International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights

States parties and signatories to the ICESCR:      states parties      non-state parties signatories      non-state parties non-signatories

The International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR) is a multilateral treaty adopted by the United Nations General Assembly on December 16, 1966, and in force from January 3, 1976. It commits its parties to work toward the granting of economic, social, and cultural rights (ESCR) to individuals, including labour rights and rights to health, education, and an adequate standard of living. As of September 26, 2008, the Covenant had 159 parties.[1] A further six countries had signed, but not yet ratified the Covenant.

The ICESCR is part of the International Bill of Human Rights, along with the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), including the latter's first and second Optional Protocols.[2]

The Covenant is monitored by the UN Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights.

Contents

Genesis

The ICESCR has its roots in the same process that led to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. A "Declaration on the Essential Rights of Man" had been proposed at the 1945 San Francisco Conference which led to the founding of the United Nations, and the Economic and Social Council was given the task of drafting it.[2] Early on in the process, the document was split into a declaration setting forth general principles of human rights, and a convention or covenant containing binding commitments. The former evolved into the UDHR and was adopted on December 10, 1948.[2]

Drafting continued on the convention, but there remained significant differences between UN members on the relative importance of negative Civil and Political versus positive Economic, Social and Cultural rights.[3] These eventually caused the convention to be split into two separate covenants, "one to contain civil and political rights and the other to contain economic, social and cultural rights."[4] The two covenants were to contain as many similar provisions as possible, and be opened for signature simultaneously.[4] Each would also contain an article on the right of all peoples to self-determination.[5]

The first document became the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, and the second the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. The drafts were presented to the UN General Assembly for discussion in 1954, and adopted in 1966.[6]

Summary

The Covenant follows the structure of the UDHR and ICCPR, with a preamble and thirty-one articles, divided into five parts.[7]

Part 1 (Article 1) recognises the right of all peoples to self-determination, including the right to "freely determine their political status",[8] pursue their economic, social and cultural goals, and manage and dispose of their own resources. It recognises a negative right of a people not to be deprived of its means of subsistence,[9] and imposes an obligation on those parties still responsible for non-self governing and trust territories (colonies) to encourage and respect their self-determination.[10]

Part 2 (Articles 2 - 5) establishes the principle of "progressive realisation" - see below. It also requires the rights be recognised "without discrimination of any kind as to race, colour, sex, language, religion, political or other opinion, national or social origin, property, birth or other status".[11] The rights can only be limited by law, in a manner compatible with the nature of the rights, and only for the purpose of "promoting the general welfare in a democratic society".[12]

Part 3 (Articles 6 - 15) lists the rights themselves. These include rights to

Many of these rights include specific actions which must be undertaken to realise them.

Part 4 (Articles 16 - 25) governs reporting and monitoring of the Covenant and the steps taken by the parties to implement it. It also allows the monitoring body - originally the United Nations Economic and Social Council - now the Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights - see below - to make general recommendations to the UN General Assembly on appropriate measures to realise the rights (Article 21)

Part 5 (Articles 26 - 31) governs ratification, entry into force, and amendment of the Covenant.

Core provisions

Principle of progressive realisation

Article 2 of the Covenant imposes a duty on all parties to

take steps... to the maximum of its available resources, with a view to achieving progressively the full realization of the rights recognized in the present Covenant by all appropriate means, including particularly the adoption of legislative measures.[15]

This is known as the principle of "progressive realisation". It acknowledges that some of the rights (for example, the right to health) may be difficult in practice to achieve in a short period of time, and that states may be subject to resource constraints, but requires them to act as best they can within their means.

The principle differs from that of the ICCPR, which obliges parties to "respect and to ensure to all individuals within its territory and subject to its jurisdiction" the rights in that Convention.[16] However, it does not render the Covenant meaningless. The requirement to "take steps" imposes a continuing obligation to work towards the realisation of the rights.[17] It also rules out deliberately regressive measures which impede that goal. The Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights also interprets the principle as imposing minimum core obligations to provide, at the least, minimum essential levels of each of the rights.[18] If resources are highly constrained, this should include the use of targeted programmes aimed at the vulnerable.[19]

The Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights regards legislation as an indispensable means for realising the rights which is unlikely to be limited by resource constraints. The enacting of anti-discrimination provisions and the establishment of enforceable rights with judicial remedies within national legal systems are considered to be appropriate means. Some provisions, such as anti-discrimination laws, are already required under other human rights instruments, such as the ICCPR.[20]

Labour rights

Main article: Labor rights

Article 6 of the Covenant recognises the right to work, defined as the opportunity of everyone to gain their living by freely chosen or accepted work.[21] Parties are required to take "appropriate steps" to safeguard this right, including technical and vocational training and economic policies aimed at steady economic development and ultimately full employment. The right implies parties must guarantee equal access to employment and protect workers from being unfairly deprived of employment. They must prevent discrimination in the workplace and ensure access for the disadvantaged.[22] The fact that work must be freely chosen or accepted means parties must prohibit forced or child labour.[23]

The work referred to in Article 6 must be decent work.[24] This is effectively defined by Article 7 of the Covenant, which recognises the right of everyone to "just and favourable" working conditions. These are in turn defined as fair wages with equal pay for equal work, sufficient to provide a decent living for workers and their dependants; safe working conditions; equal opportunity in the workplace; and sufficient rest and leisure, including limited working hours and regular, paid holidays.

Article 8 recognises the right of workers to form or join trade unions and protects the right to strike. It allows these rights to be restricted for members of the armed forces, police, or government administrators. Several parties have placed reservations on this clause, allowing it to be interpreted in a manner consistent with their constitutions (China, Mexico), or extending the restriction of union rights to groups such as fire-fighters (Japan).[25]

The right to social security

Main article: Social security

Article 9 of the Covenant recognizes "the right of everyone to social security, including social insurance."[26] It requires parties to provide some form of social insurance scheme to protect people against the risks of sickness, disability, maternity, employment injury, unemployment or old age; to provide for survivors, orphans, and those who cannot afford health care; and to ensure that families are adequately supported. Benefits from such a scheme must be adequate, accessible to all, and provided without discrimination.[27] The Covenant does not restrict the form of the scheme, and both contributory and non-contributory schemes are permissible (as are community-based and mutual schemes).[28]

The Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights has noted persistent problems with the implementation of this right, with very low levels of access.[29]

Several parties, including France and Monaco, have reservations allowing them to set residence requirements in order to qualify for social benefits. The Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights permits such restrictions, provided they are proportionate and reasonable.[30]

The right to family life

Main article: Children's rights
Main article: Fathers' rights
Main article: Women's rights

Article 10 of the Covenant recognises the family as "the natural and fundamental group unit of society", and requires parties to accord it "the widest possible protection and assistance."[31] Parties must ensure that their citizens are free to establish families and that marriages are freely contracted and not forced.[32] Parties must also provide paid leave or adequate social security to mothers before and after childbirth, an obligation which overlaps with that of Article 9. Finally, parties must take "special measures" to protect children from economic or social exploitation, including setting a minimum age of employment and barring children from dangerous and harmful occupations.[33]

The right to an adequate standard of living

Main article: Right to food
Main article: Right to water
Main article: Right to housing

Article 11 recognises the right of everyone to an adequate standard of living. This includes, but is not limited to, the right to adequate food, clothing, housing, and "the continuous improvement of living conditions."[34] It also creates an obligation on parties to work together to eliminate world hunger.

The right to adequate food, also referred to as the right to food, is interpreted as requiring "the availability of food in a quantity and quality sufficient to satisfy the dietary needs of individuals, free from adverse substances, and acceptable within a given culture."[35] This must be accessible to all, implying an obligation to provide special programmes for the vulnerable.[36] The right to adequate food also implies a right to water.[37]

The right to adequate housing, also referred to as the right to housing, is "the right to live somewhere in security, peace and dignity."[38] It requires "adequate privacy, adequate space, adequate security, adequate lighting and ventilation, adequate basic infrastructure and adequate location with regard to work and basic facilities - all at a reasonable cost."[38] Parties must ensure security of tenure and that access is free of discrimination, and progressively work to eliminate homelessness. Forced evictions, defined as "the permanent or temporary removal against their will of individuals, families and/or communities from the homes and/or land which they occupy, without the provision of, and access to, appropriate forms of legal or other protection", are a prima facie violation of the Covenant.[39]

The right to health

Main article: Right to health

Article 12 of the Covenant recognises the right of everyone to "the enjoyment of the highest attainable standard of physical and mental health."[40] "Health" is understood not just as a right to be healthy, but as a right to control ones own health and body (including reproduction), and be free from interference such as torture or medical experimentation.[41] States must protect this right by ensuring that everyone within their jurisdiction has access to the underlying determinants of health, such as clean water, sanitation, food, nutrition and housing, and through a comprehensive system of healthcare, which is available to everyone without discrimination, and economically accessible to all.[42]

Article 12.2 requires parties to take specific steps to improve the health of their citizens, including reducing infant mortality and improving child health, improving environmental and workplace health, preventing, controlling and treating epidemic diseases, and creating conditions to ensure equal and timely access to medical services for all. These are considered to be "illustrative, non-exhaustive examples", rather than a complete statement of parties' obligations.[43]

The right to health is interpreted as requiring parties to respect women's' reproductive rights, by not limiting access to contraception or "censoring, withholding or intentionally misrepresenting" information about sexual health.[44] They must also ensure that women are protected from harmful traditional practices such as female genital mutilation.[45]

The right to education

Main article: Right to education

Article 13 of the Covenant recognises the right of everyone to education. This is to be directed towards "the full development of the human personality and the sense of its dignity",[14] and enable all persons to participate effectively in society. Education is seen both as a human right and as "an indispensable means of realizing other human rights", and so this is one of the longest and most important articles of the Covenant.[46]

Article 13.2 lists a number of specific steps parties are required to pursue to realise the right of education. These include the provision of free, universal and compulsory primary education, "generally available and accessible" secondary education in various forms (including technical and vocational training), and equally accessible higher education. All of these must be available to all without discrimination. Parties must also develop a school system (though it may be public, private, or mixed), encourage or provide scholarships for disadvantaged groups, and are encouraged to make education free at all levels.

Articles 13.3 and 13.4 require parties to respect the educational freedom of parents by allowing them to choose and establish private educational institutions for their children, also referred to as Freedom of education. It also recognises the right of parents to "ensure the religious and moral education of their children in conformity with their own convictions".[47] This is interpreted as requiring public schools to respect the freedom of religion and conscience of their students, and as forbidding instruction in a particular religion or belief system unless non-discriminatory exemptions and alternatives are available.[48]

The Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights interpret the Covenant as also requiring states to respect the academic freedom of staff and students, as this is vital for the educational process.[49] It also considers corporal punishment in schools to be inconsistent with the Covenant's underlying principle of the dignity of the individual.[50]

Article 14 of the Covenant requires those parties which have not yet established a system of free compulsory primary education, to rapidly adopt a detailed plan of action for its introduction "within a reasonable number of years."[51]

The right to participation in cultural life

Main article: Right to culture
Main article: Right to development
Main article: Right to public participation

Article 15 of the Covenant recognises the right of everyone to participate in cultural life, enjoy the benefits of scientific progress, and to benefit from the protection of the moral and material rights to any scientific discovery or artistic work they have created. The latter clause is sometimes seen as requiring the protection of intellectual property, but the Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights interprets it as primarily protecting the moral rights of authors and "proclaim[ing] the intrinsically personal character of every creation of the human mind and the ensuing durable link between creators and their creations".[52] It thus requires parties to respect the right of authors to be recognised as the creator of a work. The material rights are interpreted as being part of the right to an adequate standard of living, and "need not extend over the entire lifespan of an author."[53]

Parties must also work to promote the conservation, development and diffusion of science and culture, "respect the freedom indispensable for scientific research and creative activity",[54] and encourage international contacts and cooperation in these fields.

Reservations

A number of parties have made reservations and interpretative declarations to their application of the Covenant.

Algeria interprets parts of Article 13, protecting the liberty of parents to freely choose or establish suitable educational institutions, so as not to "impair its right freely to organize its educational system."[25]

Bangladesh interprets the self-determination clause in Article 1 as applying in the historical context of colonialism. It also reserves the right to interpret the labour rights in Articles 7 and 8 and the non-discrimination clauses of Articles 2 and 3 within the context of its constitution and domestic law.[25]

Belgium interprets non-discrimination as to national origin as "not necessarily implying an obligation on States automatically to guarantee to foreigners the same rights as to their nationals. The term should be understood to refer to the elimination of any arbitrary behaviour but not of differences in treatment based on objective and reasonable considerations, in conformity with the principles prevailing in democratic societies."[25]

China interprets the labour rights in Article 8 in a manner consistent with its constitution and domestic law.[25]

Egypt accepts the Covenant only to the extent it does not conflict with Islamic Sharia law.[25]

France views the Covenant as subservient to the UN Charter. It also reserves the right to govern the access of aliens to employment, social security, and other benefits.[25]

India interprets the right of self-determination as applying "only to the peoples under foreign domination"[25] and not to apply to peoples within sovereign nation-states. It also interprets the limitation of rights clause and the rights of equal opportunity in the workplace within the context of its constitution.[25]

Indonesia interprets the self-determination clause (Article 1) within the context of other international law and as not applying to peoples within a sovereign nation-state.[25]

Ireland reserves the right to promote the Irish language.[25]

Japan reserved the right not to be bound to progressively introduce free secondary and higher education.[25]

Kuwait interprets the non-discrimination clauses of Articles 2 and 3 within its constitution and laws, and reserves the right to social security to apply only to Kuwaitis. It also reserves the right to forbid strikes.[25]

Mexico interprets the labour rights in Article 8 within the context of its constitution and laws.[25]

Monaco interprets the principle of non-discrimination on the grounds of national origin as "not necessarily implying an automatic obligation on the part of States to guarantee foreigners the same rights as their nationals",[25] and reserves the right to set residence requirements on the rights to work, health, education, and social security.

New Zealand reserved the right not to apply Article 8 (the right to form and join trade unions) insofar as existing measures (which at the time included compulsory unionism and encouraged arbitration of disputes) were incompatible with it.[25]

Norway reserves the right to strike so as to allow for compulsory arbitration of some labour disputes.[25]

Pakistan has a general reservation to interpret the Covenant within the framework of its constitution.[25]

Thailand interprets the right to self-determination within the framework of other international law.[25]

Trinidad and Tobago reserves the right to restrict the right to strike of those engaged in essential occupations.

Turkey will implement the Covenant subject to the UN Charter. It also reserves the right to interpret and implement the right of parents to choose and establish educational institutions in a manner compatible with its constitution.[25]

The United Kingdom views the Covenant as subservient to the UN Charter. It made several reservations regarding its overseas territories.[25]

United States - Amnesty International writes that "The United States signed the Covenant in 1979 under the Carter administration but is not fully bound by it until it is ratified. For political reasons, the Carter administration did not push for the necessary review of the Covenant by the Senate, which must give its “advice and consent” before the US can ratify a treaty. The Reagan and Bush (Sr.) administrations took the view that economic, social, and cultural rights were not really rights but merely desirable social goals and therefore should not be the object of binding treaties. The Clinton Administration did not deny the nature of these rights but did not find it politically expedient to engage in a battle with Congress over the Covenant. The current Bush (W.) administration follows in line with the view of the previous Bush (Sr.) administration."[55] The Heritage Foundation, a critical conservative think tank, argues that signing it would obligate the introduction of policies that it opposes such as universal health care.[56]

Draft Optional Protocol

Many other UN human rights instruments, such as the ICCPR, the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women and the Convention Against Torture have optional protocols which allow for individuals to make complaints directly to the relevant monitoring body. Currently the ICESCR does not have such a Protocol, but has been working towards one for many years.[57] Currently an open-ended working group[58] is in the process of producing a draft Optional Protocol[59]for discussion. In the meantime, other monitoring bodies may be able to consider complaints related to economic, social and cultural rights in the context of its treaty.[60] In 2008, draft Optional Protocol was submitted to the General Assembly.[61]

The Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights

The Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights is a body of human rights experts tasked with monitoring the implementation of the Covenant. It consists of 18 independent human rights experts, elected for four-year terms, with half the members elected every two years.[62]

Unlike other human rights monitoring bodies, the Committee was not established by the treaty it oversees. Rather, it was established by the Economic and Social Council following the failure of two previous monitoring bodies.[32]

All states parties are required to submit regular reports to the Committee outlining the legislative, judicial, policy and other measures they have taken to implement the rights affirmed in the Covenant. The first report is due within two years of ratifying the Covenant; thereafter reports are due every five years.[63] The Committee examines each report and addresses its concerns and recommendations to the State party in the form of “concluding observations”.

The Committee typically meets every May and November in Geneva.[64]

The current (as of January 2007) membership of the Committee is:[65]

The Committee held an election at the end of April 2008 to replace those members whose terms expire at the end of 2008.[66]

References

  1. ↑ "ICESCR ratification status". UN OHCHR (2008-04-18). Retrieved on 2008-12-04.
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 "Fact Sheet No.2 (Rev.1), The International Bill of Human Rights". UN OHCHR (June 1996). Retrieved on 2008-06-02.
  3. ↑ Sieghart, Paul (1983). The International Law of Human Rights. Oxford University Press. pp. 25. 
  4. ↑ 4.0 4.1 United Nations General Assembly Resolution 543, February 5, 1952.
  5. ↑ United Nations General Assembly Resolution 545, February 5, 1952.
  6. ↑ United Nations General Assembly Resolution 2200, December 16, 1966.
  7. ↑ The following section summarises the text of the Covenant.
  8. ↑ ICESCR, Article 1.1
  9. ↑ ICESCR, Article 1.2
  10. ↑ ICESCR, Article 1.3
  11. ↑ ICESCR, Article 2.2
  12. ↑ ICESCR, Article 4
  13. ↑ ICESCR, Article 7
  14. ↑ 14.0 14.1 ICESCR, Article 13.1
  15. ↑ ICESCR, Article 2.1
  16. ↑ "ICCPR" Article 2.1. UN. Retrieved on 2008-07-13.
  17. ↑ Paragraph 9, "CESCR General Comment 3". UN OHCHR (1990-12-14). Retrieved on 2008-06-02.
  18. ↑ CESCR General Comment 3, paragraph 10.
  19. ↑ CESCR General Comment 3, paragraph 12.
  20. ↑ CESCR General Comment 3, paragraphs 3 - 6.
  21. ↑ ICESCR, Article 6.1.
  22. ↑ "CESCR General Comment 18: The Right to Work" paragraph 31. UN Economic and Social Council (2006-02-06). Retrieved on 2008-06-02.
  23. ↑ CESCR General Comment 18, paragraph 23.
  24. ↑ CESCR General Comment 18, paragraph 7.
  25. ↑ 25.00 25.01 25.02 25.03 25.04 25.05 25.06 25.07 25.08 25.09 25.10 25.11 25.12 25.13 25.14 25.15 25.16 25.17 25.18 25.19 25.20 "International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, Declarations and Reservations". UN OHCHR (2008-04-18). Retrieved on 2008-06-02.
  26. ↑ ICESCR, Article 9.
  27. ↑ "CESCR Draft General Comment 19: The right to social security". UN Economic and Social Council (2008-02-04). Retrieved on 2008-07-13.
  28. ↑ CESCR Draft General Comment 19, paragraph 5.
  29. ↑ CESCR Draft General Comment 19, paragraph 7.
  30. ↑ CESCR Draft General Comment 19, paragraph 37.
  31. ↑ ICESCR, Article 10.1.
  32. ↑ 32.0 32.1 "Fact Sheet No.16 (Rev.1), The Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights". UN OHCHR (July 1991). Retrieved on 2008-06-02.
  33. ↑ ICESCR, Article 10.3.
  34. ↑ ICESCR, Article 11.1.
  35. ↑ "CESCR General Comment 12: The right to adequate food" paragraph 8. UN Economic and Social Council (1999-05-12). Retrieved on 2008-06-02.
  36. ↑ CESCR General Comment 12, paragraph 13.
  37. ↑ "CESCR General Comment 15: The right to water" paragraph 3.. UN Economic and Social Council (2003-01-20). Retrieved on 2008-07-13.
  38. ↑ 38.0 38.1 "CESCR General Comment 4: The right to adequate housing". UN OHCHR (1991-12-13). Retrieved on 2008-06-02.
  39. ↑ "CESCR General Comment 7: The right to adequate housing: forced evictions". UN OHCHR (1997-05-20). Retrieved on 2008-06-02.
  40. ↑ ICESCR, Article 12.1
  41. ↑ "CESCR General Comment 14: The right to the highest attainable standard of health" paragraph 9.. UN Economic and Social Council (2000-08-11). Retrieved on 2008-06-02.
  42. ↑ CESCR General Comment 14, paragraphs 11-12.
  43. ↑ CESCR General Comment 14, paragraph 7.
  44. ↑ CESCR General Comment 14, paragraph 34.
  45. ↑ CESCR General Comment 14, paragraph 35.
  46. ↑ "CESCR General Comment 13: The right to education" paragraph 1. UN Economic and Social Council (1999-12-08). Retrieved on 2008-06-02.
  47. ↑ ICESCR, Article 13.3
  48. ↑ CESCR General Comment 13, paragraph 28.
  49. ↑ CESCR General Comment 13, paragraph 38.
  50. ↑ CESCR General Comment 13, paragraph 41.
  51. ↑ ICESCR, Article 14.
  52. ↑ "CESCR General Comment 17: The right of everyone to benefit from the protection of the moral and material interests resulting from any scientific, literary or artistic production of which he is the author". UN Economic and Social Council (2006-01-12). Retrieved on 2008-06-02.
  53. ↑ CESCR General Comment 17, paragraph 16.
  54. ↑ ICESCR, Article 15.3
  55. ↑ "Economic, Social and Cultural Rights: Questions and Answers" 6. Amnesty International. Retrieved on 2008-06-02.
  56. ↑ Cowin, Andrew J. (1993-07-29). "Human Rights Treaty Poses Dangers For America". Heritage Foundation. Retrieved on 2008-06-02.
  57. ↑ "History of the OP-ICESCR Process". ESCR-Net. Retrieved on 2008-07-13.
  58. ↑ "Open-ended Working Group on an Optional Protocol to the ICESCR". UN OHCHR. Retrieved on 2008-07-13.
  59. ↑ "Revised Draft Optional Protocol to the ICESCR". UN OHCHR. Retrieved on 2008-07-13.
  60. ↑ "Monitoring the economic, social and cultural rights". UN OHCHR. Retrieved on 2008-06-02.
  61. ↑ [1]
  62. ↑ "ECOSOC Resolution 1985/17". UN OHCHR (1985-05-28). Retrieved on 2008-06-02.
  63. ↑ "Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights". UN OHCHR. Retrieved on 2008-06-03.
  64. ↑ "Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights - Sessions". UN OHCHR. Retrieved on 2008-06-03.
  65. ↑ "Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights - Members". UN OHCHR (2007-01-01). Retrieved on 2008-06-02.
  66. ↑ "Election of the Members of the Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights to replace those whose terms are due to expire on 31 December 2008". UN OHCHR. Retrieved on 2008-06-02.

External links

Human rights
List of Organisations · National institutions
Legal instruments