Wikipedia:Wikiproject The Simpsons/Vote2

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Image:Simpsons tv icon.svg WikiProject The Simpsons
Main project page talk
Project Watchlist talk‎
Core articles improvement drive‎ talk‎
Featured Topic Drive talk
Season 8 (2 more FAs needed to maintain FT) talk
Season 9 (1 more FA needed to maintain FT) talk
Featured content talk
Guide to sources talk
Style guide talk
Naming conventions talk
Questions for Bill Oakley talk
Participants
Userboxes
Portal talk
IRC channel #wpsimpsons

Votes for high importance episodes...

Let's say everyone picks 5 episodes... whatever you think are the most important / funniest / best / most influential episodes... no real qualifications, we'll just tally the results when the time comes... take the 5 highest voted, and make them high importance instead of the blanket mid on all the other episodes...

This round, you pick five out of a list of nominees. These episodes all received at least one vote in the previous round of voting. If the episode you picked isn't there, then add it, but ONLY do it if you voted for it in the previous round. Otherwise, using nominees would be pointless.

Please note that Simpsons Roasting on an Open Fire has already been classed as high importance and thus is not included here.

[edit] Nominees

Please sign your vote with 4 tildes (~~~~)... unsigned votes don't help us any... please do not change other peoples votes... and please no discussions here... just votes...

  • While I think the entire concept of designating episodes as high importance without a justifiable reason (just because they are popular or funniest) is silly, as I think either few if any episodes are "important" or there are tons of episodes that have "significance" for various reasons; Nevertheless, I will point out several important episodes:
    • Who Shot Mr Burns? - the first, and I think, only(?) cliffhanger ep which was a major media event
    • Krusty Gets Busted - establishes Krusty and Sideshow bob - two important recurring universe elements and episode genres
    • The Way We Was - the first flashback ep, one of the first "unique" format episodes, and the origin of homer and marge
    • Bart Gets Famous - one of the first major self-referencing episodes from a plot perspective.

But there are many more and for many more reasons TheHYPO 07:32, 28 February 2007 (UTC)

--The preceding comment was signed by User:Sp3000 (talk•contribs) 07:36, 28 February 2007 (UTC)

There are more that should be included as well, Homer's Phobia, The Itchy and Scratchy and Poochie Show. Gran2 07:39, 28 February 2007 (UTC)

  • Well, I can't do that without people saying that it's ust my favourite episodes. I needed a guideline, and following it meant several of my favourites (Homer: Badman) and others favourites would be left out.

--K.Z Talk • Vandal • Contrib 07:49, 28 February 2007 (UTC)

si»abhorreo»T 08:21, 28 February 2007 (UTC)

Support as per Sapientia abhorreo imprudentia Cocoaguy ここがいい contribstalkTodays Pick 13:30, 28 February 2007 (UTC)

I'd just like to chime in again and ask what the basis is for this vote? It seriously needs some parameters or guidelines. I don't think wikipedia is out there to take an informal poll of a dozen or two project members on what was the funniest episode and declare those episodes as more important than others; For a random example from this list: Margical History Tour - One of a large pile now of 3-story episodes; nothing unique (various historical stories told with Simpsons characters); no contribution to either in-universe or real-world Simpsons history... I don't understand how most of these episodes could ever be classified as more important than 90% of other Simpsons episodes; on the other hand, almost every episode of the first and second season introduce important universe elements and many have notable real-world significance in terms of production, ratings, tv scheduling, etc. and it would be hard to rate any of those as more significant than any other of those... If it's going to be 'most important' episodes, I think there should be some discussion as to what 'important' means - and 'most funny' should definately NOT be one of the parameters. TheHYPO 00:20, 1 March 2007 (UTC)

The original criteria was to just pick your favourites and many users complied. And in this second round, I just followed the criteria layed down in the first one. I agree that some of the choices are confusing, but I figured that this voting thing should be completed. -- Scorpion 00:26, 1 March 2007 (UTC)
I'll vote for The Seemingly Never-Ending Story, because of the good plot in which many things are happening in a lot of things which makes it a bit confusing. Also liked it because this was the first episode i saw with Snake's son and introduces of a lot of people's backgrounds a bit. The last four will be

Temari of Wind13 17:51, 3 March 2007 (UTC)

I'll chip in with mine...

That's my bits --Mortice 22:44, 1 March 2007 (UTC)

--- Simpsons Roasting on an Open fire The City of New York vs. Homer Simpson Trash of the Titans Who Shot Mr Burns?

Can't think of another important one.--Andy mci 20:49, 7 March 2007 (UTC)

I Vote I D'oh-Bot and Behind the Laughter and Lemon of Troy -- User:Izzy259

  • Mr. Plow is my favorite epsiode in the Simpsons
  • Bart Star is a pretty entertaining episode, and it should be voted for.
  • Behind the Laughter is a great Behind the Scenes show how the Simpsons evolved and was very interested to the Simpsons fan.
  • 22 Short Films About Springfield is a nice episode with a lot of funny jokes etc.
  • Deep Space Homer is a great episode as well with many amusing jokes (carbon rod and the chips in outerspace]]

Brennerdlinger 08:24, 22 May 2007 (UTC)

Rufous-crowned Sparrow 00:47, 27 May 2007 (UTC)

Just one comment: Treehouse of Horror episodes should NOT be incl here for the simple fact that they are in a class all their own! A vote on the best TOH ep I can see, but not lumped in here.

Ones that were inexplicably ignored on this list of noms (I was too late in discovering this WikiProj so I hope I'm not offending too many by breaking etiquette here):

Tommyt 14:49, 12 July 2007 (UTC)

I Agree With Tommyt That Treehouse of Horror Episodes Should not Be Included. Also These Episodes are Ones I Think Are Important NOT My Favourite Episodes.

Linczone 11:16, 31 July 2007 (UTC)