gora) dedicates a section to Serbophobia during World War II.

Prior to and during the extermination campaign on the Serbs during World War II, mass propaganda was initiated by the Germans and their Croatian collaborators as to dehumanize and justify the slaughter just as had been done to the Jews previously.[16][17]

During World War II the persecution of Serbs manifested itself in:

Serbs were persecuted by Croatian authorities during World War II by the Croatian Ustaša along with Jews and Roma in the Independent State of Croatia.[18] The number of murdered Serbs is estimated in a wide range, from at least 300 000 to 800 000. At least 80 000 people, of which the majority were Serbs, died in the Jasenovac concentration camp between 1941 and 1945.

During World War II, hundreds of thousands of Serbs were Catholicized by the Fascist Croatian Ustaše regime.

1980s

In the 1986 draft Memorandum of the Serbian Academy of Sciences and Arts Serbophobia is mentioned.[19]

1990s

1991 Dalmatian anti-Serb riots

Cadik Danon, the then-Chief Rabbi of Yugoslavia et al. in an open letter[20] to the American Jewish Committee in 1995, during the bombing of Republika Srpska by NATO during Bosnian War, wrote of a background of "... unrestrained anti-Serbian propaganda, raging during all this war, following the Nazi model, but much more efficient means and in a much more sophisticated and more expensive way.... Even American Jews were not able to withstand this propagandistic poison,... they did not recognize the Nazis and racist nature of the Serbophobic dogma. They did not identify Serbophobia as a twin sister of anti-semitism...."

The Federal Republic of Yugoslavia submitted to the International Court of Justice[21] in 1997 claims that acts of genocide against Serbs had been incited by anti-Serb sentiment and rhetoric communicated through all forms of the media.

Persecution may refer to death, beating, torture, confiscation or destruction of property, or destruction or desecration of monasteries and churches in Goražde, Bosnia and Herzegovina,[22] and in Kosovo.[23]

Persecution of Serbs by Kosovo Albanian extremists occurred during and after the 1998-1999 Kosovo War.[24][25][26][27][28][29][30][31][32]

Serbophobia has been claimed to occur in many Hollywood films including: Behind Enemy Lines and Harrison's Flowers, where the Serbs are exaggeratedly portrayed as rapists and terrorists.[33]

Current United States Vice President Joe Biden is on record as speaking in an anti-Serb manner. During the 1999 NATO attack on Slobodan Milosevic's Serbia, he appeared on Meet the Press (9 May 1999) and called for "a Japanese-German style occupation of that country, while his son publicly praised the Albanians' resolve in expelling the "degenerate thugs" from Kosovo".[34][35][36][37] Due to these statements, during his official visit to Belgrade in 2009 he was met with heavy criticism branding him racist from media and public figures alike as well as numerous protests against his visit.[38][39][40]

2000s

Some Kosovo Albanians publicly use an ethnic slur to refer to the Serb minority in Kosovo.[42]

Srbe na vrbe

The slogan Srbe na vrbe!, meaning "Hang Serbs from the willow trees!" is hate speech calling for the extermination of Serbs. The slogan originates from a poem of the Slovene politician Marko Natlačen published in 1914, at the beginning of the war of Austria-Hungary against Serbia.[59][60]

It was popularized before World War II by Mile Budak, the chief architect of the Ustaše ideology against Serbs, and during World War II there were mass hangings of Serbs in the Independent State of Croatia, as part of the Holocaust and the Ustaše's persecution of the Serbs.

In present-day Croatia, Croatian neo-Nazis, extreme nationalists and people who oppose return of Serbian refugees often use the slogan. Graffiti with the phrase is common, and has been observed by the press when it was painted on a church in 2004,[61] 2006,[62] on another church in 2008,[63] and in 2010, when a banner with the slogan appeared in the midst of the tourist season at the entrance to Split, a major tourist hub in Croatia, during a Davis Cup tennis match between the two countries. It was removed by the police within hours and otherwise ignored.[64] The police later apprehended the author of the banner and charged him with a felony.[65][66]

Criticism

Critics associate the use of the term Serbophobia with the politics of Serbian nationalist victimization of late 1980s and 1990s as described, for example, by Christopher Bennett. According to him, Serbian nationalist politicians have made associations to Serbian "martyrdom" in history (from the Battle of Kosovo in 1389 to the genocide during World War II) to justify Serbian politics of the 1980s and 1990s; these associations are allegedly exemplified in Slobodan Milošević's Gazimestan speech at Kosovo Polje in 1989. The reaction to the speech as well as the use of the associated term Serbophobia is a matter of heated debate even today.[67] In late 1988, months before the Revolutions of 1989, Milošević accused critics of his regime and political tactics like the Slovenian leader Milan Kučan of “spreading fear of Serbia”.[68] According to political scientist David Bruce Macdonald, the term was popularised in the 1980s and 1990s during the re-analysis of Serbian history.[69] The term was often likened to anti-Semitism, and expressed itself as a re-analysis of history where every event that had a negative effect on the Serbs was likened to a "tragedy".[69] Often associated with the politics of Serbian victimization of late 1980s and 1990s.[70]

See also

References

  1. ^ The Serbs and Croats: So Much in Common, Including Hate, May 16, 1991
  2. ^ Croatian hate site, National Post, December 11, 2008
  3. ^ a b http://books.google.se/books?id=ovCVDLYN_JgC
  4. ^ a b http://books.google.se/books?id=0pmkrY29qkIC
  5. ^ Dimitrije Tucović, Serbia and Albania: A Contribution to the Critique of the Conqueror Policy of the Serbian Bourgeoisie
  6. ^ Dimitrije Tucović, Srbija i Arbanija (u Izabrani spisi, knjiga II, str. 131) Prosveta, Beograd, 1950.
  7. ^ Review of "Serbia and Albania" by Dimitrije Tucovic
  8. ^ Dimitrije Tucović, Srbija i Arbanija (u Izabrani spisi, knjiga II, str. 117) Prosveta, Beograd, 1950.
  9. ^ Dietmar Müller, Staatsbürger aus Widerruf: Juden und Muslime als Alteritätspartner im rumänischen und serbischen Nationscode: ethnonationale Staatsbürgerschaftskonzepte 1878-1941, p. 183-208. ISBN 3447052481, 9783447052481
  10. ^ a b c d e f g Religion and the politics of identity in Kosovo, p. 73: see footnotes
  11. ^ Sarajevo: a biography, by Robert J. Donia
  12. ^ Beginning the twentieth century: a history of the generation that made the war, by Joseph Ward Swain
  13. ^ Yugoslavia's bloody collapse: causes, course and consequences, by Christopher Bennett
  14. ^ A history of Eastern Europe: crisis and change, by Robert Bideleux, Ian Jeffries
  15. ^ Trifkovic, Srdja (April 13, 2000). "Why Yugo-Nostalgists are Wrong". Chronicles. http://en.wikisource.org/wiki/User:Mdupont/Archive/WHY_YUGO-NOSTALGISTS_ARE_WRONG. Retrieved 2006-04-29. 
  16. ^ "History of the holocaust: Yugoslavia"
  17. ^ Federal Bureau of Statistics in 1964. Published in Newspaper Danas on November 21, 1989
  18. ^ [1]
  19. ^ SANU
  20. ^ C. Danon, 'et al.': Open letter asking for help from the American Jewish Committee. 1995.
  21. ^ a b c d INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE 17 December 1997 Case Concerning Application of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishmnent of the Crime of Genocide. Retrieved 26 August 2007.
  22. ^ The persecution of Serb civilians in wartime Gorazde
  23. ^ KOSOVO & Systematic Persecution by KLA
  24. ^ The genocide of the Serb population and persecution of the non-Albanian population must be stopped
  25. ^ PERSECUTION OF NON-ALBANIANS CONTINUES IN KOSOVO
  26. ^ Humanitarian Bombing vs. Iraqi Freedom
  27. ^ KLA - Truth in facts and testimonies
  28. ^ In the Aftermath: Continued Persecution of Roma, Ashkalis, Egyptians and Others Perceived as “Gypsies” in Kosovo
  29. ^ Kosovo & the Systematic Persecution by KLA
  30. ^ INTERNATIONAL FORCES HAVE FAILED TO PROTECT NON-ALBANIANS IN KOSOVO
  31. ^ KOSOVO: SERBIA’S TROUBLESOME PROVINCE
  32. ^ The Lie of a "Good War"
  33. ^ Behind Enemy Lines: Fact or Fiction?
  34. ^ Biden Does the Balkans, May 20, 2009
  35. ^ Biden calls Serbs illiterate degenerates, 19/05/09
  36. ^ Biden recognized as racist in Serbia, 21/05/09
  37. ^ Serbian nationalists bash Joe Biden, August 29, 2008
  38. ^ Biden is on the record as being very belligerent towards Serbia, May 20th, 2009
  39. ^ gets mixed reception in Belgrade, May 20, 2009
  40. ^ ‘Go home Nazi scum,’ Serb hardliners tell Biden, May 20, 2009/
  41. ^ Trial of Gnjilane Group continues
  42. ^ Civil Rights Defense Minority Communities, March 2006
  43. ^ Split mayor in media swipe at Serbs, Sept 21, 2009
  44. ^ Protest to Croatia over Split mayor's comments, Sept 22, 2009
  45. ^ Croatian medic denies Serb, BBC News, Sept 10, 2009
  46. ^ Croatian doctor refuses to help Serb, B92, Sept 7, 2009
  47. ^ Melbourne eatery hails leader of Nazi-allied Croatia, Jerusalem Post, April 16, 2008
  48. ^ Croatian NGO plans monument to Nazi collaborator Ante Pavelic, Jerusalem Post, October 6th, 2009
  49. ^ Croats honour Nazi collaborator, October 9th, 2009
  50. ^ Croat hooligans attack Serbia manager, B92, October 12th, 2009
  51. ^ Football match marred by racist violence, RTS, October 12th, 2009
  52. ^ Croat state TV boss in chauvinist outburst, B92, October 19th, 2009
  53. ^ Croatian TV Director Against "Chetniks", Novosti, October 19th, 2009
  54. ^ HRT Director ethnically insults reporter, Press Online, October 19th, 2009
  55. ^ Vijesti.net - Thompson pozdravio Norca, rulja uzvikivala "Ubij Srbina!"
  56. ^ 60 tisuća ljudi po nevremenu dočekalo Thompsona, vikalo se i 'Ubij, ubij Srbina!' - Dnevnik.hr
  57. ^ If you want to kill Serbs, go to the Maksimir stadium, Nov 1st, 2008
  58. ^ Serb tourists targeted in Croatia, July 27, 2009
  59. ^ Dr. Božo Repe (2005). "Slovene History – 20th Century, selected articles" (PDF). Department of History of the University of Ljubljana. http://www.ff.uni-lj.si/oddelki/zgodovin/DANIJELA/HISTORY/_private/20th/bozorepe.pdf. Retrieved 2010-08-06. 
  60. ^ Petition of 120 Croatian intellectuals. "O Mili Budaku, opet: Deset činjenica i deset pitanja - s jednim apelom u zaključku" (in Croatian). Index.hr. http://www.index.hr/clanak.aspx?id=218775. Retrieved 2010-08-06. 
  61. ^ "Ominous Ustashe graffiti on churchyard wall of Church of the Dormition of the Most Holy Mother of God in Imotski". Information Service of the Serbian Orthodox Church. April 28, 2004. http://www.spc.rs/Vesti-2004/04/28-4-04-e01.html#usta. Retrieved 2010-08-06. 
  62. ^ "World Report 2006 - Croatia". Human Rights Watch. January 2006. http://www.unhcr.org/cgi-bin/texis/vtx/rsd/rsddocview.html?tbl=RSDCOI&id=43cfae9e16. 
  63. ^ "Uvredljivi grafiti na Pravoslavnoj crkvi u Splitu (Offensive graffiti on the Serbian Orthodox church in Split)" (in Croatian). Nova TV/Dnevnik.hr. January 18, 2008. http://dnevnik.hr/vijesti/crna-kronika/uvredljivi-grafiti-na-pravoslavnoj-crkvi-u-splitu.html. Retrieved 2010-08-06. 
  64. ^ "Na ulazu u Split osvanuo sramotni transparent (Shameful banner appears at the entrance to Split)" (in Croatian). Jutarnji list. 2010-07-09. http://www.jutarnji.hr/na-ulazu-u-split-osvanuo-uvredljivi-transparent--srbe-na-vrbe-/845477/. Retrieved 2010-08-06. 
  65. ^ "Otkriven idejni začetnik izrade rasističkog transparenta - Antonio V. (23) osmislio transparent "Srbe na vrbe"" (in Croatian). Večernji list. 2010-07-23. http://www.vecernji.hr/vijesti/antonio-v-23-osmislio-transparent-srbe-vrbe-clanak-171159. Retrieved 2010-08-06. 
  66. ^ Croatian Parliament (1997-10-21). "Kazneni zakon" (in Croatian). Narodne novine NN 110-1997. http://narodne-novine.nn.hr/clanci/sluzbeni/1997_10_110_1668.html. Retrieved 2010-08-06. "Rasna i druga diskriminacija - Članak 174." 
  67. ^ Comment: Serbia's War With History by C. Bennett, Institute for War & Peace Reporting, April 19, 1999
  68. ^ Communism O Nationalism!, Time Magazine, October 24, 1988
  69. ^ a b MacDonald, D. B. (2003)
  70. ^ Bennett, C. (1999)

Further reading

National Library of Serbia's catalogue lists following books written about serbophobia:

External links

Use in various languages