Unitary state

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This article does not cite any references or sources. (March 2008)
Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unverifiable material may be challenged and removed.

A map showing the unitary states.

A unitary state is a state whose three organs of state are governed constitutionally as one single unit, with one constitutionally created legislature. The political power of government in such states may well be transferred to lower levels, to national, regional or local elected assemblies, governors and mayors (devolved government), but the central government retains the principal right to recall such delegated power (for example Farum Municipality was ruled by the Danish Government for a time).

In a unitary state, any sub-governmental units can be created or abolished, and have their powers varied, by the central government. The process in which sub-government units and/or national or regional parliaments are created by a central government is known as devolution. A unitary state can broaden and narrow the functions of such devolved governments without formal agreement from the affected bodies. In federal systems, by contrast, assemblies in those states composing the federation have a constitutional existence and a set of constitutional functions which cannot be unilaterally changed by the central government. In some such cases, such as in the United States, it is the federal government that has only those powers expressly delegated to it.

Most federal states also have unitary lower levels of government. Thus while the United States itself is federal, the U.S. states are themselves unitary, with counties and other municipalities having only the authority given (devolved) to them by the state constitution or legislature.

The majority of the world's countries are unitary states.^{[citation needed]} Many of the non-unitary states of the world are very large in size, particularly Mexico, Canada, United States, Brazil, India and Australia. This does not imply that large size will invariably result in non-unitary government; China, for instance, due to its political and socio-cultural history, has not seen the rise of a non-unitary arrangement, though certain economists argue that the current political and economic situation in mainland China constitute a unique form of Chinese federalism. Other counter-examples are Belgium and Switzerland, which despite a small territory have developed a complex federal system.

1 Notable examples
2 Devolved state
3 List of unitary states
4 See also
5 References

[edit] Notable examples

The United Kingdom is a State with a series of parliament-created devolved assemblies, for Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, all of which were created between 1998 and 1999. Ireland is a unitary state without subnational governments.

China is principally a unitary state formed with the central government having direct authority over the provinces and delegating authority to provincial governments. However the status of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region (SAR) is open to debate, depending on one's interpretation of the Hong Kong Basic Law. Most Chinese legal scholars argue that the Basic Law is purely domestic legislation deriving its authority from the Constitution of the People's Republic of China, in which case the SAR is a devolved government entirely consistent with the view of China as a unitary state. However others argue that the Basic Law derives its authority directly from the Sino-British Joint Declaration, in which case it is possible to regard it as a constitution, implying a federal relationship between China and Hong Kong and placing China in the hybrid category. Similar considerations affect the Macau SAR.

India is mostly a federal state but under the controversial Article 356 of the Indian Constitution, a president can dismiss a state government.

Singapore a city-state.

[edit] Devolved state

A "devolved state" is an increasingly common form of unitary state which allows regions extensive powers, but the central government reserves the right to withdraw those powers at will, regions having no actual right to any powers. The powers of regions are therefore held entirely at the pleasure of the central government.

In the devolved state model, the regional entities have their own governments and may have their own laws, and typically practice a large degree of autonomous decision making. In this way, they are similar to the federal model. However, the state is still unitary, and the subnational entities (unlike in a federation) do not have any constitutional rights to challenge national legislation or preserve their powers. Depending on the exact legal status of the devolved powers, the laws of the subnational entity may be overridden, or the entity's law-making power curtailed, by an ordinary law of the national government, or by a simple decision of the head of government. The United Kingdom is a good example of this: Scotland has a wide degree of autonomous law-making power, however, there is no right for Scotland to challenge the constitutionality of UK national legislation, and laws of Scotland can be overridden, and the powers of the Scottish parliament revoked or reduced, by an act of the national parliament or a decision of the Prime Minister. In the case of Northern Ireland, the devolved powers of the region have been suspended by a simple government decision on several occasions. Thus, the UK is still a unitary state, despite superficially appearing somewhat like a federal state in practice.

Devolution (like federation) may be symmetrical (all regions having the same powers and status) or asymmetric (regions varying in their powers and status). UK devolution is asymmetric.