User talk:William M. Connolley/Whats-wrong-with-wikipedia

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

I don't agree that climate is fairly clean, and I have a new challenge for you. It's a variation on my "climate club" idea from last year. I'll start the project page and send you a link. Cheers. Uncle Ed July 8, 2005 13:46 (UTC)

Hmmm, well, we know we differ about such things. But in this case, I think that we're talking about different things: by "clean" I don't mean NPOV (though I think that much of the climate sutff is now about righ, except where SEW has stuff junk into GCM...) I mean that there is no wacky speculative unreferenced nonsense in there (unlike, say, the Nikola Tesla articles and related dynamic theory of gravity). In all your conflicts with me, I don't think you've accused me of putting unref'd or speculative stuff in. Its just that we disagree as to the correct balance. But I await your project page with interest. William M. Connolley 2005-07-08 14:06:39 (UTC).