Wikipedia talk:User categories

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

The page as it stands seems a little too tight on whether it truly is consensus that user categories be used in the manner prescribed. There's been no consensus on whether redlinked cats shgould be removed from user talk pages at the pump, and the consensus for what constitutes usefulness in a user cat differs on the mailing list to that which is argues at WP:UCFD. Personally I think every category should be judged on its own merits, and that a consensus of Wikipedians should decide the utility or lack of it. Hiding T 23:35, 13 January 2008 (UTC)