Treatment of human head lice

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Hunting lice by candlelight by Andries Both, ca 1630 (National Gallery, Budapest)
Hunting lice by candlelight by Andries Both, ca 1630 (National Gallery, Budapest)

The treatment of human head lice is a process that has been debated and studied for centuries. However, the number of cases of human louse infestations (or pediculosis) has increased worldwide since the mid-1960s, reaching hundreds of millions annually.[1] There is no product or method which assures 100% destruction of the eggs and hatched lice after a single treatment. However, there are a number of treatment modalities that can be employed with varying degrees of success. These methods include chemical treatments, natural products, combs, shaving, hot air, and silicone-based lotions.

Contents

[edit] Treatment

[edit] General recommendations for treatment

Because eggs hatch 6–9 days after oviposition, if a pediculicide is used, treatment is recommended to be repeated at least once and this after 10 days, when all lice have hatched from the eggs.[2] Between the two treatments i.e., days 2–9, the person will still be infested with lice, which hatch from eggs not killed by the anti-louse product. Therefore, with some products a third treatment on day 5 is recommended. Between the treatments, it is advised to wet the hair and comb daily with a louse-comb to remove the hatching lice. The instructions for use should be read carefully before using any anti-louse product. During the treatment, it is particularly important to note the starting time and to treat the hair for the exact period specified in the instructions. Contact of the product with the eyes of the infested person should be avoided by holding a towel over the face, and eyes should be rinsed well with water if the product does get in contact. After the treatment and while the hair is still wet after rinsing with water, hair should be combed for 3–4 minutes with a louse comb to remove lice and eggs. One to three days after the last treatment, i.e., days 11, 12 and 13, hair should be checked with a louse comb. If no living lice are found, the treatment was successful, even if nits/eggs are visible on the hair. If living lice are still present, the treatment should be repeated using an anti-louse product with a different active ingredient. Prophylactic treatment with pediculicides is not recommended[3] Itching may persist for up to a week after head lice eradication.

[edit] Chemical treatments

Today, insecticides used for the treatment of head lice include organochlorines (lindane, DDT), organophosphates (malathion), carbamates (carbaryl), pyrethrins (pyrethrum), and pyrethroids (permethrin, phenothrin, bio-allethrin). Laboratory and clinical studies found that many of the pediculicides in the market are either not or not fully effective when they are used according to the instructions.[4] [5] [6] [7]

Pediculicides may rapidly lose their efficacy because of the development of resistance. Resistance of head lice to insecticides such as lindane, DDT, malathion, phenothrin and permethrin has been reported.[8] [9] [10]

[edit] Natural products

Natural products tested clinically and found to be safe and effective could be very important in the control of head lice, as the complexity of the active ingredients may prevent the rapid development of resistance. They are more acceptable to some parents who are concerned with the use of chemical pediculicides. Several plant products such as aniseed, coconut, neem and tea tree oils offer promise for new compounds to treat head lice infestation. However, the number of clinical studies is very limited.[6] [11]

[edit] Enzyme-based products

Certain protease enzymes can have insecticidal effects. This process works through using naturally occurring enzymes similar to those within the insects themselves. These protease enzymes cause the insect to hatch and molt prematurely, destroying the creatures exoskeleton. These enzymes are similar to those found in meat tenderizers and digestive aids. The benefits of this type of treatment is that the lice do not develop resistance and these products are less toxic. There are several available brands, some of which are pH balanced.[12]

[edit] Combs

For a treatment with the louse comb alone, it is recommended to comb the hair for 3–10 minutes (depending the length and type of the hair) daily or every second day for 14 days. Wetting the hair with water and especially with water and shampoo or conditioner will facilitate the combing and the removal of lice, eggs and nits. [13][14][15] [16]

[edit] Louse combs

A special finetooth comb that can pick out lice is used. The space between the teeth of the comb should be no more than 0.3 mm (0.01 inch). Plastic combs are effective for very short-term use, but the spacing between the teeth will quickly spread out after repeated usage. Metal combs, being inflexible, are more effective for multiple uses.

Following are instructions for wet combing:

  • First, comb through wet hair with an ordinary comb to relieve knots and tangles.
  • Apply Hair conditioner to make it easier to comb the hair with the fine-toothed comb.
  • Comb through every bit of hair, pulling the comb from the scalp to the hair ends. After every comb-through, examine and rinse the comb. Use an old toothbrush to remove eggs and nits from the comb and flush the eggs down the sink. Comb through the entire head and scalp at least twice. Afterwards, rinse the conditioner out.
  • Repeat the aforementioned steps every day or every second day to catch any new lice that have hatched since the previous combing.
  • Repeat the aforementioned procedure until lice are not found for at least two treatments in a row. The Pharmaceutical Society of Australia recommends treating with comb and conditioner every two days until lice are not found for ten consecutive days.

[edit] Hot air

Several devices blowing hot air onto the scalp have been tested for their efficacy to kill lice and eggs. The most successful method, which used a custom-built machine called the LouseBuster, resulted in nearly 100% mortality of eggs and 80% mortality of hatched lice.[17]

[edit] Silicone-based lotions

Dimethicone is a silicone-based lotion, which after drying coats and smothers the lice causing its death either by suffocation or dehydration. Most lotions do not kill nits because the nits have only one breathing orifice, the operculum, so the dimethicone has less access there.

Accelerated Nano X-ray tomography of headlice treated with Silcap(4% dimethicone/96% mineral oil) ([1]).  After 15 min the lice and nits are suffocated and dry out. Courtesy of Oystershell NV & University of Ghent, ''
Accelerated Nano X-ray tomography of headlice treated with Silcap(4% dimethicone/96% mineral oil) ([1]). After 15 min the lice and nits are suffocated and dry out. Courtesy of Oystershell NV & University of Ghent, ''

Therefore most treatments should be repeated after 7–10 days to kill any lice that hatch from the eggs or to treat reinfection by family members or class mates .[18] Combination lotions and foams exist (e.g. Silcap, Oystershell NV) that have an immediate effect on nits (15 min, 96% mortality) by combining the rather viscous dimethicone with penetrating excipients that increase the delivery through the abdominal spiracles of adults and the operculum of the nits [19]. Another treatment, the Nuvo Method, uses the skin cleanser Cetaphil to suffocate the lice.[20] The method consists of thoroughly coating the scalp with the cleanser, removing the excess lotion from the hair with a comb, and using a blow dryer to dry the lotion to the scalp. However, the dried coating must remain on the scalp for 8 hours and in stead of one application, the treatment consists of 3 applications done at one week intervals.[21]


[edit] Shaving the head

Shaving the head or cutting the hair extremely short can be used to control lice infestation. Short hair, baldness, or a shaven scalp are generally seen as a preventitive measure against lice infestation. However, it is not recommended that children be suddenly shorn due to the psychological damage the child might experience. See the Treatment modalities not recommended section for more information.

[edit] Products in development

A number of promising compounds are currently in development for the treatment of head lice. Approval of any of these products may make it much easier to treat head lice in the future.

  • Summers Laboratories is developing a non pesticide lice treatment that kills by asphyxiation (Summer's Non-pesticide Lice Asphyxiator). This product is a water-based, water-soluble gel, similar in consistency to a hair conditioner. It consists of a mixture of dermatological and cosmetic ingredients. The product was acquired by Sciele Pharma for distribution in the United States, Canada, and Mexico. Sciele announced the New Drug Application (NDA) was accepted by the FDA on August 16, 2007.
  • ParaPRO is developing a crème rinse containing a family friendly formulation that is lethal to head lice. [22] The active ingredient, Spinosad, is derived from a naturally occurring soil organism and was awarded the Presidential Green Chemistry Challenge award to recognize its innovation in cleaner and smarter chemistry. The product, tentatively branded NatrOVA, is currently being tested in FDA approved clinical trials.
  • BTG (LSE: BGC) is developing a proprietary gel-based formulation for use as a topical treatment of head lice infestation. The product is a non-pesticide product derived from a natural source. In laboratory studies, BGC20-0582 killed both lice and their eggs following very short treatment times and was shown to be superior to a leading over-the-counter lice treatment product.

[edit] Treatment modalities not recommended

It is not recommended to use kerosene (alone or in combination with oil and vinegar), hair bleaches and dyes, antibiotics or ivermectin for treatment and garlic and Vitamin B for prevention.[3]

Food-grade oils, hair gels, Vaseline and mayonnaise as well as formulations meant only for parasitic insects on pets or free-living insects in the household (e.g., ants and cockroaches) are not recommended for head lice treatment.[23]

Shaving the head or even a short haircut for prevention or control of lice is not recommended due to the psychological damage the child might experience. Infestation with lice is not a disease and the medical symptoms are normally minimal. In any case, health providers and parents should try not to create emotional problems for the child during examination and treatment.[24]

[edit] See also

[edit] References

  1. ^ Gratz, N. (1998). "Human lice, their prevalence and resistance to insecticides.". Geneva: World Health Organization (WHO). 
  2. ^ Mumcuoglu, Kosta (2006). "Effective Treatment of Head Louse with Pediculicides". Journal of Drugs in Dermatology 5: 451–452. 
  3. ^ a b Mumcuoglu, Kosta Y.; Barker CS, Burgess IF, Combescot-Lang C, Dagleish RC, Larsen KS, Miller J, Roberts RJ, Taylan-Ozkan A. (2007). "International Guidelines for Effective Control of Head Louse Infestations". Journal of Drugs in Dermatology 6: 409–414. 
  4. ^ Roberts, RJ; Casey D, Morgan DA, Petrovic M (12 August 2000). "Comparison of Wet Combing With Malathion for Treatment of Head Lice in the UK: A Pragmatic Randomised Controlled Trial" (abstract). The Lancet 356 (9229): 540–544. Amsterdam: Elsevier. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(00)02578-2. 
  5. ^ Mumcuoglu, KY; Miller, J. (1991). "The Efficacy of Pediculicides in Israel.". Israel Journal of Medical Sciences 27 (10): 562–565. Jerusalem: Weizmann Science Press. 
  6. ^ a b Vander Stichele, Robert H; Dezeure Els M, and Bogaert Marc G. (2 September 1999). "Systematic Review of Clinical Efficacy of Topical Treatments for Head Lice". British Medical Journal (BMJ) 311 (7005): 604–608. London: BMJ Publishing Group Ltd. PMID 7545045. 
  7. ^ Meinking, Terri L.; Entzel, Pamela; Villar, Maria Elena; Vicaria, Maureen; Lemard, Glendene A; Porcelain, Sherri L. (March 2001). "Comparative Efficacy of Treatments for Pediculosis Capitis Infestations". Archives of Dermatology 137 (3): 287–292. Chicago: American Medical Association. PMID 11255326. 
  8. ^ Pollack, Richard J.; Kiszewski, Anthony; Armstrong, Philip; Hahn, Christine; Wolfe, Nathan; Rahman, Hasan Abdul; Laserson, Kayla; Telford III, Sam R; Spielman, Andrew (September 1999). "Differential Permethrin Susceptibility of Head Lice Sampled in the United States and Borneo". Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine 153 (9): 969–973. Chicago: American Medical Association. doi:10.1001/archpedi.153.9.969. PMID 10482215. 
  9. ^ Burkhart, Craig G. (May 2004). "Relationship of Treatment-Resistant Head Lice to the Safety and Efficacy of Pediculicides". Mayo Clinic Proceedings 79: 661–666. Rochester, Minnesota: Mayo Clinic. 
  10. ^ Yoon, Kyong Sup; Gao, Jian-Rong; Lee, Si Hyeock; Clark, J. Marshall; Brown, Leon; Taplin, David (August 2003). "Permethrin-Resistant Human Head Lice, Pediculus capitis, and Their Treatment". Archives of Dermatology 139 (8): 994–1000. Chicago: American Medical Association. doi:10.1001/archderm.139.8.994. 
  11. ^ Mumcuoglu, Kosta; Miller, Jacqueline; Zamir, Chen; Zentner, Gary; Helbin, Valery; and Ingber, Arieh (October 2002). "The In Vivo Pediculicidal Efficacy of a Natural Remedy". Israel Medical Association Journal 4: 790–793. Ramat Gan: Israel Medical Association. 
  12. ^ Tvedten, Stephen. [http://www.stephentvedten.com/16_Lice_&_Scabies.pdf The Best Control for Human Lice and Scabies] (PDF). Retrieved on 2008-04-02.
  13. ^ Abdel-Ghaffar, Fathy; Semmler, Margit (10 August 2006). "Efficacy of Neem Seed Extract Shampoo on Head Lice of Naturally Infected Humans in Egypt". Parasitology Research 100: 329–332. Würzburg: University of Würzburg. doi:10.1007/s00436-006-0264-2. 
  14. ^ Mumcuoglu, Kosta Y. (Jul-Sep 1999). "Prevention and Treatment of Head Lice in Children". Paediatric Drugs 1 (3): 211–218. Yardley, Pennsylvania: Adis International. 
  15. ^ Bingham, P; Kirk S, Hill N, Figueroa J (2000). "The methodology and operation of a pilot randomized control trial of the effectiveness of the bug busting method against a single application insecticide product for head louse treatment". Public Health 114 (4): 265–268. Amsterdam: Elsevier. doi:10.1016/S0033-3506(00)00342-5. 
  16. ^ Plastow, Liz; Luthra, Manjo; Powell, Roy; Wright, Judith; Russell, David; Marshall, Martin (April 2001). "Head lice infestation: bug busting vs. traditional treatment". Journal of Clinical Nursing 10 (6): 775–783. Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishing Inc.. doi:10.1046/j.1365-2702.2001.00541.x. 
  17. ^ Goates, Brad M.; Atkin, Joseph S; Wilding, Kevin G; Birch, Kurtis G; Cottam, Michael R; Bush, Sarah E. and Clayton, Dale H. (5 November 2006). "An Effective Nonchemical Treatment for Head Lice: A Lot of Hot Air". Pediatrics 118 (5): 1962–1970. American Academy of Pediatrics. doi:10.1542/peds.2005-1847. 
  18. ^ Burgess, Ian F.; Brown, Christine M. and Lee, Peter N. (10 June 2005). "Treatment of head louse infestation with 4% dimeticone lotion: randomised controlled equivalence trial". British Medical Journal (BMJ) 330 (7505): 1423. London: BMJ Publishing Group Ltd. doi:10.1136/bmj.38497.506481.8F. 
  19. ^ PCT/EP2008/050417 Foamable composition for killing arthropods and uses thereof.
  20. ^ Pearlman, Dale L. (September 1, 2004). "A Simple Treatment for Head Lice: Dry-On, Suffocation-Based Pediculicide". Pediatrics 114 (3): e275-e279. Elk Grove Village, IL: American Academy of Pediatrics. doi:10.1542/peds.2003-0666-F. 
  21. ^ Pearlman, Dale. Nuvo Method for Treating Head Lice. Retrieved on 2008-01-04.
  22. ^ Cueto, G. Mougabure; Zerba, E. N. ; Picollo, M. I. (May 2006). "Permethrin-Resistant head Lice (Anoplura: Pediculidae) in Argentina Are Susceptible to Spinosad". Journal of Medical Entomology 43: 634–635. Entomological Society of America. doi:10.1603/0022-2585(2006)43[634:PHLAPI]2.0.CO;2. 
  23. ^ Mumcuoglu, Kosta Y. (1991). "Head Lice in Drawings of Kindergarten Children". The Israel Journal of Psychiatry and Related Sciences 28: 25–32. 

[edit] External links