Wikipedia:WikiProject Israel Palestine Collaboration/I-P editing battleground statistics

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

One goal for this WikiProject is "to monitor and evaluate the tensions, battling and disruption over editing Israel-Palestine topics." We hope the transparency of such monitoring will both elicit help from uninvolved parties and serve to induce good practices by editors involved in POV disputes. Accordingly, this page documents the battleground statistics on disputes over Israeli-Palestinian articles. Here are some reporting rules and guidelines (draft, subject to revision):

  • The purpose of this page is to provide summary data.
  • Please fill in the article name and associated information. (Useful tool: All logs)
  • Backup links and evidence may be footnoted or placed in the Talk page. Disputed battle stats to be discussed in Talk, too.
  • Do not use this page to detail evidence or lodge complaints against individual users. (Try WP:DR, WP:AN, etc.)
  • Do not use this page to carry on a discussion of article topics.
  • Cite only Requests/Reports made within WP Noticeboards (and the like) and their explicit, official outcomes/findings. Do not cite claims made on Talk pages or your own interpretation of disputes or user conduct.

Instructions: Copy the "BriefName" and preceding line for prosperity. Replace sample "BriefName" with article title. Fill in known data. Place in alphabetical order. If table damaged, revert to previous useful version.

Contents

[edit] Recent disputes in articles

Please include articles and data from the last 30 days only. Please date items so we know when they they "expire" from the table

Recent editing hotspots
Article name Protection Moves & AfDs WP:DR Dispute resolution efforts Related blocks, tags, noticeboards & warnings Focus of dispute Other
Pallywood Feb 2/1RR/week limit Edit warring  ?
Syro-Palestinian archaeology (date) (date/type) (date/type) (date/type) (deletions of sourced material)  ?
ArticleName (date) (date/type) (date/type) (date/type) (neutral description)  ?

[edit] Annual monitoring report

Please include data from Jan. 10, 2007 to Jan. 31, 2008 only.

Battleground statistics
Article name AfDs Moves or RMs Protection RfCs or 3POs Related Noticeboards Related 3RR & blocks Tags & warnings Other
Adam Keller # # Full, 3x; semi, 1x #/#  ? #/#
Allegations of Israeli apartheid 7 3 Full, 7x # #/# yes ArbCom
Arab citizens of Israel # # 1 semi -> full #/#  ? #/#  ?
Battle of Jenin # 1 Full, 3x #/# RS #/#  ?
Causes of the 1948 Palestinian exodus # # 1 full #/#  ? #/# 2-party mediation
Convoy of 35 # # Full, 1x #/#  ? #/#  ?
Carlos Latuff # # 2 full #/# 0 #/#  ?
Definitions of Palestine and Palestinian # # 0 #/#  ? #/#  ?
Deir Yassin massacre # # 2x #/#  ? #/#  ?
Gilad Shalit # # 0 #/#  ? #/#  ?
1929 Hebron Massacre # 0 0 #/#  ? #/#  ?
House demolition in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict # 1 move (rv) 2 full, 1 semi #/#  ? #/#  ?
Islam: What the West Needs to Know # # 1 full #/#  ? #/#  ?
Israeli-Palestinian conflict # # 3 full #/#  ? #/#  ?
Jewish Lobby # # 2 full; 1R/editor/day #/#  ? #/# Pov/Ltd, Unbalanced, WP:OR mediation accepted - link works
List of massacres committed during the Second Intifada 1 (?) 6 moves 1 full #/#  ? #/#  ?
Media Coverage of the Arab-Israeli Conflict # # 0 #/#  ? #/#  ?
Mohammed Al-Dura # # 0 #/#  ? #/#  ?
Norman Finkelstein # # Full, 2x #/#  ? #/#
New antisemitism # (2) 5 #/#  ? #/# Mediation requested
Occupation of the Gaza Strip by Egypt 0 6 Mv, 1x 0/0 AN/I 0/0 -
Palestinian people # 1 4x 2?/# AN/I #/#  ?
Palestinian Fedayeen # # 0 #/# 0 #/#  ?
Palestine Peace Not Apartheid # 1 move 0 #/#  ? #/#  ?
Pallywood # 4 moves 0 #/#  ? #/#  ?
Ilan PappĂ© 1 # Full, 3x #/#  ? #/#
Saeb Erekat # # Full, 2x #/#  ? #/# (concerns)
Samson Option # 1 0 1/#  ? #/#
Second intifada # 9 Full, 2x #/# AN/I #/# Con, Heat Med Cabal
Shimon Tzabar # # Full, 1 #/# AN/I #/#
Six-Day War # # 1 full, 1 semi, (1 temp) #/#  ? #/# 1 editor 1RR
Tanya Reinhart # # Full, 1x #/#  ? #/#
Uri Avnery # # Semi, 1x #/#  ? #/#
ArticleName # #  ? #/#  ? #/#  ?

List of tags. Con=Controversial. Heat=Calm talk, Disputed, POV, Total=Totally disputed, Unbalanced, etc.

[edit] List of casualties within past 12 months

[edit] Editors blocked in last 12 months

[edit] Block-free editors in last 5 months

This is a sublist, for those listed above, to showcase progress in block-free editing behavior


(NB. Again, do not use this page to file complaints or pile up links on individuals. Thank you.)

[edit] Articles to be added to the annual report

Scope: "The entire set of Arab-Israeli conflict-related articles, broadly interpreted" per ArbCom wording. Add the following hotspot articles to the Table above, if you please:

  • Please add high tension articles here, or directly into the above Table, annual report
  • Kindly help us fill in the data for the annual report Table by article
  • After an article is entered into the above Table (annual report), delete it from the to-do list below:
Note: 8 of the above 23 articles have been protected, 22x overall

[edit] Articles that may or may not be included in topic area

Instructions: Project members may move articles here from above. Do not add these articles to the tables above. Feel free to compile the relevant dispute stats. Thank you for your interest and cooperation.

  • Islamophobia - heat, forum, cont, troll (3 old afds), 11 prot (!), failed MedCom
  • Islamic terrorism - neut, cont, topic, (2006 afd), 1 RM
  • Al-Qaeda - full (current), neut. (Has I-P matters, not usual disputants.)

[edit] Notes and Documentation

  1. ^ See Talk.