Agent Orange

A UH-1D helicopter from the 336th Aviation Company sprays a defoliation agent on a dense jungle area in the Mekong Delta. 07/26/1969/National Archives photograph.

Agent Orange is the code name for a powerful herbicide and defoliant used by the U.S. military in its Herbicidal Warfare program during the Vietnam War. During the Vietnam War, an estimated 21,136,000 gal. (80 000 m³) of Agent Orange was sprayed across South Vietnam.[1]

From 1961 to 1971, Agent Orange was by far the most widely used of the so-called "Rainbow Herbicides" employed in the Herbicidal Warfare program. Degradation of Agent Orange (as well as Agents Purple, Pink, and Green) released dioxins, which have caused health problems for those exposed during the Vietnam War. Agents Blue and White were part of the same program but did not contain dioxins.

Studies of populations exposed to dioxin, though not necessarily Agent Orange, indicate increased risk of various types of cancer and genetic defects; the effect of long-term low-level exposure has not been established.

Since the 1980s, several lawsuits have been filed against the companies which produced Agent Orange, among them; Dow Chemical, Monsanto, and Diamond Shamrock (which produced 5%[2]). U.S. veterans obtained a $180 million settlement in 1984, with most affected veterans receiving a one-time lump sum payment of $1,200. According to the Department of Veterans Affairs, shortly after the Vietnam War veterans reported various health complications which can be traced to exposure to the chemical Agent Orange. The Department of Veterans Affairs responded by providing health care services, disability compensation, and scientific research and education for these veterans. [3]

American veterans of the Vietnam war were seeking recognition of Agent Orange syndrome, compensation and treatment for diseases that they and their children suffered from; many exposed to Agent Orange have not been able to receive promised medical care through the Veterans Administration medical system, and only in exceptional cases have their affected children received healthcare assistance from the government. With the production of Agent Orange, dioxins are created as a by-product. These dioxins are known to be deadly. Humans often show symptoms of dioxin poisoning when exposed to the contaminant.

Vietnam veterans and their families who brought the original Agent Orange lawsuit 25 years ago alleged that the government "is just waiting for us all to die". They alleged that most of those still alive would succumb to the effects of toxic exposure before the age of 65.

In Australia, Canada and New Zealand, veterans obtained compensation in settlements that same year. In 1999, South Korean veterans filed a lawsuit in the Korean courts. In January 2006, the Korean Appeal Court ordered Monsanto and Dow to pay US$62 million in compensation. However, no Vietnamese have received compensation, and on March 10, 2006, Judge Jack B. Weinstein of the United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York dismissed the lawsuit filed by the Vietnamese victims of Agent Orange against the chemical companies which produced the defoliants and herbicides.

Contents

Early development

The earliest form of the compound triiodobenzoic acid was studied by Arthur Galston as a plant growth hormone. The research was motivated by the desire to adapt soybeans for short growing season. Arthur Galston is widely known for the social impact his work had on science. This defoliant was modeled after Galston’s discovery of triiodobenzoic acid in 1943. Galston was especially concerned about the compound’s side effects to humans and the environment. [4]Galston found that excessive usage of the compound caused catastrophic defoliation - a finding used by his colleague Ian Sussex to develop a family of herbicides[5] (Galston later campaigned against its use in Vietnam). These herbicides were developed during the 1940s by independent teams in England and the United States for use in controlling broad-leaf plants. Phenoxyl agents work by mimicking a plant growth hormone, indoleacetic acid (IAA). When sprayed on broad-leaf plants they induce rapid, uncontrolled growth, eventually defoliating them. When sprayed on crops such as wheat or corn, it selectively kills only the broad-leaf weeds in the field, leaving the crop relatively unaffected. First introduced in 1946 in the agricultural farms of Aguadilla, Puerto Rico, these herbicides were in widespread use in agriculture by the middle of the 1950s.

Description

Agent Orange was given its name from the colour of the 55 U.S. gallon (210 litre) orange-striped barrels it was shipped in. It is a roughly 1:1 mixture of two phenoxyl herbicides in ester form, 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D) and 2,4,5-trichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4,5-T).

Internal memos from the companies that manufactured it reveal that at the time Agent Orange was sold to the U.S. government for use in Vietnam it was known that it contained a dioxin, 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzodioxin (TCDD), a by-product of the manufacture of 2,4-D and 2,4,5-T.[6] The National Toxicology Program has classified TCDD to be a human carcinogen, frequently associated with soft-tissue sarcoma, Non-Hodgkin's lymphoma, Hodgkin's disease and chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL). In a study by the Institute of Medicine, a link has been found between dioxin exposure and diabetes.[7][8] Three studies have suggested an increase in the risk of acute myelogenous leukemia in the children of Vietnam veterans, which might be associated with exposure to Agent Orange.[9] A variety of other conditions have been suggested to be linked to exposure, but studies have failed to confirm a link with these diseases.[10]

Vietnam case

During the Vietnam war, between 1962 and 1971, the United States military sprayed 77 million litres of chemical defoliants in South Vietnam as part of a defoliant program. [11] The first objective was to reduce the dense jungle foliage so that Communist forces might not use it for cover and to deny them use of crops needed for subsistence. The second objective was spot clearing in sensitive areas such as around base perimeters. [12]

According to Vietnamese Ministry of Foreign Affairs, 4.8 million Vietnamese people were exposed to Agent Orange, resulting in 400,000 deaths and disabilities, and 500,000 children born with birth defects. [13] The most affected zones are the mountainous area along Truong Son (Long Mountains) and the border between Vietnam and Cambodia. The affected residents are living in sub-standard conditions with many genetic diseases.[14] The use of Agent Orange still has an effect on the citizens of Vietnam, poisoning their food chain and creating concern about its effect on human beings. This chemical has been reported to cause serious skin diseases as well as a vast variety of cancers in the lungs, larynx, and prostate. Children in the areas where Agent Orange was used have been affected and have multiple health problems including cleft palate, mental retardation, hernias, and extra fingers and toes. [15]

Much of the information on the effects of Agent Orange in Vietnam until the 21st century, were compiled by Vietnamese scientists in Vietnamese and largely unavailable to the worldwide English reader. However, general public perception in Vietnam is that the effects are severe and clearly visible in children of veterans and people in affected areas. Veterans have become increasingly concerned about the effects of Agent Orange to humans. While in Vietnam, the veterans were told not to worry, and were persuaded that the chemical was harmless. In the last few years, this opinion has changed, and studies show the true effects Agent Orange has on humans. [16]

Use outside of Vietnam

Sources claim Agent Orange was widely used by the US Military from the late 1940s through the 1970s.[17][18]

Korea

In September 2000, the Veteran Administration (VA) recognized that Agent Orange was used in Korea in the late 1960s.[19] Republic of Korea troops are reported to have done the spraying, which occurred along the demilitarized zone with North Korea. The VA has also acknowledged that Agent Orange was used domestically by U.S. forces[20].

Canadian Forces Base Gagetown, New Brunswick, Canada

The U.S. military, with the permission of the Canadian government, secretly tested many unregistered U.S. military herbicides, including Agent Orange, in the forests near the Canadian Forces Base Gagetown in New Brunswick in 1966 and 1967. On September 12, 2007, Greg Thompson, Minister of Veterans Affairs, announced that the government of Canada is offering a one-time ex gratia payment of $20,000 as the compensation package for Agent Orange exposure at CFB Gagetown.[21]

Globe, Arizona

Billee Shoecraft died of cancer in 1977. She began suffering from cancer after a helicopter sprayed her with the defoliant Kuron. Before her death, Shoecraft wrote a book about her experience in which she said that after she was sprayed her eyes were nearly swollen shut, her arms and legs were swollen to twice their normal size and her hair was falling out in patches.[22] Kuron, a herbicide related to Agent Orange, was sprayed by the U.S. Forest Service to thin foliage and increase water runoff in the Pinal Mountains of the Tonto National Forest near Globe, Arizona, in 1968 and 1969. Dow Chemical Company and the U.S. Forest Service paid an undisclosed sum to five families. Shoecraft wrote a book entitled, Sue the Bastards!, about her incident in 1971.

Innisfail, Australia

It is speculated [23] [24] that the Australian military tested Agent Orange on Innisfail, a small town in northern Queensland, between 1964 and 1966[25] . Files from the Australian War Memorial archives showed the chemicals 2,4-D, Diquat, Tordon and dimethyl sulphoxide (DMSO) were sprayed on the rainforest in the Gregory Falls area in June 1966, as part of a wider chemical weapons test program dubbed 'Operation Desert'. These claims were made by Jean Williams, who was given the Order of Australia medal for her work concerning Vietnam War veterans. She claimed she found evidence pertaining to the use of toxic herbicide, but that evidence was missing from archives. [26] Anna Bligh, the Queensland Premier stated that the government would investigate thoroughly the supposed tests in the rainforest. [27]

These claims have since been proved false by a Defence Science and Technology Organisation (DSTO) investigation. They found that there was a small-scale defoliation trial conducted in the Gregory Falls area near Innisfail in 1966 but it did not involve Agent Orange. Claims the cancer rate was 10 times as high in Innisfail were also proved to be untrue by QLD health who have stated it was called by media miscalculations.

Guam

After a veteran contracted a disease from Agent Orange, the United States Court of Appeals for Veterans concluded that toxic herbicides have been used in Guam. During the Vietnam War, Guam was used a storage facility for Agent Orange. A CBS News report on June 12, 2005, said Agent Orange was sprayed on Guam from 1955 to 1960s, and in the Panama Canal Zone from 1960s to 1970s. [28]

Kelly AFB/ALC A/K/A San Antonio Air Material Area (SAAMA) stockpiled and stored Agent Blue and Agent Orange as documented by Kelly AFB Base Realighment and Closure IRP Closure report Site SS009 9/97 Final F41650-95-D02005-5016, East Kelly, Site S-7. On June 13, 1975 the San Antonio Express News printed "Poision Herbicide used locally despite EPA ban. "The Director AeroSpace Fuelsand and on January 17,1972 HQ USAF advised HQ AFLC and San Antonio Air Material Area (SAAMA) that herbicide Orange at Navy Combat Batallion Center (CBC) Gulfport Missippi and declare excess to the Air Force requirements and should be transferred to Redistribution and Marketing(RM)." *Fiscal Year 72 San Antonio Air Material Area (SAAMA).

History

On Feburary 4,1972, the 837,815 gallons of Orange at Combat Batallion Center(CBC)were transferred to Redistribution and Marketing(R&M). *Fiscal Year 72 History of San Antonio Air Material Area(SAAMA). A termination date was June 30 1975, San Antonio Air Material Area (SAAMA) Director of Aerospace Fuels was relived of responsibilities, and SAAMA Director of Distribution was named storage and final disposition monitor. monitor. Various U.S.Departments Of Agriculters (USDA)stations, Bureau of Indian Affairs in New Mexico, South Dakota and Colorado. Federal Aeronautical Administration Naval Air Station and other Orginizations were ship 2,4D. However, this was not the case as the reported in court case below.

U.S. v's Zimmerman explains the prosecution of people in Louisiana for the handling illegal Agent Orange sold through Texas Surplus and obtain by Kelly SAAMA Director of Distribution or Defense reutilization Market Office (DRMO).

Texas Water Commission Investigation No. EF9001563 as reported on Texas Water Commission Interoffice Memomrandum April 25,1991, Investigaator Phil Bynum Districit 8, Investigation No. EF9001563. Mr. Bynum reported that Mr. Marvin Titzman-Excutive Director Texas Surplus Agency stated "although they had handled surplus Agent Orange and other Pesticides at the facility none of the material was ever burried." This was the Texas Surplus Site located at 2103 Ackerman Road San Antonio, Tx.

In a Nature Volume 422, 17 April 2003, The Extent and Patterns of Usage of Agent Orange and other Herbicides in Vietnam page 683, it is sated that the fate of the Kelly AFB stockpiled surplus Vietnam herbicides were not known.

Alvin L. Young, Special Collection of National Agriculter Library has the history of USAF official documents created by Alvin L. Young and Agent Orange documents. Alvin L. Young library shows Batelle was contracted by the USAF for Impact studies related to Agent Orange storage and removal at Johnston Atoll Island. Kelly AFB/ALCis not on any official sites which Tested Evaluated or stored Agent Orange.

In December 2006 Alvin L. Young,Ph.D. submitted for the Office of the Under Secretary William Van Houten, contract No. DAAD19-02-D-0001 TCN 05204/D,O.0691. Prime Contractor Batelle, and Subcontracted Alvin L. Young,INC.In Alivn L. Kelly AFB/ALC is not on any official sites which Tested Evaluated or stored Agent Orange.

Any Vietnam Herbicide levels of Dioxins or any other contamination were unacceptable for commercial use due to speed of manufacturing. Agent Orange was especially high in levels of dioxins and was never legal for commercial use.

Effects of the program

New Jersey Agent Orange Commission

In 1980, New Jersey created the New Jersey Agent Orange Commission, the first state commission created to study its effects. The commission's research project in association with Rutgers University was called "The Pointman Project". It was disbanded by Governor Christine Todd Whitman in 1996.[29]

During Pointman I, commission researchers devised ways to determine small dioxin levels in blood. Prior to this, such levels could only be found in the adipose (fat) tissue. The project compared dioxin levels in a small group of Vietnam veterans who had been exposed to Agent Orange with a group of matched veterans who had not served in Vietnam. The results of this project were published in the Journal of the American Medical Association in 1988.[30]

The second phase of the project continued to examine and compare dioxin levels in various groups of Vietnam veterans including Army, Marines and brown water riverboat Navy personnel.

Lawsuits

In 1984, Agent Orange manufacturers paid Australian, Canadian and New Zealand veterans in an out-of-court settlement.[31]

U.S. Vietnamese victims class action lawsuit

On January 31, 2004, a victim's rights group, the Vietnam Association for Victims of Agent Orange/Dioxin (VAVA), filed a lawsuit in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York in Brooklyn, against several U.S. companies for liability in causing personal injury, by developing and producing the chemical. Dow Chemical and Monsanto were the two largest producers of Agent Orange for the U.S. military and were named in the suit along with the dozens of other companies (Diamond Shamrock, Uniroyal, Thompson Chemicals, Hercules, etc.). A number of lawsuits by American GIs were settled out of court - without admission of liability by the chemical companies - in the years since the Vietnam War. In 1984, some chemical companies that manufactured Agent Orange paid $180 million into a fund for United States veterans following a lawsuit.

On March 10, 2005, Judge Jack B. Weinstein - who had defended the U.S. veterans victims of Agent Orange - dismissed the suit, ruling that there was no legal basis for the plaintiffs' claims. The judge concluded that Agent Orange was not considered a poison under international law at the time of its use by the U.S.; that the U.S. was not prohibited from using it as a herbicide; and that the companies which produced the substance were not liable for the method of its use by the government. The U.S. government is not a party in the lawsuit, claiming sovereign immunity.

In order to assist those who have been impacted by Agent Orange/Dioxin, the Vietnamese have established "Peace villages", which each host between 50 to 100 victims, giving them medical and psychological help. As of 2006, there were 11 such villages, thus granting some social protection to fewer than a thousand victims. U.S. veterans of the war in Vietnam and individuals who are aware and sympathetic to the impacts of Agent Orange have also supported these programs in Vietnam. An international group of Veterans from the U.S. and its allies during the Vietnam war working together with their former enemy - veterans from the Vietnam Veterans Association - established the Vietnam Friendship Village[32] located outside of Hanoi. The center provides medical care, rehabilitation and vocational training for children and veterans from Vietnam who have been impacted by Agent Orange.

The U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs has listed prostate cancer, respiratory cancers, multiple myeloma, type II diabetes, Hodgkin’s disease, non-Hodgkin's lymphoma, soft tissue sarcoma, chloracne, porphyria cutanea tarda, peripheral neuropathy, and spina bifida in children of veterans exposed to Agent Orange as side effects of the herbicide.

South Korean lawsuit

In 1999, about 20,000 South Koreans filed two separated lawsuits against U.S. companies, seeking more than $5 billion in damages. After losing a decision in 2002, they filed an appeal.

In January 2006, the South Korean Appeals Court ordered Dow Chemical and Monsanto to pay $62 million in compensation to about 6,800 people. The ruling acknowledged that "the defendants failed to ensure safety as the defoliants manufactured by the defendants had higher levels of dioxins than standard", and, quoting the U. S. National Academy of Science report, declared that there was a "causal relationship" between Agent Orange and 11 diseases, including cancers of the lung, larynx and prostate. However, the judges failed to acknowledge "the relationship between the chemical and peripheral neuropathy, the disease most widespread among Agent Orange victims" according to the Mercury News.

Canada lawsuit

On July 12, 2005, Merchant Law Group LLP on behalf of over 1,100 Canada veterans and civilians who were living in and around the CFB Gagetown filed a lawsuit to pursue class action litigation concerning Agent Orange and Agent Purple to the Court of Queen's Bench of Manitoba. Until September 30, 2007, the case is still going.[33]

See also

Rainbow Herbicides

Agent Orange · Agent Purple · Agent Pink · Agent Green · Agent Blue · Agent White

Notes

  1. ↑ "Agent Orange". United States Department of Veterans (January 9, 2008). Retrieved on 2008-08-18.
  2. ↑ Answers.com - Ultramar Diamond Shamrock Corporation. Retrieved on 19 April 2007
  3. ↑
  4. ↑
  5. ↑ JEREMY PEARCE (June 23, 2008). "Arthur Galston, Agent Orange Researcher, Is Dead at 88 - Obituary". New York Times. Retrieved on 2008-08-18.
  6. ↑ Barlett, Donald P. and James B. Steele (May 2008) Vanity Fair - http://www.vanityfair.com/politics/features/2008/05/monsanto200805?currentPage=1 Retrieved 2008-12-09
  7. ↑ Institute of Medicine - http://www.iom.edu/CMS/3793/4689/4695.as Agent Orange are respiratory cancers, prostate cancer, multiple myeloma, primary amyloidosis.
  8. ↑ National Academy of Sciences - Data Suggest a Possible Association Between Agent Orange Exposure and Hypertension: "the report also concluded that there is suggestive but limited evidence that AL amyloidosis is associated with herbicide exposure".Retrieved on 19 May 2008.
  9. ↑ Frumkin H (2003). "Agent Orange and cancer: an overview for clinicians". CA: a cancer journal for clinicians 53 (4): 245–55. PMID 12924777. http://caonline.amcancersoc.org/cgi/pmidlookup?view=long&pmid=12924777. 
  10. ↑ MSNBC - "Agent Orange study ends, no cancer link found" by the Associated Press. Originally published 7 September 2006. Retrieved on 19 April 2007.
  11. ↑ Vietnam Agent Orange Campaign - Agent orange and the war in Vietnam Prof Van-Tuan,Nguyen, Garvan Institute of Medical Research and University of New South Wales, Australia. Published by Giao Ðiem, 2005.
  12. ↑ [Tucker, Spencer. Encyclopedia of the Vietnam War: Political, Social and Military History. ABC-CLIO, Inc. Santa Barbara. 1998.
  13. ↑ The Globe and Mail, June 12, 2008. 'Last Ghost of the Vietnam War'
  14. ↑ Vietnam Ministry of Foreign Affairs - [http://www.mofa.gov.vn/vi/tt_baochi/nr041126171753/ns050118101044 Support Agent Orange Victims in Vietnamese.
  15. ↑
  16. ↑
  17. ↑ Agent Orange information site
  18. ↑ Specifics of Agent Orange use
  19. ↑ "Agent Orange: Information for Veterans Who Served in Vietnam" (PDF). Retrieved on 2008-08-18.
  20. ↑ "Report on DoD Herbicides Outside of Vietnam" (PDF). Retrieved on 2008-08-18.
  21. ↑ "People angry with Agent Orange package turn to class-action lawsuit", The Canadian Press (2007-09-13). Retrieved on 2007-10-01. 
  22. ↑ Herbicide case in Arizona is settled NY Times March 5, 1981
  23. ↑ "Qld Govt calls for probe into Agent Orange claims". ABC News (Australian Broadcasting Corporation) (May 19, 2008). Retrieved on 2008-08-18.
  24. ↑ "Vets expecting Agent Orange cover-up". ABC News (Australian Broadcasting Corporation) (May 19, 2008). Retrieved on 2008-08-18.
  25. ↑ "Agent orange town", The Sydney Morning Herald (2008-05-18). Retrieved on 2008-05-18. 
  26. ↑ [1] May 19, 2008
  27. ↑ [2] May 18, 2008
  28. ↑ [3]
  29. ↑ New York Times, 3 July 1996
  30. ↑ Vol. 259 No. 11, 18 March 1988
  31. ↑ "Korea orders Agent Orange payments", Mercury News (January 26, 2006). 
  32. ↑ "Vietnam Friendship Village Project". Retrieved on 2008-08-18.
  33. ↑ "Agent Orange Class Action", Merchant Law Group LLP. Retrieved on 2007-10-01. 

Further reading

External links