Wikipedia:Trial adminship

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This proposal has failed to attain consensus within the Wikipedia community. A failed proposal is one for which a consensus to accept is not present after a reasonable amount of time, and seems unlikely to form, regardless of continuing discussion.

• Any editor can request probationary (trial) adminship, if the editor can find a serving administrator who is willing to endorse the editor's application and mentor the applicant during the probationary adminship. Enthusiasm is what counts, not editcountitis.
• Probation of an endorsed candidate will be discussed for a few days and is passed unless there are compelling reasons not to based on the user's past deeds. Speculative reasoning, and "lack of participation in process X" are explicitly not good reasons.
• A bureaucrat makes the decision as to whether "compelling reasons" have been raised or not. If the mentor has been an admin for only a short time, or is already mentoring someone else, the bureaucrats may require the candidate to find another mentor.
• Probation lasts one month. At that point, the user gets regular adminship unless (1) at least ten regular users object to that, in which case a regular RFA decides, or (2) the user has barely used the tools at all (as judged by the mentor), in which case the editor probably doesn't need them.
• Trial admin status can be revoked instantly by the mentor, or by any bureaucrat who considers that necessary. (Yes, I know they can't demote technically, but they get to make the decision; other users get to convince the 'crat.)
• An editor can only become a trial administrator once. Thereafter, adminship must be through a regular RfA. An editor who has already had an unsuccesful RFA is not eligible for a trial.